Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a little heartbroken about having a boy

408 replies

bm2b · 03/09/2025 20:52

I already have a daughter and recently found out that this baby is a boy. I feel incredibly grateful to be pregnant again, and I know how lucky I am to be carrying a healthy baby. I already love him, and I know I’ll adore him completely when he arrives. But I’ve been caught off guard by this quiet feeling of sadness that I didn’t expect.

I’m very close to my mum. We speak every day, go on little trips together, help each other out, and are part of each other’s daily lives. I’ve started to build something similar with my daughter, even though she’s still young, and I suppose I imagined continuing that dynamic with another girl.

With a boy, I’m not sure what that relationship will look like in the long term. In so many families I’ve seen, sons gradually become more distant from their parents as they get older, especially once they have partners and children of their own. It often ends up being the wife’s parents who are more involved, while his own mum becomes more of an occasional visitor.

Of course there are exceptions. I can think of the odd “friend of a friend’s cousin” whose son stayed close and prioritised both sides of the family equally, or doesn’t automatically side with his partner when she’s being unfair. But in my experience, that feels like the exception rather than the norm.

I also worry about what raising a boy will be like day to day. I know it’s a stereotype, but the boys I’ve been around — nephews, friends’ kids — tend to be more energetic, more physical, and more chaotic. I’m a bit afraid I won’t enjoy that stage as much, or that I won’t know how to connect with him in the same way.

If anyone has felt this way too, I’d love to hear from you. Especially mums of older boys — did the bond end up being just as close, even if it looked a bit different? What parts of having a son surprised you in a good way?

OP posts:
Hedgehogbrown · 03/09/2025 21:32

Maray1967 · 03/09/2025 21:24

I have two sons, 25 and 17, and I have never wished they were girls. The eldest has moved out and yes, he and GF do live closer to her parents, but we see them plenty and they both seem keen to come here. They do both houses on Christmas Day!

I loved Star Wars light sabre battles in the garden, nerf gun parties, taking several boys to Alton Towers.

What I am glad I have not had to deal with (as most of my friends with DDs have) are endless fallings out with friends and associated dramas.

And yes, they are stereotypes, but I don’t know a single DM/DD who spent hours in the garden acting out Star Wars scenes like we did.

My advice based on observation of a relationship I know well is … don’t say in the presence of your DS that you really wanted another girl. It does not work out well.

Yes because girls can't have nerf guns or go to Alton Towers.

Redburnett · 03/09/2025 21:32

Boys are great and I am sure you will be helping to make a decent man for the future (unlike the many not so decent men we read about on MN).

Birthoptionss · 03/09/2025 21:31

Hi, I’m a mum to three boys (all under the age of 5). When I was pregnant with my first, I really wanted a girl. Everything changed once my eldest was born and by the second I was hoping for another boy and by the third I was practically begging for it to be another boy. I’m very girly and everybody always seems so shocked to hear that I genuinely wasn’t ‘going for the girl’, this is truly because boys are the bloody best. I adore them and they are my pride and absolute joy. Your feelings will drastically change.

HedwigIsMySpiritAnimal · 03/09/2025 21:31

Dundonia · 03/09/2025 21:01

I kind of get it. I have two girls. I’m not having any more children but a big factor in that is that I don’t really want a boy. I know there are exceptions and it’s not a hard and fast rule but a lot of the time what you describe about future relationships is pretty spot on.

“Boy moms” (you know, the weird and creepy ones, not all mums of boys) make me roll my eyes. I’m getting this in before they descend on this thread and start putting down little girls (rather than talking about the wonders of little boys).

Edited

What the fuck is a “weird and creepy” boy mum? 🙄 I’ve got nothing negative to say about girls - but lots to say about smug mums of girls who make horrible comments about not having another baby for fear of having a boy 🙄. They’re weird and creepy.

Enigma54 · 03/09/2025 21:31

Heartbroken? Really? OP, we are talking human life, the greatest gift. It’s a privilege to be able to bring life into the world, not a right. I speak as a parent of a girl and a boy. My DS ( now 17) is smart, witty and hard working. DD the same. Both are unique and I adore them
both. You will too.

marchmash · 03/09/2025 21:30

Fully agree with the last poster: it's a person! I think birth order plays as much a role as sex (e.g. older one is more achieving, people pleasing and second one is more questioning and controversial). Have to say that adolescence has been much harder with my DD! My DS was very sweet and not hectic/super active as a kid, he was more into trains and lego etc. I got irritated with the ridiculous comments about 'boy' things and 'girl' things. I think it's nice to have one of both, or two of one, or whatever. Don't let stupid stereotypes bother you. I did really want a girl and my DH wanted a boy, how does your partner feel? Presumably he is also happy to have one of each?

Mummyto3ginismyfriend · 03/09/2025 21:30

I felt the same gender disappointment.
My first baby was a boy and still born.
I then went on to have 2 more planned babies. Both were boys. I was disappointed when the youngest was a boy. I then had a surprise baby and that turned out to be my daughter.
I'm the closest to my middle child, my loving caring, sweet boy. My eldest son is wonderful too but more distant (although he is a teenager now)
My daughter is also wonderful but is a daddy's girl and much closer to him. She is also autistic and I had the same fears about the boys leaving and getting closer to their spouses parents etc.
I don't know if DD will ever have the marriage and life we envision for our daughters. But I've come to peace that I will always be there for all 3 and try to encourage a close bond no matter what.
What I'm trying to say is that you cannot control what sort of relationship you'll have with any of your children no matter what their gender and you love them no matter what genitals they have.

ucandmykids · 03/09/2025 21:30

Boys are the best. He’ll be so much more loving than your dd believe me

AboogaBooga · 03/09/2025 21:29

bm2b · 03/09/2025 21:15

Yes, I have a brother and a sister. My sister is really close to our mum — they talk every day, go shopping together, and she always invites her to the kids’ events or just over for a chat “because she was nearby.” They have this natural, everyday closeness in the same way I do with her.

My brother’s relationship with our mum is very different. He’s not distant or unkind, but everything is more formal and a bit hands-off. Any visits are arranged well in advance and usually come with a time slot, “we can do Sunday, but just from 12 to 3.” And I know his wife doesn’t appreciate it when my mum “oversteps” by bringing food or asking if she should help with pickups. Meanwhile, his wife’s parents are round all the time — her mum picks the kids up from school, drops off little meals, even goes on holiday with them. Our mum doesn’t get that same level of access. I know my brother asked about mum coming to one of the kids’ plays and the wife said there’s not enough tickets - her parents went.

It’s the same story in my husband’s family. He has a sister who’s incredibly close to their mum — constant calls, spontaneous visits etc. My husband’s relationship with her is friendly, but distant by comparison. And not because he doesn’t care, but just because he’s not as naturally in that rhythm, he’s busy with work and in all honesty I find her a bit overstepping when she does some things my mum does, and some things she does with her own daughter. I think everyone is just more welcoming of their own mum.

And I think that’s the case in most families I’ve seen — the woman tends to set the tone for how involved grandparents are, and understandably, she leans toward her own side. So yes, seeing that dynamic play out in both of our families (and most friends) does shape how I’m feeling now. Not because I think boys love their mums any less but because I’m afraid I just won’t get to stay as close.

So you’re projecting your own shitty view of your MIL onto your unborn sons hypothetical future wife and how she will feel towards you.

Maybe now is a good time to reflect and show some empathy to your MIL and be a little more welcoming. There is not a written law anywhere that says this is how it has to be. Do better now, and maybe your son won’t push you out in the future.

Hedgehogbrown · 03/09/2025 21:29

I understand what you are saying about being an in law when your son is married, but what you say about boys being more energetic is nonsense. Do you think girls just sit there and sew? Out of all my niblings it's the girls who enjoy rough and tumble and outdoors more. Everyone is different, and these stereotypes are really damaging to girls. Girls often end up that way because their parents expect them to be more meek and polite and put pressure on them from a young age.

You don't have to stereotype your children. Don't put him in grey every day, don't allow boisterous behaviour of you don't allow it in your daughter, don't force him to do 'boy' things.

Flopsyturvy · 03/09/2025 21:28

I know I shouldn’t have clicked on it but I absolutely hate these posts.
I really can’t fathom gender disappointment. Everything you talked about mimicking the relationship with your mum - what if your daughter doesn’t want that kind of relationship with you in the future? She’s her own person regardless of her gender and expected duties as your daughter. Same goes for your future son.
I just think GD is one of the most self-centred issues I read about on here.

Kimmeridge · 03/09/2025 21:27

Ffs you haven't even given birth to this child yet and youre worried about your relationship once hes married. Do you realise how ridiculous that sounds

KawasakiBabe · 03/09/2025 21:25

I have a boy 23, and a girl, 19, I’m just as close yo my boy as I am to my girl. He’s amazing and a blessing.HTH

GreyPearlSatin · 03/09/2025 21:25

Whatever you're building with your daughter you should build with your son. Your kids will individuals, so it will never be exactly the same (even if the youngest had been a girl). But please love them both equally for who they are as people.

blackberryhill · 03/09/2025 21:25

SJ198 · 03/09/2025 21:18

With a boy, I’m not sure what that relationship will look like in the long term. In so many families I’ve seen, sons gradually become more distant from their parents as they get older

Goodness you are writing this like your relationship with your son is in no way in your hands? I think mothers who assume they will be closer to their DDs and more distant from their DS’s often end up with a self fulfilling prophecy to be honest. Surely you can continue that dynamic with a boy?

You said it better than I could. OP, your son isn't even here yet and you've already decided that you're he's not going to be as close to you as your daughter is and that he'll become more distant from you as he gets older. You're pushing him away before he's even here. Have you ever considered that all of those men who aren't as close to their mothers as their sisters are ended up less close to their mothers because from an early age their mothers prioritised their relationships with their daughters over their sons? Is there any time for your brother if your mum is always on the phone and put shopping with you and your sister and your kids?

pinenuts75 · 03/09/2025 21:25

I have two sons and I wanted my youngest to be a girl, but I certainly wasn’t heartbroken he was a boy, the main thing is he was healthy and alive! I don’t know how anyone could be heartbroken of the sex of their child.

Maray1967 · 03/09/2025 21:24

I have two sons, 25 and 17, and I have never wished they were girls. The eldest has moved out and yes, he and GF do live closer to her parents, but we see them plenty and they both seem keen to come here. They do both houses on Christmas Day!

I loved Star Wars light sabre battles in the garden, nerf gun parties, taking several boys to Alton Towers.

What I am glad I have not had to deal with (as most of my friends with DDs have) are endless fallings out with friends and associated dramas.

And yes, they are stereotypes, but I don’t know a single DM/DD who spent hours in the garden acting out Star Wars scenes like we did.

My advice based on observation of a relationship I know well is … don’t say in the presence of your DS that you really wanted another girl. It does not work out well.

Mustbethat · 03/09/2025 21:23

Floundering66 · 03/09/2025 21:11

I am super close to my mum - talk everyday, always planning things together, she’s my best friend and I can’t spend enough time with her. I actually think it’s very simplistic to think if I had a girl I would automatically have a copy of that relationship. Your daughter could decide to travel to Australia at 20, meet the love of her life and never come home - your son could live ten minutes from you and be round your house with his family every Sunday for dinner (this is what happened to a colleague of mine).
I have a little boy (who I adore!) when I first found out I was having a boy I had some feelings of “no girly shopping trips” “no spa days” … but I wasn't disappointed. He’s perfect 🥰

And that’s why I don’t get on with my mum. She has visions of spa days and shopping, I hate them. We have very little in common, and she spent the majority of my childhood trying to stop me doing what I enjoyed- sport, animals, being active, and trying to persuade me i needed to go shopping for new clothes, let’s go and get our eyebrows done….

dh on the other hand gets on really well with his mum.

he also loves clothes and fashion, so it’s him who takes our dc clothes shopping.

i think the boys growing away from their families is self fulfilling. Mums keep girls closer and bring them up to enjoy girly things. They make less effort with boys because they think they have nothing in common, they don’t like football, or they split off into genders, dad takes boy, mum takes girl.

then they’re surprised when their boys move on.

Floundering66 · 03/09/2025 21:23

bm2b · 03/09/2025 21:15

Yes, I have a brother and a sister. My sister is really close to our mum — they talk every day, go shopping together, and she always invites her to the kids’ events or just over for a chat “because she was nearby.” They have this natural, everyday closeness in the same way I do with her.

My brother’s relationship with our mum is very different. He’s not distant or unkind, but everything is more formal and a bit hands-off. Any visits are arranged well in advance and usually come with a time slot, “we can do Sunday, but just from 12 to 3.” And I know his wife doesn’t appreciate it when my mum “oversteps” by bringing food or asking if she should help with pickups. Meanwhile, his wife’s parents are round all the time — her mum picks the kids up from school, drops off little meals, even goes on holiday with them. Our mum doesn’t get that same level of access. I know my brother asked about mum coming to one of the kids’ plays and the wife said there’s not enough tickets - her parents went.

It’s the same story in my husband’s family. He has a sister who’s incredibly close to their mum — constant calls, spontaneous visits etc. My husband’s relationship with her is friendly, but distant by comparison. And not because he doesn’t care, but just because he’s not as naturally in that rhythm, he’s busy with work and in all honesty I find her a bit overstepping when she does some things my mum does, and some things she does with her own daughter. I think everyone is just more welcoming of their own mum.

And I think that’s the case in most families I’ve seen — the woman tends to set the tone for how involved grandparents are, and understandably, she leans toward her own side. So yes, seeing that dynamic play out in both of our families (and most friends) does shape how I’m feeling now. Not because I think boys love their mums any less but because I’m afraid I just won’t get to stay as close.

I don’t think this is the norm, we see both sides equally and have just been away with my husband’s parents. I’ve just booked a Christmas trip with my husband’s parents too. I have eight close friends with young children and every single one of them makes sure they spend time with their in-laws!

Bathingforest · 03/09/2025 21:23

Not a great thread. Are you pro choice because the vibe of your thread is evil

Woody617 · 03/09/2025 21:22

All I ever wanted was a son. I find threads like this weird.

It felt like I’d won the lottery when I was told at the scan that my baby was a boy. It was the best feeling ever.

Parker231 · 03/09/2025 21:22

bm2b · 03/09/2025 20:52

I already have a daughter and recently found out that this baby is a boy. I feel incredibly grateful to be pregnant again, and I know how lucky I am to be carrying a healthy baby. I already love him, and I know I’ll adore him completely when he arrives. But I’ve been caught off guard by this quiet feeling of sadness that I didn’t expect.

I’m very close to my mum. We speak every day, go on little trips together, help each other out, and are part of each other’s daily lives. I’ve started to build something similar with my daughter, even though she’s still young, and I suppose I imagined continuing that dynamic with another girl.

With a boy, I’m not sure what that relationship will look like in the long term. In so many families I’ve seen, sons gradually become more distant from their parents as they get older, especially once they have partners and children of their own. It often ends up being the wife’s parents who are more involved, while his own mum becomes more of an occasional visitor.

Of course there are exceptions. I can think of the odd “friend of a friend’s cousin” whose son stayed close and prioritised both sides of the family equally, or doesn’t automatically side with his partner when she’s being unfair. But in my experience, that feels like the exception rather than the norm.

I also worry about what raising a boy will be like day to day. I know it’s a stereotype, but the boys I’ve been around — nephews, friends’ kids — tend to be more energetic, more physical, and more chaotic. I’m a bit afraid I won’t enjoy that stage as much, or that I won’t know how to connect with him in the same way.

If anyone has felt this way too, I’d love to hear from you. Especially mums of older boys — did the bond end up being just as close, even if it looked a bit different? What parts of having a son surprised you in a good way?

I have DT’s - b/g - perfect combination imo. They are now mid 20’s and our relationship is equally strong with DD and DS. I don’t understand why it would be any different. DS contacts us and visits as much as DD. They were brought up the same way. If you treat them differently, your relationship will be different.

SharkPants · 03/09/2025 21:21

I already have a daughter and when I became pregnant, I did not find out whether my baby was a boy or a girl.
When I had him in hospital, they held him up to me and I saw that he was a boy, I was in absolute shock, I don't know why, it was always obviously 50:50. Initially, I felt a bit sad that my daughter wouldn't have the same bond that my sister and I share. But she and her little brother couldn't be closer.
Everything you have said about little boys is true about my son; he's extremely energetic, chaotic and very mischievous. But honestly, the love he gives is the best. He is so gorgeous. Today was his first day of school and I'm so proud of the little person he is and to be a boy mum.
You will love your son and will have the most precious bond, you have so much to look forward to and do not waste time worrying about the future, I know so many men who still adore their mums.

Squishymallows · 03/09/2025 21:21

I have a boy and 2 girls. My boy is SO incredibly loving and says the sweetest things!! I feel like as a grown up he will call me all the time and never stop giving me cuddles even when he’s 30!

but yes he is chaotic and messy and loud and energetic and NEVER runs out of energy

Swipe left for the next trending thread