Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a little heartbroken about having a boy

408 replies

bm2b · 03/09/2025 20:52

I already have a daughter and recently found out that this baby is a boy. I feel incredibly grateful to be pregnant again, and I know how lucky I am to be carrying a healthy baby. I already love him, and I know I’ll adore him completely when he arrives. But I’ve been caught off guard by this quiet feeling of sadness that I didn’t expect.

I’m very close to my mum. We speak every day, go on little trips together, help each other out, and are part of each other’s daily lives. I’ve started to build something similar with my daughter, even though she’s still young, and I suppose I imagined continuing that dynamic with another girl.

With a boy, I’m not sure what that relationship will look like in the long term. In so many families I’ve seen, sons gradually become more distant from their parents as they get older, especially once they have partners and children of their own. It often ends up being the wife’s parents who are more involved, while his own mum becomes more of an occasional visitor.

Of course there are exceptions. I can think of the odd “friend of a friend’s cousin” whose son stayed close and prioritised both sides of the family equally, or doesn’t automatically side with his partner when she’s being unfair. But in my experience, that feels like the exception rather than the norm.

I also worry about what raising a boy will be like day to day. I know it’s a stereotype, but the boys I’ve been around — nephews, friends’ kids — tend to be more energetic, more physical, and more chaotic. I’m a bit afraid I won’t enjoy that stage as much, or that I won’t know how to connect with him in the same way.

If anyone has felt this way too, I’d love to hear from you. Especially mums of older boys — did the bond end up being just as close, even if it looked a bit different? What parts of having a son surprised you in a good way?

OP posts:
FlipFlopVibe · 04/09/2025 20:36

I was once you too with an older girl first, wondering how I’d feel about it but oh my goodness, the love from little boys is unreal! He’s so gorgeous and cuddly, he has this lovely cheeky grin and giggle. Honestly I don’t know if I’ll ever be a good ‘boy mum’ standing at the side of a football pitch in the rain but I’d do anything for him. He absolutely has my heart. I promise you’ll love it even more this time round. We aren’t having any more but I’d genuinely want another boy if we did!

TinyTeachr · 04/09/2025 20:12

Focus on wonderful, loving men in your life. Your DS may well end up reminding you of them as they get older. Did you have a good relationship with your father? You might be able to see parts of him in their faces as they age, and in their character.

I have 2 boys and 2 girls, but still young. As it happens, my boys are more boisterous and always have been. They remind me of puppies at times. They are no more loving than my girls, but not less either. One suggested this morning that perhaps we should all stay at home and cuddle in bed with books instead of going to school. They are a bit more rough with each other than I'd really like, but they remember to be gentle with their little sister.

You are mourning an ideal you had pictured. That ideal may not have hapenned anyway, your hypothetical baby girl might not have been at all girly. Your boy may well be just as loving and connect with you like your eldest. Let go of that picture you were holding onto. You will love your son when he is here. He will be wonderful in his own way.

On the note about long term relationship with you. I know lots of families where the MIL does childcare or spends lots of time with grand children. They are the ones that cultivated a good relationship with their DIL before children were in the picture. That's something I'll be bearing in mind when my sons are older.

Genuinelyenquiring · 04/09/2025 20:08

HedwigIsMySpiritAnimal · 03/09/2025 21:31

What the fuck is a “weird and creepy” boy mum? 🙄 I’ve got nothing negative to say about girls - but lots to say about smug mums of girls who make horrible comments about not having another baby for fear of having a boy 🙄. They’re weird and creepy.

THIS THIS THIS. Thank you for saying this.

Janus · 04/09/2025 19:54

My brother and I are in our 50s, we’ve both been extremely close to our Mum and Dad all our lives. Yes I guess I went to my mum a bit more when my kids were young, I live some distance away and before they started school I’d regularly go down for a week or so at a time. My mum looked after both my brothers children though when him and his wife worked during half terms and the summer holidays. My Dad passed away 18 months ago and my brother has gone in at least 5 times a week for a cuppa with her. I go down about once every 6 weeks for about 4 days. My brother is amazing and him and my mum have an amazing bond.
I have 4 children, 3 girls and a boy, my boy is the youngest and an absolute sweetheart. He knows when I’m sad and will always be there with a hug. Sometimes I just come home and he’s here and he just comes right over to me and says something like ‘I haven’t seen you today, I need a hug’ and he’s 14!
I love my girls and I love my boy. You will be so lucky to have both believe me.

ProfessorofCunning · 04/09/2025 19:35

I love my boys. I’m biased though as lost many pregnancies so I honestly didn’t care what they were when they were born. My husband and his brother are very close to their mum, so I think it’s more the dynamic your mum and brother have. I hope I’ve treated my boys with love and respect, that they wish to have me in their lives when they are adults, which the older ones very nearly are. My youngest will quite often come running into the room looking like he has something urgent to say “guess what? It’s really important you listen……I love you” and then will run out again, or randomly say “mummy I love you” in the middle of a conversation. I hope he continues as he becomes a teenager 😁
I love my mum, but only see her once or twice a month despite being only 20 minutes away. She doesn’t help with DC at all, and is much closer to my childless sister. It depends on the person and what they are like I guess. We see my in-laws a lot more, and go on holiday with them etc, despite them living over 300 miles away. My MIL is lovely, and I hope she feels I’ve become a part of her family, rather than taking her rather nice son away from her.

Openyoureyes102733 · 04/09/2025 19:33

OP I think you are getting an incredibly rough time due to people’s inability to empathise or try to understand how someone could be feeling.

You will love your little boy so so much when he arrives, don’t worry all children are different. I was TERRIFIED because of the little boys I knew.

You are pregnant and will not be rationale at the moment, surely those who have had children would understand that. Pregnancy is such a vulnerable and scary time regardless of if it’s your first second or 10th. Give yourself some grace.

It’s easy to let your mind spiral when you are worried or scared. Speaking to a therapist might help you to not feel overwhelmed.

The women here that are belittling and abusing this poor woman over a post - shame on you

PorridgeAndSyrup · 04/09/2025 19:30

BatchCookBabe · 03/09/2025 22:21

I bet it's the mums who say this isn't it? 🙄

Why do they need their son(s) to be really cuddly and affectionate?

This bizarre dynamic that (some) boy mums have is really bizarre! And I am cringing at anyone who brags that their son is cuddly and affectionate, and so much more so than their daughters.

Again, I feel sorry both for the daughters - and the sons in these cases...

Why do you assume they're making it up or imposing it on the child somehow, rather than describing their experience? I'd say you've got some hangups of your own there... (I don't have boys myself, although I was an au pair for a pair of kids and the boy was very cuddly with his mum and dad, that's just the way he was and I have no ulterior motive for describing him that way!)

Louoby · 04/09/2025 19:30

I have three boys. Aged 10, 4 and 3 and we have the closest bond. I love them all dearly and they are mummy’s boys. I appreciate as they get older they may stray further away than a daughter would however, the bond you create with them will allow them to know you’ll always be there. There’s no guarantee a daughter will stay close by. I know of a couple who are desperate for a child and are struggling and have been struggling to get pregnant for almost 4 years. Please just be grateful.🥲

Freud2 · 04/09/2025 19:14

I have only one child- born through IVF in my forties. I had a scan which showed the sex and remember feeling disappointed when they said it was a boy. I always wanted a girl for the same reasons you gave. However I was grateful to be having a baby at all and I soon adjusted my mind to having a boy. He's 27 now and the light of my life. He's kind and sensitive and brilliant company. He's hasn't met the love of his life yet and I must say I worry that I won't like his partner or she doesn't like me and that distance is put between us. You're very lucky that you already have a girl to be your best friend and with your son you'll have a different yet rewarding relationship. Try not to worry - you've a lot of interesting experiences to look forward to!

MyPeppyTurtle · 04/09/2025 19:09

Another perspective - when I fell pregnant, I honestly didn't care what I had. I was pregnant with twins. Cut a very long story short, one of my sons died at birth and was brought back by the neonatal team. He was in intensive care for four months and has ongoing health issues. So, when a mother isn't happy about having a boy or a girl, it really upsets me. Just prey that whatever you have lives a happy healthy life.

Wemdubz · 04/09/2025 18:57

IcedPurple · 04/09/2025 13:23

Of course the children will get to see it. The older ones very likely already have. Imagine growing up knowing that your parents' first reaction at your birth was not happiness at the arrival of a healthy baby, but extreme disappointment because you were the 'wrong' sex.

If I had been the show producer I'd have been reluctant to include that part,

I agree.
One of my colleagues last year came into work crying because her scan revealed she was having a second daughter when she’d wanted a son. She described herself over the following days as devastated, gutted, depressed. I had never seen someone look so miserable.
Fast forward to now and every day there’s a Facebook post about how she adores her daughter, is ‘obsessed’ with her (her words), her family unit is complete. And I don’t for one minute doubt this. But all I think about when I see her posts is how devastated she was on the day of the scan.

Waitingfordoggo · 04/09/2025 18:19

My DCs are late teens/young adults. I’m as close to my DS as I am to my DD. I actually have more in common with DS in terms of personality and interests.

As for adult DCs and their relationship with their parents, my DH is an extremely devoted son to his parents- he sees them several times a week, helps them out with things, and really enjoys their company. His brother is a bit more distant- they just have very different personalities. Equally I know plenty of women who aren’t close to their mums.

You just can’t predict how things will turn out.

ColdWaterDipper · 04/09/2025 17:57

You’re right, you will love him just the same when he arrives. Plus, boys are fab! I have all boys and wouldn’t want it any other way really (although I do joke with mine now they are tweens/teens about their imaginary sisters who would obviously always be behaving perfectly when the boys are wrestling or being general roustabouts and a bit boisterous). Mine are very sporty, loving, funny and clever - I always wanted boys anyway, but honestly they are great. My husband and his brother are very close to their parents, while their sister only visits their parents once a year at most and has a bit of a strained relationship. I’m probably equally close to my own parents (who due to distance I see far less often) and my in laws, who are lovely.

SpiritedFlame · 04/09/2025 17:52

One of my brothers is closer to my Mum than me (female). So I think it really does vary.

ishimbob · 04/09/2025 17:48

Ihavetoask · 04/09/2025 17:45

Yes totally. I think clothes today can find a good balance but I dont think there is anything wrong with teaching kids that not everywhere is a playground and some places you aren't as physically active as in others.

I don't personally think a kids party is that sort of place - usually they are quite physically active for social events

I have boys (the horror! Send help!) and I have no trouble getting them in a smart shirt and trousers for a wedding or a christening but I don't think of kids parties as in that category as I want them to be comfortable for the bouncy castle and similar

Ihavetoask · 04/09/2025 17:45

JambonetFromage · 04/09/2025 17:36

Or turn that around and see the problem as being that from a young age girls are encouraged to value looking pretty over being able to be comfortable, move about freely and run climb and jump?

So many times over the years I've been at things like soft play parties and girls are turning up wearing elaborate sequined dresses and parents are fussing about them not dropping ketchup on their posh frock.

Yes totally. I think clothes today can find a good balance but I dont think there is anything wrong with teaching kids that not everywhere is a playground and some places you aren't as physically active as in others.

JambonetFromage · 04/09/2025 17:36

Ihavetoask · 04/09/2025 16:52

no party dresses/skirts/cardies/shoes on top of the every day outfits…

Ive always noticed this. Parents turn up to a party with their daughters dressed to the nines in a special party dress, and their boys in a scruffy old tracksuit. They'll say its what the boys will wear because they want to play football at the christening, but they don't realise they created these norms. If they had always made sure their boys understood that you have to "dress up" for parties and wear clothes you don't ordinarily wear and slow down on the climbing and fighting, then they would be used to wearing nice party clothes.

It would also help men understand that they have to make an effort. How many women complain their male partner has no idea of appropriate dress code?

Or turn that around and see the problem as being that from a young age girls are encouraged to value looking pretty over being able to be comfortable, move about freely and run climb and jump?

So many times over the years I've been at things like soft play parties and girls are turning up wearing elaborate sequined dresses and parents are fussing about them not dropping ketchup on their posh frock.

Ihavetoask · 04/09/2025 16:52

MzHz · 04/09/2025 16:22

Boys are sooooooooo much cheaper and I dare say easier to please!

no party dresses/skirts/cardies/shoes on top of the every day outfits…

secret to boy management is BRING SNACKS. Make sure they’re kept busy, active and fed. That’s it.

my son is coming up for 20yo, about to start uni, lives at home now with his girlfriend who we took in too.

not going to say it was all plain sailing, 15-17yo was a challenge as he wanted more freedom than I was personally comfortable with, but we worked through it and now he’s back being the charming, respectful young man he’d always been

i get hugs every time I see him, proper hugs and I love yous. We’ve had a tough time recently as he lost a friend to drugs, but it’s made us closer and helped him refind himself somehow. Make time to check in with him. Make sure he’s doing okay mentally. Be the safe haven.

boys are an absolute blessing. You have to be clear with behaviour tho, no backchat, criticism of behaviour not person, be fair, be reasonable and overall, a benign dictator in the formative years to make sure the fundamentals are all in place.

congrats 🥳

no party dresses/skirts/cardies/shoes on top of the every day outfits…

Ive always noticed this. Parents turn up to a party with their daughters dressed to the nines in a special party dress, and their boys in a scruffy old tracksuit. They'll say its what the boys will wear because they want to play football at the christening, but they don't realise they created these norms. If they had always made sure their boys understood that you have to "dress up" for parties and wear clothes you don't ordinarily wear and slow down on the climbing and fighting, then they would be used to wearing nice party clothes.

It would also help men understand that they have to make an effort. How many women complain their male partner has no idea of appropriate dress code?

HeartbrokenCatMum · 04/09/2025 16:48

Boys are awesome to raise, mine are so loving, funny, affectionate, kind, well behaved etc. Raise and shape them to be close to you, have shared interests, be affectionate with them.

MzHz · 04/09/2025 16:22

Boys are sooooooooo much cheaper and I dare say easier to please!

no party dresses/skirts/cardies/shoes on top of the every day outfits…

secret to boy management is BRING SNACKS. Make sure they’re kept busy, active and fed. That’s it.

my son is coming up for 20yo, about to start uni, lives at home now with his girlfriend who we took in too.

not going to say it was all plain sailing, 15-17yo was a challenge as he wanted more freedom than I was personally comfortable with, but we worked through it and now he’s back being the charming, respectful young man he’d always been

i get hugs every time I see him, proper hugs and I love yous. We’ve had a tough time recently as he lost a friend to drugs, but it’s made us closer and helped him refind himself somehow. Make time to check in with him. Make sure he’s doing okay mentally. Be the safe haven.

boys are an absolute blessing. You have to be clear with behaviour tho, no backchat, criticism of behaviour not person, be fair, be reasonable and overall, a benign dictator in the formative years to make sure the fundamentals are all in place.

congrats 🥳

WhereIsMyJumper · 04/09/2025 16:13

I have one DS. I can’t speak on behalf of all boys, obviously - he is nearly 8 and very affectionate and also very calm. He’s actually a total angel.

typicaltuesdaynight · 04/09/2025 16:08

Mum of 2 ds one just turned 19 one ds 8 I have the closest relationship with both my boys . We do loads of fun stuff together I can’t imagine why it would be any different if I had girls

ZoeCM · 04/09/2025 15:56

IcedPurple · 04/09/2025 15:05

I remember reading an interview with Naomi Watts some years ago, where she said she'd only have a 3rd child if she could guarantee a girl (she has two sons). Well, what do you know, her younger boy is now a 'girl'. Funny that.

Something similar happened on MN several years ago. A mother of three sons was desperate for a girl and asked for advice on adopting one. She didn't want to try to conceive naturally again in case the baby was another boy. MN told her that no adoption agency would approve a couple who only wanted a girl. A few months later, the same poster returned, asking for advice on her three-year-old "daughter", who had recently realised "she" was trans.

The affirmation of gender disappointment on parenting forums is dangerous. People are increasingly talking about "GD" as though it's some sort of infertility diagnosis, when really it's mostly just entitlement. A few years ago, a psychiatrist went to the press about the number of parents he'd seen at the Tavistock who were claiming their young child was transgender when it was obvious that they just had gender disappointment. Society needs to stop sticking its head in the sand. Gender disappointment should not be indulged.

Ihavetoask · 04/09/2025 15:49

IcedPurple · 04/09/2025 15:10

Yes, and in at least 9 out of 10 cases, the 'trans kid' was born a boy.

I think its about 50/50.

Ihavetoask · 04/09/2025 15:48

labooboo · 04/09/2025 15:41

I know this is lighthearted but I do wonder when I see some of the young transgender men about their parents. They had a little girl who now has a deep voice and full facial hair and a boys names. It must be difficult to get your head round.

It really isnt. It's pervasive in the parents of TIP (trans identified people)