Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour smoking cigars in garden

32 replies

lovelibrary · 28/07/2025 21:16

We live in a semi-detached house. Both our house and our neighbour’s house (ie the one attached to us) have patio areas leading from kitchen to garden.

Our neighbour has started to smoke cigars on his patio area. The smell is really nasty - I don’t think these are expensive cigars! The issue is that the smoke wafts over and enters our house if we have any windows open. It is making the rooms at the back of our house stink, which includes a child’s bedroom.

I can’t decide whether I should have a gentle word with the neighbour, explain what we can smell and suggest that he smokes at the bottom of his garden.

Is that a reasonable request? Or do most think it’s unreasonable?

Our general relationship with said neighbours is ok-ish. We do say hello to each other, put bins out when on holiday, etc. But we have also had some fallings out over building work.

We have overheard conversations about why the neighbour has started to smoke cigars - apparently they help him to relax.

OP posts:
Anotherparkingthread · 28/07/2025 21:34

Eh you can ask him but he can ignore you. It's his garden at the end of the day.

Grantanow · 28/07/2025 21:31

Needs careful handling. He is entirely within his rights to smoke in his property. Full disclosure: I smoke Havanas on my back patio without complaint.

Brenda34 · 28/07/2025 21:31

YABU though I have a ton of sympathy with you.
You'll need to close your windows.

CarCrashLifes · 28/07/2025 21:31

He can do what he wants in his garden! You would be making an unreasonable request.

Trophy136 · 28/07/2025 21:29

lovelibrary · 28/07/2025 21:16

We live in a semi-detached house. Both our house and our neighbour’s house (ie the one attached to us) have patio areas leading from kitchen to garden.

Our neighbour has started to smoke cigars on his patio area. The smell is really nasty - I don’t think these are expensive cigars! The issue is that the smoke wafts over and enters our house if we have any windows open. It is making the rooms at the back of our house stink, which includes a child’s bedroom.

I can’t decide whether I should have a gentle word with the neighbour, explain what we can smell and suggest that he smokes at the bottom of his garden.

Is that a reasonable request? Or do most think it’s unreasonable?

Our general relationship with said neighbours is ok-ish. We do say hello to each other, put bins out when on holiday, etc. But we have also had some fallings out over building work.

We have overheard conversations about why the neighbour has started to smoke cigars - apparently they help him to relax.

Completely unreasonable. You can’t dictate where your neighbours smoke cigars. If it was weed i would have a different opinion though.

Whammyyammy · 28/07/2025 21:29

Neighbour smokes cigars in HIS garden...

DoneitagainhaventI · 28/07/2025 21:28

How absolutely horrible for you OP.

I'm afraid my experience with neighbours and smoking has been a very negative one. I would assume if you ask this person to smoke at the bottom of his garden he won't take it well and will probably go down the route of saying he can smoke wherever he wants in his own house and garden.
I may be totally wrong but that's what I would expect the reaction to be.