Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find these comments from new mum friend intensely irritating

243 replies

HopalongHorace · 18/08/2025 06:25

A friend has recently had a baby and I’m getting “first person in the world to ever have a baby” vibes and starting to find it irritating. For context I have a 8 month old and a few other girls in our friendship group also have had babies in the past year or so. Naturally everyone was thrilled when friend got pregnant as it’s something she’s wanted for a while, but was waiting to meet the right partner (which she now has).

I’ll give some examples of comments she has made -

Is it normal to not let the baby out of your sight and just want to look at them all the time, I don’t know how other mums get anything done as I just can’t stop staring at Kevin (not his real name)

I know everyone says it’s amazing when you have a baby but for me it’s just something more, this incredible bond like nothing else, a very unique thing between me and Kevin

Gosh I don’t know how you can bear to leave your baby (I recently left mine with my sister for 4 hours for the first time), I don’t think I could leave Kevin as our bond is too strong and he needs me

Maybe I’m being sensitive but it feels like she thinks she loves Kevin more than the rest of us love our kids (which I don’t think is true), has anyone else experienced this or AIBU?

OP posts:
JMSA · 18/08/2025 23:17

God, she sounds like a total bore.

InMyShowgirlEra · 18/08/2025 22:56

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 22:26

Of course there's nothing wrong with leaving a baby with their father before six months or with grandparents for a few hours. Bit I chose not to, because I didn't want to leave my baby. Which massively riles up the ones crowing about how desperate you'll be to palm them off. I do believe it's wrong to leave a young baby for a whole weekend from a biological and attachment point of view.

These kinds of "I can't believe" blanket statements irritate people, make them feel they're are doing something wrong, whilst giving you the pleasure of appearing, falsely, oh so righteous.

I haven't made any self righteous comments or "I can't believe" statements, I simply don't understand these people. There are lots of people I don't understand in life. I can't understand the spitefulness they show jeering at happy mums that they too will be desperate to palm their kids off soon enough either. I think it's sad that they feel that way, they're clearly unhappy to wish misery on the rest of us.

If it's oh so righteous to tell these spiteful harpies that actually some mums enjoy being with their babies all the time and it's not a given that they will want to give their kids over to whoever will take them for an hour soon because they're awful and annoying, then I'll gladly take that medal thanks ☺️

As for making vulnerable new mums feel stressed by having an opinion, don't be ridiculous.

I'm more concerned about what you did to your child's bond with their father by never letting them have a moment alone together before 6 months. 😢By 6 months, my husband and I were equal parents and he did everything I did except breastfeeding, I can't imagine how much they'd have both missed out on if I'd kept my baby like property.

Screamingabdabz · 18/08/2025 22:47

Oh ignore the dickheads op. You’re perfectly right to be irritated. I would just take the piss and say “yes well you’re obviously such a better mother than the rest of us. We must not love our babies much at all compared to your infinite love for Kevin…” and roll your eyes. Hopefully holding a mirror up to her ridiculous affirmations might make her come back to reality a bit.

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 22:26

Of course there's nothing wrong with leaving a baby with their father before six months or with grandparents for a few hours. Bit I chose not to, because I didn't want to leave my baby. Which massively riles up the ones crowing about how desperate you'll be to palm them off. I do believe it's wrong to leave a young baby for a whole weekend from a biological and attachment point of view.

These kinds of "I can't believe" blanket statements irritate people, make them feel they're are doing something wrong, whilst giving you the pleasure of appearing, falsely, oh so righteous.

I haven't made any self righteous comments or "I can't believe" statements, I simply don't understand these people. There are lots of people I don't understand in life. I can't understand the spitefulness they show jeering at happy mums that they too will be desperate to palm their kids off soon enough either. I think it's sad that they feel that way, they're clearly unhappy to wish misery on the rest of us.

If it's oh so righteous to tell these spiteful harpies that actually some mums enjoy being with their babies all the time and it's not a given that they will want to give their kids over to whoever will take them for an hour soon because they're awful and annoying, then I'll gladly take that medal thanks ☺️

As for making vulnerable new mums feel stressed by having an opinion, don't be ridiculous.

Bccbonbon · 18/08/2025 20:49

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 10:06

What a mean spirited thread.

It's not a given that she's struggling and miserable and faking being happy, that's a whole.load of projection from the vipers. Some mums just love being with their baby all the time.

My daughter is 15 months and I still won't leave her without anyone other than my husband unless it's an emergency. She goes to nursery two afternoons a week while we're both at work and the rest of the time she's at home with one of us. I didn't leave her with my husband until she was 6 months old and even then it was only for a few hours at a time. I still did everything I did before having her, I just took her with me. She's spent half her life in a sling around horses while I muck out and stuff hay nets. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being attached to your baby.

I have no idea how parents of babies can leave their baby with grandparents overnight or even for a whole weekend which is what someone I know did! Bonkers. I really don't understand the mums who complain endlessly about their kids and are always desperate to hand them off to anyone who will take them. It's sad.

And there's absolutely nothing wrong with leaving your baby with their father before six months, or with grandparents for a few hours. This is so context dependent. What kind of father, what kind of grandparent. How involved, how capable, how loving, how nurturing they are, what's your relationship with them... These kinds of "I can't believe" blanket statements irritate people, make them feel they're are doing something wrong, whilst giving you the pleasure of appearing, falsely, oh so righteous. Especially new and first time mums can be emotionally vulnerable and making such generalist, frankly unthoughtful comments only creates stress on them whilst making you feel superior. But you aren't. A superior person would be non judgmental, and understanding. Here is a medal, bravo.

Bccbonbon · 18/08/2025 20:48

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 10:06

What a mean spirited thread.

It's not a given that she's struggling and miserable and faking being happy, that's a whole.load of projection from the vipers. Some mums just love being with their baby all the time.

My daughter is 15 months and I still won't leave her without anyone other than my husband unless it's an emergency. She goes to nursery two afternoons a week while we're both at work and the rest of the time she's at home with one of us. I didn't leave her with my husband until she was 6 months old and even then it was only for a few hours at a time. I still did everything I did before having her, I just took her with me. She's spent half her life in a sling around horses while I muck out and stuff hay nets. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being attached to your baby.

I have no idea how parents of babies can leave their baby with grandparents overnight or even for a whole weekend which is what someone I know did! Bonkers. I really don't understand the mums who complain endlessly about their kids and are always desperate to hand them off to anyone who will take them. It's sad.

And there's absolutely nothing wrong with leaving your baby with their father before six months, or with grandparents for a few hours. This is so context dependent. What kind of father, what kind of grandparent. How involved, how capable, how loving, how nurturing they are, what's your relationship with them... These kinds of "I can't believe" blanket statements irritate people, make them feel they're are doing something wrong, whilst giving you the pleasure of appearing, falsely, oh so righteous. Especially new and first time mums can be emotionally vulnerable and making such generalist, frankly unthoughtful comments only creates stress on them whilst making you feel superior. But you aren't. A superior person would be non judgmental, and understanding. Here is a medal, bravo.

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 17:53

thepariscrimefiles · 18/08/2025 17:02

There's nothing wrong with liking having your child with you. It doesn't mean that mums who let their child sleep over at their grandparents occasionally don't enjoy their child's company. It's definitely very bitchy for you to call them 'miserable mummies'.

Also, according to this thread there is something wrong with liking having your child with you. There are a lot of unhappy people on this thread.

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 17:52

thepariscrimefiles · 18/08/2025 17:02

There's nothing wrong with liking having your child with you. It doesn't mean that mums who let their child sleep over at their grandparents occasionally don't enjoy their child's company. It's definitely very bitchy for you to call them 'miserable mummies'.

Having an older child sleep over at grandparents occasionally is very different from leaving a young baby for a whole weekend. That's not normal in my opinion and it's the ones desperate to hand their kids off to anyone who will have them for an hour that are judging and taking the piss out of a mum who doesn't want to leave her baby like it's weird and she's just being stupid and one day she will see that actually Kevin is awful and she'll be desperate to ditch him too. Mean mummies indeed.

I stand by my statement.

thepariscrimefiles · 18/08/2025 17:02

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 14:50

No need to be so bitchy.

She's a very happy and capable child, I just prefer to have her with me and am not desperate to bin her off like these miserable mummies 😀

Nothing wrong with actually liking having your child with you, if you're so offended by the concept you might want to think about why that is.

There's nothing wrong with liking having your child with you. It doesn't mean that mums who let their child sleep over at their grandparents occasionally don't enjoy their child's company. It's definitely very bitchy for you to call them 'miserable mummies'.

WickWood · 18/08/2025 17:00

Milly16 · 18/08/2025 16:46

I got from mum friends with boys that they loved their babies more because of the special mum son thing. I don't know why it upset me but it did at the time, very deeply. I felt they pitied me and I was missing out. Of course I should have focused on me and my baby but it's a time when you are very sensitive and other people can be extremely insensitive

I have a baby boy and this is so odd. I'm sorry people said that to you! I love my son just as much as id have loved a girl and the same amount as anyone else!

thepariscrimefiles · 18/08/2025 16:53

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 10:06

What a mean spirited thread.

It's not a given that she's struggling and miserable and faking being happy, that's a whole.load of projection from the vipers. Some mums just love being with their baby all the time.

My daughter is 15 months and I still won't leave her without anyone other than my husband unless it's an emergency. She goes to nursery two afternoons a week while we're both at work and the rest of the time she's at home with one of us. I didn't leave her with my husband until she was 6 months old and even then it was only for a few hours at a time. I still did everything I did before having her, I just took her with me. She's spent half her life in a sling around horses while I muck out and stuff hay nets. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being attached to your baby.

I have no idea how parents of babies can leave their baby with grandparents overnight or even for a whole weekend which is what someone I know did! Bonkers. I really don't understand the mums who complain endlessly about their kids and are always desperate to hand them off to anyone who will take them. It's sad.

You call this a mean-spirited threat and then you come out with this judgemental load of crap:

'I have no idea how parents of babies can leave their baby with grandparents overnight or even for a whole weekend which is what someone I know did! Bonkers. I really don't understand the mums who complain endlessly about their kids and are always desperate to hand them off to anyone who will take them. It's sad.'

Milly16 · 18/08/2025 16:46

I got from mum friends with boys that they loved their babies more because of the special mum son thing. I don't know why it upset me but it did at the time, very deeply. I felt they pitied me and I was missing out. Of course I should have focused on me and my baby but it's a time when you are very sensitive and other people can be extremely insensitive

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 16:00

Ddakji · 18/08/2025 15:35

I agree that those comments are mean-spirited, I just think your post was as well.

Cool.

Ddakji · 18/08/2025 15:35

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 15:20

Shame away. I wouldn't pay any notice.

Loving being with your babies and not wanting to be separated from them is fine and normal, why is there 6 pages of mean spirited comments saying "She'll see! She'll be desperate to palm him off soon when Kevin is awful!"? So they can all point and laugh at the happy mum who loves being with her baby when she realises how shit it actually is? Because they want her to be unhappy and stressed like they are? This thread is dripping with "I'm miserable and can't wait for you to be too!" vibes. For some reason it really annoys other mums when a mum is actually happy with her baby, you see it here all the time and in real life.

I agree that those comments are mean-spirited, I just think your post was as well.

Springtimehere · 18/08/2025 15:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Springtimehere · 18/08/2025 15:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 15:20

Ddakji · 18/08/2025 10:30

Your post is also mean-spirited.

And you do leave your baby with someone other than you/your DH if she’s in nursery 2 afternoons a week.

I could shame you for doing that as I didn’t send DD to nursery until she was 2. But I won’t because that would be pretty shitty of me.

Shame away. I wouldn't pay any notice.

Loving being with your babies and not wanting to be separated from them is fine and normal, why is there 6 pages of mean spirited comments saying "She'll see! She'll be desperate to palm him off soon when Kevin is awful!"? So they can all point and laugh at the happy mum who loves being with her baby when she realises how shit it actually is? Because they want her to be unhappy and stressed like they are? This thread is dripping with "I'm miserable and can't wait for you to be too!" vibes. For some reason it really annoys other mums when a mum is actually happy with her baby, you see it here all the time and in real life.

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 15:05

Astleyxyz · 18/08/2025 10:30

Yey !! Let’s shame all the working parents who didn’t have a choice but to leave their babies with relatives or childcare ffs, because they have bills to pay.

I work full time. So does my husband.

No shame for working parents here, you're imagining it.

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 15:04

WickWood · 18/08/2025 10:28

This is such an odd take, imo. I could say, i don't understand how I could drop my baby off at nursery with strangers, thus I've resigned from my job so my baby doesn't go to nursery and I'm with them 24/7 (actually true) But what would I gain from that, other than trying to make someone - you - feel bad? I dont love my baby more than you love yours just because I'm able to give up work to be with him all the time. But, nor do you love your baby more than others just because you won't leave them with anyone.

I haven't claimed I love my baby any more than else.

I just find the culture of telling mums that are attached to their babies that "They will see!! They'll be desperate to palm them off on anyone who will have them for half an hour in two months!!" Weird and sad. It's very often not true, they just want it to be, for some strange reason. It was repeated to me a lot when my daughter was born, id be desperate to get rid of her for an hour by the time she's 6 months old! Then that came and went and people said I'd be desperate to get rid of her for a few hours by 8 months! Then that came and went. People have only just stopped telling me I'll be desperate to get rid of her a for a few hours soon and she's 15 months.

Why are women so hell-bent on telling other women how desperate they will be to palm their kids off for an hour in the future so that they can presumably laugh at them and say see! That baby love haze didn't last did it!? It's just mean spirited and sad.

Radiowaawaa · 18/08/2025 14:59

If Kevin is still very new then your friend is still in the whirlwind of shock and awe. She will stop soon.

KarmenPQZ · 18/08/2025 14:58

Awwww the new born stage is so special. I remember spending hours just staring at my brand new baby.

try to be kind to her - I’m sure her hormones are all over the place. Maybe have some stock replies like above when she’s being like this?

CatsMagic · 18/08/2025 14:58

Ah don’t overthink it, she’s just verbalising what everyone secretly thinks anyway - our own babies are always the most loved/precious/special.

Just smile and nod.

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 14:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ due to privacy concerns.

Good for you! There's nothing wrong with being attached to your baby!

It's such a shame all these nasty women need to take the piss out of women who are attached to their babies and make snide comments about how she will be dying to hand her baby off in 6 months to anyone who will have him. Spoiler, I didn't and she may not either! That will really annoy them won't it!

Digidestined · 18/08/2025 14:54

OneNeatBlueOrca · 18/08/2025 10:19

She's spent half her life in a sling around horses while I muck out and stuff hay nets. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being attached to your baby.

My friend has just had surgery to wire her fractured jaw after her horse kicked her in the face while tending to it.

You actually kept your baby in a sling around horses, constantly. Theyre easily spooked and easily bolt.

See, we can all do it.You won't leave your baby anyone with any other human but think she is safe strapped to your front in the presence of horses.

Never would I ever risk my baby around that after hearing what happened to my friend. The baby wouldn't have survived if my friend had it strapped to her in a sling when it did that.

So we can all do it how can you risk your baby's life around such dangerous animals. She's safer with her grandparents. Don't get me started on nurseries.

Edited

Lol there's always a fence between me and the horses if my daughter is in the sling, I never handle the horses while she's with me. I don't take any risks with her safety but thanks for your concern 😉

Nurseries are good for socialisation but if you think they're going to murder your child then it's your right not to use them. No one is making you.

LoztWorld · 18/08/2025 14:51

GRex · 18/08/2025 14:24

He's a newborn baby. You can turn of the panic sirens at the awful thought that he might realise he's loved for a fucking minute.

😂