Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a little heartbroken about having a boy

408 replies

bm2b · 03/09/2025 20:52

I already have a daughter and recently found out that this baby is a boy. I feel incredibly grateful to be pregnant again, and I know how lucky I am to be carrying a healthy baby. I already love him, and I know I’ll adore him completely when he arrives. But I’ve been caught off guard by this quiet feeling of sadness that I didn’t expect.

I’m very close to my mum. We speak every day, go on little trips together, help each other out, and are part of each other’s daily lives. I’ve started to build something similar with my daughter, even though she’s still young, and I suppose I imagined continuing that dynamic with another girl.

With a boy, I’m not sure what that relationship will look like in the long term. In so many families I’ve seen, sons gradually become more distant from their parents as they get older, especially once they have partners and children of their own. It often ends up being the wife’s parents who are more involved, while his own mum becomes more of an occasional visitor.

Of course there are exceptions. I can think of the odd “friend of a friend’s cousin” whose son stayed close and prioritised both sides of the family equally, or doesn’t automatically side with his partner when she’s being unfair. But in my experience, that feels like the exception rather than the norm.

I also worry about what raising a boy will be like day to day. I know it’s a stereotype, but the boys I’ve been around — nephews, friends’ kids — tend to be more energetic, more physical, and more chaotic. I’m a bit afraid I won’t enjoy that stage as much, or that I won’t know how to connect with him in the same way.

If anyone has felt this way too, I’d love to hear from you. Especially mums of older boys — did the bond end up being just as close, even if it looked a bit different? What parts of having a son surprised you in a good way?

OP posts:
littleburn · 03/09/2025 23:47

Part of the gender disappointment in boys that I find odd is so much of it is based on the idea that a daughter is preferable because she’ll be a mini-me/best friend for life, who’ll share all your interests and want to hang out with you forever more. But our kids don’t just exist as an extension of us, there to meet our wants and needs, they’re individuals and human beings in their own right. I honestly find framing being a parent in that way borderline narcissistic.

Oopsadaisysgranny · 03/09/2025 23:43

And to add as a grandparent I am lucky enough to the closest mt granddaughters !! I am very lucky

Oopsadaisysgranny · 03/09/2025 23:39

I have 5 children all adults and it’s the boys who seem to be closer to me . They are the ones I go on shopping trips with ect . My daughter are more independent and off doing their own things . The boys have wonderful children and partners and it doesn’t stop them wanting their old mum !!! So stop worrying about being close to your new little boy he may be your shopping buddy when his sister is busy

maybein2022 · 03/09/2025 23:37

Haven’t RTFT. OP, I was desperate for a daughter. My first, like yours, was a girl. When I got pregnant with my second I was secretly hoping for another girl. He was a boy, as was my third. Hand on heart, having boys has been amazing. I love my daughter beyond measure but she has been far and away my most tricky child. It’s not what I imagined. You can build a picture up in your head of what life will look like with children of whatever gender, but that’s all it is. A picture that may or may not become reality. Wishing you all the best with your pregnancy and enjoy your little boy.

Carolenarua · 03/09/2025 23:36

ChessorBuckaroo · 03/09/2025 22:53

Just to follow up on this. I said this topic ("heartbroken with a boy"), conditional love based on sex, is an English thing, but that was being too broad (for instance I couldn't imagine Scouse mums being disappointed with their sons or not being close to them throughout their life, for I know they are close). Rather this coldness applies to a certain type of English woman (who also seem to populate this site).

On the closeness of boys to their mums in Ireland, this much loved Irish electricity board advert from the 1980s (showing a son returning home while his mum is waiting for him) is indicative of that bond.

I remember that advert. How lovely. Thanks for posting. I'm right now holding my adorable 6 week old boy. Go raibh maith agat.

Bridgetjonesheart · 03/09/2025 23:36

IcedPurple · 03/09/2025 23:05

Saying she's 'heartbroken' simply because her baby is a boy is a bit more than 'voicing reservations'.

She knew there was a 50% chance that the baby would be a boy, so why get pregnant if you're going to be 'heartbroken' at an outcome that is as likely as not?

Well yes it’s not ideal but people throw around the phrase ‘heartbroken’ really lightly. If she said I’m in the depth of a prolonged depression and a crippling existential crisis I might wonder why she’d taken the gamble but if she’s a bit disappointed and weepy I reckon it’ll pass with time. Plus you can’t always foresee how you’re going to feel. She might not have realised she was going to feel like this when trying for baby. Either way berating her isn’t going to help.

Zezet · 03/09/2025 23:33

Hi! I was very disappointed when I discovered I would have a boy. I wanted the closeness of a girl, I wanted the closer relationship that's more likely with grandchildren, all of it.
Then, when he was born, he was just so perfect and so mine. He is my son, yes, but he is much more like me than my daughter. It's very easy to find complicity with him. He fiercely admires his mum and is fiercely feminist. My husband has a very good relationship with his mum so I feel my son will learn from my husband to do the same. He is very protective of his younger sister and other small children. He is good-humored and very polite. He is just delightful to be around and all the ease and complicity that I expect from a girl, I have also found with him.

HeyThereDelila · 03/09/2025 23:32

They’re not dolls. They’re not extensions if your personality. They’re not there to fulfil your need for friends or closeness.

Have a word with yourself and be thankful for two healthy DC.

Frankenpug23 · 03/09/2025 23:27

My DS is 21 he is loving, kind, more dependant and great fun to be around. He was and continues to be so much easier than my DD - who is independent, feisty, funny, kind, is never in, risk takes ++++ and has kept me awake worrying most nights since she hit 18!!! I love them both tremendously, they are both loud , confident and have wonderful friends but blimey she has given me grey hairs 😂 and he has been a doddle!

DramaLlamacchiato · 03/09/2025 23:27

highincalifornia · 03/09/2025 23:20

Uggh, I spoke too soon. You absolutely never get a post about being disappointed in a girl
pregnancy , quite rightly, but then imagine one a week saying how much better boys are then girls! Cuddly, affectionate, give hugs , kisses, girls: stroppy, emotional, indifferent, etc. The post may start with boy disappointment but after so many posts saying how much better boys are it’s pretty tough being told you’ve missed out as a girl mum. There are no posts about the great qualities of girls, probably because there aren’t any, babies are babies are babies etc

I know what you mean. I’ve got boys but I find those posts full on cringe! Plus as a female myself let alone the fact I have 6 amazing nieces why would I slag off girls!

Enko · 03/09/2025 23:24

Ds is 23 and he is just amazing. He is close to dh and I his sisters abd is vuulding a great relationship with his girlfriends parents. I do not believe he will filter away as dh never did with mil. Ds rolemodel is what he saw for mil and dh. Mil was 91 when she passed we visited most weeks. The kids knew dad spoke to grandma daily and that is just the norm..

We have ds home for september and in truth i love it.. i love the girls fiercely but ds is the closest to me in temperament and i find him such easy company. Even if he is taller than me and likes rugby..

Tumbleweed101 · 03/09/2025 23:23

My son is 27 and I still see him as much as his adult sister. I find him far less dramatic than his sisters! Having a boy is lovely.

highincalifornia · 03/09/2025 23:20

Uggh, I spoke too soon. You absolutely never get a post about being disappointed in a girl
pregnancy , quite rightly, but then imagine one a week saying how much better boys are then girls! Cuddly, affectionate, give hugs , kisses, girls: stroppy, emotional, indifferent, etc. The post may start with boy disappointment but after so many posts saying how much better boys are it’s pretty tough being told you’ve missed out as a girl mum. There are no posts about the great qualities of girls, probably because there aren’t any, babies are babies are babies etc

IcedPurple · 03/09/2025 23:17

Objectiontime · 03/09/2025 23:09

I just dont understand why people get pregnant if they are only wanting a specific sex, It's just horrible!! Boys and girls are both special, unique and wonderful.
Its roughly a 50 50 chance so just be grateful for this new little life you are nurturing please.

Yeah, in any other aspect of life a person who took a bet which had a 50% chance of producing a result which would make her 'heartbroken' would be considered nuts!

Smugzebra · 03/09/2025 23:16

Yep... You are being unreasonable.

Youre lucky enough to get pregnant.
You know it's 50/50.
You got a boy.
This is the only info you have, you have no idea what that little human being will be just yet.

Could mamby pamby and say "gender disappointment is a very real, understandable thing that lots of people get" ... It is.... But it's still unreasonable.

TheOpalMoose · 03/09/2025 23:15

I have the most wonderful loving son. It breaks my heart I can't give him a sibling. You have no idea how fortunate you are op.

Objectiontime · 03/09/2025 23:09

I just dont understand why people get pregnant if they are only wanting a specific sex, It's just horrible!! Boys and girls are both special, unique and wonderful.
Its roughly a 50 50 chance so just be grateful for this new little life you are nurturing please.

LancashireButterPie · 03/09/2025 23:09

We need to lose the gender stereotypes.
We are all people, some good, some not so good.
I believe that to a large extent, you reap what you sow.
Be loving and gentle with your children and they repay that by loving you back.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 03/09/2025 23:09

YABU. If you had 5 boys for example id understand although I'd still think saying you were "heartbroken was a major over reaction.

Concernedauntie3 · 03/09/2025 23:08

Why assume your boy will be heterosexual?!

89redballoons · 03/09/2025 23:06

I have two boys, aged 3 and 5, and am currently expecting my third boy.

In all honesty, I'm close to my mum now in my 30s, but we had an incredibly fraught and complicated relationship when I was growing up, especially for the years when she was going through menopause and I was in my late teens/early 20s.

I have a younger brother and his relationship with my mum was, and is, much more straightforward. I am grateful I have boys, from that perspective.

Everyone is different, though, and of course all boys and girls are their own personalities and form their own relationships.

DarcyProudman · 03/09/2025 23:05

Get a bloody grip. YABTU

IcedPurple · 03/09/2025 23:05

Bridgetjonesheart · 03/09/2025 22:51

I voted not unreasonable. You’re just at the start of a journey and you’re allowed to voice reservations. He’ll bring his own love though and you’ll look back and wonder why you worried.

Saying she's 'heartbroken' simply because her baby is a boy is a bit more than 'voicing reservations'.

She knew there was a 50% chance that the baby would be a boy, so why get pregnant if you're going to be 'heartbroken' at an outcome that is as likely as not?

Comeinupto40 · 03/09/2025 23:04

I can’t believe these threads. As I teacher, I have known simply adorable, utterly obnoxious, quiet, loud and ear-splitting children of both sexes.

My friend’s 8 year old son likes to curl up with a story book and will sketch pictures of horses and dragons for hours. My six year old niece, on the other hand, is hyperactivity personified and is constantly filthy, much to my sister’s dismay. You really must not stereotype!

Mustbethat · 03/09/2025 23:01

LayeredlikeanOnion · 03/09/2025 22:57

Boys are wonderful. They adore their mums and its the best relationship.

Oh wow, I didn’t realise girls don’t like their mums, it must be a boy thing…

how does it work anyway, boys are so loving and cuddly, and all adore their mums, yet they get married and suddenly decide they like their in-laws better?

yet girls are standoffish, but they are the ones that stick around…

Swipe left for the next trending thread