Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel hurt that some women who cannot conceive seem to take it out on other women who get pregnant but never the men?

433 replies

joyjoyw · 08/08/2025 17:53

I struggled with infertility for years. It was painful, isolating, and at times it felt like my body was betraying me. Along the way, I made a few close friendships with other women who were going through the same. We bonded over the grief, the tests, the waiting, the hope.

But when I finally got pregnant, something I never even believed would happen, I was overjoyed, but also mindful. I didn’t make big announcements. I tried to be sensitive. But several of those women just cut me off, almost overnight. No explanation, no "I need space", just silence. It hurt deeply.

What confuses me is that their anger or pain seemed to be directed only at me, the woman who got pregnant not at my husband. As if I did something to them personally. As if my pregnancy was a betrayal. But the men? Never held to account. No one stopped talking to my husband.

I completely understand that grief and comparison can make people pull away. I know it's not always rational. I know what it feels like to watch others get what you’re desperately hoping for. But I never imagined that when it finally happened to me, I'd lose people I’d once leaned on.

AIBU to feel like there’s something deeply unfair about how women carry so much of this emotional fallout, sometimes even punishing each other while men walk away untouched?

OP posts:
Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 12:04

TheTwitcher11 · 09/08/2025 11:45

I can think of a few - a lot of disabled people slowly withdraw from society, for example.

I’ve had to limit my in person contact with friends who have neurotypical children because my pre-verbal 6 year old will try and eat stones or elope and because their lives revolve around their kids extra curricular activities, we have very little in common anymore, what do you suggest people do in this scenario? Reality is that I’ll be caring for my son for the rest of my life so my circumstances are not going to change? So it’s easier to surround myself with people who truly understand (eg are in same position)

That's a fair point,and I'm sorry for you. I think what you describe feels more like a growing apart due to practical circumstances, rather than avoidance of pain. And to be honest, sometimes the emotional reaction to pregnancy can feel like a personal attack,or at least a guilt trip, as opposed to an acceptance life is just different for the parties involved and not close enough to survive it

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 12:02

freakyfriday23 · 09/08/2025 11:57

Op.i see you thought my post was amusing. Interesting....perhaps these friends distanced themselves from you for reasons that had nothing to do with your pregnancy but used it as an excuse to jump ship ....just a thought 😊

😂

OP posts:
CottageGoblin · 09/08/2025 11:59

Yes but @Winterwonders24 youre making my comment into something that it wasn’t.

Your point is valid, but not really anything to do with mine.

KimberleyClark · 09/08/2025 11:58

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 11:54

We were all friends to start with, and then some of us got closer because of the fertility stuff. But it wasn’t like my husband was on the outside. He was part of the group too. We all did things together, nights out, birthdays, weekends away.

When I got pregnant, the women stopped talking to me but still saw my husband. They’ve gone out with their husbands and him, chatted, even when he’s had the baby with him.

That’s why I think there is a male/female element. He’s also becoming a parent, but no one has treated him like a reminder or a problem. I’m the one who got shut out.

Because, for the umpteenth time, you were the one having the pregnancy experience that they wanted.

It never hit me quite as hard if a male colleague announced they were becoming a dad as when a female colleague announced their pregnancy.

freakyfriday23 · 09/08/2025 11:57

Op.i see you thought my post was amusing. Interesting....perhaps these friends distanced themselves from you for reasons that had nothing to do with your pregnancy but used it as an excuse to jump ship ....just a thought 😊

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 11:57

CottageGoblin · 09/08/2025 11:23

christ! With this level of whatabouttery it’s amazing anyone can see anything from a different point of view.

I never mentioned disabled people. You did. Friendships made from trauma change. And lots of other posters said that.

I have never said it was fine to ghost people you thought were your friends either.

Its not whataboutary, it happened to me: 20 years of significant health and disability, but always supportive of my friend and hearing about her travels and work opportunities: then,one day when she found out we were going to have a baby, the jealousy and lack of pleasure for us was painful. When she did get pregnant, all was fine again. I still love her,always will, but I'll never forget she couldn't give me what id always given her.

TheTwitcher11 · 09/08/2025 11:55

I think you need to remember that people’s lives change forever once they have a child, which means the friendship will never be the same (it’s very different if someone is childfree by choice) it isn’t a case of not being able to afford the same car or luxury holiday as a friend.

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 11:54

longdistanceclaraaa · 09/08/2025 11:46

But were these women close friends with your husband? I got the impression from your OP that they were your support network and vice versa and not your husband's. If that's right, then how could they turn their back on your husband? You also said in an earlier post that no one stopped talking to your husband. Do you mean that these women kept a friendship going with your husband that now excluded you?

I think you are making this a male/female issue when it is not one.

We were all friends to start with, and then some of us got closer because of the fertility stuff. But it wasn’t like my husband was on the outside. He was part of the group too. We all did things together, nights out, birthdays, weekends away.

When I got pregnant, the women stopped talking to me but still saw my husband. They’ve gone out with their husbands and him, chatted, even when he’s had the baby with him.

That’s why I think there is a male/female element. He’s also becoming a parent, but no one has treated him like a reminder or a problem. I’m the one who got shut out.

OP posts:
longdistanceclaraaa · 09/08/2025 11:46

joyjoyw · 08/08/2025 18:04

I have not forgotten what it feels like. I was in that waiting room for years too. I remember every painful cycle, every negative test, every moment of hope followed by crushing disappointment. Infertility is brutal. I would never wish it on anyone.

But it hurts to be told that my feelings now are less valid because I eventually had a baby. Getting pregnant does not erase what I went through. And it definitely does not mean I cannot feel hurt by how some people reacted.

What I find especially difficult is how it is always the woman who gets punished. My partner was just as involved in our fertility journey. He went through it all with me. But when I got pregnant, no one turned their backs on him. No one stopped talking to him. He was not a reminder of anything, apparently. It is always the woman who becomes the symbol of someone else's loss, and it is always the woman who pays the emotional price for it.

Infertility is soul destroying. But being emotionally abandoned by women who once understood your pain is its own kind of grief and men almost never have to deal with that part.

But were these women close friends with your husband? I got the impression from your OP that they were your support network and vice versa and not your husband's. If that's right, then how could they turn their back on your husband? You also said in an earlier post that no one stopped talking to your husband. Do you mean that these women kept a friendship going with your husband that now excluded you?

I think you are making this a male/female issue when it is not one.

TheTwitcher11 · 09/08/2025 11:45

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 11:38

But if they don't say it but think it,they still are: not healthy for them, and I can't think of other circumstances this is so readily excused socially

I can think of a few - a lot of disabled people slowly withdraw from society, for example.

I’ve had to limit my in person contact with friends who have neurotypical children because my pre-verbal 6 year old will try and eat stones or elope and because their lives revolve around their kids extra curricular activities, we have very little in common anymore, what do you suggest people do in this scenario? Reality is that I’ll be caring for my son for the rest of my life so my circumstances are not going to change? So it’s easier to surround myself with people who truly understand (eg are in same position)

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 11:45

KimberleyClark · 08/08/2025 23:09

Yes, but how many of those things are comparable to not being able to have the children you wanted? That cause genuine grief and heartbreak as opposed to disappointment?

Physical health, disability. That's fairly common and people just have to accept it.

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 11:38

TheTwitcher11 · 08/08/2025 21:03

I also understand why they ghosted her - they probably thought the conversation is too difficult to have and they know they sound irrational. Also, reality is, their relationship would be v different with OP once she became a mum as it’s all consuming - for the first few years of the child’s life you speak about little else as they are so dependent on you and your life is naps / bottles/ potty training etc. It wouldn’t be fair on OP to feel she couldn’t speak about her child or on her friends to pretend they want to hear about it! I think it’s easy to say ‘just be honest’ but truth is if they were, they’d only be labelled horrible and bitter.

But if they don't say it but think it,they still are: not healthy for them, and I can't think of other circumstances this is so readily excused socially

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 11:35

NotEnoughKnittingTime · 08/08/2025 20:56

You obviously don't understand infertility and the pain of it. 🤷

What about other life circumstances? Is that ok to just cut people out as they have something you don't?

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 11:29

FlyRedRobin · 08/08/2025 20:49

I'm still in disbelief how not understanding you are. Kindness does go a long way, OP. and being kind is understanding why these ladies are hurting now. You only think of yourself.

They are only thinking themselves, too. Why is "kindness" a one way street?

CottageGoblin · 09/08/2025 11:23

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 10:44

Christ, with this thinking, how on earth do disabled people have friends who are able?!?

christ! With this level of whatabouttery it’s amazing anyone can see anything from a different point of view.

I never mentioned disabled people. You did. Friendships made from trauma change. And lots of other posters said that.

I have never said it was fine to ghost people you thought were your friends either.

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 11:01

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 10:44

Christ, with this thinking, how on earth do disabled people have friends who are able?!?

According to this thinking, it is fine to ghost anybody who has what you do not.

OP posts:
Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 10:44

CottageGoblin · 08/08/2025 20:00

But you don’t fit into their group anymore OP.

You are allowed to feel how you feel, but you can only control your own actions and feelings.

I understand the injustice of it all, but it is strange and unusual that they are still friendly with your husband. I do think you’re misreading that as them maybe just being polite. I don’t really think men feel the same about infertility as women, for the husbands to still be friends with your DP.

Christ, with this thinking, how on earth do disabled people have friends who are able?!?

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 09:46

MushMonster · 09/08/2025 09:41

Congratulations OP!!! You know is nothing personal towards you. So let them go and enjoy what is ahead of you. For them to avoid your hisband too, which difference would make to you? He should not reply to them if they are not talking to you, by the way.
People have lost a huge amoint of coping strategies andcmanners, to be honest. Too much pandering to their situation makes them unable to be happy for others, which is a massive flaw. But society seems to be favouring those with the sad story. It is wrong. Being sensible, yes. But they should celebrate with you. Specially when they know what you have been through.

I do think there is a level of pandering with some yes. Many people experience very difficult times in their lives but in this case it seems to be acceptable to be unpleasant. I have no problem if people want to distance themselves or need space, just say it rather than cutting others off out of nowhere,

DH has explained to his friends with the cutting off wives that he won't be seeing them anymore because of their treatment of me. He did the decent thing and told them instead of just ghosting them.

OP posts:
Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 09:45

Posted twice in error

Winterwonders24 · 09/08/2025 09:44

MemorableTrenchcoat · 08/08/2025 17:58

Why is it skewed? I can well believe some women can bitchy about this. They probably don’t do it to men because they wouldn’t understand/care.

I think it's unjustified to do this to men OR women: life's not fair, but we don't need to hurt others because of it

KimberleyClark · 09/08/2025 09:42

Adultautismdiagnosis · 09/08/2025 09:29

It's not being bitchy to distance yourself when you're in extreme pain. Main character syndrome has absolutely nothing to do with it.

Edited

This. And distancing yourself from things you can’t face is the opposite of making your infertility other people’s problem.

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 09:42

freakyfriday23 · 09/08/2025 09:06

YABVVU OP. You say you understand but in truth i think it is the opposite. Tbh I view you as a bit of a traitor op One would think you had never experienced infertility. Oh how some women forget the minute they have a successful implantation. You are a disappointment to the sisterhood IMHO. I would get it immediately. I've been there. A true friend would understand. I get why you are hurt, you miss them but at the end of the day you are pg whilst they aren't.

😂

OP posts:
MushMonster · 09/08/2025 09:41

Congratulations OP!!! You know is nothing personal towards you. So let them go and enjoy what is ahead of you. For them to avoid your hisband too, which difference would make to you? He should not reply to them if they are not talking to you, by the way.
People have lost a huge amoint of coping strategies andcmanners, to be honest. Too much pandering to their situation makes them unable to be happy for others, which is a massive flaw. But society seems to be favouring those with the sad story. It is wrong. Being sensible, yes. But they should celebrate with you. Specially when they know what you have been through.

joyjoyw · 09/08/2025 09:40

piccalili · 09/08/2025 09:05

I think the problem is actually your DH … as if your friends have completely ghosted you - then why has he still been continuing involvement with them?

Try reading the update.

OP posts:
GoldThumb · 09/08/2025 09:32

joyjoyw · 08/08/2025 21:54

Yes of course they wanted to be pregnant and become mums. I get that. But the end goal was always having a baby and becoming a parent, not just being pregnant. My husband is becoming a parent too. Just because he is not carrying the baby does not mean he is not part of the thing they are grieving.

If it was really just about seeing someone get what they want and cannot have, then both of us would be reminders. But I am the one who got cut off, while he is still getting invited out, still chatting with them like nothing has changed. That is not just about pregnancy. It is about how people treat women differently.

He shouldn’t be going.

You need to speak to him, he shouldn’t be facilitating your exclusion like this, regardless of why it’s happening