Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry with people who describe the old age pension as a "benefit"?

578 replies

FlubandSlub · 01/09/2025 15:08

When I started my working life, aged 16, I entered into an agreement with the government for them to save my pension money for me. It was stated that it would be until I turned 60 which would be when I could starting drawing my old age pension. Even though I made my FULL pension payment contributions by the time I turned 51 the government has decided it will not abide by the original agreement and that it is going to keep MY money until I am 67. Probably hoping I will die before then.

Consider this, not only did I contribute to my pension, my employer did too. It totalled 15% of my income before taxes. If you averaged only £15 000 p a. over your working life, that's close to £220,500. Read that again. Did you see anywhere that the Government paid in one single penny?

We are talking about the money that I and my employer put in a Government bank to ensure that I would have a retirement pension. It was not money that the Government had any right to spend on other things! Upon reaching the age to take it back they've started to call the money we paid in a "benefit" !

If you calculate the future invested value of £2500 per year (yours & your employer's contribution) at a simple 5% interest (that's less than what the govtpays on the money that it borrows from overseas), after 49 years of working you'd have
£892,919.98.

This money was supposed to be in a securely locked box, not to be used as part of the Government's general funds.
Successive governments borrowed the money to spend on other things but that doesn't make my pension some kind of charity or handout!! If a private pension company did this we would sue them. Unfortunately the Government can legally rob us blind and get away with it

IT'S MY MONEY! IT IS NOT A BENEFIT!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
superdup · 01/09/2025 23:31

Lifestooshort71 · 01/09/2025 20:22

Was this quite a while ago? I was cut off by some jobsworth from the Pension Service because I refused to refer to my pension a benefit - he rather snottily said thst he wouldn't engage with me again until I accepted it was a benefit. I wouldn't so there wasn't any point ringing them back. I can still remember how angry I felt being spoken to as though I was some schoolgirl (even though I was being a tad childish).

It was a few years ago now but it’s not changed. Unfortunately the people the DWP employ on the phones tend to be ‘street to seat’ whereas when I started (I was there for quite a long time), we had 13 weeks training!

TheArtfulNavyDreamer · 01/09/2025 23:07

Surely the actual issue is that it was set up by the government on the basis that you put in and you will receive when you retire but when it’s not actually invested and is based upon economy and government spending at some point it will fail and the people who have paid in will not receive a state pension. It’s a bad design that only works in a growing economy. I also think it’s frustrating when it’s described as a benefit as technically if they hadn’t taken that percentage and people had invested then it would achieve said pension for them and they wouldn’t be accused of being a drain on the economy that they’ve paid into all their lives. Otherwise just call it income tax rather than national insurance.

Outofmilkagain · 01/09/2025 22:46

Each person can check their own state pension information here

Date due to be paid
How much due to be paid - However some people can claim other money on top, depending on their circumstances
Eg
Pension credit
Rent for accommodation
Council tax reduction
Attendance allowance

www.gov.uk/check-state-pension

PreciousLittleLifeForms · 01/09/2025 22:44

LBFseBrom · 01/09/2025 22:41

You are 100% correct and I, as a pensioner, do not understand why some pensioners resent the word 'benefit', when they do benefit! I was happy to pay contributions while working and am now happily receiving my state pension. What's the problem?

because they see people who claim benefits as scroungers. They dont want to be lumped in with that group

Outofmilkagain · 01/09/2025 22:42

Each person can view their own National Insurance record here

It shows each individual year
It shows
Fully paid
Part paid
No payment
So if a person worked or claimed benefits the info is here

https://www.gov.uk/check-national-insurance-record

Check your National Insurance record

Find out if you've paid enough National Insurance to qualify for the full State Pension - check gaps, contributions and credits, get a National Insurance statement, call the helpline.

https://www.gov.uk/check-national-insurance-record

LBFseBrom · 01/09/2025 22:41

Waterbaby41 · 01/09/2025 22:38

The simple face is the State Pension is - and always had been - a contributory benefit. And it has always been the case that current contributions from current tax payers pay for the State Pension. Nothing in your rant acknowledges those fundamental facts.

You are 100% correct and I, as a pensioner, do not understand why some pensioners resent the word 'benefit', when they do benefit! I was happy to pay contributions while working and am now happily receiving my state pension. What's the problem?

Waterbaby41 · 01/09/2025 22:38

The simple face is the State Pension is - and always had been - a contributory benefit. And it has always been the case that current contributions from current tax payers pay for the State Pension. Nothing in your rant acknowledges those fundamental facts.

PreciousLittleLifeForms · 01/09/2025 22:32

JG24 · 01/09/2025 21:57

It is a benefit. There's nothing wrong with being on benefits of you need them. That's what they are there for.

Yes it is a benefit. What does your bank statement say if you claim pension? Does it say DWP? Because I am on Universal Credit and it says the same.
We are the same. We are getting benefits from DWP.

No shame in it. I do think people try and separate it as they think people on UC are workshy scroungers.

rainingsnoring · 01/09/2025 22:27

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 01/09/2025 22:06

Can we ask also for patronising as shit thread policing posts to be taken down? 😉

The other poster is correct. The initial post is both stupid and steaming with anger so I can't blame the responder for being a bit patronising.

SouthernNights59 · 01/09/2025 22:26

DolphinOnASkateboard · 01/09/2025 16:57

I've seen this exact post doing the rounds on Facebook. Copied and pasted nonsense. It really is extraordinary how many people (my mother included) have absolutely no understanding of how pensions of any kind work, never mind the state one.

Maybe because it's such a complicated sounding system is why people like your mother and the OP get so confused.

Where I live we just pay straightforward tax, and it goes towards everything.

Completely off topic, how I hate the word "pension", it sounds so old fashioned and when combined with "old age" it makes me shudder. 😬

rainingsnoring · 01/09/2025 22:25

Sorry @FlubandSlub but it's a benefit. You can be as angry as you like but it doesn't change the facts.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 01/09/2025 22:06

AnnaQuayInTheUk · 01/09/2025 15:11

You really don't understand how the state pension works.

Read up on it and educate yourself. If you understood how it worked, you'd understand that it's not your money. You haven't made any contract with the government.

In the meantime, you should ask for your post to be taken down.

Edited

Can we ask also for patronising as shit thread policing posts to be taken down? 😉

atamlin · 01/09/2025 22:06

Why are you so defensive about receiving a benefit? It doesn’t mark you out as “less than”.

Hotflushesandchilblains · 01/09/2025 22:05

I get that it is disappointing if you thought you would retire at 60 and the age went up. But so has everyones. Mine has gone up twice in my working life and I expect it to go up again before I actually retire. I never understood why women got to retire earlier anyway, and the claims that people did not know about the changes does not ring true.

WorriedRelative · 01/09/2025 22:03

NI doesn't just pay for the state pension. You are forgetting, the NHS, contributions based benefits, maternity allowance, and social care for starters.

More than 50% of households take out more than they contribute.

suburburban · 01/09/2025 22:02

Portakalkedi · 01/09/2025 21:58

Well, surely state pension IS a benefit for those who have not worked or contributed. For those of us who have worked and paid in all our lives it's no less than what we expect to receive by having paid such contributions for many years (not that we had much choice).

Yes exactly

I’m sure if I hadn’t gone back to work in the 00s when ED was 6 my n.i. Stamp wouldn’t have been paid and I would’ve had to pay extra N.I. Contributions

Portakalkedi · 01/09/2025 21:58

Well, surely state pension IS a benefit for those who have not worked or contributed. For those of us who have worked and paid in all our lives it's no less than what we expect to receive by having paid such contributions for many years (not that we had much choice).

JG24 · 01/09/2025 21:57

It is a benefit. There's nothing wrong with being on benefits of you need them. That's what they are there for.

Outofmilkagain · 01/09/2025 21:52

National Insurance not only pays for State pensions, but for other benefits too. It goes into a big pot for communal use.

Pot pays for

Job seekers
Maternity
Child benefit
Non working people
NHS

People also have the opportunity to pay into a private pension too.

Hoardasauruskaren · 01/09/2025 21:50

KeepOnKeepingOn25 · 01/09/2025 16:21

Does anyone know there is an agency that can advise on pensions? I’m not sure but maybe the CAB do this?

I’ve been a bit worried that I won’t qualify for a state pension as a full time mum I don’t pay NI and struggle with chronic illness so not sure if/ how I will manage to re enter taxable employment. I assume disabled people still qualify for state pension though? I kind of assumed I might get something but reading this is maybe wishful thinking 😞. Sorry to derail the thread and thanks in advance for any replies x

Do you claim Child Benefit? You will get NI credits for the years you claim Child Benefit. Certain disability benefits such as Employment Support Allowance also give you NI credits. PIP or DLA do not as they are not means tested.

RoamingToaster · 01/09/2025 21:40

I wonder how common this view is. My mother holds it. I mentioned once the issues countries face with a growing retired population, and she seemed confused as she thought like the OP that that money was saved away somewhere.

SerendipityJane · 01/09/2025 21:39

“When I started my working life, aged 16, I entered into an agreement with the government for them to save my pension money for me.”

That agreement has been varied every single election since. With the publics consent. Because - shock horror - that's how things work.

Existentialistic · 01/09/2025 21:38

OP - I think you need to re-educate yourself on the welfare state - it’s definitely not a savings bank, but a “social security” system and is paid for by the working population for the most vulnerable in society (including the elderly). I agree with you about lack of fairness, like you I’ll be waiting until 67, despite working (or studying) for over 45 years and never claiming benefits. Our adult children will probably have to wait until age 70 at least. We’re all living longer than our parents’ and grandparents’ generations so something has to give. I also think it’s right that men and women have an equal retirement age - we can’t expect to retire several years before men and yet still be seen as equals - society doesn’t work like that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread