Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

On phone in stationary traffic

281 replies

Charttopper · 05/08/2025 21:37

NC for this. I'm wondering if any legal folk have advice or whether you all think IABU.

A few weeks ago I was stopped at traffic lights for some time in standstill traffic so I briefly picked up my phone to look at a message that had come through. I was on my own with my baby in the back. Suddenly I was aware of something to my right and when I turned, there was a man in a high vis jacket on a bicycle, stopped right next to my door, and bending down to stare at me through my window. He didn't engage, just stared straight at me for what felt like an age. His position meant that I couldn't get out of the car and it felt very intimidating. I didn't know what his intentions were, or what he'd do next.

He then cycled off ahead and stopped by the windows of one or two other drivers and did the same thing. I felt quite shaken by the experience.

I later learned that he either reported me or was an undercover policeman as he had filmed me on my phone with his helmet camera.

I have now received 6 points and a £200 fine. I accept that the law states that checking your phone including when stationary is an offence so I am not disputing that there should be a consequence.

However, I can't help but feel that 6 points is a disproportionate punishment given that I was stationary and not actually causing risk. If I was moving it would be a different matter but I was not driving without due care and attention, i was stationary with the break on.

Secondly, the method of capturing this footage - a man staring into a woman's car, on her own with a baby, and instilling fear and blocking her in surely is not acceptable?

Can I challenge any of this?

OP posts:
Whammyyammy · 06/08/2025 10:56

Im glad you got 6 points and a £200 fine, enjoy your insurance premium next year.

People that use their phones while driving infuriates me, it's selfish and dangerous. So many people have lost their lives due to someone just checking social media or making a call.
My husband has a camera and if he sees people using phones whilst on his motorbike he records and sends to the police.

Aaron95 · 06/08/2025 10:47

helloquitty · 05/08/2025 22:04

Oh my good lord the people on here. Proper load of saints.

what was the risk of harm? None

it’s just ridiculous. I say this as a person who had a family member killed by a lorry driver using a phone.

stationary in traffic glancing at your phone is not the same.

It's really annoying when the lights go green and the car at the front doesn';t move. Then you pass them and realise the driver is so engaged in their phone they have not noticed the lights have changed. It's not a rare occurance around here.

Dbank · 06/08/2025 10:44

RoseAlone · 05/08/2025 22:56

You broke the law. It's illegal to even touch your phone when you're in a car. You've been banged to rights.

It's not illegal to touch or use your phone while driving. It's not actually illegal to hold your phone, the offence is "holding and using".

nomas · 06/08/2025 10:34

Mycatmyworld · 06/08/2025 10:20

If I receive a message while driving I just ask Siri to read it for me, after that she says do I want to reply? If I f do, I just talk & then she reads it back & asks do I want to send or amend simple , why anyone needs to touch a phone when in a car is beyond me

.

LlynTegid · 06/08/2025 10:28

An unreasonable decision as you have not been banned for a period. Others are treated far too leniently I think and two wrongs don't make a right.

Oreosareawful · 06/08/2025 10:24

You are being very unreasonable and I can't believe you are trying to play the victim in this situation! 😂

Hopefully you've learnt your lesson

Marmiteontoastgirlie · 06/08/2025 10:23

@Mycatmyworld One time I was in a lovely area and had opened Rightmove at the lights and typed in the neighbourhood before I came to my senses and chucked my phone in the passenger footwell out of reach. That was silly and really sobered me up to the fact that I might actually have a problematic addiction to Rightmove.

Mycatmyworld · 06/08/2025 10:20

If I receive a message while driving I just ask Siri to read it for me, after that she says do I want to reply? If I f do, I just talk & then she reads it back & asks do I want to send or amend simple , why anyone needs to touch a phone when in a car is beyond me

Marmiteontoastgirlie · 06/08/2025 10:19

honestly @Charttopper if the way you were caught actually was due to this deranged cyclists “evidence” (did the letter say how they caught you?) I think you could have grounds to push back on this and if there is a chance you can get those demerit points scrubbed I would take it - otherwise you’ll lose your licence if you for e.g. get two speeding fines in the next three years, or even less if you already have demerit points for something else.

Marmiteontoastgirlie · 06/08/2025 10:15

CallMeFlo · 05/08/2025 21:55

So send a letter to court lying about the circumstances. Fabulous advice considering the guy has probably sent in a recording from his helmet camera which will clearly show she had her phone in her hand when he turned to her car

Bottom line is SHE BROKE THE LAW

I mean I would definitely ask to see all the footage to see if it checks out with the story - being filmed by a private citizen is a strange way for evidence gathering for prosecution. It could constitute harassment, no way to know whether the video was tampered with etc - what’s to stop any old weirdo with a vendetta just sending in an AI video of you on your phone in the car? There are solicitors who deal with challenging fixed penalty notices OP, perhaps you could talk to them and see if you have any grounds to challenge given the odd nature of how you were caught - man filming you without permission and being super weird about it.

TheNightingalesStarling · 06/08/2025 10:08

OP, if you had had a thread about a man coming up to your car and filming you in stationary traffic no mention of phonepeople would have agreed with you his behaviour was wierd and unsettling.

To find the Phone users, he has to film and look in every car. He can't see from behind as he approaches them!

RedRiverShore5 · 06/08/2025 10:00

I don't think about my phone while driving, it's in my bag with 'I'm driving' switched on. It can wait until I get to my destination. I wouldn't be able to accidentally answer my phone.

Charttopper · 06/08/2025 09:53

Hibernatingtilspring · 06/08/2025 09:34

I'm curious how the OP thought that the cyclist was going to steal her baby out the car and make off on his bike while filming his crime...

Actually she mentions 'someone else' but if you're really that frightened of being ambushed in your car, wouldn't you want to keep an eye on who is around you? I wonder if the OP has the same thought every time a car pulls alongside her. Car parks must be a nightmare!

Just to be clear, I don't sit around thinking everyone is a threat and going to steal my baby.

What I said was that in that moment, with a man behaving strangely (as I felt at the time as I didn't know what he was doing) all sorts went through my head. Have you never had an irrational thought in the moment of feeling a bit spooked?

I can accept responsibility and still think that particular part of the situation was unsettling.

OP posts:
Londontown12 · 06/08/2025 09:45

You had a baby in your car and used your phone Jesus Christ !
u deserved those points and fine !
doesn’t matter if your stationary it’s against the law !!!

Hibernatingtilspring · 06/08/2025 09:34

I'm curious how the OP thought that the cyclist was going to steal her baby out the car and make off on his bike while filming his crime...

Actually she mentions 'someone else' but if you're really that frightened of being ambushed in your car, wouldn't you want to keep an eye on who is around you? I wonder if the OP has the same thought every time a car pulls alongside her. Car parks must be a nightmare!

Tippertapperfeet · 06/08/2025 09:28

Can you set your car to auto lock the doors when you drive off?

nomas · 06/08/2025 09:28

Charttopper · 06/08/2025 08:03

In summary, let's be reasonable that checking your phone when stationary is not causing danger in that immediate moment, unlike reading your phone whilst actually driving which is dangerous (and inexplicably remains legal if you're reading on your car screen).

However, I do take on board the point that it is a distraction and you're potentially not aware of your surroundings so could then go on to cause a problem if you don't focus before pulling away. To those who have kindly noted this, thank you for making me think on this.

And thanks again for those coming to my defence against the scolders 😂

It can be dangerous because I know someone who crashed into the car in front after looking up from reading his phone during stationary traffic.

Anyway, we’ve all done it rarely but you were too blasé and got caught.

PollyBell · 06/08/2025 09:23

No one dies from shoplifting, fraud, illegal parking, secual assault but they have laws for that too

So we want society where one law is more serious than another we should all just do what we want?

Sadcafe · 06/08/2025 09:21

No you can’t challenge it, the laws clear, if your engine is switched on and I’m pretty sure that includes stopped with stop/ start, you cannot use a mobile phone unless it’s hands free, frustrating though it seems, it is what it is

BananaCaramel · 06/08/2025 09:19

Look OP, I basically agree with you that checking your phone in stationary traffic is not dangerous and shouldn’t be treated as the same as people who scroll through insta at 70mph on the motorway and swerve about. But that’s not the law. So you choose to risk it (as many people do so I get why it feels unfair), you have to accept the consequences. There is no appeal.

UsingAMansNameInAWomensWorld · 06/08/2025 09:19

If you're worried someone might steal your baby then locking the doors at every set of traffic lights is probably sensible

And stop using your phone whilst in the car

PollyBell · 06/08/2025 09:18

TheNightingalesStarling · 06/08/2025 08:28

That goes for speeders, red light jumpers, middle lane huggers etc too but there is awareness courses for them.

Let's face it... many drivers wouldn't pass a Driving test now.

The fact people need a course in common sense as well says a lot about society

PhoneMeATaxi · 06/08/2025 09:03

@Charttopper it is my peri brain. My age begins with a 5 and as you said "my baby" in the back I don't think we are the same age, I wish I was your age. My baby has just gone out by himself, he is 19 Grin

Bingbangboo · 06/08/2025 09:03

cyvguhb · 05/08/2025 21:49

Which lives are in danger if a person looks at their phone when stationary at traffic lights?

Well she wasn't aware of a cyclist because she was looking down at her phone for a start.

Tippertapperfeet · 06/08/2025 08:58

You’re in the wrong.

I know the police by us use a white van to get pics of people from above and it would not surprise me if they used a bike too.