Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taylor Swift engagement - puzzled

290 replies

LouisaJG · 27/08/2025 17:45

I’m in my 30s and so unreasonable to be posting/caring about this on every level. BUT. I didn’t see a post. So…

AIBU to be puzzled that the man Taylor Swift has finally decided to settle down with is so different to the type she has seemed to date pretty consistently through her 20s and 30s up to then? She seemed so keen on soft, arty, mainly British boys - and now she’s gone for the direct opposite. Is it because her previous long relationship with a soft, arty British boy (Joe Alwyn) didn’t go the distance and so she decided she really needed to change her type if she wanted marriage and kids? Is it a fairly cynical marketing reaction to the current political situation in the States (no idea if TK is actually a Republican but he looks like someone who could appeal to Republicans, very much unlike Joe Alwyn)? Is it just a return to her American, country roots? What gives? I’m her age and I just can’t imagine my tastes changing as dramatically as that.

We used to like the same type of man, and now I feel like I don’t know her any more (I know, I know, I know) 🤣

OP posts:
ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 27/08/2025 20:39

Without googling I think she’s marrying an American sportsman, possibly footballer, at least I have a vague idea she was dating someone like that. I know I could check, but I don’t want to risk going down a rabbit hole as I know I would. Maybe all her previous relationships have given her a very good idea of what she doesn’t want, so she’s sure when she’s found what she does want. As you get older you get more clarity of thought in these things I’ve found.

I don’t pay a great deal of attention to celebrities, but I do admire her for holding her head high in the face of years of media abuse. I’ve also grown to appreciate her music via my obsessed eleven year old DD. “Mean” really strikes a chord with me. I hope she lives happily ever after.

Babybirdmum · 27/08/2025 20:38

Maybe his values are more traditional therefore marriage is on his agenda. Maybe if you’re more of a hippy rebel type boy you would be less keen on marriage in general

bignosebignose · 27/08/2025 20:38

It’s possible for a man to be exceptionally good at sport and still be a gentleman. The story of how they met suggests that he might be one of the good guys.

ChicOliveCritic · 27/08/2025 20:34

LouisaJG · 27/08/2025 17:45

I’m in my 30s and so unreasonable to be posting/caring about this on every level. BUT. I didn’t see a post. So…

AIBU to be puzzled that the man Taylor Swift has finally decided to settle down with is so different to the type she has seemed to date pretty consistently through her 20s and 30s up to then? She seemed so keen on soft, arty, mainly British boys - and now she’s gone for the direct opposite. Is it because her previous long relationship with a soft, arty British boy (Joe Alwyn) didn’t go the distance and so she decided she really needed to change her type if she wanted marriage and kids? Is it a fairly cynical marketing reaction to the current political situation in the States (no idea if TK is actually a Republican but he looks like someone who could appeal to Republicans, very much unlike Joe Alwyn)? Is it just a return to her American, country roots? What gives? I’m her age and I just can’t imagine my tastes changing as dramatically as that.

We used to like the same type of man, and now I feel like I don’t know her any more (I know, I know, I know) 🤣

💭...but that is precisely what love is! Love doesn't conform to type and often has no rhyme or reason. When I was younger, I was rather superficial and thought I had a "type". As I've grown, that's changed rather considerably (hopefully because I myself have matured and learnt lessons). So outwardly, the type of man I thought I wanted has changed and what matters to me more now is who he is internally. I'm now with the most gorgeous and incredible human being who the 20 year old me most likely wouldn't have given a chance before because of life, societal pressures and because I thought he had to look a certain way.🤭
Outwardly appearance still matters but as I've aged, it's reduced in my priorities when dating. It's just about finding and matching with a good human. 🙂

Jorge80 · 27/08/2025 20:34

DH was the boyfriend who was most different to me, esp politically. But he was the most kind and respectful.

I assumed Kelce was a Republican. She seems less vocal about being a Democrat nowadays (since the previous election) or is that just me? I love her and hope it works out.

Tiswa · 27/08/2025 20:33

newyorker74 · 27/08/2025 20:11

Didn't his his team win a Superbowl since they've been dating?

won one lost one - but it is pretty hard to get to the Super Bowl.

I think he is confident in his own career and in his move to acting (his role in Grotesquerie was something else) and therefore doesn’t need her. He is pretty well known in his own right and very well known in the sporting circles in his own right and comfortable with his family and friends

he has grown on me and certainly has grown on DD who watches the podcasts and to be fair they do model a good relationship

Hotflushesandchilblains · 27/08/2025 20:31

LouisaJG · 27/08/2025 17:52

Yeah but my point is the falling seriously and long-term in love with someone who is the polar opposite of everyone you have dated in the past. That isn’t something I’ve experienced, and it’s not something I’ve witnessed often with friends, I can think of maybe one example max in my personal circle. It’s strange to me.

Well, at the risk of being really obvious - what she had gone for before hadnt worked out for her? And to be fair, I dont think there is as much difference between moderate republicans and conservative democrats in the US as there might be between the equivalent here.

newyorker74 · 27/08/2025 20:29

RuthChrisSt · 27/08/2025 20:25

Yes and they also lost one. Your point being?

Just that as they won one and lost one, at best, it appears to have had zero impact either way.

RuthChrisSt · 27/08/2025 20:25

newyorker74 · 27/08/2025 20:11

Didn't his his team win a Superbowl since they've been dating?

Yes and they also lost one. Your point being?

CanOfMangoTango · 27/08/2025 20:24

Her previous "types" didn't work out so she thought she would try something different.

A lot of women have been there. I have. My DH is the polar opposite of what I thought I wanted when I was younger.

For all the glitz and glamour it's fairly obvious that Taylor is a small town, country fair, apple pie, kind of woman.

There's a lot of cultural capital her previous exes wouldn't have had, Travis knows exactly where she's from. And the fact he's 6 foot whatever, built like a brick shithouse and is totally enamoured with her can't hurt.

Best of luck to them.

2021x · 27/08/2025 20:23

They have a common culture, same age and he seems happy to go along with what she wants.

They are in different t facets of the entertainment industry and so are not competing, and are good for each others brands unlike Joe who I don’t think wants to be part of Taylor’s brand.

I think it’s a good match, even if it is a showmance .

PInkyStarfish · 27/08/2025 20:17

Showmance. Obviously.

LouisaJG · 27/08/2025 20:15

Screamingabdabz · 27/08/2025 20:10

The Daily Mail (also looking into this conundrum) suggests it’s because he’s ‘chivalrous’ which is what Taylor has always wanted.

I am suitably chastened to hear that I have anything in common with the Daily Mail

OP posts:
MyGreyStork · 27/08/2025 20:11

Her former type obviously didn’t work and this one has. Not everyone dates the same type for years, essentially you’re just dating the wrong man over and over.

newyorker74 · 27/08/2025 20:11

RuthChrisSt · 27/08/2025 20:06

Yes, his age has played a factor in his decline but certainly his relationship has as well. Dinners out the night before a game, the overwhelming attention she gets at the games, he's always looks distracted now when he plays. There's a noticeable difference in his whole persona since dating her.

Didn't his his team win a Superbowl since they've been dating?

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 27/08/2025 20:10

All the men she's dated in the past are her exes for a reason.

If you dated someone who was a carbon copy of your ex, wouldn't that just be making the same mistake twice?

Maybe he's just a really great guy and so she doesn't care that he's not her usual type.

Screamingabdabz · 27/08/2025 20:10

The Daily Mail (also looking into this conundrum) suggests it’s because he’s ‘chivalrous’ which is what Taylor has always wanted.

witheringrowan · 27/08/2025 20:10

I have a very tangential link to the Joe/Taylor relationship via a friend - from what it sounds like, his arty but actually just mummy & daddy funded mates never really clicked with her. While they were very happy to enjoy the private jets flying them out to holidays in Greece & parties at the North London mansions, ultimately they all (including Joe) saw themselves as far cooler & more artistic than someone as nakedly commercial & mainstream as she is. Whereas Travis seems all in on everything. Must be nice to have that whole hearted support after a succession of partners (Calvin, Joe, Matty) didn't act in the same way.

PoppyTries · 27/08/2025 20:08

turkeyboots · 27/08/2025 18:27

She is engaged to a man who is also hugely famous and understands the associated lack of freedom in their incredibly well off lives. They'll have way more in common than with some musician who'll never reach her level of success.

And they are both very close with their families. I think that is a pretty strong foundation and there are probably more similarities than differences. He seems to adore her and is tremendously supportive and proud of her, maybe that’s exactly what she needs. She’s spent 20 years writing songs about how she wants to be loved, he just needed to follow directions.

RuthChrisSt · 27/08/2025 20:06

ShesTheAlbatross · 27/08/2025 19:22

Admittedly I don’t know much (anything) about American football, but he’s 35. Isn’t a decline in performance (that also includes winning the Super Bowl, so can’t be totally appalling unless he was a liability for that season) kind of expected at that sort of age? It feels old for a professional sports player.

I’ve no idea about their relationship though. Certainly not enough to make me assume it’s fake, so I’d assume it’s genuine unless there was a reason not to.

Yes, his age has played a factor in his decline but certainly his relationship has as well. Dinners out the night before a game, the overwhelming attention she gets at the games, he's always looks distracted now when he plays. There's a noticeable difference in his whole persona since dating her.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 27/08/2025 20:06

Snapplepie · 27/08/2025 19:25

Have you watched the podcast she did with the kelce brothers? I did and I get it now. He seems to be charming, supportive and funny. He also looks like he somehow manages to be a calming person to be around as well as the life of the party.

I saw a clip of that podcast on the news last night and thought he seemed quite nice. Then he used the word "butthurt" and I had to change my opinion completely. (I'm sure he is still nice but I have an irrational hatred of that word and anyone who uses it).

Bontonbonbon · 27/08/2025 20:06

Travis and his entire family are registered Democrats. Just being a football player doesn’t make you a Republican. He was one of the first NFL players to take the knee in support of Colin Kapernak. Jason and Kyle Kelce are massive supports of the Eagle’s Autism awareness charity. They are very liberal people

Taylor released a long statement in support of Kamala and also sold merch to support Kamala’s campaign.

LouisaJG · 27/08/2025 20:02

Firealarm1414 · 27/08/2025 19:29

Does literally everything have to be made into politics? Maybe she is rebelling against the tedious artsy "cool" types who do this by going for someone who is the complete opposite? Some of his teammates are republicans and even trumpers and they still hang out. Its ok not to let politics rule your life.

Er politics will rule your life whether you ‘let’ it or not. Roe v Wade has been repealed. If you live in a state where that’s the case and you or someone close to you faces dying in childbirth, closing your eyes and thinking happy thoughts isn’t going to cut it.

OP posts:
QuantumPanic · 27/08/2025 20:00

Ia he's the rebound that stuck. I'm pretty sure she wanted marriage and kids with Joe ("talking rings and talking cradles, I wish I could un-recall how we almost had it all" - ok, so her lyrics aren't definitive proof, but 🤷🤷) and Travis is the one if she's going to stick to any kind of timeline. That's not a bad thing - I think at a certain point you grow up and realise that a tall, athletic millionaire who you get on with, who wants the same things in life and who wants to marry you is actually a pretty good catch.

TheHillIsMine · 27/08/2025 19:58

None of my previous partners have been alike in anyway so I do find it odd that people have a type. The only thing is there are a couple of famous people I quite fancy and they look like the LOML.