Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not really sympathize with a ‘shocking secret’ in my partner’s family?

83 replies

Nightrainrocketqueen · 28/08/2025 14:03

I’ll try to keep this short.
Basically, my partner’s aunt and uncle lost a child to illness many years ago—before either of us were born. I can’t say I’m particularly fond of his aunt; she’s done some spiteful things within the family and tends to act like the “CEO” of it all. His uncle, on the other hand, has always been polite to me, although a bit quiet.

They live in a tiny village on the outskirts of a city where we live and work. One day at work, I happened to mention to a colleague who lives or parents live in said Village, that my partner’s aunt and uncle live there as just as casual conversation. My colleague responded along the lines of, “Oh yeah, I know of them. He’s very odd.” I didn’t think much of it at the time but later mentioned it to my partner. He went a bit quiet and sheepish and confided in me as to what that comment could have been in relation to;

Apparently, back in the early '90s (either before my partner was born or when he was very young), his uncle was arrested after several complaints of flashing at women in parks. He was taken to court, placed on some sort of sex offenders register (or whatever the equivalent was back then), and sentenced to community service or similar. According to what my partner was told by his dad, the incident caused a massive scandal within the family and made his aunt and uncle outcasts in the village for a while.

His dad—who is the aunt’s brother—was livid at first and apparently went straight round to confront him. The uncle's explanation was, “I’m not coping,” referring to the loss of his child years earlier. And that was sort of… it. It was brushed under the rug. The family now seems to tiptoe around his uncle a bit . My partner was told explicitly that it’s not something to ever be discussed and that was the end of it.

Of course, I do have sympathy for the grief they experienced, and I understand mental health struggles. But I still think what he did was really wrong. As a young woman, it makes me feel incredibly uneasy. Women should be able to go about their lives without this kind of behaviour—regardless of when it happened. I also feel for the victims, who likely never got closure. And I can’t help but think: what if he hadn’t been caught? Where could it have escalated? What if a vulnerable or intellectually challenged woman had been involved? It’s disturbing.

Ive come here because I can’t talk about this with anyone as;
A) I’m not supposed to know—it was a family secret,
B) I want to respect my partner.

But I’m really struggling with how to feel about it. From a young woman’s point of view, it just doesn’t sit right with me. I don’t buy the “grieving parent” excuse—it was still a sexual crime.
Am I being heartless?

OP posts:
AMiddleClassWomanOfACertainAge · 28/08/2025 14:25

How many women get convicted of sexual offences because they were grieving or stressed etc? It’s a bullshit excuse imo and one we see played out today when predators get minimal or suspended sentences.

Your gut is telling you this is all wrong because it is and no amount of ignoring it or trying to rationalise it away is going to work because it can’t be done.

TwoTuesday · 28/08/2025 14:25

He's already been tried, convicted and served his sentence 30 years ago. That's closure. He's not even a blood relative of your partner. If you don't like him, and his wife, don't mix with them.

Nightrainrocketqueen · 28/08/2025 14:24

MyGreyStork · 28/08/2025 14:16

He was caught and punished. There’s no point in going over what could have happened. Either tell your husband or mind your own business. It appears your dislike for the aunt is influencing this decision. If you liked her would you consider saying anything? I doubt it.

Not at all if anything its made me like her more and understand why she has these funny ways

OP posts:
Nightrainrocketqueen · 28/08/2025 14:23

Orangepate · 28/08/2025 14:06

What do you think that dragging this all out into the open will achieve exactly?

That is not my intention at all I just wanted to talk to someone about it as I don't know how I should feel

OP posts:
MyGreyStork · 28/08/2025 14:16

He was caught and punished. There’s no point in going over what could have happened. Either tell your husband or mind your own business. It appears your dislike for the aunt is influencing this decision. If you liked her would you consider saying anything? I doubt it.

heldinadream · 28/08/2025 14:16

@Orangepate what are you on about?
@Nightrainrocketqueen has come here to discuss something very upsetting, precisely because she feels she cannot, and quite possibly doesn't want to, drag it all out into the open, as you put it.

@Nightrainrocketqueen you're not being heartless at all, you've stumbled into something of emotional complexity and been told that you can't talk about it.
But you probably need to talk about it in order to come to terms with it. If I were you I'd probably book some counselling sessions where I could talk freely in order to make sense of it for myself.

My instinct are like yours; they must be very damaged but does that mean that crimes of a sexual nature that will have damaged others can be excused? Not really. Then where does that leave you? You must be feeling really uncomfortable to say the least.
You have my good wishes and my sympathy. I don't think you can just shut this down and pretend you don't know.

ClawedButler · 28/08/2025 14:12

Gently, I think you could drive yourself mad going over all the what-ifs and if-onlys. They didn't happen, and they haven't happened since (as far as we know).

It's totally grim, and I'm with you that there isn't an excuse for this kind of behaviour (lots of people lose children, tragically, but most don't take up sex offending to deal with it). However, all you can reasonably do now is distance yourself from them (not hard, you're hardly living in each other's pockets) and leave it alone.

It's not your secret to reveal.

Orangepate · 28/08/2025 14:06

What do you think that dragging this all out into the open will achieve exactly?