Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want ex involved in uni drop-off?

615 replies

stripycats · 30/08/2025 12:07

I am very aware I may be UR here so I would like to know what others think, especially if they have dropped dc off at university and are divorced.

Ds is going somewhere that is a 4 hour round trip away. He lives with me around 80% of the time and ex no longer drives due to a medical issue. Therefore, it has been a non-issue that I will be dropping off ds and for me it will be quite a challenging day. Obviously I'm immensely proud of ds and happy and excited for him that he's going to his first choice university and starting the next phase of his life. But this is tinged with sadness that he is leaving and I am going to miss him terribly.

We were discussing the plans yesterday and he mentioned his dad perhaps wanting to come and be involved. This completely took me aback as it had not occurred to me that he would be. Drop offs are, from what I've read, quite hectic (it's a city location) with not much time for hanging around. On a practical level I don't think it will work to be arranging to meet ex and having to factor that in. Moreover, I am absolutely not prepared to take him in the car. We are civil when required but barely speak. He has behaved in ways that are very hard for me to forgive, the details of which ds is of course unaware. But the thought of having him in the car on this difficult day is unbearable to me, especially on the way back when I would be otherwise on my own and am planning a good cry! Graduations, weddings etc - no issue at all and completely different. I will sit with him if needed, or not, and there will be no issue. But this is different.

I told ds I didn't think it would work him being there and he said maybe not but it wasn't up to me, which is fair enough to an extent. He said he isn't going to bring it up to his dad, but if his dad asks he isn't going to tell him he can't come. I get that but I honestly don't see the point. However, I didn't press that but did say I wasn't giving him a lift. Ds seemed fine with that and there are good train connections between the two places and ex travels by train a lot, so it should be fine. But I am just so worried on the day he will say something about the trains being a nightmare or there will be engineering works and I will end up having to offer a lift back. Without saying he categorically can't come I can't prevent that from happening.

So AIBU to say he can't come?

OP posts:
Kelly1969 · 01/09/2025 22:08

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 01/09/2025 19:44

It is my opinion that lying to one's children is generally a mistake.

And if it would be a lie to pretend an ex was a fine chap and there is nothing the matter with him, divorcing him was just an impulse decision made for no reason, why are mothers always expected to do it?

totally agree, there is some seriously molly coddled adults on here who still think they’re the centre of the universe and that they’re parents should all be playing happy families to appease them!

Lockdownsceptic · 01/09/2025 21:59

It strikes me you are making a lot of unnecessary fuss about this. It is not the big event you think it is and it’s not your event in any case. Drop offs are exactly that and I’d be surprised if there was any need for you to stay longer than the time it takes to carry everything into your son’s new room.
If ds wants his dad there then you shouldn’t get in the way. It’s churlish to say you won’t drive him. If all four of you go you won’t have to be alone in the car on the way back.
That said, I suggest your ds would be far better off going on his own by train. You can always see him off at the station and go home for a good cry.

sugarapplelane · 01/09/2025 21:27

Saladbrains · 01/09/2025 18:28

“… but I don’t badmouth him [the ex]”

You don’t realise it but you have repeatedly bad-mouthed your sons’ father in these posts.

Over and over and over.

You don’t realise you’re doing it…

But only to us here on this forum.
Op hasn’t bad mouthed ex to her sons

Come on - mumsnet is here for people to vent where they can’t otherwise in real life. You should know this.If you don’t I’m a bit gobsmacked.

InterIgnis · 01/09/2025 21:18

Millytante · 01/09/2025 21:11

Fair enough. :-)
I hope all the uncertainty re his dad’s attending will urgently be ironed out, and a concrete order of events agreed, not least that no transport can be offered, even if all the train drivers stage a lightning strike.
Setting OP’s mind at rest on that key point would greatly improve matters.

(It’s a task for the son which he might not fancy a lot, but only he can bring it off really. It’s a ‘bite the bullet’ chat with his dad maybe, but he’ll be all the better having managed it. )

It already has been, at least between OP and her son. She knows her ex may be attending, and that no one is asking her to do anything to help him either get there or get home. The plans OP has with her son haven’t changed.

Anything beyond that is between him and his father 🤷🏻‍♀️ they’ll sort it or they won’t, but either way it’s not something OP needs to concern herself with.

InterIgnis · 01/09/2025 21:15

Millytante · 01/09/2025 21:03

I’m well aware I’m not in sync with most posters in this discussion.

I don’t want to carry on pissing them off, but as a last gasp, I’ll just reiterate that I strongly reject the idea that this lad’s wants and needs on any day less glorious (or even solemn) than his wedding/ installation as Archbishop of York/ reception at the Palace for a gong are more important than the high emotional turmoil affecting his mother.
I said elsewhere that I think it’s she who should be gently prioritised in arranging the trip, since she is the person enduring a loss, whereas the son is off to sunlit uplands and gaiety, we hope.
Nobody’s suggesting she be ‘kid gloved’ etc, but neither should she be dismissed as deserving no consideration.

Indeed I’d say it’s nobody’s personal ‘day’ at all, in terms of anyone as good as wearing a crown, the cynosure of all eyes (as seems to be the prevailing vibe), but rather an exciting milestone involving this new student (and truly, many hurrahs to him for getting this uni place) and his mum equally, and if his dad joins them in a way that will not marr either’s enjoyment of the send off, then hurrah again.
I just think there’s way too much pressure and expectation of bells and whistles in the air for them all.

Her son going to Uni isn’t about her. Her feelings of loss are not the responsibility of her son, or something he needs to centre, on his first day at Uni. As excited as he may be, he may also be nervous and anxious himself, and wants his father there as well as his mother. This is very much his choice and not hers, as he’s very plainly told her.

He’s not prioritizing either parent above the other, and nor is it reasonable to ask him to. OP is responsible for managing her own feelings, as her ex is responsible for managing his. Their feelings are not their son’s burden to carry.

Millytante · 01/09/2025 21:11

InterIgnis · 01/09/2025 20:43

I didn’t get the impression he’s cowed by his mother either, tbf. The impression I got is that he’s not open to discussing it further with her.

It also doesn’t sound like he’s asking her to be ultra festive, or even particularly congenial with her ex. He’s just said that his father may there on the drop off day.

Fair enough. :-)
I hope all the uncertainty re his dad’s attending will urgently be ironed out, and a concrete order of events agreed, not least that no transport can be offered, even if all the train drivers stage a lightning strike.
Setting OP’s mind at rest on that key point would greatly improve matters.

(It’s a task for the son which he might not fancy a lot, but only he can bring it off really. It’s a ‘bite the bullet’ chat with his dad maybe, but he’ll be all the better having managed it. )

Millytante · 01/09/2025 21:03

InterIgnis · 01/09/2025 20:38

Ironically, the only person making a big thing of this is OP. No one has asked her to give her ex a lift.

Posters are insisting that it’s his day because, well, it is. What plans he makes with his father are between him and his father, not between the three of them. That OP may not like it doesn’t mean he’s done anything wrong, either.

What OP wants is not more important than what he wants on a day that centres him. If his father wants to go then he wants him there, the same as he wants his mother there.

I’m well aware I’m not in sync with most posters in this discussion.

I don’t want to carry on pissing them off, but as a last gasp, I’ll just reiterate that I strongly reject the idea that this lad’s wants and needs on any day less glorious (or even solemn) than his wedding/ installation as Archbishop of York/ reception at the Palace for a gong are more important than the high emotional turmoil affecting his mother.
I said elsewhere that I think it’s she who should be gently prioritised in arranging the trip, since she is the person enduring a loss, whereas the son is off to sunlit uplands and gaiety, we hope.
Nobody’s suggesting she be ‘kid gloved’ etc, but neither should she be dismissed as deserving no consideration.

Indeed I’d say it’s nobody’s personal ‘day’ at all, in terms of anyone as good as wearing a crown, the cynosure of all eyes (as seems to be the prevailing vibe), but rather an exciting milestone involving this new student (and truly, many hurrahs to him for getting this uni place) and his mum equally, and if his dad joins them in a way that will not marr either’s enjoyment of the send off, then hurrah again.
I just think there’s way too much pressure and expectation of bells and whistles in the air for them all.

ASimpleLampoon · 01/09/2025 20:51

You can stop him making his own way but no one can force you to give him a lift. You do the lions share of the parenting all DS life Plea

InterIgnis · 01/09/2025 20:43

Millytante · 01/09/2025 20:32

I didn’t say he should do any such thing, but was responding to (and hoping to negate) a comment describing how he is cowed by his mother. I hadn’t gained that impression.

I do admit I thought the requirements concerning the car journey are a bit much and since I do not share this vibe of compulsory ultra-festive celebrations for such an occasion, I expressed that with a bit of hyperbole, it’s true. Too dramatic.

I didn’t get the impression he’s cowed by his mother either, tbf. The impression I got is that he’s not open to discussing it further with her.

It also doesn’t sound like he’s asking her to be ultra festive, or even particularly congenial with her ex. He’s just said that his father may there on the drop off day.

Millytante · 01/09/2025 20:42

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 01/09/2025 19:44

It is my opinion that lying to one's children is generally a mistake.

And if it would be a lie to pretend an ex was a fine chap and there is nothing the matter with him, divorcing him was just an impulse decision made for no reason, why are mothers always expected to do it?

Yep, and any such pretence should not be asked of her by anyone, including offspring.

InterIgnis · 01/09/2025 20:38

Millytante · 01/09/2025 20:20

I ought not to pounce on your comment in particular, as this is about all the other comments in the same vein, but honest to God, anyone would think this were about an emotionally wrenching farewell at Southampton to a GI bride heading to the wilds of Minnesota, possibly never to be seen again by her parents.

This young man is only moving out and starting at university a couple of hours away. (He could come home every weekend, though the general and sensible idea is that it’ll be the last thing he’ll want)
It’s very exciting, and he’s definitely earned his tripes, but why there has to be such angst and fussing around for everyone really boggles me.

All this insistence that it’s ’his day’, and thus all his wishes are law, as though he were getting married or ordained, seems massively out of proportion to the actual day when he’s dropped off in hall or at digs.
What do such parents do at all, come graduation day? It all seems like terribly unregulated behaviour, though clearly it’s the norm now.

I do honestly wish OP a very happy day of it, but just wish she were not being encouraged here in the inflexible belief the student prince is actually the Sun King in all his pomp.

Above all I don’t think she deserves these brickbats for mentioning her own heavy apprehensions around the degree to which she may be required to interact with exH.
I think that far from her being required to masquerade as chuffed to spend the day with him for the sake of a quite unnecessary show of unity, her son should be the one being mindful of his mum’s double worry (she’s already in heartbreak mode about his departure into adulthood, so additional gut punches are cruel).

She is the one in the vulnerable emotional position on the day, not the son, (whom we can expect to be on a high of excitement and eagerness)
He could do a lot requiring very little effort, to ease her mind right now.

Leaving open the question of his dad’s possible involvement is not on, if he can pin dad down and exact clear agreement about it all (eg a train there and back, and absolutely no possibility of a lift)
It’d be a considerable gift to his mum and mean a great deal, I’d imagine.
Self interest is part of it: if both parents are clear about their ‘lines’, and the day’s expectations, so much anxiety and potential for upset would be lifted from the gathering. A much better day for him!

Ironically, the only person making a big thing of this is OP. No one has asked her to give her ex a lift.

Posters are insisting that it’s his day because, well, it is. What plans he makes with his father are between him and his father, not between the three of them. That OP may not like it doesn’t mean he’s done anything wrong, either.

What OP wants is not more important than what he wants on a day that centres him. If his father wants to go then he wants him there, the same as he wants his mother there.

Millytante · 01/09/2025 20:32

InterIgnis · 01/09/2025 20:07

Why would he need to tread softly, or fear his mother’s wrath, over plans he may make with his father?

He hasn’t made any demands of her, imperious or otherwise, he’s simply told her his father may be there. That’s it.

Whether it’s making too big a deal over a Uni drop off, or may make the day complicated for him is irrelevant. He wasn’t asking should his father be there.

I didn’t say he should do any such thing, but was responding to (and hoping to negate) a comment describing how he is cowed by his mother. I hadn’t gained that impression.

I do admit I thought the requirements concerning the car journey are a bit much and since I do not share this vibe of compulsory ultra-festive celebrations for such an occasion, I expressed that with a bit of hyperbole, it’s true. Too dramatic.

Millytante · 01/09/2025 20:20

RoseAlone · 01/09/2025 16:57

You have to get over yourself, this is about your son, not your grievances. Put your big girls pants on and set a good example for your son. It's a huge day for him, he doesn't deserve to have to worry about you and what you're going to say to his dad.

I ought not to pounce on your comment in particular, as this is about all the other comments in the same vein, but honest to God, anyone would think this were about an emotionally wrenching farewell at Southampton to a GI bride heading to the wilds of Minnesota, possibly never to be seen again by her parents.

This young man is only moving out and starting at university a couple of hours away. (He could come home every weekend, though the general and sensible idea is that it’ll be the last thing he’ll want)
It’s very exciting, and he’s definitely earned his tripes, but why there has to be such angst and fussing around for everyone really boggles me.

All this insistence that it’s ’his day’, and thus all his wishes are law, as though he were getting married or ordained, seems massively out of proportion to the actual day when he’s dropped off in hall or at digs.
What do such parents do at all, come graduation day? It all seems like terribly unregulated behaviour, though clearly it’s the norm now.

I do honestly wish OP a very happy day of it, but just wish she were not being encouraged here in the inflexible belief the student prince is actually the Sun King in all his pomp.

Above all I don’t think she deserves these brickbats for mentioning her own heavy apprehensions around the degree to which she may be required to interact with exH.
I think that far from her being required to masquerade as chuffed to spend the day with him for the sake of a quite unnecessary show of unity, her son should be the one being mindful of his mum’s double worry (she’s already in heartbreak mode about his departure into adulthood, so additional gut punches are cruel).

She is the one in the vulnerable emotional position on the day, not the son, (whom we can expect to be on a high of excitement and eagerness)
He could do a lot requiring very little effort, to ease her mind right now.

Leaving open the question of his dad’s possible involvement is not on, if he can pin dad down and exact clear agreement about it all (eg a train there and back, and absolutely no possibility of a lift)
It’d be a considerable gift to his mum and mean a great deal, I’d imagine.
Self interest is part of it: if both parents are clear about their ‘lines’, and the day’s expectations, so much anxiety and potential for upset would be lifted from the gathering. A much better day for him!

Firefly100 · 01/09/2025 20:16

OP you can’t stop your ex going (nor should you) but you don’t have to facilitate it. If the situation occurs that he asks for a lift back then you simply say no, I am not comfortable to share a car journey with you for 2 hours. Simple and truthful. Leave your phone off if you think ex might contact you during the day. If he contacts your son saying where shall we meet, just tell son to give him the address of his halls where you are, not your problem how he gets there. If you finish by the time he arrives - so what? Not your problem. If he does turn up and hover uselessly whilst you are unpacking - just carry on as you would if he were not there, grey rock all the way. He is NOT your issue to fix, keep that mantra in your head the whole time. If you have all finished and it looks like he is angling to be included in a group meal, suggest that son have some quality time with his dad and push off home.

InterIgnis · 01/09/2025 20:07

Millytante · 01/09/2025 16:49

Blimey. This really is a strong reminder how ten people reading (say) an Agatha Christie, might each initially land on a different perpetrator!

I couldn’t discern much fear of his mother’s wrath nor a habit of treading softly in her midst, in general. Caring about her reactions doesn’t strike me as proven at all!
As for OP, she appears merely intent on finding some way of serving both his imperious demands and understandably ensuring that an emotionally difficult experience (over and above the farewell itself) is avoided.

The reality may well be just as you outline it, but my goodness it’s not how I grasped it at all. That’s a facer.

Edited

Why would he need to tread softly, or fear his mother’s wrath, over plans he may make with his father?

He hasn’t made any demands of her, imperious or otherwise, he’s simply told her his father may be there. That’s it.

Whether it’s making too big a deal over a Uni drop off, or may make the day complicated for him is irrelevant. He wasn’t asking should his father be there.

MrsMcGarry · 01/09/2025 20:01

@stripycats I think you sound like a great parent, who just needs to make a slight adjustment to having adult kids rather than kid kids.

And bollocks to having to have a co-parenting relationship as the parents of adult children. I've absolutely expressed that to mine that I don't like their father and find it difficult to spend time with him. I've also made sure to tell them that my relationship with him shouldn't affect their relationship with him.

His awfulness as a husband (which I have not and probably will not fully explain to them ever) doesn't make him a bad father. There are other things that make him that but it's my job to teach my kids to navigate their relationship with him, but only in the same way that it's my job to help them to navigate any relationship that they have.

.
When they moan about him to me, I listen to them and validate their feelings and try to help them to manage their emotions in exactly the same way I would when they moan to me about a romantic partner or friends or flatmates.

You've done your coparenting. (Well you will have done in two years for your youngest. You don't need to facilitate the relationship between two adults anymore. You are almost free of him, and the need you seem to have still been carrying to look after him. Celebrate that!

Happygolucky314 · 01/09/2025 19:45

stripycats · 31/08/2025 22:33

It would be a bit odd wouldn't it since I'm the only one who can drive (not ex's fault) and it's in my house that 90% of ds's stuff is, including everything that I have bought him for university. No contribution from ex - that is something he can take ownership for. I appreciate this doesn't give me the right to dictate what happens on the day, but it does make comments like, 'what if ex says you can't come,' somewhat irrelevant. Even if that weren't the case, I would still feel that the parent who has picked and chosen which bits of parenting he does and how often certainly doesn't get to tell the other parent what they can and can't be involved in.

@stripycats youre not being unreasonable anyone and everyone on this thread expecting you to take your ex in your car is being unreasonable. I wouldn’t take my ex either never mind sit with him in a car on my own for 2 hours x

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 01/09/2025 19:44

It is my opinion that lying to one's children is generally a mistake.

And if it would be a lie to pretend an ex was a fine chap and there is nothing the matter with him, divorcing him was just an impulse decision made for no reason, why are mothers always expected to do it?

Millytante · 01/09/2025 19:38

Saladbrains · 01/09/2025 18:24

What imperious demands?

the father has not communicated to the OP?

You’re making it up, same as the OP

I am referring to the son.
And while there’s every chance I am making things up as you claim, how could anyone here know better than OP what is or is not the case, yet you say she too is at the same caper!

stripycats · 01/09/2025 19:26

Saladbrains · 01/09/2025 18:28

“… but I don’t badmouth him [the ex]”

You don’t realise it but you have repeatedly bad-mouthed your sons’ father in these posts.

Over and over and over.

You don’t realise you’re doing it…

Um, I do realise but my kids aren't reading this. Surely you can see there's a difference.

OP posts:
Homegrown11 · 01/09/2025 19:13

Why don’t you suggest that you do the drop off and set up weekend, and that he invites dad up the following weekend to see him once he’s settled in. He’ll get longer to talk to him and show him around as there won’t be the jobs to do like on the first day. If he insists on going that day, then just make it clear he needs to get the train. If he asks outright for a lift home just say sorry, no. You don’t need to give him a reason. And don’t pick up any hints he drops if he doesn’t ask directly.

Dramatic · 01/09/2025 19:13

stripycats · 31/08/2025 16:46

I know I'm spiralling again, but I have a vision of us being part-way through unloading the car and ex ringing ds to say he's just arrived at the railway station and when can we meet. Then ds will get super-stressed as he won't want to let his dad down and won't want to say we're in the middle of it you'll need to wait. Then if gets a taxi or bus to the halls and we're done by then... This is what I mean about it not being practical for him to be there.

If this was the case I think your DS would need to get his dad to meet him at the halls, tell him to get an Uber to the halls and meet you there, leaving the halls and trying to meet him at the station/in the city centre seems daft really.

Also fwiw I don't think yabu at all. my DD was due to go to uni this year but is taking a gap year. I absolutely would not agree to take her dad with me in the car, not a hope in hell. I wouldn't even want him there but would grit my teeth for my daughter's sake if she did want him there. I would not be offering him a lift back and if he asked I'd just say "no sorry, I can't" and don't elaborate at all.

MeridianB · 01/09/2025 19:03

I think you’re over-thinking this OP. There are some variables you can’t and shouldn’t try to control - whether ex comes up and hangs around awkwardly is the main one.

Focus on a decision about what you can control. This is not wanting to take ex in the car or drive back with him. It’s totally reasonable. Just be clear with DS about it so he doesn’t have or create any expectation. And then make peace with a white lie about ‘heading somewhere else’ on the way home.

FWIW my DH’s high-conflict exP has made a total nuisance of herself expecting lifts to and from Uni. DH didn’t want to spend any time with her and especially not just the two of them on the way home. He sucked it up for the very first drop off but has dodged her every time since. It hasn’t stopped her practically demanding a space in our car for events etc. Her self-awareness is nil so it was up to DH to set and keep boundaries.

Kelly1969 · 01/09/2025 18:55

Saladbrains · 01/09/2025 14:07

When will someone pipe up and explain that DS wouldn’t say to the OP that he wanted his Dad to attend.

OP is clearly not competent at emotional self-regulation and the DS has no doubt learnt a long time ago not to show any approval or acceptance towards Dad in front of Mum.

DS is in fear of how Mum would take any acceptance of Dad as some sort of personal betrayal of what she suffered during and after the marriage.

It’s tragic when children have to hide their true feelings about one parent because the other parent cannot abide any positive opinion of their former spouse.

Nowhere here has the OP had the grace to admit or accept that Dad has done anything positive as a role model, as a father, or as a parent.

That will not have gone unnoticed by DS1 & DS2.

The DS won’t be risking the OP’s wrath by saying anything resembling the truth of how he feels about having his Dad present at Uni.

The phrasing along the lines of “I won’t mention it to Dad but if he mentions it I’ll have to let him know” is a clear statement by the DS that the DS does not feel safe to mention anything about his Dad to the OP.

It is NOT a sign that DS doesn’t want his Dad present.

It’s a beacon that highlights that the OP has created an environment where any opinion about Dad contrary to the OP's opinion of Dad is not tolerated and is received with anger and possibly rejection.

DS will want OP to depart the Uni drop-off quickly so as to ensure that Dad and OP have no risk of encountering each other.

Omg 😳
so judgemental, about OP, DS, the ex and all the relationships!!!
How do you know how DS feels, do your powers extend to predicting lotto numbers?!

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 01/09/2025 18:42

angelfacecuti75 · 01/09/2025 18:17

Why can't his dad do it without you ?! Why do you have to be the one that accommodates ex ....I get that you might want to say goodbye...in which case go up there via train and let exdh do all the lifting and shifting. I am sure its crap regarding exdh but surely you dont need to talk to each other plus you usually have lots of crap so unless he plans on being on the roof rack let him sort himself out ...if he doesn't drive let him go by train .

OPs ex is disabled and the OP has said he won't be able to help with the lifting and carrying.