Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband unhappy with my friendship with a man

232 replies

Lll09 · 16/08/2025 06:41

I knew my friend long before I met my husband; we have been close friends for years, and it's purely platonic, with no romantic feelings whatsoever. However, my husband has become increasingly annoyed at the amount of time I've even spending with them - he has been made redundant and has a lot of free time.
My husband asked me to stop spending so much time together, I refused and 6 months ago he left.

On the whole, I thought we had a happy marriage, aside from this issue. We have 2 children, plus 1 from my previous marriage. I thought, he'd clam down and we'd progress to counselling but he's made it clear he isn't interested.

At the start of the school holidays, he told me he is no longer willing to financially support me and has told me to find a full time job. It's going to be a nightmare because he has been very noncommittal about providing childcare for his step child, although he has said he will continue to contribute to their school fees.

A few friends have said I should have acquiesced, and I sometimes thing i should have.

OP posts:
ThatBlackCat · 16/08/2025 12:05

Balloonhearts · 16/08/2025 12:03

I'd tell him to grow the fuck up. I have male friends. If I wanted to bang them, I would have done years ago.

Would you say that to a male who is spending 4 days a week with his female friend? OP needs to grow up. She blew up her marriage for a deadbeat sidepiece that doesn't even work himself.

ThatBlackCat · 16/08/2025 12:03

usedtobeaylis · 16/08/2025 12:01

I think this is being missed. If she's fully responsible for the childcare and works part time, I don't think meeting up with friends, even if it's the same friend, four times a week is unreasonable. One of those times is during the day when presumably the husband is at work then so effectively two evenings a week and a few hours on one weekend day for some of the year. That could potentially add to to no more than 10 hours in total over the course of a week, with ALL the other hours taken up with work and caring for 3 children and running the house.

10 hours a week is way too much. Especially when she won't spend any time with her family.

If this was a male spending time with a female friend no one would let him off the hook. This OP is deeply and utterly obsessed with a man outside of her marriage and chose to blow her entire marriage up and her children's security for him. And the deadbeat friend doesn't work either.

Balloonhearts · 16/08/2025 12:03

I'd tell him to grow the fuck up. I have male friends. If I wanted to bang them, I would have done years ago.

usedtobeaylis · 16/08/2025 12:02

ThatBlackCat · 16/08/2025 11:58

Read the OP's posts @usedtobeaylis . He didn't try to 'control' anything. He said he was uncomfortable with the amount of time she was spending with him. She refused to change. Couldn't, because she is obsessed with this sidepiece man. Leaving her husband no option but to leave. She chose her sidepiece over her husband and her family. Her husband is such a good man that he is paying for her child, that isn't even his, school fees while OP until now has refused to get a job to pay for her own children. She has used and taken advantage of her husband and blown her marriage up. Her husband deserves better.

I've read them and I don't think the time she spent with friends is unreasonable given she is working part time and clearly responsible for he children at all other times.

usedtobeaylis · 16/08/2025 12:01

jeaux90 · 16/08/2025 06:56

If I’m honest I’d be pissed off of my partner was just working part time and hanging out with friends, but I assume you are doing the majority of the childcare which is why you are part time? Sometimes we just don’t share the same objectives, shared goals and ethics and this can definitely break a marriage. You need to get practical and start sorting out child access (get a CAO in place as part of the divorce) and work out the split of assets. See a solicitor

I think this is being missed. If she's fully responsible for the childcare and works part time, I don't think meeting up with friends, even if it's the same friend, four times a week is unreasonable. One of those times is during the day when presumably the husband is at work then so effectively two evenings a week and a few hours on one weekend day for some of the year. That could potentially add to to no more than 10 hours in total over the course of a week, with ALL the other hours taken up with work and caring for 3 children and running the house.

ThatBlackCat · 16/08/2025 11:58

usedtobeaylis · 16/08/2025 11:54

No you shouldn't have acquiesced. When your partner starts trying to control who you're friends with or how often you see them, no. I have been there and ended up losing touch with two very, very good male friends and I should never have allowed that.

It will be difficult trying to juggle everything in ways you're not used to but you will get through it and in the end won't have anyone telling you how to conduct your friendships. The fact that he has been non-commital about childcare makes me wonder if he was also objecting to looking after the children while you were out with friends. He will have to contribute financially to whatever childcare is in place for them (not necessarily for his step child but for his biological children).

Edited

Read the OP's posts @usedtobeaylis . He didn't try to 'control' anything. He said he was uncomfortable with the amount of time she was spending with him. She refused to change. Couldn't, because she is obsessed with this sidepiece man. Leaving her husband no option but to leave. She chose her sidepiece over her husband and her family. Her husband is such a good man that he is paying for her child, that isn't even his, school fees while OP until now has refused to get a job to pay for her own children. She has used and taken advantage of her husband and blown her marriage up. Her husband deserves better.

Desmodici · 16/08/2025 11:56

Apart from you thinking that your exH should take care of a child that isn't his, I was kind of verging on your side, having had an ex who had massive issues with me having anything to do with the male friends I'd had long before I met him. But then I read all your comments. You saw him three times a week for most of the year? I'm on team husband. You messed up.

usedtobeaylis · 16/08/2025 11:54

No you shouldn't have acquiesced. When your partner starts trying to control who you're friends with or how often you see them, no. I have been there and ended up losing touch with two very, very good male friends and I should never have allowed that.

It will be difficult trying to juggle everything in ways you're not used to but you will get through it and in the end won't have anyone telling you how to conduct your friendships. The fact that he has been non-commital about childcare makes me wonder if he was also objecting to looking after the children while you were out with friends. He will have to contribute financially to whatever childcare is in place for them (not necessarily for his step child but for his biological children).

Casperroonie · 16/08/2025 11:52

Lll09 · 16/08/2025 07:39

My friend and I share a hobby so it was about one evening a week attending the hobby and one Saturday 9 months of the year. We'd maybe go out for lunch once a week. I also meet up with friends one evening a week.

Sounds too much. Either way you made your choice.

Silverbirchleaf · 16/08/2025 11:52

On top of the meet-ups, his often do you phone and text?

MumWifeOther · 16/08/2025 11:44

We see posts on here time after time about men and their female friendships, and how it’s not appropriate and how the man should put his wife feelings first and if he doesn’t, the wife should LTB.

Well, your case is no different. You had a good man supporting a good lifestyle for you and your kids and you put your mate first. Silly.

OneNeatBlueOrca · 16/08/2025 11:43

It hasn't been stated whether or not this male friend has a partner, wife or children. It doesn't sound like it.

The question is if he meet someone he truly wants to be with.
Or if his partner asked him to stop seeing her would he do it

I'd wager he wouldn't blow up his relationship for her and if he isn't with somebody and meet somebody, he likes she won't see him for dust.

You should never, ever make enormous life decisions for somebody who wouldn't do the same for you. He isn't going to step in and pick up the school fees, and the childcare is he? So what was it for.

Ramblethroughthebrambles · 16/08/2025 11:42

Maybe it's just the way you've written your post, but there's no indication you were upset about your DH leaving or actively tried to save your marriage until your DH threatened to remove financial and practical support. You seem to be ignoring that the issue, presumably, wasn't just the friendship but that you were leaving your DH looking after his children and yours every Saturday and 2 or 3 evenings a week when he worked FT & you already had plenty of free time.

Before you subject your DCs to another relationship, I'd have a serious talk with yourself about whether you really want a partner, and what it takes to maintain a relationship.

SomewhatAnnoyed · 16/08/2025 11:42

Lll09 · 16/08/2025 07:39

My friend and I share a hobby so it was about one evening a week attending the hobby and one Saturday 9 months of the year. We'd maybe go out for lunch once a week. I also meet up with friends one evening a week.

Lunch and dinner every week. Did you go on similar frequent dates with your ex?

pinkdelight · 16/08/2025 11:42

Maybe this platonic friend can help you out with childcare for your stepchild? Seeing as he's such a good friend that you chose him over your marriage.

Lostworlds · 16/08/2025 11:35

He doesn’t need to look after his step child though. You’ll need to arrange other childcare and that’s on you to sort and pay for since the father isn’t close by.
This is not your husbands fault.

MaggiesShadow · 16/08/2025 11:33

You've chosen your friend over your husband which is your prerogative but choices have consequences.

You can't rely on him for support, financial or otherwise, for a child who isn't his. Even if he says it now, he's under no obligation to provide for your child so you need to take that into account and figure something out.

Personally, if my DH was upset about something and wasn't being controlling or too unreasonable, and he was bankrolling my lifestyle and that of my child, I wouldn't mind cutting down on lunches and meet-ups. But we're all different.

I know if I felt uncomfortable with my husband spending too much time with another woman and he refused to stop, I'd also be out the door, so...

In my opinion, you've been breath-takingly audacious and entitled. But you need to sort yourself out sooner rather than later. And that means being financially independent. And solely responsible for your child since their other actual parent pissed off to another country and left you and their stepfather to raise them.

Zezet · 16/08/2025 11:32

Not much to add, is there.
You fucked about, you found out. Poor kids.

I too have a best male friend. That's fine. But you seem to have worked under the illusion that as long as you only have sex with one person, it doesn't matter how you divide the rest of your attention, time, care or priorities. Even when your husband indicated he needed more of the latter. That's so insanely dumb and misguided that it's hard to figure out what the hell you were thinking.

BlueMum16 · 16/08/2025 11:31

Lll09 · 16/08/2025 10:55

He only contributes to the fees, the rest are picked up my me and the child's father.

I will struggle if I need to drop the 2 children with him and find someone else to look after my DC. Her father lives in another country for work, and isn't involved aside from paying his child support

I cannot believe you would expect an ex, that you have refused to listen to their concerns about your marriage, to pay school fees and provide care for a child.

You need to get a job, arrange shared parenting with him for your joint children. Is he wanting 50:50? As difficult it is you'll need to explain to your older child why things are different for them.

How old are your DC?

Swiftie1878 · 16/08/2025 11:28

Lll09 · 16/08/2025 10:29

Not time off but if he isn't able to look after all 3 children then I'll need to find alternative childcare.

You sound very cold and transactional.
I suspect there was a deeper unhappiness for your poor husband, and the request for you to pare back your contact with your friend was just a litmus test.

MrsSkylerWhite · 16/08/2025 11:26

olympicsrock · 16/08/2025 07:06

He has no responsibility for his step child at all. Give your head a wobble.

This

Graphinette · 16/08/2025 11:24

Did you aye.

Pherian · 16/08/2025 11:24

Lll09 · 16/08/2025 06:41

I knew my friend long before I met my husband; we have been close friends for years, and it's purely platonic, with no romantic feelings whatsoever. However, my husband has become increasingly annoyed at the amount of time I've even spending with them - he has been made redundant and has a lot of free time.
My husband asked me to stop spending so much time together, I refused and 6 months ago he left.

On the whole, I thought we had a happy marriage, aside from this issue. We have 2 children, plus 1 from my previous marriage. I thought, he'd clam down and we'd progress to counselling but he's made it clear he isn't interested.

At the start of the school holidays, he told me he is no longer willing to financially support me and has told me to find a full time job. It's going to be a nightmare because he has been very noncommittal about providing childcare for his step child, although he has said he will continue to contribute to their school fees.

A few friends have said I should have acquiesced, and I sometimes thing i should have.

You chose your friendship over your marriage and ultimately another man over your husband.

No matter how unfounded his fears were you only asked to do counselling after you pushed him away. You didn’t think about his feelings at all.

Unless he’s adopted your child from the previous marriage he has no responsibility whatsoever to provide for them.

You 100% should be looking for a full time job so you can support yourself.

It’s cheeky that you still expect the benefits of marriage and partnership after it’s over. You really have some nerve.

How is your friendship now after it’s destroyed your marriage ?

pinkyredrose · 16/08/2025 11:22

Why was he contributing to your kids school fees?

Ihatelittlefriendsusan · 16/08/2025 11:22

Your dh owes your child from previous relationship nothing. He has no obligation to provide to school fees or childcare so for that you need to get over your entitlement and pay for your child.

In respect to the friend...I am torn here. I have a few very close male friends, nothing even close to romantic and far before of a sibling relationship. My dh wouldn't dream of making me choose and knows full well it would not end well for him. So I do understand your refusal to reduce the friendship. And actually I think your dh is being a controlling arsehole if your post about the amount of time you spend together is the truth.

That said there are always 2 sides and I wonder if you are being honest about the real reason for the split. Sounds more like your dh is sick of bank rolling someone else's child.

Put frankly, if you and the child's dad cant afford the private school fees without input from your dh then they shouldn't be going.