Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop letting my friend’s child come over because he eats so much?

336 replies

GazerJame · 02/08/2025 13:53

My DS (7) has a friend from school who comes over a couple of times a week after school. He’s a sweet boy, very polite, no behaviour issues or anything like that. The boys get on well and it’s honestly nice for DS to have someone to play with. But I’m really starting to dread the visits because of how much he eats.

It’s not just a biscuit and a drink after school. He’ll have two or three snacks straight away, like fruit, crackers, cereal bars, whatever’s in the cupboard, and then still be asking when tea is. I usually do something like pasta or fish fingers and beans, and without fail he’ll ask for seconds, sometimes thirds. Then pudding. Last week he had three bowls of pasta and then asked if we had any cake.

I wouldn’t think much of it once or twice but it’s every single time. It’s starting to feel like he arrives absolutely starving and I honestly don’t know if he’s just got a big appetite or if they’re sending him here expecting me to feed him properly. I’m not being tight, I really don’t mind giving a child food, but it’s getting expensive and it’s just a lot on top of everything else.

I’m tempted to start saying we can’t do weekday playdates anymore because it’s becoming too much. But then I feel bad because he’s only 7 and it’s not his fault. And I don’t want to make DS miss out either.

AIBU to be fed up with it and want to stop the visits for a while? Or do I just need to suck it up and plan for extra food twice a week? I feel awful even writing this but I’m not sure what the right thing is.

OP posts:
houseofwater · 02/08/2025 15:02

I haven’t read every single one of the responses but if he’s coming over after school wouldn’t you expect him to be hungry? Have you agreed with his mum to do dinner? No matter how much food I send to school my kids are hungry afterwards. One kid eats a massive amount at dinner, I even get fed up with it, he’s polite if he goes for dinner at someone else’s house after school and doesn’t eat as much but that means I have to make him a second dinner or 3 slices of toast at home as well! I actually try and avoid him staying for dinner at someone else’s house because it’s easier to feed him with the rest of us than feed him again when he gets home from a play date. I would also find this a bit annoying to navigate with someone else’s child.

Isittimeformynapyet · 02/08/2025 15:02

user1492757084 · 02/08/2025 14:28

Completely inappropriate.
The child ideally is sent home before dinner.
You are letting bad habits prevail.

Both boys could eat a couple of Weetabix, an apple and a glass of MIlo straight after school. Any snack larger will spoil their dinner.

You need to gather your power and actually parent.State that the friend is only to come over one day per fortnight/week etc. and clarify the snack details and going home plan.

I couldn't help but read this post in a very clipped schoolmistress voice 😂

"The child ideally is sent home before dinner." - weird and hilarious 🤣

Ohthatsabitshit · 02/08/2025 15:01

Decency pasta is about £2 for half a kilo. It’s not going to break the bank for most people and really isn’t posh pasta.

spoonbillstretford · 02/08/2025 15:01

I wouldn't do loads of snacks but make some proper doorstep sandwiches when you come in and make sure the pasta is rich with plenty of protein. And just let them serve themselves. I wouldn't care about how much he ate. Either he is a big eater or he's not being fed properly, or he just really enjoys your food, or more than one of the above. Either way it doesn't need to be an expensive problem.

LaDeeDaDeeDumb · 02/08/2025 15:00

I remember throwing my lunch away when I was this age because I didn’t like what I’d been given and then being starving after school. It’s possible the mum has no idea.

It’s also possible he might not be eating what’s being offered at home if you’re giving him stuff that’s more like treats (cereal bars etc). I would do as others have suggested and just provide cheap toast. Then talk to the mum and find out how she finds him eating at home. If she’s offering him food and he’s never hungry she might have no idea what’s happening at your house.

AnneLovesGilbert · 02/08/2025 14:58

3 plates of pasta plus pudding is nuts for a 7 year old.

Offer what you want to and say no to any further requests. I don’t make enough pasta for a single meal for anyone to be having thirds unless I’m planning leftovers for a second meal the next day.

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 02/08/2025 14:57

Are your portions particularly small? Maybe he's just used to more pasta than what you're sharing, so asks for more. Or maybe it's habit, he is used to asking for more without thinking of he actually needs it.
If you're serving a normal sized portion, don't be afraid to say No more pasta left, everyone has had their fair share. If you're still hungry you can have a banana, but wait 5 minutes so your dinner has a chance to reach your tummy.

tripleginandtonic · 02/08/2025 14:57

A cheap pack of bread with break the bank OP. I'd say bread and spread only if he's still hungry after tea

Thingsthatgo · 02/08/2025 14:55

I’d offer cheap but filling things. Peanut butter on toast or crumpet as a snack with a banana. After dinner, if he is still hungry, I would offer pasta or toast.

Ddakji · 02/08/2025 14:53

GazerJame · 02/08/2025 14:07

I think I’ve ended up in a bit of a cycle with it. The first couple of times he came over, he said he was hungry so I gave him snacks, and it’s just escalated from there. Now he expects it and I haven’t known how to rein it back in without seeming unkind. He’s not cheeky or rude about it, just very matter of fact, like it’s normal to have three bowls of food and still ask for pudding. I suppose I’ve been trying to avoid making it awkward or having him feel told off when he’s just a guest.

I hadn’t really thought much about the food situation at home until some of you mentioned it. It could just be a big appetite, but now I’m wondering. He always turns up starving, eats really quickly and doesn’t seem to have had anything since lunch. I know his mum works a lot and there’s no dad in the picture, so maybe things are stretched. I don’t want to be unkind if he’s not getting enough at home, but I also can’t keep doing full dinners several times a week when I’m already feeding three of my own. Especially with the cost of food now.

I think I do need to set some limits. Maybe just stick to one snack and no seconds at tea. I’ll try saying it more firmly but kindly. I just feel so uncomfortable doing that with someone else’s child, especially if I think they might be going hungry. It’s such a tricky one.

It’s not tricky. You say “no”.

I can’t believe you’d stop the play dates because you can’t say no.

Westfacing · 02/08/2025 14:52

Aw, poor lad - how much can it cost you to feed him twice a week. Maybe he just has a big appetite, or your bowls of pasta are small!

Is he visibly overweight, looking like he has an eating disorder?

He always turns up starving, eats really quickly and doesn’t seem to have had anything since lunch.

If he's coming over twice a week after school, as you say he is, then most kids won't have eaten anything since lunch.

MasterBeth · 02/08/2025 14:50

roses2 · 02/08/2025 14:19

I buy Dececco as this is the only brand I like which isn't particularly cheap.

Why is this kid at your house several times per week for dinner - do you have an arrangement? If not send him home when it's dinner time.

Well maybe don't feed waifs and strays with your fancy pasta. Get a £1 bag from Aldi and use that. Crackers and pasta are affordable unless she's on a severe budget.

Dheops · 02/08/2025 14:49

Give him one big jam sandwich

UpMyself · 02/08/2025 14:48

He's asking for it because he will get it.
Asking is rude, and you are enabling him.

JustGoClickLikeALightSwitch · 02/08/2025 14:48

Would add that I have a taller than average 7yo who routinely comes home hungry from school because the portions aren't big enough for her. She's not overweight but is tall and just isn't given enough.

JustGoClickLikeALightSwitch · 02/08/2025 14:47

I agree with others - at the moment it's not clear on whether you're just giving really great snacks, or he's hungry because he's growing, or he's hungry because he isn't eating enough at school/home.

I'd get in a big bag of apples, bananas, carrots, popcorn, bread with butter/jam/cheese as snacks, and a basic pasta with sauce for dinners, and assess whether he's actually hungry without blowing your budget.

DD has friends like this, same age. Three boys. Absolutely no chance of neglect and they, despite being quite slight/slim can just eat and eat and eat, even if what is on offer isn't particularly interesting. I tend to do the above.

Isittimeformynapyet · 02/08/2025 14:46

Aliksa · 02/08/2025 14:44

Offer buttered toast or a carrot as a snack - tell him you’ve run out of other snacks this week.

Regarding pudding just say “we don’t have pudding every day because it’s not healthy . You are welcome to have some bread and butter or a sliced apple if you are still hungry.”

Regarding the pasta - my son age 6 can eat and burn off a plateful as big as my 15 year old dd. I just make sure I serve less sauce and I put out a bowl of carrot sticks.

Christ! How big is the plate?! Or how small is the 15yr old?

Figcherry · 02/08/2025 14:46

I agree with serving toast, relatively cheap and no worse than crisps.

Aliksa · 02/08/2025 14:44

Offer buttered toast or a carrot as a snack - tell him you’ve run out of other snacks this week.

Regarding pudding just say “we don’t have pudding every day because it’s not healthy . You are welcome to have some bread and butter or a sliced apple if you are still hungry.”

Regarding the pasta - my son age 6 can eat and burn off a plateful as big as my 15 year old dd. I just make sure I serve less sauce and I put out a bowl of carrot sticks.

Isittimeformynapyet · 02/08/2025 14:44

tempname1234 · 02/08/2025 14:06

Yes, you are being tight as you are saying it is getting expensive. You do mind or you wouldn't be here posting about it.

you don’t really know what is going on with this child. Is he not being fed enough at home? If that is the case and you can feed a hungry child - why complain?

Is he doing a lot of sport at school and building up an appetite? so is arriving hungry? Does that make a difference? There is still an hungry child visiting you. Are they going through a growth spurt?

If you really don’t mind, are not being tight - why not just get in things that you can afford to give him in bulk? Brand - buy the cheaper brand for when he comes over. Fill him up with beans on toast or a jacket potato and brand with cheese on the days he visits. Same for pasta. Get cheaper brand for the day he visits.

bulk - fill him with bulky food as above or add rice cakes as snacks. Or rice pudding - cheap to make and fills them right up. Oat bars from whole oats - really heavy in the tummy, fills them up. Cheap to make.

Crikey, how to heap the responsibility onto OP, where it doesn't belong!

All that thinking (growth spurt? Sports? History of neglect?)

Rice cakes. Jacket potatoes. Extra pasta. Brands/non brands (could you get the word brand in a couple more times?) Make oat bars. Cook rice pudding.

Nuts - this is not OP's child!

Cinaferna · 02/08/2025 14:42

Just put the expensive snacks out of the way and have some very cheap ones on hand. And make cheaper dinners with extra bulk when he comes over. As PP have said, a few slices from a cheap loaf of bread with a bit of jam or an extra scoop of budget pasta is not going to break the bank. Worth it if he is a good friend to your child and otherwise nice to have around.

Isitreallysohard · 02/08/2025 14:39

If you can afford it I'd suck it up, good friends are priceless

EuclidianGeometryFan · 02/08/2025 14:39

If the children like playing together, it would be a shame to stop him coming over. Does your DC still like him coming or is he getting bored / fed up of his company? If DC is bored of him, cut back the visits.
This is separate to the question of food.

You could speak to his mum about the food, but that would be embarrassing if she is genuinely struggling. On the other hand, she may just be a CF.

I would just offer lots of really cheap food, as others have said.
The worst thing would be if the boy is genuinely hungry and you are his lifeline, and you stopped feeding him.
If you suspect he is genuinely underfed at home, you should flag up a warning with the school.

getsomehelp · 02/08/2025 14:37

Is he standard size?
Could you say he goes home to his house & snacks then come over.
Or send him home for his dinner.
Or Tell his mother he’s welcome at yours but you are not feeding him as he's a veritable locust

ComfortFoodCafe · 02/08/2025 14:37

My eldest is like this, he is a bottomless pit. Hes really tall (6 ft 6 at 14!!) and he constantly needs to eat. I give him toast, not a treat but its filling.
cheap too!