Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think The West is morally bankrupt

382 replies

Elrae · 27/07/2025 00:19

America democratically elects an adjudicate rapist who sympathises with racists, hates women and will do anything to hang onto power. The UK and it's lickspitrlw leader fawn over Trump and says that Israel has rhe right to cut off food and water to Gaza. Then wairs a year watching children die before saying it is intolerable. Except he is tolerating it.We all are.
The West is pumping out carbon at a vast rate and will no doubt reject the flood of refugees that this will cause.
The West takes more than it's fair share of the world's wealth. Much of the West is based on colonial exploration and murder of the global south.
I used to think we were the good guys.
We are not. We are one of the worst things ever to happen to the planet and it's inhabitants.

OP posts:
WaverleyOwl · 27/07/2025 22:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You are spouting things as if they were facts, and they aren't.

You are just coming across as a left wing wanker that has a bunch of talking points. Calling anyone that disagrees as middle class. As if that's an insult.

WaverleyOwl · 27/07/2025 22:45

Elrae · 27/07/2025 20:20

Britain is a colonising nation whose history and accumulated wealth involves invading other countries, stealing their resources and murdering their people. As well as setting up colonial administrations such as in the Raj in India. One of these colonised nations was a country whose western tip almost touched the very east of what we called Asia. The religiously persecuted Brethren who first arrived in this nation, and other colonisers, made it into a white Protestant setyller nation and in the process murdered many of the people who lived there for centuries. They then imported people from West Africa to be slaves working on cotton plantations. These people, still murdered today by the white selttler police, are today known as African Americans. Another white racist group, the German Nazis, decided to throw their lot in with a psychopath who thought Jews were the root of all their problems. He murdered millions of them, and miliions of those who fought against him. This legitimised the post war colonisation of Palestine by the co-religionists of the people who had been murdered. The co religionists, unwanted by Europe, created a new nation to assuage European guilt, called Israel. This new nation then threw Palestinian people off their land and became settler colonisers themselves. Supported by colonial countries like the UK and the US, and many European countries. The settler colonial guilt derived nation mistreated the indigenous inhabitants and then, almost 2 years ago, they were delighted that a terrorist group gave them a pretext for genocide through murderous acts. They murdered and starved thousands of children. Whenever anyone said "no" they cried "antisemitism"
Alternatively, just carry on drinking your fucking Merlot, listening to your bullshit BBC, believing the crap you have been fed,

Ah, you're one of those 'we were colonisers so we are baaad people'.

Of course, some of that was bad, but there was so much more that was good.

Do you know that the British stopped the slave trade?

WilfredsPies · 27/07/2025 22:38

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:09

I get that it is easier to think that countries like the UK and USA are morally ok. They're not. Thats why people are so upset about this. You are not ok

You’re just being silly now. You’ve either not read, or have misunderstood what people have said. Why do you think that none of us know our history? None of us think that our ancestors went round the world to say hello to all the different countries, had a cup of tea and then went on our merry way without upsetting anyone, ffs. If you used to think that the west were ‘the good guys’ then it’s clearly you who wasn’t aware of British history.

The reason people think you’re being ridiculous is that you’re singling the west out as an evil entity, responsible for all the ills in the world. Well we’re not. There are countries we colonised who are doing far better than we are. There are countries nobody colonised which are bloody terrible places to live. Your argument is short sighted.

Elrae · 27/07/2025 22:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WaverleyOwl · 27/07/2025 22:21

Elrae · 27/07/2025 00:46

oh how convenient for you..you come on here, choose to insult me, do not challemge intellectually a single point I said, post some video which. I have no intention of clicking on, then you're overcome with fatigue.
Is Trump not am adjudicated rapist?
Did 75 million Americans not hoose to vote him in?
Did Dtarmer not say what I heard and stated he said re: Israel?
Does the West not disproportionately cause carbon emissions?
Do carbon emissions not cause climate change?

start wherever you like

I'm sorry I can't answer you on your schedule. So sad, never mind.

I will break it down into a few, easily digestible, points.

The Christian West that we live in is the most enlightened society that has ever lived. The one where individuals have the most free will. The one where you can have a job and live a life without being the property of a man.

The Muslim world (if you'd watched the video I linked to, it would have given you a lot of good historical context if you can't be bothered to do research) has been on a genocidal path since Mohammad died in the 600s. Europe has been a battleground between Christianity and Islam for the last 1500 years.

I personally would prefer to live in a Christian nation than one that thinks that I am half the worth of a man.

If you think that the west is morally bankrupt, maybe go try living in one of those non-western countries and see how you get on.

Fimofriend · 27/07/2025 22:20

Elrae · 27/07/2025 00:46

oh how convenient for you..you come on here, choose to insult me, do not challemge intellectually a single point I said, post some video which. I have no intention of clicking on, then you're overcome with fatigue.
Is Trump not am adjudicated rapist?
Did 75 million Americans not hoose to vote him in?
Did Dtarmer not say what I heard and stated he said re: Israel?
Does the West not disproportionately cause carbon emissions?
Do carbon emissions not cause climate change?

start wherever you like

No, it seems that China emits the most carbon. We don't know about Russia as their numbers can't be trusted. They have this tendency of executing their head statisticians if the government doesn't like their results.

In Pakistan women are lucky if they get arrested after they get raped as that might save their lives. The new thing now is that if the men who commit a rape films the rape, the rapist can then blackmail his victim forever as she will get killed and nothing or very little will happen to him if the tape gets out. Smart, isn't it? He can make her sleep with him or anybody, get money and jewellery from her etc. A bit difficult to be more morally corrupt than that.

UsingAMansNameInAWomensWorld · 27/07/2025 22:17

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:29

No, only 75 million

Who presumably live all across the USA...

EmmaSheen · 27/07/2025 22:14

Elrae · 27/07/2025 22:09

It is too late. We are all shafted, Your 75 million friends who voted for the adjudicated rapist are irredeemable. Give it maybe another 3 or 4 generations and climate change caused by arseholes voting for arseholes will finish us off anyway. But no just carry on fiddling while Rome burns. And fuck the people starving to death in Palestine. Israel can never do anything wrong, can it?

Thank you for assuming I'm popular enough to have 75 million friends....joking aside.

How would you choose to solve the issues you brought up? I'm honest enough to hold my hands up and say I don't have the answers but I do at least understand that anger isn't the answer either

Elrae · 27/07/2025 22:09

EmmaSheen · 27/07/2025 22:01

@Elrae Please do not put words in my mouth or assume my political beliefs.

It's clear you haven't read my posts.

No one has a definitive answer to a better future but condemning 75 million people certainly isn't going to help.

By taking the stance that those people are bad and irredeemable you are ironically driving them further towards the things you dislike.

Edited

It is too late. We are all shafted, Your 75 million friends who voted for the adjudicated rapist are irredeemable. Give it maybe another 3 or 4 generations and climate change caused by arseholes voting for arseholes will finish us off anyway. But no just carry on fiddling while Rome burns. And fuck the people starving to death in Palestine. Israel can never do anything wrong, can it?

OP posts:
CapeGooseberry · 27/07/2025 22:05

EasternStandard · 27/07/2025 22:01

Ok so whereabouts do you live?

Perhaps an Iranian National Guard Bot?

EmmaSheen · 27/07/2025 22:01

@Elrae Please do not put words in my mouth or assume my political beliefs.

It's clear you haven't read my posts.

No one has a definitive answer to a better future but condemning 75 million people certainly isn't going to help.

By taking the stance that those people are bad and irredeemable you are ironically driving them further towards the things you dislike.

EasternStandard · 27/07/2025 22:01

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:09

I get that it is easier to think that countries like the UK and USA are morally ok. They're not. Thats why people are so upset about this. You are not ok

Ok so whereabouts do you live?

CapeGooseberry · 27/07/2025 21:53

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:28

Name a country colonised by Gambia

Are you in Gambia?

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:52

EmmaSheen · 27/07/2025 21:35

That's incredibly sad. All your current way of thinking will do is continue the status quo or usher in and even worse future.

What is the way of thinking you think will usher in a better future? Yes, great that so many Americans voted for a vile individual. Brilliant that the UK voted in a milksop in one of their once in a generational interludes between Tory fuckwits. All your problems are because of immigrants, Farage will solve everything and nobody in the British Royal Family, which is beyond reproachm ever did anything wrong.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 27/07/2025 21:39

Oooo the monthly slag off the UK thread. Jolly good.

EmpressoftheMundane · 27/07/2025 21:39

@Elrae you seem a little immature and formulaic. Are you for real? Or just bored? Your opinions are pretty sophomoric.

As for countries being immoral, wasn’t it Reinhold Niebuhr who argued that individuals can be moral, but nations cannot by their very nature? Moral Man and Immoral Society

Sure the UK and USA are not moral. Nor is any other country on earth. It’s a virtue you can ascribe to individual people, but not large groups.

EmmaSheen · 27/07/2025 21:35

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:31

No it is not. No I will not. So what, America is finished, So are we all, thanks to the rapist in chief and his friends

That's incredibly sad. All your current way of thinking will do is continue the status quo or usher in and even worse future.

SpaceRaccoon · 27/07/2025 21:35

So are we all, thanks to the rapist in chief and his friends

Maybe go for a walk, get some fresh air.

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:31

EmmaSheen · 27/07/2025 21:28

Condemning 75 million people is morally bankrupt at best. They may have voted for someone you don't like but until you take a step back and try to understand why rather than resorting to anger you'll only push that number higher.

No it is not. No I will not. So what, America is finished, So are we all, thanks to the rapist in chief and his friends

OP posts:
Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:29

UsingAMansNameInAWomensWorld · 27/07/2025 21:27

You think the whole of the US is full of disastrous people?

No, only 75 million

OP posts:
EmmaSheen · 27/07/2025 21:28

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:23

America is a complete and utter disaster of a country, with at least 75 million disastrous people. But no, carry on persuading yourself that it is ok to be that shit, because nowhere is perfect

Condemning 75 million people is morally bankrupt at best. They may have voted for someone you don't like but until you take a step back and try to understand why rather than resorting to anger you'll only push that number higher.

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:28

TheHateIsNotGood · 27/07/2025 21:24

The UK has been one of the safest places to live for centuries - no predatory animals or plants for a start; no 'tribal lords' to kill us and religion hasn't been too important for most of us for quite some time. Even the climate is mild.

Due to this we are very tolerant and I don't blame anyone for wanting to come here. But then no one should blame any UK person, historically or now, for feeling a bit adventurous and wanting to seek warmer climes.

Every country has been 'colonialist' in their history, at least the UK gives some credence to this with the Commonwealth and the granting of certain rights to people that are part of it.

I'm as pissed off with things as anyone here is but am also so sick of hearing of 'historical' reasons of why I or anyone could be.

It's the here and now we deal with and just getting on with it is how the UK works. If anyone is looking to live differently to that needs to either be mighty rich or find some other country more suited to their 'values' to live in.

Name a country colonised by Gambia

OP posts:
UsingAMansNameInAWomensWorld · 27/07/2025 21:27

You think the whole of the US is full of disastrous people?

TheHateIsNotGood · 27/07/2025 21:24

The UK has been one of the safest places to live for centuries - no predatory animals or plants for a start; no 'tribal lords' to kill us and religion hasn't been too important for most of us for quite some time. Even the climate is mild.

Due to this we are very tolerant and I don't blame anyone for wanting to come here. But then no one should blame any UK person, historically or now, for feeling a bit adventurous and wanting to seek warmer climes.

Every country has been 'colonialist' in their history, at least the UK gives some credence to this with the Commonwealth and the granting of certain rights to people that are part of it.

I'm as pissed off with things as anyone here is but am also so sick of hearing of 'historical' reasons of why I or anyone could be.

It's the here and now we deal with and just getting on with it is how the UK works. If anyone is looking to live differently to that needs to either be mighty rich or find some other country more suited to their 'values' to live in.

Elrae · 27/07/2025 21:23

America is a complete and utter disaster of a country, with at least 75 million disastrous people. But no, carry on persuading yourself that it is ok to be that shit, because nowhere is perfect

OP posts: