Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to go to their bbq?

241 replies

Mrsunderstood · 20/08/2025 00:18

BIL and the OW have now moved in together and she’s organised this family bbq day. I had a good relationship with ex SIL but DH didn’t want me to to speak to her anymore after there separation so i didnt. Now I’m being forced into situation such as this. He’s saying I have to go I’m his wife and just to get over it.

I think the both of them are disgusting and if there happy then fair enough good luck to them they’ve both cheated on their long term partners and cause so much destruction and now playing happy families.

The only issues are my children obviously have there cousins that they want to see. DH is more than capable to take the kids on his own.

Do I have to suck it up and go? It completely goes against my morals and the person that I am it feels so wrong.

OP posts:
Chilliandbanana · 20/08/2025 08:07

Agree with the majority of posters on here. Your husband doesn’t get to say who you do and don’t see. If he wants to pretend at one big happy family, let him. You don’t have to!

Shoxfordian · 20/08/2025 08:04

You would have made a great Puritan op. Sitting there judging others and not going to events to show you have the moral highground. Well done.

Birdied · 20/08/2025 08:01

FlockofSquirrels · 20/08/2025 02:02

What's the endgame here? Is this a one time pass on an event or do you plan to refuse to attend any family functions with them? If it's the latter, how do you see that benefiting anyone? Will it improve your children's family experience? Heal any hurt?

When I was a child one of my aunts cheated on her husband and her older sister decided to refuse to speak to or see her. The "other man" became husband and everyone healed and moved on except the self-righteous sister who kept this up for years once she had taken her stand, seemingly because she didn't know how to let it go once she'd started. Eventually she gave it up (without ever admitting perhaps she was wrong) and now both the ex husband and husband attend our family reunions, the sisters pretend it never happened, and all anyone has to show for it is years of hurt and missing time together.

Taking a pass on one family gathering is reasonable. Telling your DH you're going to continue your friendship with your ex-SIL (without getting involved in any conflict between the two) is reasonable. But be cautious about making a painful situation worse for everyone.

Exactly this.

ClairDeLaLune · 20/08/2025 08:01

Your DH is controlling. It’s not up to him who you’re friends with. Me ex-SIL is one of my best friends and I love her dearly. If DH told me to break contact with her I’d tell him to fuck off. But he wouldn’t, because he doesn’t try to control me.

Same with the bbq. It’s not up to your DH if you go or not. He’s not the boss of you. Make decisions for yourself and tell DH he has to accept that. And if he doesn’t then you have more problems unfortunately.

Ewock · 20/08/2025 07:59

My dh does not tell me who I can and can not speak to and I wouldn't tell him. Who the hell does your dh think he is to tell you to stop speaking to your sil?
If ky dh tried that controlling shit with me there'd be the possibility of another divorce.
I wouldn't go, but ai would contact sil and spend time with her instead. Your dh is as much scum as his cheating db.

jeaux90 · 20/08/2025 07:55

I’d go for the kids sake and try and work through the situation. Life is too short for this shit.

BUT I’d tell DH to do one over the ex SIL. No way I’d let myself get told I can’t be friends with someone.

ThatCyanCat · 20/08/2025 07:40

Does he always tell you who you can and can't see? I'm assuming his ex is the mother of his children, if so then how is everyone going to never see or speak to her? So she's been cheated on, dumped and her effective in laws are now freezing her out?

Crazycrazyfrog · 20/08/2025 07:35

If you truly don’t want to go then just send the children with DH… however, you need to play the long game. Don’t cut yourself off from family and all the related family events.
I’d go to the bbq, focus on your kids and your niece/nephews (they would probably like you to be there, especially if they don’t want the new woman around).
I’d be civil, but not friendly. I wouldn’t help with the food/cleanup - you’re a guest, a plus one if your husband. I’d grey rock and offer nothing. It’ll make it clear to DH and BIL that this is the relationship you’re offering and if asked I’d have no qualms saying that I’ve learnt to not get attached to BILs partners as history shows they won’t be around long term…

Poppins21 · 20/08/2025 07:35

Mrsunderstood · 20/08/2025 00:59

Thank you!! He wanted me to post this thread as he thinks I’m being AIBU. He can go and take the kids that’s absolutely fine. But I don’t want any part of it.

Well he is got a shock then! Enjoy your time alone and maybe have coffee with ex SIL?

Imbusytodaysorry · 20/08/2025 07:34

@Mrsunderstood when you said “they are both disgusting “ at first I thought you went you husband and his brother. Because they are both as bad. Is your husband always as controlling ? Why do you allow it ?

Yell him you are not going end of .

Imbusytodaysorry · 20/08/2025 07:33

MrsEMR · 20/08/2025 00:48

I would not have gone along with ditching the ex-SIL if I was friends with her. Even more so if the cousins enjoy spending time together. As for BBQ situation, inform DH that you cannot be held responsible for any upset caused if you go, so he should be prepared for fireworks.
TBH I think I’d let him go alone with the kids & try and meet up with ex-SIL as she’ll be child free too that day.

This

GabriellaMontez · 20/08/2025 07:30

Lots of family occasions have someone there that i don't like. I go anyway, to see the people I do like and for the benefit of dp and children.

Isn't that how all big family type dos are?

However, dp does not tell me who i can be friends with, and if he tried Id set him straight.

thepariscrimefiles · 20/08/2025 07:24

Well now you know how your DH's family will treat you if your DH has an affair and leaves you and the kids.

Your poor SIL had to deal with your BIL leaving her for the other woman and then losing your friendship because your DH told you to stop seeing her. That was a really mean thing for him to do and I'm not sure why you agreed to stop being friends with her.

I'm glad that you have decided not to attend this BBQ.

Auroraloves · 20/08/2025 07:24

Your husband is being very unreasonable to tell you who you can be friends with.

mamagogo1 · 20/08/2025 07:23

What sort of time scale is this? If it is pretty new and raw then I get your point but if they have been established a while then for the sake of family harmony you need to superficially get along. I would not have ditched a friend though

HideousKinky · 20/08/2025 07:22

DH didn't want me to speak to her any more after their separation so I didn't

Why did you agree to this? You are laying the groundwork for what has now happened - first he tells you who you can't see and now he's telling you who you must see. He sounds controlling

Whyherewego · 20/08/2025 07:22

Maray1967 · 20/08/2025 07:16

I would make sure PIL know my views and that it would be better if I don’t see BIL. I have a friend who told her own parents she was disgusted by her brother’s behaviour (similar to this) and she did not see him while he was with OW - relationship didn’t last long. She also told her parents that she was not impressed with how they had basically dumped their DIL as though she had never existed.

Just incidentally I had no desire to maintain a relationship with my ex PIL or ex BIL when I split up with my ex.
And indeed my parents didnt maintain a relationship with my ex.
I do think that's fair enough. I mean if I saw them in the street we'd both say hello. But I certainly didnt want to hang out

Slightyamusedandsilly · 20/08/2025 07:22

Mrsunderstood · 20/08/2025 00:59

Thank you!! He wanted me to post this thread as he thinks I’m being AIBU. He can go and take the kids that’s absolutely fine. But I don’t want any part of it.

Yup!!! You've already MASSIVELY had his back by cutting contact with your ex SIL. Too much to be honest. I'd remain friends and she must be very hurt that you've dropped her.

MushMonster · 20/08/2025 07:21

Hold on a minute, the BBQ is not the issue here! Your DH told you not to talk to your SIL? Seriously! Does she have children? Because if you do have your children's cousins from her side, there is no way on this Earth my stupid husband is telling me not to keep contact with her! That is crazy!
And if she does not have children, then I would keep a cordial how are you? Happy birthday, Merry Christmas.... going on if I liked her.
Whatever happened between your DH's brother and her has nothing to do with you.
The BBQ, well, given your DH shitty behaviour above, I would not feel like going. Just to make the point. If he is treating his SIL like this, he may do the same in his own marriage later in life...
But there is the chance your BIL and the OW stay together in the long term, so it will not be wise to create a rift here. For me, it would be more important to keep a decent relationship left with my SIL. I just cannot believe your DH commands you on this......

AbzMoz · 20/08/2025 07:20

You should do whatever you want. That includes going to the bbq (or not), being friends with xSiL (or not),…

Are there other aunt/uncles and GPs attending? I bet no one feels entirely comfortable but BiL has made his choice and now has the consequences. It will be a lesson for you around how your DHs family will act if you were to ever split up…

Louoby · 20/08/2025 07:19

What’s worse is that he stopped contact with you and your former sister in law. Why does he get to chose this? She is the mother of your children’s cousins.

Namechangerage · 20/08/2025 07:16

Mrsunderstood · 20/08/2025 00:59

Thank you!! He wanted me to post this thread as he thinks I’m being AIBU. He can go and take the kids that’s absolutely fine. But I don’t want any part of it.

Don’t go!!

And maybe message your SIL to apologise, poor her. Your DH can’t dictate who you talk to, WTF.

Maray1967 · 20/08/2025 07:16

I would make sure PIL know my views and that it would be better if I don’t see BIL. I have a friend who told her own parents she was disgusted by her brother’s behaviour (similar to this) and she did not see him while he was with OW - relationship didn’t last long. She also told her parents that she was not impressed with how they had basically dumped their DIL as though she had never existed.

PestoHoliday · 20/08/2025 07:15

Get in touch with your SIL and apologise for not being there for her.
NB She might decide she's not interested in staying on good terms with someone who dropped her like a hot potato when her husband was whoring around behind her back.

Tell your DH he isn't the boss of you, and means it. You don't have to drop friends, attend social functions or create Mumsnet posts just because he says so.

Don't go to the BBQ.

If this relationship lasts long-term you'll have to accept it for family occasions like Christmas. You don't have to be friends but you'll need to be polite.

Currently, though, it's just your slutty BIL and his current affair partner. Who knows how many of those he'll go through if he's prepared to cheat on the mother of his children.

MC846 · 20/08/2025 07:14

Why on earth did you drop your SIL as a friend because your DH told you to, if mine did that I'd laugh in his face. He doesn't get to dictate your friends and who you spend time with because you're his wife! You're not his property. If course you don't need to go to their BBQ, if he wants to take the kids that's fine. I wouldn't go 💐