Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To seriously judge this man?

117 replies

Canyoucreateoneplease · 17/08/2025 16:11

A colleague of mine’s BIL has had an affair, got his affair partner pregnant, and is now moving to China to be with her. He’s divorcing his wife and leaving behind his three sons, who are 17, 11 and 5.

How can anyone do this? I know affairs happen and lots of people leave their partners, but how can he leave his kids? Colleague is backing him and following her DH’s line that he’s been unhappy for years and his wife is awful, which I completely believe, but leaving behind your kids? I can’t fathom how anyone could do it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SorcererGaheris · 19/08/2025 17:40

MidnightMeltdown · 17/08/2025 22:03

How is it a good relationship? You said that you’re not sure that he ever loved her. Would you want to spend the rest of your life in a relationship with someone you don’t love? I certainly wouldn’t.

@MidnightMeltdown

I think the OP meant that he has (or had) a good relationship with his sons, not a good relationship with his wife.

It's not so much leaving his wife that the OP is disgusted by, it's the fact that he's planning to move so far away from his children.

VaseofViolets · 19/08/2025 15:20

RhaenysRocks · 19/08/2025 14:57

sure, but then you have left your kids, severed that parenting relationship and cannot expect to be thought well of. Especially if then you are telling anyone who will listen what a psycho your ex is - but not so pyscho that she can't be trusted with the kids?

I agree - they know people will think poorly of them and that the relationship with the children will change, but that’s obviously the price they’re willing to pay.

RhaenysRocks · 19/08/2025 14:57

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 19:43

Of course it’s possible that someone can make your life a living hell and you decide to move away - whether that’s China or somewhere else.

sure, but then you have left your kids, severed that parenting relationship and cannot expect to be thought well of. Especially if then you are telling anyone who will listen what a psycho your ex is - but not so pyscho that she can't be trusted with the kids?

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 19:43

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 19:22

No, it’s not. No one can make you leave your kids to live in China.

Of course it’s possible that someone can make your life a living hell and you decide to move away - whether that’s China or somewhere else.

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 19:22

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 18:44

I was talking in general, not about this specific example. But sure, China, it’s possible.

No, it’s not. No one can make you leave your kids to live in China.

OP posts:
hazelowens · 18/08/2025 18:57

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 18:47

‘I do think if I had kept the boys away from him he wouldn’t have fought for them’

But why would you want to do that?

And he shouldn’t have to fight for them in any case. They’re just as much his children as they are yours.

Edited

I wouldn't have kept his children from him but I had to remind him that his children needed him more than a few hours on a Tuesday.

He had said to me he would never have another woman keep him from his children. I now realise that he was never kept from his children, he just never bothered with them and his first wife wasn't that bothered about him having a relationship with his kids

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 18:47

hazelowens · 18/08/2025 15:17

When I met my now exdh he told me that any kids we had would be coming with him if we split up as his first ex wife had taken his kids away from him. Fast Forward 17 years and he is having an affair and I find out and tell him to leave, that was the Monday, on the Tuesday he did come and take the boys who were 7,10 and 13 out for a few hours, he might have taken them for dinner. I was ready for the fight and went to see a lawyer on the Wednesday, heard nothing from him from that Tuesday to the following Tuesday when again he took the boys for a few hours. This carried on for a wee while till I reminded him of the no woman will take my children again talk he had had with me. I had to tell him when he was seeing the boys cause at the time the boys were desperate to see their dad. Now 11 yrs on the now 24 yr old has his own place but does think the sun shines out his dad's butt. The 21 yr old can't be bothered with him and hasn't stayed over with him since he was about 15 and our now 18 yr old still sees him but has to ask permission from his dad's girlfriend if he wants to stay at his dad's at the weekend. He only wants to stay as it means he can get rid work easier.

I do think if I had kept the boys away from him he wouldn't have fought for them but would be telling the world that I was stopping him from seeing them

‘I do think if I had kept the boys away from him he wouldn’t have fought for them’

But why would you want to do that?

And he shouldn’t have to fight for them in any case. They’re just as much his children as they are yours.

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 18:44

Nanny0gg · 18/08/2025 18:00

To China?

Sorry, that's on him

I was talking in general, not about this specific example. But sure, China, it’s possible.

Nanny0gg · 18/08/2025 18:00

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 00:08

Some women hate their ex more than they love their children, so do their utmost to drive him away.

To China?

Sorry, that's on him

hazelowens · 18/08/2025 15:17

When I met my now exdh he told me that any kids we had would be coming with him if we split up as his first ex wife had taken his kids away from him. Fast Forward 17 years and he is having an affair and I find out and tell him to leave, that was the Monday, on the Tuesday he did come and take the boys who were 7,10 and 13 out for a few hours, he might have taken them for dinner. I was ready for the fight and went to see a lawyer on the Wednesday, heard nothing from him from that Tuesday to the following Tuesday when again he took the boys for a few hours. This carried on for a wee while till I reminded him of the no woman will take my children again talk he had had with me. I had to tell him when he was seeing the boys cause at the time the boys were desperate to see their dad. Now 11 yrs on the now 24 yr old has his own place but does think the sun shines out his dad's butt. The 21 yr old can't be bothered with him and hasn't stayed over with him since he was about 15 and our now 18 yr old still sees him but has to ask permission from his dad's girlfriend if he wants to stay at his dad's at the weekend. He only wants to stay as it means he can get rid work easier.

I do think if I had kept the boys away from him he wouldn't have fought for them but would be telling the world that I was stopping him from seeing them

Sasssquatch · 18/08/2025 15:05

Eyesopenwideawake · 17/08/2025 16:40

You have no right to judge when you don't know all the details. Simple.

I disagree. I think we should be more vocally disapproving of shitty behaviour. being intensely insular and disinterested in others behaviour does not a good society make. It allows it to continue. It validates and condones it.

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 14:56

StrokeRecovery25 · 18/08/2025 14:25

He's deluded if he thinks young teens, who presumably don't speak Chinese & have been abandoned by their Dad are going to go & live in China.

can he afford to pay for them to visit him frequently?

they're MUCH more likely to say 'fuck you' than to go live there.

I agree. I think it’s likely the relationships never recover.

OP posts:
Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 14:55

thepariscrimefiles · 18/08/2025 14:22

Is he intending to support his kids financially or will he take advantage of the fact that the UK doesn't have any reciprocal enforcement of maintenance arrangements with China to avoid paying child maintenance?

Why does he think that his older boys will come to live with him in China when they reach the age of 18 if they have stopped speaking to him?

He's quit his job so I’m not sure what money he has to give.

I think he’s trying to ease his own guilt.

OP posts:
StrokeRecovery25 · 18/08/2025 14:25

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 13:57

Yep, exactly how I feel.

He has always doted on the kids too. He apparently thinks the older two will follow him to China in a few years.

He's deluded if he thinks young teens, who presumably don't speak Chinese & have been abandoned by their Dad are going to go & live in China.

can he afford to pay for them to visit him frequently?

they're MUCH more likely to say 'fuck you' than to go live there.

StrokeRecovery25 · 18/08/2025 14:25

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 13:57

Yep, exactly how I feel.

He has always doted on the kids too. He apparently thinks the older two will follow him to China in a few years.

He's deluded if he thinks young teens, who presumably don't speak Chinese & have been abandoned by their Dad are going to go & live in China.

can he afford to pay for them to visit him frequently?

they're MUCH more likely to say 'fuck you' than to go live there.

amillionandone · 18/08/2025 14:23

It's breathtakingly selfish to put your sexual desires above your children's need for a present parent. Whatever his issues with his wife, he chose to have three kids with her, and now he's happily moving far away, where he can't reasonably expect to be a meaningful part of their lives. The younger two especially will be damaged by this choice to abandon them.

He could at least have chosen someone who lives in the same country so he wouldn't be moving halfway around the world. It's a shitty thing to do, and no amount of excuse-making can change that.

thepariscrimefiles · 18/08/2025 14:22

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 14:08

That’s the thing, he was always a good dad. He doted on the kids, they were his world. He was very young when the oldest boy was born and many boys his age might not have stepped up like he did. And then one day to leave them all for another woman and baby?

Is he intending to support his kids financially or will he take advantage of the fact that the UK doesn't have any reciprocal enforcement of maintenance arrangements with China to avoid paying child maintenance?

Why does he think that his older boys will come to live with him in China when they reach the age of 18 if they have stopped speaking to him?

StrokeRecovery25 · 18/08/2025 14:17

IfYoureLeavingTakeMeToo · 18/08/2025 10:24

Completely agree

You don't know the full story

He's leaving his 3 children & moving to the other side of the world (for some AP) What more story do we need?

your user name is ironic

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 14:08

housethatbuiltme · 18/08/2025 13:59

TBF the kind of person that abandons their young child probably wasn't a 'good' parent that will be missed anyway.

I fully think parents relationships are ZERO reflection on parenting, it can be GOOD parenting to leave miserable or abusive relationships. Moving on and having another relationship isn't an attack on your children either. Parents are people with lives too and can have lives and still be good parents to their kids.

Being a deadbeat parent is a choice. Walking away from your kids like they never existed is just shit parenting but if they weren't a good dad to begin with the kids are probably fine (my dad was an emotionally abusive twat, I never missed him when he vanished. I was relieved actually).

As for cheating, well its just shitty behavior but I'm not going to hate a stranger (I have more things in my own life to worry about).

That’s the thing, he was always a good dad. He doted on the kids, they were his world. He was very young when the oldest boy was born and many boys his age might not have stepped up like he did. And then one day to leave them all for another woman and baby?

OP posts:
StrokeRecovery25 · 18/08/2025 14:08

TempestTost · 18/08/2025 10:23

I also find this sort of thing flabberghasting. Not the end of the marriage, but moving away so far.

The best spin I can put on it is that he sees it as a choice between abandoning those kids or abandoning the new one. Which is certainly a difficult proposition if the new woman won't leave China.

Frankly though I think he's a fool to settle in China. I imagine a pp who says he is running away from his problems is correct.

As for the colleagues - it may be they are only supportive in a very shallow sense, because it's not a personal relationship and they don't see it as their role to be openly critical.

Nope, not a difficult decision in my book.

3 children 17, 11 & 5 V a pregnancy (with a woman who could probably live here if she wanted to).

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 14:06

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 13:59

Honestly, you just keep repeating yourself now. We get it, you think he’s a bastard, and I’m sure your opinion will matter to him enormously…

Why do you care so much? 🥱

If it bothers you then just hide the thread.

OP posts:
tinytemper66 · 18/08/2025 14:02

It is nothing to do with you.

housethatbuiltme · 18/08/2025 13:59

TBF the kind of person that abandons their young child probably wasn't a 'good' parent that will be missed anyway.

I fully think parents relationships are ZERO reflection on parenting, it can be GOOD parenting to leave miserable or abusive relationships. Moving on and having another relationship isn't an attack on your children either. Parents are people with lives too and can have lives and still be good parents to their kids.

Being a deadbeat parent is a choice. Walking away from your kids like they never existed is just shit parenting but if they weren't a good dad to begin with the kids are probably fine (my dad was an emotionally abusive twat, I never missed him when he vanished. I was relieved actually).

As for cheating, well its just shitty behavior but I'm not going to hate a stranger (I have more things in my own life to worry about).

VaseofViolets · 18/08/2025 13:59

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 13:54

What could there be to know that would justify leaving your kids to move to China?

Honestly, you just keep repeating yourself now. We get it, you think he’s a bastard, and I’m sure your opinion will matter to him enormously…

Why do you care so much? 🥱

Canyoucreateoneplease · 18/08/2025 13:57

StrokeRecovery25 · 18/08/2025 13:53

This.

leaving his wife, well, it happens & we've no idea what he has/hasn't trued or what she's really like.

moving out if the family home when you have kids. Sad but sometimes for the best.

moving away so you're not near by. Not ideal but sometimes jobs/col have to be considered

moving continents away, unacceptable (except for possibly a few reasons & strategies put in place). Moving to bloody Chinese for an AP & leaving your 3 children ???

though given he can do this to them. They're probably better off without him!!

Yep, exactly how I feel.

He has always doted on the kids too. He apparently thinks the older two will follow him to China in a few years.

OP posts: