Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel hurt that some women who cannot conceive seem to take it out on other women who get pregnant but never the men?

433 replies

joyjoyw · 08/08/2025 17:53

I struggled with infertility for years. It was painful, isolating, and at times it felt like my body was betraying me. Along the way, I made a few close friendships with other women who were going through the same. We bonded over the grief, the tests, the waiting, the hope.

But when I finally got pregnant, something I never even believed would happen, I was overjoyed, but also mindful. I didn’t make big announcements. I tried to be sensitive. But several of those women just cut me off, almost overnight. No explanation, no "I need space", just silence. It hurt deeply.

What confuses me is that their anger or pain seemed to be directed only at me, the woman who got pregnant not at my husband. As if I did something to them personally. As if my pregnancy was a betrayal. But the men? Never held to account. No one stopped talking to my husband.

I completely understand that grief and comparison can make people pull away. I know it's not always rational. I know what it feels like to watch others get what you’re desperately hoping for. But I never imagined that when it finally happened to me, I'd lose people I’d once leaned on.

AIBU to feel like there’s something deeply unfair about how women carry so much of this emotional fallout, sometimes even punishing each other while men walk away untouched?

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 10/08/2025 12:02

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 11:55

They are making themselves scarce to anyone who gets pregnant. They have ousted someone else in the group now.

I am beginning to see it as a good thing. I don't need that kind of bitterness in my life.

Edited

Accusing women struggling with infertility of being bitter is really quite cruel. Your empathy button obviously switched off the moment you got your bfp.

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2025 12:00

I have experienced infertility, permanent in my case. Had I been a member of a group of people with fertility issues and become pregnant, I would tactfully withdraw from that group. I would not expect them to react in the same way as friends with children or not trying to have them.

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 11:55

SerafinasGoose · 10/08/2025 11:34

I think - if this is real - that it’s increasingly clear why these friends have made themselves scarce.

They are making themselves scarce to anyone who gets pregnant. They have ousted someone else in the group now.

I am beginning to see it as a good thing. I don't need that kind of bitterness in my life.

OP posts:
joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 11:54

SerafinasGoose · 10/08/2025 11:28

OP. You need a harsh wake-up call I’m afraid. Posters have responded very tactfully in the main to this screed of self-pity (this is what it is; no sugar-coating) and you have doubled down, responding with more self-pity and insistent justification of your feelings of injured resentment.

As others have gently tried to tell you, what you are experiencing is not misogyny. It’s not a sexual double-standard, and I am the first poster to jump on a sexist injustice when I see one. It’s an immutable, biological reality. Irrespective of men’s part in the process, only women get pregnant. Only women gestate. Only women give birth. This has been pointed out to you numerous times but you were rigidly disinclined to listen or see it from the other perspective, and are likely to continue in this vein now.

You are resolute that those undergoing the pain of infertility are maintaining sexist double standards, are oblivious to the pain they face, are determined to project misogynistic double standards onto their natural feelings of hurt over a tangible reminder of what they can’t have, and are insistent that they should ‘be kind’. It’s striking that those who trot out that phrase are nearly always the ones demanding kindness but least willing to extend that desired commodity onto other people. Interestingly enough it’s usually women from whom the kindness is demanded.

You’re being wholly unreasonable, which is even more unfathomable given you’ve so recently been in the same situation. You are asking too much. And I don’t know you, but your stubborn determination to be the injured party here, with no understanding of anyone’s feelings but your own, give some insight into why you are now experiencing the problems you are. You show a staggering lack of empathy, which does beg the question of whether your pregnancy is the only reason your friends have distanced themselves.

You now have a choice: to spend what should be the happiest time of your life wallowing in negativity and resentment. Or you can cherish your happiness at finally achieving what you so desperately wanted, and look forward to future female friendships made at baby groups or breastfeeding support groups. In your shoes I’d be extremely grateful that I had these options.

It’s up to you.

I am not wallowing in negativity and resentment. Just because you wonder about something and post about it does not define your whole life.

I think some of the women in my former group are wallowing in negativity and resentment though. I didn't cut anyone off who got pregnant in my circle like the others did. I was genuinely happy for them even though I was struggling to deal with the death of my child.

Another woman in the group is now getting the same treatment now she is finally pregnant. They have kicked her out of the whatsapp group. She is now experiencing the same treatment as me but then she cut others off too. Karma I guess. She has come to share her happy news with me. I wish her all the best but I not going to resume the friendship.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 10/08/2025 11:51

SerafinasGoose · 10/08/2025 11:34

I think - if this is real - that it’s increasingly clear why these friends have made themselves scarce.

I have come to that conclusion too.

SerafinasGoose · 10/08/2025 11:34

Dodeedoo · 10/08/2025 10:51

I actually understood your point until you posted this

I think - if this is real - that it’s increasingly clear why these friends have made themselves scarce.

SerafinasGoose · 10/08/2025 11:28

OP. You need a harsh wake-up call I’m afraid. Posters have responded very tactfully in the main to this screed of self-pity (this is what it is; no sugar-coating) and you have doubled down, responding with more self-pity and insistent justification of your feelings of injured resentment.

As others have gently tried to tell you, what you are experiencing is not misogyny. It’s not a sexual double-standard, and I am the first poster to jump on a sexist injustice when I see one. It’s an immutable, biological reality. Irrespective of men’s part in the process, only women get pregnant. Only women gestate. Only women give birth. This has been pointed out to you numerous times but you were rigidly disinclined to listen or see it from the other perspective, and are likely to continue in this vein now.

You are resolute that those undergoing the pain of infertility are maintaining sexist double standards, are oblivious to the pain they face, are determined to project misogynistic double standards onto their natural feelings of hurt over a tangible reminder of what they can’t have, and are insistent that they should ‘be kind’. It’s striking that those who trot out that phrase are nearly always the ones demanding kindness but least willing to extend that desired commodity onto other people. Interestingly enough it’s usually women from whom the kindness is demanded.

You’re being wholly unreasonable, which is even more unfathomable given you’ve so recently been in the same situation. You are asking too much. And I don’t know you, but your stubborn determination to be the injured party here, with no understanding of anyone’s feelings but your own, give some insight into why you are now experiencing the problems you are. You show a staggering lack of empathy, which does beg the question of whether your pregnancy is the only reason your friends have distanced themselves.

You now have a choice: to spend what should be the happiest time of your life wallowing in negativity and resentment. Or you can cherish your happiness at finally achieving what you so desperately wanted, and look forward to future female friendships made at baby groups or breastfeeding support groups. In your shoes I’d be extremely grateful that I had these options.

It’s up to you.

Tinnybinnylinny · 10/08/2025 11:16

Blessthismess2 · 10/08/2025 10:03

be grateful they have shown you who they are.

who they are???
Who they are is people in a lot of pain.

Did you not read it? I am one of them…..all the pain.

But people are always going to have children……to be bitter and twisted is a terrible way to live a life.

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 11:16

Here is someone admitting jealousy so it is not uncommon:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/amibeingunreasonable/5324584-to-be-struggling-with-new-niece

MN is full of these kinds of threads which proves it is not just pain that women feel but a range of emotions that can include jealousy, bitterness and resentment.

OP posts:
joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 11:12

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2025 11:08

But any jealousy or resentment is a result of the pain. They would not be feeling these things if they werent feeling the pain of infertility.

But they are still feeling those feelings right? There is still jealousy and resentment even if it is because of the pain.

OP posts:
applegingermint · 10/08/2025 11:10

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 10:58

It is unrealistic to say it could only ever be pain and nothing else. Sometimes there’s jealousy or resentment mixed in too. That doesn't mean the pain isn’t real, it means feelings are complicated and not always one thing.

Humans are complex creatures!

Can you please stop using Chat GPT to write your responses. It’s obvious from a mile away.

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2025 11:08

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 10:58

It is unrealistic to say it could only ever be pain and nothing else. Sometimes there’s jealousy or resentment mixed in too. That doesn't mean the pain isn’t real, it means feelings are complicated and not always one thing.

Humans are complex creatures!

But any jealousy or resentment is a result of the pain. They would not be feeling these things if they werent feeling the pain of infertility.

Reportedex · 10/08/2025 11:03

Why did you ask AIBU when you’re not prepared to hear you might be?

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 10:58

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2025 10:42

You've known the pain of infertility. I can't believe you could say something like this.

It is unrealistic to say it could only ever be pain and nothing else. Sometimes there’s jealousy or resentment mixed in too. That doesn't mean the pain isn’t real, it means feelings are complicated and not always one thing.

Humans are complex creatures!

OP posts:
MaturingCheeseball · 10/08/2025 10:52

I think I’ve rarely seen an OP so unreasonable! Actually more than unreasonable - straight down the line unkind.

It’s utterly self-centred and boorish not to appreciate others’ (very painful) feelings about infertility if you have been there yourself.

Dodeedoo · 10/08/2025 10:51

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 10:31

It might not always be pain though. Sometimes it’s jealousy, sometimes resentment, sometimes just not wanting to see someone else move on. Only they know which it is.

I actually understood your point until you posted this

Reportedex · 10/08/2025 10:50

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 10:31

It might not always be pain though. Sometimes it’s jealousy, sometimes resentment, sometimes just not wanting to see someone else move on. Only they know which it is.

I can’t believe you actually typed that. Wow.

Dodeedoo · 10/08/2025 10:50

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 16:27

I was just agreeing with what another poster said. Several posters have commented it is unpleasant to cut someone off without warning. I know the pain of infertility. It does not get wiped out just because a baby finally comes. I also lost a baby too.

No it doesn’t get wiped away. Does it not make it easier though?

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2025 10:42

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 10:31

It might not always be pain though. Sometimes it’s jealousy, sometimes resentment, sometimes just not wanting to see someone else move on. Only they know which it is.

You've known the pain of infertility. I can't believe you could say something like this.

SophieJo · 10/08/2025 10:39

Wishimaywishimight · 08/08/2025 20:06

You come across as being very lacking in empathy and utterly determined that these women, who are suffering a pain that you are not any longer, are punishing you. They are not, they are protectng themselves. You don't like how they have gone about it but you could try and see things from their point of view.

I don't know you posted in AIBU as you are quite certain you are not.

I totally agree with this comment. You really are very persistent in being completely unreasonable.

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 10:31

Blessthismess2 · 10/08/2025 10:03

be grateful they have shown you who they are.

who they are???
Who they are is people in a lot of pain.

It might not always be pain though. Sometimes it’s jealousy, sometimes resentment, sometimes just not wanting to see someone else move on. Only they know which it is.

OP posts:
Blessthismess2 · 10/08/2025 10:03

Tinnybinnylinny · 10/08/2025 06:36

OP - I am on the other side of this, as in I never had the baby. Some friends that knew about the issues have been positively bizarre with me such as not including me in BBQ invites/ first birthday events. I have reached out and offer to do things with them and their kids, response: I will get back to you on that.

Had I been friends with you, it wouldn’t have bothered me that you were now a mum and I am not, but I think that is because I can rationalise that what happens in your life doesn’t affect the outcome of mine and it’s a long life of being bitter and twisted.

its just women: are on the whole grudge bearing; jealous; frenemies; fake friends….its actually one of the things that if I think about makes me pretty sad.

I agree - a quick text ‘this is hard for me right now’, albeit I did that and got accused of being unhinged (I had lost a baby the same day another person had one and couldn’t at that particular point in time cope with the pics of baby pics - think I am in the hospital just having a D&E and the pics come in kind of thing).

Thankfully that phase of my life is over, I say chose your friends wisely and be grateful they have shown you who they are.

Me - while I have moved on, I am very conscious that people have shown me who they are, it’s noted, while I am not going to hold a grudge I chose my inner circle more carefully now.

Edited

be grateful they have shown you who they are.

who they are???
Who they are is people in a lot of pain.

Grow123 · 10/08/2025 08:13

steff13 · 09/08/2025 18:51

Yeah, it was originally framed as they were all hanging out together and excluding her, but now it sounds more like her husband was going to watch the game with his friend and the wife just happened to be there because it was her house.

Hanging out with the husband is fair enough. But I still think it is kinda unfair that wife is totally fine with op's husband coming over to their house and her being all.ncie and friendly, when she has just cut out op. Or that husbands have organised a day out together for a sports thing and she just comes along as if nothing has happened.

As mentioned, I do understand that pregnant woman is triggering in a different way than a man. Husbands (with each other and with op) can have their individual friendship. But i do think it is understandable that op is hurt that these people have cut op out but still happily and voluntarily spends time with her husband. It would be totally different if husbands just went together. Politely saying hello is one thing, but sitting down and having a chat or even spending an event together (that was initially agreed by just the husbands) when you've cut of their wife is another. These women could do some self reflection now that the dust has settled from the pregnancy news.

But op, these were not true friends. Your husband is doing the right thing for leaving the group. Would have been nice if he (and you) could have still spend time together with those who didnt cut you off, but if their partners are being like this, can't blame you for needing to cut them out in return.

joyjoyw · 10/08/2025 08:11

thisistoofunny · 10/08/2025 06:18

You're nuts. Leave these women alone.

They are being left alone. The one who chose to come back happy to share the news of her pregnancy is also being left alone. I hear now the other women in the group have also cut her off. Good luck to all of them.

OP posts:
Tinnybinnylinny · 10/08/2025 06:36

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 20:19

I followed up a few times then gave up when it was clear they were ghosting me.

Yes I did mention that they might be finding it difficult and I asked after them regarding certain personal things they had told me. No response whatsoever so I left it.

One has come back saying she is now pregnant. That is lovely news for her.

OP - I am on the other side of this, as in I never had the baby. Some friends that knew about the issues have been positively bizarre with me such as not including me in BBQ invites/ first birthday events. I have reached out and offer to do things with them and their kids, response: I will get back to you on that.

Had I been friends with you, it wouldn’t have bothered me that you were now a mum and I am not, but I think that is because I can rationalise that what happens in your life doesn’t affect the outcome of mine and it’s a long life of being bitter and twisted.

its just women: are on the whole grudge bearing; jealous; frenemies; fake friends….its actually one of the things that if I think about makes me pretty sad.

I agree - a quick text ‘this is hard for me right now’, albeit I did that and got accused of being unhinged (I had lost a baby the same day another person had one and couldn’t at that particular point in time cope with the pics of baby pics - think I am in the hospital just having a D&E and the pics come in kind of thing).

Thankfully that phase of my life is over, I say chose your friends wisely and be grateful they have shown you who they are.

Me - while I have moved on, I am very conscious that people have shown me who they are, it’s noted, while I am not going to hold a grudge I chose my inner circle more carefully now.