Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My partner broke up with me for telling lies

90 replies

Luciferthethird · 24/08/2025 22:30

I accidentally put telling lies in the titl, I meant keeping secrets

I F36 have been with my DP M34 for 2 years we don’t live together because between us we have 6 kids he has 4 and he keeps them every other weekend and I have 2 mostly full time.
Our homes aren’t big enough and we would like to buy together so we were saving a deposit.

Now onto the secrets, before we met I used to have a situationship with someone in the same workforce as my partner but not the same area.

I didn’t tell my partner about this because in my mind it was in the past, it’s my business and I didn’t want to make his work place uncomfortable.
My situationship doesn’t have any feelings for me nor him me but if we bump into each other at the gym we’d usually stop for a chat.

I should have told him when we chatted at the gym in front of DP and I tried I really did but I couldn’t bring myself to.
My DP got a transfer to the same workplace as my situationship and well it turns out someone from work knew about us and spread it around his work and my partner felt like everyone was talking about him until someone finally told him what was being said.
They also said that my situationship had a girlfriend at the time and that I was aware and met with him anyway, I didn’t I assumed if he was messaging me they’d separated. My DP didn’t like that I would be willing to sleep with someone in a relationship, I wouldn’t have if I’d known.

My partner was not happy but we talked it out and seemed to move on. That was 18 months ago

Now onto the next secret, my friends all female wanted to go on a trip. I agreed and it was booked. My partner is a little insecure about these things so I put off telling him when I did tell him he told me he’d seen it on my phone (said he wasn’t snooping but had seen a notification about it) the month before and was just waiting for me to tell him.

He felt that it was a singles trip, and that the one single girl in the group would be bringing boys back to the room etc. this did not happen. So now the previous (situationship) lie and this one is coming up and long story short he’s broken up with me, says he can’t trust me has removed me from all social media and is already on tinder.

I go from feeling like I’m glad it’s done to wanting to beg him to come back

I just don’t know what to do, do you think I should have done better? Should I have told him all these things straight away?

He’s also said he doesn’t know if he can live with me and that he likes things organised, I am organised but life has been hectic atm

I’ve been loyal to him I’ve never cheated I just love and miss him so much but I can’t believe that someone who claims to love me could do this to me

OP posts:
Luciferthethird · 25/08/2025 16:42

ZoggyStirdust · 25/08/2025 16:35

Interesting.
there have been many threads where women have a male partner who lies and they are told to dump them….

To be fair not one person has told me to make it work

OP posts:
ZoggyStirdust · 25/08/2025 16:35

Interesting.
there have been many threads where women have a male partner who lies and they are told to dump them….

nomas · 25/08/2025 16:27

OP, no one has the right to police your language.

I’m glad you saw it as a situationship rather than a relationship.

And he’s not a FWB because he’s not a friend.

Ignore all the nitpickers like @Propagandalf and @Mydadsbirthday

Luciferthethird · 25/08/2025 16:15

Mydadsbirthday · 25/08/2025 11:53

I agree, you both sound really immature and he sounds like a shit parent which should be a massive red flag to you

I couldn’t think of another way to describe it “friends with benefits” might of been better I wanted to get across that it wasn’t a relationship 🤷‍♀️

I’m just going to address about his children, it’s hard to put all the details in one post.
He would have his kids more and during holidays and such he does. They live an hours drive away and with school and their routines they find it works better this way. This was the arrangement their mother asked for

I spoke to him on the phone, I have only spoken to him once on the phone since this happened
I didn’t go into too much with him because he’s on pain medication, he brought up the money and told me he gets paid tomorrow and he’s going to pay me back then and he brought up tinder told me he was sorry he was drunk and lonely and that it wasn’t fair to me and that’s he’s not speaking or dating anyone. Not that he could with his injuries atm
I left the conversation there.
His immaturity levels throughout all this have absolutely astounded me.

OP posts:
FollowSpot · 25/08/2025 15:46

You didn’t tell him about either thing because you feared his reaction.

His ‘insecurity’ is very close to jealousy and control.

I bet he was snooping in your phone, and he then went on to test you / set a trap to see when you would tell him. If he had innocently seen a message he could have just said. His suspicions about men coming back are just ridiculous.

It wasn’t a healthy relationship.

And it’s good you are thinking of some counselling because it would be good to work on your self esteem and boundaries before going into another relationship.

BellissimoGecko · 25/08/2025 15:45

Windthebloodybobbinup · 24/08/2025 22:37

I think it’s more important that you are reluctant to tell him normal things and that is creating the situation. There is something wrong if you have to pick and choose what you say or position information in a certain way that he will accept. You need to think carefully about whether you want to live with that level of insecurity which is also controlling behaviour.

This.

Idontjetwashthefucker · 25/08/2025 15:36

HerecomesMargo · 25/08/2025 13:43

It’s him who has the lucky escape!

Because?

Onthebusses · 25/08/2025 15:33

Ew what a big whiny baby and how desperate to go on tinder right away and how immature to block you. Congrats on getting rid of him.

HerecomesMargo · 25/08/2025 13:43

OhBuggerandArse · 24/08/2025 22:35

You have probably had a lucky escape.

It’s him who has the lucky escape!

overwhelmedsinglema · 25/08/2025 12:39

Had a child with a man like this! Never felt so insecure and like I was going mad, as I did when I was with him! He’s insecure and controlling! Men like this act a certain way, so you feel you can’t be transparent with them in case you offend them. So you start avoiding telling them things to avoid confrontation and then they find out what you’ve been keeping from them and make a big thing about it! That’s no way to live!

Figgygal · 25/08/2025 12:36

PersephoneParlormaid · 25/08/2025 07:59

I think he’s got the problem, not you. Move on.

Agree
He sounds like a controlling prat who judges you and snoops on your phone and from what you've said here someone you can't be honest with him due to his reactions.
He wants you to beg and run now to get control let him go

Gatekeeper · 25/08/2025 12:33

What on earth is a 'situationship'???

Mydadsbirthday · 25/08/2025 11:53

Propagandalf · 24/08/2025 22:51

I put YABU for using "situationship".

I agree, you both sound really immature and he sounds like a shit parent which should be a massive red flag to you

Mehmeh22 · 25/08/2025 11:29

Regardless of him being an arse or not or you keeping secrets....even if you get back together, this will always be in the background. He will never fully trust you and you will always be trying to make amends.

Promise you, this relationship is dead in the water. Don't waste your time with it. Move on

GreyCarpet · 25/08/2025 08:27

Theoturkeyflieswest · 25/08/2025 04:51

I could understand him being upset if you were married and living together and sharing finances
But your not doing any of those things
So he didn't have a right to any of that information
You didn't tell him , because you knew how he would react
And his actions show ,you were correct.
Let him go ,he's not the one

Tbf, I'd want to know something that might put me off someome at the early stages of dating. By the time you're married, living together and sharing finances, it can often feel its too late or much harder to extricate yourself. Because it is.

Honesty is important because then people can decide if this is the sort of person they want to be with. It also demonstrates and builds trust.

The OP hid something from her boyfriend that she thought he might dump her for if he knew. He found put, the trust was broken and so he dumped her.

A simple explanation of how she'd once casually dated his colleague and later discovered he was actually married or whatever would have meant he didn't feel like he was the last to know when it became workplace gossip.

No one has the right to know every detail of another person's past but it's the decent thing to do to give them a heads up when it's going to impact them..

5128gap · 25/08/2025 08:22

Please rethink setting up a permenant home with this man. People who have arguments about this sort of petty thing, the past, what friends may do are on holiday, listen to gossip from randoms, they are stuck at a level of maturity that's not enough to head a blended household of 6 children, with all the real grown up challenges that will bring. Your life with this guy will be a chaotic drama of fallings out about teenage nonsense which will seriously get in the way of of raising a large family.

TammyJones · 25/08/2025 08:11

** he’s being Ridiculous- not ridicules

PersephoneParlormaid · 25/08/2025 07:59

I think he’s got the problem, not you. Move on.

TammyJones · 25/08/2025 07:57

Lucky escape for you.
Everyone has a past.
Maybe you should have mentioned it when they started to work at the same place - but if they worked opposite shifts , it may not have come out - why poke the bear?
I also think he snooped on your phone.
But you’re not married or even living together - so if you’re planning a trip it doesn’t effect him (it’s not like he’d be suddenly having to cook his own dinner or find additional child care- cos you don’t do that. )
So it is entirely up to you when you tell him of any of your plans.
He’s being ridicules ….. and immature.
The money is a different story…and he should offering to pay that back … instalments if necessary.

Laura95167 · 25/08/2025 07:14

Luciferthethird · 24/08/2025 22:49

Tbf, they work in 2 separate departments and opposite shifts. Yes I should have told him.

“what else he might not know “ is his issue
and I would of loved to have told him but I felt that his anxiety would build until I went away, if I’d known he would end the relationship over it I wouldn’t of done it

That's the problem he cant get past. You kept thinking the truth would make him feel X so you hid it. And generally in my experience men who've said I didnt tell you because it would upset you, actually meant im hiding it from you because if you know the truth is I might have to deal with the consequences.

If you were so sure hed feel anxious you could have not gone, or explained from the get go what was happening and how he could trust you. But you didnt so of course he feels unable to trust you at all. I dont think this choice is one holiday, its a serious of lies that made him feel vulnerable and unable to trust you.

You could ask for another chance but I think youd have to change your approach with him

WaltzingWaters · 25/08/2025 06:11

Obviously you shouldn’t be keeping secrets in a relationship. But then again, it sounds like you only did it out of fear of his reaction. You shouldn’t have to walk on eggshells in your relationship. You’ve had a lucky escape. Don’t go back to him.

PollyBell · 25/08/2025 05:33

yes this is blunt but why are you doing this to yourself, yes some women are desperate for attention they dont care if they are being treated badly, it is wrong. and I hope the children involved dont see this and think it is normal then go on to to do the same themselves be a good role model and learn from it break the never ending cycle that women keep on puting up with in the hope some one will throw them a few crumbsmm keep what little self respect you have left and move on

Harsh but one day someone may listen

Corfumanchu · 25/08/2025 05:27

You should have told him about the affair you had had with one of his new work colleagues. Did you not imagine how humiliated he would feel that everyone else knew about his girlfriend's grubby affair and not him? That is dishonest - lying by omission. Ditto the holiday-if it was no big deal, wby didnt you tell him? You 'didn't feel able' is not a reflection on him, it is a reflection on your lack of courage.

Theoturkeyflieswest · 25/08/2025 04:51

I could understand him being upset if you were married and living together and sharing finances
But your not doing any of those things
So he didn't have a right to any of that information
You didn't tell him , because you knew how he would react
And his actions show ,you were correct.
Let him go ,he's not the one

Velmy · 25/08/2025 04:00

There's a lot here. If after two years, while you still have things to sort out (money, property etc) he's dumped you and gone straight on Tinder...that's a massive red flag for his level of maturity and how little the relationship meant to him.

He's sounds very insecure and jealous. Snooping is never good, whether he was right or wrong to suspect something. He'll be doing it forever.

I'm not really sure about the guy at his work. Unless you knew they were friends, or worked directly together, I'm not sure it's any of his business. Although personally I'd have mentioned it. From the sounds of him, he's have been just as insecure if he knew though.

You should have told him about the holiday. I can't imagine booking to go away and keeping it from my OH at any point in our relationship. It's just good manners...what if he'd have booked you a surprise trip on the same date?

His reasoning is off though. There's only one single girl, and he thinks she will bring men back for everyone else who's in a relationship, and you're all going to cheat together? That's insane levels of paranoia. If that's where his head is at, he'll never trust you.

The real issue from your end is the fact that you felt you couldn't be honest with him about two completely normal, innocent bits of information...presumably because you knew he wouldn't have reacted well.

What happens next time you go away with the girls, or on a night out, or a work trip, or mention a male co-worker you get lunch with? If you're deliberating over what you can tell him, or if he's emotionally blackmailing you over completely innocent behavior...is it worth the hassle?

If you think he's The One and he wants to talk it out, you both need to be frank in that you won't keep secrets and he needs to get over his jealousy.

But to be honest, I'd be writing this one off to experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread