Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pick my daughter up from holiday camp 150 odd miles away

257 replies

ShatnerssBasoon · 05/08/2025 07:49

Please be kind as first time posting properly and first time any of my children have been away without family. DD is 12 and has gone away to children's summer camp for 7 days. Went on Sunday... there's no mobile phones but she's called on camp computer at allocated time to say she is having a bad time and wants to come home. She was in tears and says other girls are not being nice and there's not much to do. She's in a communal tent with other girls but not hanging out with her. She has one local friend who's there but it's snubbing her now they are there. It breaks my heart a bit to have her crying and wanting to come home. I want to go and get her... DH says it's nuts and she'll be fine. What should I do? I work in MH and he says my judgement is clouds by this

OP posts:
crumblingschools · 05/08/2025 16:08

@CaptainMyCaptain most medications on a camp would be locked away. DS always had to hand his over on school residentials and scouting camps

Is Ritalin something you take when needed rather than all the time?

EdithBond · 05/08/2025 16:07

Have you asked the camp leaders what they recommend? They have a duty if care to her. What’s their view? Leaders would surely be best placed to see how she is throughout the day. She may’ve been emotional when talking to you as a way to let the stress out. If she seems very unhappy, the leaders would surely recommend she should leave.

If you go to get her, it may help to have a chat with her and see if you can support her to stay, rather than go with the purpose of bringing her home. However, if she’s clearly not enjoying any aspect and feels she doesn’t want to keep giving it a go, then you should bring her home.

NikNak321 · 05/08/2025 16:07

FloraBotticelli · 05/08/2025 07:51

I would have a chat with the adults at the camp first. If you work in mental health you should know that it’s not bad for kids to feel difficult feelings. It’s bad for them to be left alone with those feelings. She’s not alone - you’ve listened to her and will comfort her when she gets home.

This ☝️☝️☝️. Part of growing up is learning to navigate difficult social situations and manage upset. This could be a growth opportunity. It could be dealt with by talking it over and with camp staff? If it's really awful I would possibly step in, but encourage my child to lean into difficulties, try and deal with and encourage some personal resilience first 👌👌

HarpieDuJour · 05/08/2025 15:43

Resilience is a great thing, but it is easy to accidentally teach the wrong lesson. When I was sent to boarding school at 11, I was expected to manage all aspects of my life by myself. I asked my parents for help about some of the worst aspects of a fairly miserable experience, but over the 5 years I was there, I never once got any actual help or even emotional support. It had always suited my parents to cast me as "the independent one" because it meant that they only needed to deal with me when I had to be punished.

My parents would say that it taught be to be independent. Actually, it taught me that there was no point in asking for help, because nobody cared.

OP, I think you have hit the right balance. Rushing over to take her home at the first sign of a problem wouldn't have really helped her, but allowing her to make the decision to leave early once she has given it a good try is fair.

CaptainMyCaptain · 05/08/2025 15:26

justasking111 · 05/08/2025 14:59

Son at the end of his A levels did six weeks camp America as a junior. Was on the USA Canadian border. Parents would leave children of this age for up to three weeks.

These pallid nervous kids would arrive rattling with ritalin. Those in charge would take all the prescriptions and lock them away safely to be administered as required.

The days would start early. It was breakfast, say canoeing all morning, packed lunch, then afternoon activities, also full on. Back to camp, BBQ, smores, camp stories, they were curled up asleep by 8.30 pm absolutely knackered.

He said that the kids didn't take the ritalin, they just didn't want or need it. They went home, brown, happy and full of stories of adventures.

Reminds me of an old song. Hello mother, hello father. Probably on YouTube.

They confiscated prescribed medication? That's appalling, I have mixed feeling about the question in the OP but the staff at a summer camp have no right to decide whether children get to take their medication.

Robinredd · 05/08/2025 15:19

There are different ways to teach a child 'coping skills' and leaving your 12 year old to 'cope' when they've cried to you asking for your help isn't one of them. it's setting them up for mental health issues and my children's well being will come before any so called coping lessons.

You can dress it up whatever way you like but I say not going to get them is absolutely shit parenting.

zingally · 05/08/2025 15:19

I think you've made the right call asking her to stick it until Thursday when you're free from work.
You might find that he knowing she's only got 2 more sleeps there might help her rally.
After all, she's 12, and yes that's young still, but she's by no means a baby or a very young child. She's in secondary school. Okay, so she's not enjoying it very much, but she's not in any danger. You hear what she's saying, and will come to get her early. But I think doing as you have done, and not immediately leaping into the car is the right thing to do.

Robinredd · 05/08/2025 15:19

TeenLifeMum · 05/08/2025 08:16

They probably would. This is why so many young people don’t have coping skills - they don’t have to cope because mum will swoop in and save the day!

Over the phone I would have given some guidance on managing the situation, I’d be calling the camp team to ensure they knew dd was struggling and I’d expect dd to give it a couple more days to see if she can turn it around. “Nothing to do” could just mean she doesn’t have a phone and can’t think what else to do. Ime friendships change throughout camp week and one group suddenly invites dd in and she’ll feel accepted and love it. First couple of days are fighting for position but that calms down.

There are different ways to teach a child 'coping skills' and leaving your 12 year old to 'cope' when they've cried to you asking for your help isn't one of them. it's setting them up for mental health issues and my children's well being will come before any so called coping lessons.

You can dress it up whatever way you like but I say not going to get them is absolutely shit parenting.

Robinredd · 05/08/2025 15:13

JMSA · 05/08/2025 08:11

Those of you who’d pick up in a heartbeat, would you be so quick to do it if it was a school residential?

Yes. I would.

I'd want my children to be confident from a young age that if they ever call and ask for help that I'd be there every single time.

notwavingbutdrowning1 · 05/08/2025 15:01

Go and get her, @ShatnerssBasoon. As a child I used to get terrifyingly, disablingly homesick - it's horrible. So I told my DC that I would always come and get them without question, no matter where they were and what they are doing, if they needed me to. My DD did suffer from homesickness and we would often go and bring her home. Now she's in her twenties, really confident and independent, no problems with travelling or going away. I'm so glad I was there for her when she needed it.

justasking111 · 05/08/2025 14:59

Son at the end of his A levels did six weeks camp America as a junior. Was on the USA Canadian border. Parents would leave children of this age for up to three weeks.

These pallid nervous kids would arrive rattling with ritalin. Those in charge would take all the prescriptions and lock them away safely to be administered as required.

The days would start early. It was breakfast, say canoeing all morning, packed lunch, then afternoon activities, also full on. Back to camp, BBQ, smores, camp stories, they were curled up asleep by 8.30 pm absolutely knackered.

He said that the kids didn't take the ritalin, they just didn't want or need it. They went home, brown, happy and full of stories of adventures.

Reminds me of an old song. Hello mother, hello father. Probably on YouTube.

Frogwalk · 05/08/2025 14:52

DartmoorWanderer · 05/08/2025 09:07

This is exactly it. It’s not “damaging”, it’s building some resilience. What’s going to happen if she has bitchy coworkers?

What’s going to happen if she has bitchy coworkers?

She'll be an adult. I'm sure you can appreciate she won't still think and act like a 12-year old, she will be different in lots of ways by then. Resilience can be learned in small, everyday ways it doesn't all hinge on one monumental summer camp when she was 12 and needed her mum. Luckily for us all.

Frogwalk · 05/08/2025 14:45

I'm another one for go and get her. She's a kid - not everything has to be a try-or-die virtue lesson.

Call the camp if you want, but in my experience if it's run by 'she'll be fine, we'll tell her to put her big girl pants on' people (as some are on here) you won't get the real story anyway. If you speak to someone and you feel they are actually on your wavelength, empathy-wise, then maybe see how it goes, if your DD agrees. I'd be warming up the car though.

HonoriaBulstrode · 05/08/2025 14:14

She's in a communal tent with other girls but not hanging out with her. She has one local friend who's there but it's snubbing her now they are there.

I wonder if there are some mismatched expectations? Maybe DD thought she and the one girl she knows would stick together and do everything together, but the other girl wants to mix with the wider group?

Mydogisatool · 05/08/2025 14:13

Bloozie · 05/08/2025 13:57

I get told how strong I am all the time, and I hate it. I hate being strong, I'm tired of being strong, yes I'm resilient but honestly I would just like to break for once, and to stop carrying everything.

I also get told how confident I am all the time, how outgoing, how good I am with people - I'm a petrified introvert, social events absolutely exhaust me, but the mask gets worn and I hate every second of it. If I try and tell people, they think I'm exaggerating.

'Bloozie' is a skin I wear based on the expectations that other people placed on me when I was 12, and honestly, I am sick of wearing it.

I think we might be twins. Sending solidarity. It’s hard.

zaxxon · 05/08/2025 14:07

mauvaiseherbe · 05/08/2025 13:27

Independnce, stoicism, resilience, adaptability, sociability, goodhumour, most ofall forebearance, all chucked away as there is ‘nothing to do’ and some other kid is being mean or indifferent.

A week of social ostracism and misery is not going to instil good humour. Quite the reverse.

Think of how it feels to be at a party or a wedding where you don't know anyone, and don't enjoy the activity. Even two hours is hard going. At a camp, there's no escape; there's nowhere to retreat to.

All that my awful camp experience (details above) taught me, at 11, was that I was an unlikable, possibly even disgusting person.

99bottlesofkombucha · 05/08/2025 14:04

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 05/08/2025 10:16

You must be distressed by the situation as you have referred to another child as ' it '

now whether this was to keep the child anon so you didn't say she or he but it ?! really is a bit much.

' She has one local friend who's there but it's snubbing her now they are there.'

It looks to me like a typo for is.

Bloozie · 05/08/2025 13:57

Mydogisatool · 05/08/2025 13:36

You have summed up my feelings so well.

I’ve had some awful things happen in life and I am always told how resilient (HATE that word) and strong I am.

No, I am not. I was forced to cope alone and to be independent from a young age “stick it out! Don’t over react!” from a young age. As you say, you learn no one is coming to save you. So while I look calm on the outside, inside I am screaming and panicking, and I have spend the majority of my life hiding at home.

Thank god, I chose to raise my children the opposite way and they are completely different.

I get told how strong I am all the time, and I hate it. I hate being strong, I'm tired of being strong, yes I'm resilient but honestly I would just like to break for once, and to stop carrying everything.

I also get told how confident I am all the time, how outgoing, how good I am with people - I'm a petrified introvert, social events absolutely exhaust me, but the mask gets worn and I hate every second of it. If I try and tell people, they think I'm exaggerating.

'Bloozie' is a skin I wear based on the expectations that other people placed on me when I was 12, and honestly, I am sick of wearing it.

Mydogisatool · 05/08/2025 13:55

justasking111 · 05/08/2025 13:46

How do parents cope if said child is abroad. Do they arrange flights for them to collect a 12 year old?

By the time it got to going abroad with school, you’d hope that children had experienced being away before. Sleepovers, school trips closer to home. If you then knew your child couldn’t cope being away, you’d be pretty daft to send them abroad, and then, they would have their own preference on going anyway.

And school trips, where they are going with staff and children they know well and are with everyday, are very different to camps.

LillyPJ · 05/08/2025 13:46

justasking111 · 05/08/2025 13:46

How do parents cope if said child is abroad. Do they arrange flights for them to collect a 12 year old?

Probably!

justasking111 · 05/08/2025 13:46

How do parents cope if said child is abroad. Do they arrange flights for them to collect a 12 year old?

mauvaiseherbe · 05/08/2025 13:44

Fen476 · 05/08/2025 13:36

God I'd hate to be being bullied and be your kid. Good humour in the face of everyone leaving you out and being horrible to you? Stoicism? What kids need is to feel safe and to be listened to, not just left to fend for themselves. That's how you end up with problematic coping skills like self harm and end up feeling like you are worthless and that you deserve your needs not to be met.

Developing healthy coping skills requires a foundation of safety and support.

I'm really glad you're not my parent.

😘

MrsAvocet · 05/08/2025 13:39

This thread took me back nearly 50 years to when I was the unhappy child at Guide camp. I'd been once with our own company and absolutely loved it so when our leader told us all that another company in our town had two spaces on their camp I was first in line. It was awful. The other girls ranged from just unfriendly/disinterested to those who seemed intent on bullying me and the other girl from our company. They made it plain that they didn't want us there and the leaders weren't much better. Of course it was pre mobile phone days and the leaders wouldn't phone our parents so the two of us sneaked off and found a pay phone and asked our parents to come and get us. Both our dads arrived together at the camp that night. I was expecting mine to be livid but he just said "I know you wouldn't have called if it wasn't important and I'm not leaving you somewhere where you're being bullied." And that was it. We went home and it was never spoken of again. But knowing that my Dad believed me, without question and had my back meant the world to me.
A similar thing happened to my DD on a dancing Summer school once. She's never been one to give up at the first sign of trouble so I knew that when she called it was serious. I remembered how much my Dad's response had meant to me and did the same. We do sometimes have to put up with things that make us unhappy, but not, in my opinion, when it's a completely optional activity and the child has given it a good try.

Mydogisatool · 05/08/2025 13:36

Bloozie · 05/08/2025 13:27

Yup. Being forced to do something you hate means you won't want to do it next time.

Knowing her folks have her back would mean that next time a similar away from home situation arises, her daughter would know that it's safe to give it a go. So when she hears, 'It won't be the same as last time' (because let's face it, it won't), she isn't immediately thinking, 'But what if it is and I spend a week on my own crying again? It's safer just not to go'.

Knowing that if you're being bullied through isolation, you can come home, makes fun and growing your independence healthily more possible.

My parents forced hyper-independence and resilience on me. I need people to know that the character it has built won't ask for help, won't open up about how she feels, and actively avoids things that make her feel uncomfortable because now I'm an adult I get to choose, and I choose not being scared... It doesn't build good character. It builds a 'nobody's coming to save me and the only person I can rely on is myself' attitude. Which sounds good on paper but doesn't feel great. The only way to build independence healthily is through secure dependence.

Edited

You have summed up my feelings so well.

I’ve had some awful things happen in life and I am always told how resilient (HATE that word) and strong I am.

No, I am not. I was forced to cope alone and to be independent from a young age “stick it out! Don’t over react!” from a young age. As you say, you learn no one is coming to save you. So while I look calm on the outside, inside I am screaming and panicking, and I have spend the majority of my life hiding at home.

Thank god, I chose to raise my children the opposite way and they are completely different.

Swipe left for the next trending thread