Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most “mum friendship groups” are just thinly veiled cliques?

213 replies

SharpMintReader · 04/08/2025 08:44

The school-gate groups and WhatsApp chats often look less like support networks and more like exclusive cliques. AIBU to think “mum friendships” are too often politics in disguise?

OP posts:
SilkCottonTree · 04/08/2025 10:47

SharpMintReader · 04/08/2025 09:16

Sometimes, yes but also information, reminders, help with school stuff or even social support during tricky moments. If one group becomes the default hub for all that, it can create an uneven dynamic. That’s what I’m getting at.

This sounds like a problem with the school’s communication systems though. Why on earth would one group of friends have access to school related information that others don’t?

Fluffytoebeanz · 04/08/2025 10:46

I met my closest local friends via my daughter's school. In fact pretty much all the mums from the year group get on. There have been a few fallouts and there were a couple of mean girls but mostly we socialise, sometimes in bigger groups and sometimes in smaller ones

Chompingatthebeat · 04/08/2025 10:46

LBFseBrom · 04/08/2025 10:40

That sort of thing never appealed to me so I have no idea. I had friends and also made friends at work, didn't need school mums chatting and laughing about nothing at pick up time.

This is so sexist and sneery, how do you know they are 'chatting about nothing'

MrsSunshine2b · 04/08/2025 10:46

Zov · 04/08/2025 10:02

Yes. Plenty of times. I don't live in a rough area though, I live in a nice middle class area. So I see no fighting or arguments, just people happily drinking all night, and walking home together laughing and singing. (Men and women.) I definitely see nasty little cliques in the women in the village though - particularly the school mum groups and in the Church. I see little - in fact none really - when it comes to men.

Why do people on here get so salty when someone critisizes women? It's not against the law you know, and women are not perfect, and they ARE a lot more toxic when they fall out. Vengeful and spiteful. Not all women are like this of course, but are more likely to be like this when the friendship breaks down. They are also far more likely to have a friend, then make a new friend, and leave the first friend out. Men don't do this.

I'm sorry you're going through that but your attitude ("nice middle class area" vs "the village mums") might be why you're feeling isolated from other people.

There's only one Mum who might be described as left out in my daughter's class and it's because she can't open her mouth without turning the conversation to her husband's thriving business, their acres of landscaped gardens and her fabulous lifestyle of spa days, shopping and lunch dates.

That, and the mass invite she sent out inviting everyone to bring their kids for a group playdate then swiftly rescinded because her husband didn't want our kids in his house.

Everyone is polite to her but she's not "in the clique" and is often standing off the one side on the playground because her behaviour hasn't made her popular.

KassandraOfSparta · 04/08/2025 10:45

JMSA · 04/08/2025 10:17

I have 3 grown daughters. In all my years of doing school pick-ups and drop-offs, I never had the bitchiness that so many on here seem to encounter.

Probably because you are secure in your own skin and didn't look at picking your child up from school as some sort of social event or popularity contest.

Again the key question is - if these "cliques" are so exclusionary, and so bitchy and nasty, why would you want to be part of them anyway?

SilkCottonTree · 04/08/2025 10:44

SharpMintReader · 04/08/2025 08:56

They can be that and that’s great when it happens. But I’ve also seen situations where the group becomes exclusionary - even subtly. It’s not always about laughter and lattes; sometimes it’s about social hierarchy, even among mums.

People are entitled to form friendship groups that don’t have to include everyone just because they happened to give birth the same year.

The OPs of these types of posts are never able to give a distinction between a group of friends and a clique.

LBFseBrom · 04/08/2025 10:40

That sort of thing never appealed to me so I have no idea. I had friends and also made friends at work, didn't need school mums chatting and laughing about nothing at pick up time.

SunflowerLife · 04/08/2025 10:39

5128gap · 04/08/2025 10:07

Or perhaps some of us simply reject the idea that some groups are better than others? If you refuse to buy into the thinking that there's an aspirational crowd which you'll either be part of or excluded from, and focus on the qualities of other people, cultivating friendships with those you like and who like you, rather than those you think are perceived as superior, then you get a different perspective. If you persist with the thinking that some people are superior, for no valid reason, and focus only on trying to get them to include you (so you can be a superior person too) you've only yourself to blame if you end up on the wrong side of the hierarchy you are creating.

If this was aimed at me for what I said about being on the "wrong side", then you have misunderstood. The woman I posted about has previously done jail time for attacking another woman and also stole from an old lady at her place of work, so no I've never thought she was superior to me. Rather, she probably knew I was superior to her in many ways and decided to try and bully me.
It's not about wanting and failing to be part of a group, but when that one bad egg seems to dominate every school based social interaction and every group it makes you quite withdrawn. In the end I just ended up mostly keeping to myself because I couldn't be bothered anymore.

KawasakiBabe · 04/08/2025 10:33

I was never part of these school gate mums groups, but I was always friendly and would chat if given the chance. I mean wouldn’t everyone? I hate this “they must be bitches” if there’s a group of women talking.

I saw one of these women yesterday, coincidentally, and she was so pleased to see me. We had a lovely little chat and then went on our way. She’ll have her friends and I’ll have mine, there’s no need for any deeper thoughts on our motives for such an interaction.

Jenkibubble · 04/08/2025 10:28

SharpMintReader · 04/08/2025 08:44

The school-gate groups and WhatsApp chats often look less like support networks and more like exclusive cliques. AIBU to think “mum friendships” are too often politics in disguise?

it depends I think - location / demographic etc and how much gou want your like dominated by parenthood (ie have gou anything else in your life - hobbies etc )

I see it with my sister already (her youngest starts school this year ) she is cramming as much in to this summer as she has to write some blog about her daughter’s summer and the bar is obviously high !!!!!

NCT groups sound dire too - from what she has said !

That said , my kids went to a school in a deprived demographic and I didn’t feel any of it ( breakfast and after school clubs helped as didn’t do drop off and pick up often )
I did a what’s ap group for a collection for one teacher as son had her for 2 years .

I am still close to a couple of mums who I met at playgroups but our kids went to different schools . We hung out in beer gardens in the holidays - think Motherland

Confusdworriedmum · 04/08/2025 10:25

There were cliques when my DDs were at school. I was never in one. There were two mums who I would occasionally speak to (they weren't in the clique either) but certainly not every day.
I hated being stood on my own while other parents chatted. And heaven help you if you tried to join in with the general chat.
DS is on a reduced timetable and thankfully I don't see other parents and miss our on the clique behaviour

TheaBrandt1 · 04/08/2025 10:23

Load of old nonsense that the friendships
dont last! My fab group are a big part of my life see them several times a week! Few of our kids are still friends most on gap years / university now but the parent friendships have endured.

AlligatorTears · 04/08/2025 10:22

One more year and I’m out of it. Can’t fucking wait.

BunnyLake · 04/08/2025 10:21

tommyhoundmum · 04/08/2025 10:16

I was far too old a parent to get into that.

I met several though who are still friends today.

Me too. I’m an older parent so I didn’t involve myself in trying to get into groups. I made friends with a couple of older mums who I’m still friends with today long after the primary years. I’m generally more of a one to one friend anyway so didn’t even think about being part of a group.

Seniors they made their own way to and from.

JMSA · 04/08/2025 10:17

I have 3 grown daughters. In all my years of doing school pick-ups and drop-offs, I never had the bitchiness that so many on here seem to encounter.

tommyhoundmum · 04/08/2025 10:16

I was far too old a parent to get into that.

I met several though who are still friends today.

Barnbrack · 04/08/2025 10:16

SharpMintReader · 04/08/2025 08:56

They can be that and that’s great when it happens. But I’ve also seen situations where the group becomes exclusionary - even subtly. It’s not always about laughter and lattes; sometimes it’s about social hierarchy, even among mums.

I worry about this occasionally, I have a group of friends whose kids went to my kids nursery and a few other mums who have become part of the same chat, I do worry some people end up excluded. I always try to include anyone around but there have been occasions where I'm going for pre arranged coffee after drop off to discuss something specific with a friend, usually about the kids, and we want to mull it over as friends. And I'm a woman who has often been not included so if hate to have someone feel like that. But then I still don't think it's cliquey to want to chat to a friend I've known for 6 yes now.

Artesia · 04/08/2025 10:16

OP- what specifically is it that you think the "clique" should be doing that they aren't, in order to be offering sufficient support, access to opportunities etc? You are taking in very vague general terms so it is hard to understand what exactly they are doing wrong.

BunnyLake · 04/08/2025 10:15

Why not just get your kid and go home? School gates doesn’t have to be a thing.

Namechangerage · 04/08/2025 10:13

SharpMintReader · 04/08/2025 09:16

Sometimes, yes but also information, reminders, help with school stuff or even social support during tricky moments. If one group becomes the default hub for all that, it can create an uneven dynamic. That’s what I’m getting at.

How does a group that supports each other exclude others from getting access to information though? Surely the school shares all the info equally on whatever channel - email/app/letter in bag.

If parents set up their own support groups, to remind each other or ask questions that is up to them. You could just as equally start a WhatsApp group with some people you chat to.

At the school gate I chat to the mum of my son’s best friend as we also hang out at weekends. We text each other about stuff. I’ve naturally included other people I chat to now we have a WhatsApp group of about 6-7 mums. No other mum has ever shown interest in chatting to me.

For my younger child I sent out 30 party invites and got not one reply.

So forgive me if I just communicate with the parents that actively seem to want to engage.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2025 10:11

@Zov

I didn't ask you to apologise for anything. But thanks for confirming that you are in a clique!

I'm not in a "clique", actually. Or even a friendship group. For the record, since you're so interested, I am a member of a year-wide school WhatsApp thread (as is every parent in the year). Outside of that I have the numbers of three individual mums whose kids are friendly with my DD to arrange logistics. I don't socialise with them at all. I'm not on any school WhatsApp threads other than that.

But I am perfectly comfortable and happy that other mums at my DD's school might have a WhatsApp thread or go to the pub together once in a while. It doesn't threaten me or bother me at all.

Why are you so interested in my being part of a "clique"?

HornungTheHelpful · 04/08/2025 10:09

I am always on the outside - of everything. It is the sort of person I am. I accept that. People are polite to me, as I am to them, but rarely do they take to me. Again, I accept that. So from that standpoint I say, why on earth shouldn't they form cliques? Every friendship group is a clique, from one perspective. It's a shame if people don't want to "play" with you, but you can't make them. If they are unpleasant (as I understand what you may mean is a group who aren't pleasant to you) then why would you want to be friends with them?

If people are so insecure they can only really feel valued by reference to a third person who is not valued, then I also feel quite sympathetic towards them.

You may make friends at the school gate or you may not (pretty much like every where else) but why would you feel that because others have done where you haven't this makes them somehow wrong or unfair? Grow up

CommissarySushi · 04/08/2025 10:08

Zov · 04/08/2025 09:55

A typical response to someone who says something you don't like, and don't agree with. You must have spent AGES creating this incredible and thought-provoking response. Wink

Come on now. I don't even particularly care about the OPs post. I'm just tired of all these fake AI content generating posts.

brunettemic · 04/08/2025 10:07

I never understand why if people are bitchy and horrible etc why anyone wants to then join that group. If they actively exclude people they don’t like for whatever reason why do you care?

5128gap · 04/08/2025 10:07

Zov · 04/08/2025 09:52

@SunflowerLife

I have definitely witnessed toxic behaviour amongst some " school mum" groups. To anyone who is introverted and making friends doesn't come too easily, I can see why some might be perceived as cliques. I have had school mum friends who I saw in my own time so I understand that side of it, but I've also definitely been on the wrong side of an unpleasant group of women at the school.

Yeah this. ^ I think quite a number of women have experienced this. You can see the ones on this thread who haven't - and are very likely part of said 'cliques.' You can see the toxic comments coming out from a few posters ... Comments like 'oh you struggle to make friends so you blame other people?' So rude.

Edited

Or perhaps some of us simply reject the idea that some groups are better than others? If you refuse to buy into the thinking that there's an aspirational crowd which you'll either be part of or excluded from, and focus on the qualities of other people, cultivating friendships with those you like and who like you, rather than those you think are perceived as superior, then you get a different perspective. If you persist with the thinking that some people are superior, for no valid reason, and focus only on trying to get them to include you (so you can be a superior person too) you've only yourself to blame if you end up on the wrong side of the hierarchy you are creating.

Swipe left for the next trending thread