Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu for being unhappy my in-laws are putting a dog "first"

343 replies

GD12 · 08/08/2025 13:38

Basically my MILs son has a giant dog, I think it's a Staffordshire bull terrier but it's massive. It's also untrained. When our daughter was 4 a few years ago ist jumped up on her and scratched her chest at which point I said that our daughter couldn't stay in the house with it. She goes every summer to stay for 5 days and they usually put the dog elsewhere,the dog moving and staying with another relative etc. This year they didn't bother and the solution was to have my daughter stay with another relative instead of at her grans my mil would also stay at the relatives. Am I overreacting being annoyed about this? She has to go and stay with a relative that she's never stayed with before and sees maybe twice a year, that the dog is being allowed to stay in the house and my 7yo daughter has to move out because of it? Myself and hubby have had a fight because he can't see the problem, in fact he'd have her stay with the dog in the house. Maybe I'm being controlling but it's really pushing buttons in me.

OP posts:
Verv · 08/08/2025 15:46

BauhausOfEliott · 08/08/2025 13:59

She has to go and stay with a relative that she's never stayed with before and sees maybe twice a year, that the dog is being allowed to stay in the house and my 7yo daughter has to move out because of it?

it's not your MIL's fault that you apparently can't get through the summer without sending your child away to stay with people. Your child is your responsibility, not your in-laws'.

Your child isn't having to 'move out' of the house because she doesn't fucking live there! If you want someone else to look after your child in THEIR home for almost a week, you cannot possibly expect them to boot their own dog out just because you don't like it. You're already asking a big favour by wanting them to have your daughter for five days at a time and I don't blame them for putting their foot down and saying they're not going to off-load their dog as well.

This.
It's the dog's home, find a creche that meets your requirements elsewhere.

Jiddles · 08/08/2025 15:44

GD12 · 08/08/2025 15:37

I said elsewhere I'm not necessarily blaming her and I can see she's probably in a difficult situation My 40yo BIL however could take responsibility for it and find alternative accomodation, he's known for months. My MIL doesn't even want the dog.

Yes, he could and should. But he hasn’t. Presumably your MIL has been unable to force him to. But she clearly wants a relationship with her granddaughter, to the extent that she’s moving out of her home for a week to facilitate this. If the only issue is "she's putting the dog first!" that sounds ridiculous to me.

MayaPinion · 08/08/2025 15:44

YANBU. I wouldn’t send her. I’d not trust the parents to keep the dog away from her.

LittleMonks11 · 08/08/2025 15:43

Jiddles · 08/08/2025 15:29

Frankly, what it sounds like to me is that you don’t like the idea of your DD having a close relationship with your MIL at all. You are creating difficulties where there aren’t any.

Your MIL has done what you’ve asked and kept your DD apart from the dog. (Even though I'm not convinced by you saying the dog was being aggressive rather than playful/badly trained. Did it actually growl or try to bite anyone?)

What on earth is the problem of the two of them staying in a different relation's house? Does your DD actually care in the slightest which house it is? You are sounding sour.

Edited

What a reach

60andcounting · 08/08/2025 15:42

Oreosareawful · 08/08/2025 13:40

Does the dog live there full time? But your daughter doesn't? Why are you sending your daughter away at all?

She isn't sending the child away. The child is having a holiday with grandma (or relative)

SpaceRaccoon · 08/08/2025 15:42

If it's massive, it's not a Staffie. Proper breed-standard Staffies are quite small dogs, albeit solid.

rainbowstardrops · 08/08/2025 15:42

If you’re not comfortable with DD going away for a week then I wouldn’t have agreed to it in the first place tbh. So your husband wants a break and some peace, is he a SAHP? He could strop all he likes.
I wouldn’t send my child to a house with a feisty dog though. Where is MIL proposing to stay?

Jiddles · 08/08/2025 15:40

blacksax · 08/08/2025 15:37

It doesn't make one iota of difference.

Either it is aggressive and should never, ever be anywhere near small children, or it is jumpy untrained and won't obey commands, in which case it should be kept away from small children anyway.

Whichever way, the OP is totally in the right here.

But the child is being kept away from the dog, as OP requested, so what’s the problem?

LittleMonks11 · 08/08/2025 15:39

Littleredgoat · 08/08/2025 15:24

Well your MIL can't kick your BIL out for a week- it's his home. You've set a line, you don't want your child around this dog. So they are seeing your child elsewhere.

I don't get it. Unless this is some weird perceived hierarchy thing? You don't want your kid around the dog; your kid isn't around the dog- what's the problem???!

It’s not HIS home it’s HER home. He’s a 40 year old man who has rocked up with his big dog after splitting with his gf

Cosyblankets · 08/08/2025 15:39

KindLemur · 08/08/2025 14:47

Maybe the child doesn’t want to stay with mad Auntie Tracey who she sees once in a blue moon. She’s allowed an opinion. Will there be adequate sleeping arrangements etc, will OP know who is in the house, where her child will be sleeping and bathing etc ?

you see all these threads on here where 15 year olds aren’t even allowed to the corner shop alone Yet OP is getting slated for not being comfortable her 7 year old little girl is going to be spending a week with a relative she doesn’t even know

With her grandmother

Loopytiles · 08/08/2025 15:38

Where do you usually stay when you visit MIL as a family?

Do you trust MIL (and BIL) to ensure that DD doesn’t encounter BIL’s DoH? If not, then it’s unwise for DD to go. It’s just not worth the risk.

GD12 · 08/08/2025 15:37

GCAcademic · 08/08/2025 15:34

Yes, I agree with that. But your AIBU was about her putting the dog first. I can't see what else she can do.

I said elsewhere I'm not necessarily blaming her and I can see she's probably in a difficult situation My 40yo BIL however could take responsibility for it and find alternative accomodation, he's known for months. My MIL doesn't even want the dog.

OP posts:
blacksax · 08/08/2025 15:37

CopperWhite · 08/08/2025 13:42

Did the dog show aggression or was it just being a jumpy dog?

It doesn't make one iota of difference.

Either it is aggressive and should never, ever be anywhere near small children, or it is jumpy untrained and won't obey commands, in which case it should be kept away from small children anyway.

Whichever way, the OP is totally in the right here.

miraxxx · 08/08/2025 15:34

4forksache · 08/08/2025 15:15

Yup

God forbid anyone asks a 40-year old man staying at his mum's place to take his dog elsewhere for week.

GCAcademic · 08/08/2025 15:34

GD12 · 08/08/2025 15:30

I should be allowed to say she's not going then and not feel pressured by husband and mil and for it to cause a fight.

Yes, I agree with that. But your AIBU was about her putting the dog first. I can't see what else she can do.

Jiddles · 08/08/2025 15:33

GD12 · 08/08/2025 15:30

I should be allowed to say she's not going then and not feel pressured by husband and mil and for it to cause a fight.

But why? What would be your reason? You are just trying to pick a quarrel so you can avoid your DD having a visit with her grandmother. You’re not coming across well.

Londonrach1 · 08/08/2025 15:31

Mil comes to you for a week. I totally wouldn't want my dd near that dog and dd is used to dogs. Especially as you don't need childcare...I'll get them to drop this arrangement. Yanbu

WhereYouLeftIt · 08/08/2025 15:30

" ... a giant dog, I think it's a Staffordshire bull terrier but it's massive. It's also untrained."
A Staffordshire Bull Terrier is very much a medium-size dog. If this dog is "massive" it's more likely to be an XL Bully, surely?

There is no way I would allow myself, never mind my child, to be around an untrained XL Bully. I'd even hesitate to be around an untrained Staffie (and I used to have a Staffie, I love them). Staffies are incredibly strong dogs, and can do serious damage to a human with very little effort on their part. Why has your brother-in-law not trained his dog?

GD12 · 08/08/2025 15:30

GCAcademic · 08/08/2025 15:27

Realistically, where can she send the dog? And can she really insist that it goes elsewhere when it is not her dog? It is her son's home too, by the sounds of it.

I should be allowed to say she's not going then and not feel pressured by husband and mil and for it to cause a fight.

OP posts:
Jiddles · 08/08/2025 15:29

Frankly, what it sounds like to me is that you don’t like the idea of your DD having a close relationship with your MIL at all. You are creating difficulties where there aren’t any.

Your MIL has done what you’ve asked and kept your DD apart from the dog. (Even though I'm not convinced by you saying the dog was being aggressive rather than playful/badly trained. Did it actually growl or try to bite anyone?)

What on earth is the problem of the two of them staying in a different relation's house? Does your DD actually care in the slightest which house it is? You are sounding sour.

GCAcademic · 08/08/2025 15:27

Realistically, where can she send the dog? And can she really insist that it goes elsewhere when it is not her dog? It is her son's home too, by the sounds of it.

Littleredgoat · 08/08/2025 15:24

Well your MIL can't kick your BIL out for a week- it's his home. You've set a line, you don't want your child around this dog. So they are seeing your child elsewhere.

I don't get it. Unless this is some weird perceived hierarchy thing? You don't want your kid around the dog; your kid isn't around the dog- what's the problem???!

MavisandHetty · 08/08/2025 15:24

GD12 · 08/08/2025 15:05

FIL isn't around so he won't be there. Yes, I can imagine MIL has been pulled both ways and in some ways I don't blame her but my BIL is 40, it's not as if he's a kid, he bought this dog after he split with his GF and then moved back into his mums. We're either down there or she's up at ours a lot it's just the "week in the summer" that has become a thing and now my daughter is being "moved out" into another house which has riled me and me saying something has caused a fight. Husband wants his "weeks rest" and MIL wants daughter for a week(which I'm not objecting to in principle she can see her granddaughter as much as she wants).

Edited

Everybody has their own agenda, don’t they. DH wants DD out of the house and getting stroppy if you even try to jeopardize that. BIL doesn’t want to find somewhere to put dog. MIL wants her DGD. FIL is doing his own thing. You’re the only one not getting what she “wants” ie peace of mind. Let’s hope DD is happy with this new relative.

I often used to find myself pushed around between people like this. My DM, almost 80, still is pushed around trying to be everything to everyone. It stopped for me when I started becoming as strident as everyone else was being towards me. It shocked me how quickly people gave in, or at least accommodated my preferences. All I had to do was ask.

GD12 · 08/08/2025 15:19

TeaCupTornado · 08/08/2025 15:16

I think you need to try and communicate with husband better over this somehow. You need him onside. If for instance you ever split up (I'm not saying over this specific issue), it sounds like he'd take your daughter there to be with dog and you wouldn't have a say so.

Dogs seem to be a very emotive subject on mumsnet in general.

I'm on the fence to be honest. Someone asked you if it was aggressive and you said it had jumped up on you but you felt it wasnt being playful - but that is how untrained and excited dogs act unfortunately - not necessarily aggressive dog behaviour but certainly uncomfortable for someone who doesn't like dogs.

I agree that jumping up is very bad dog manners and shows poor training by the owners. However it doesnt sound aggressive, you dont mention biting, growling, showing teeth, hackles up etc.

With your daughter being 7 now, I wonder how she feels about dogs in general and this dog in particular?

What was your husbands opinion of his child being scratched by this dog? Was he angry or was he of the opinion these things happen?

I personally wouldn't be happy with the annual 1 week trip in general with or without the dog and I wouldn't be happy about the dog situation either. It all sounds quite delicate and I think you should consider your next steps carefully. Hopefully you get some good advice or point of view on this thread.

He was angry initially but won't go against his family or cause a fuss so it quickly became "fine"

OP posts:
TeaCupTornado · 08/08/2025 15:16

I think you need to try and communicate with husband better over this somehow. You need him onside. If for instance you ever split up (I'm not saying over this specific issue), it sounds like he'd take your daughter there to be with dog and you wouldn't have a say so.

Dogs seem to be a very emotive subject on mumsnet in general.

I'm on the fence to be honest. Someone asked you if it was aggressive and you said it had jumped up on you but you felt it wasnt being playful - but that is how untrained and excited dogs act unfortunately - not necessarily aggressive dog behaviour but certainly uncomfortable for someone who doesn't like dogs.

I agree that jumping up is very bad dog manners and shows poor training by the owners. However it doesnt sound aggressive, you dont mention biting, growling, showing teeth, hackles up etc.

With your daughter being 7 now, I wonder how she feels about dogs in general and this dog in particular?

What was your husbands opinion of his child being scratched by this dog? Was he angry or was he of the opinion these things happen?

I personally wouldn't be happy with the annual 1 week trip in general with or without the dog and I wouldn't be happy about the dog situation either. It all sounds quite delicate and I think you should consider your next steps carefully. Hopefully you get some good advice or point of view on this thread.