Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fat bias exists

133 replies

Oldfatbrenda · 19/07/2025 10:37

Over a year ago I posted as I couldn't find work. I was a size 20/22 and also in my 40s. I had head and shoulder interviews on teams and when they saw me in person it was a no. I felt like this was both age and weight bias.
One unpleasant woman who was clearly into her own looks and fashion, looked me up and down and when I left I heard her laughing. I'm convinced it was about me.
I was lucky and did get a way better job than that a few weeks later and at that point I had made the decision to try much harder to lose some significant weight.
I'm now a size 14/16 and I know without a doubt that people treat me differently. It's sad that many people are this way and look down on fat people as being lazy, having no willpower or that they will be too unhealthy to do their job.
Just for the record, I have had 1 sick day in over a year. Most of that time I was still technically obese.
Before this job search I did a bit of physical work in a hotel and yes it was bloody hard because of my size but I pulled my weight (sorry) almost more than the others to show I could and wasn't holding the team back. Yes I'd be dripping and have to go to bed when I got home but I was a model employee.
Anyway just wanted to come and say all that. I wasn't imagining it - but luckily there are still people who don't judge on looks and age. Thank the lord.
Anyone going through similar, don't give up. It will be harder but not impossible.

OP posts:
StripyShirt · 21/07/2025 17:38

privatenonamegiven · 19/07/2025 17:12

Try being fat and old....

That seeems to be a self-limiting combination.

JohnTheRevelator · 21/07/2025 17:14

Oh yes,fat bias is definitely a thing! Having lost 7 stone myself over the last few years, I have noticed a definite change in the way people treat me and speak to me. I'm still a bit overweight,just not obese any more. I was totally expecting it though, having lost quite a bit of weight many years ago,in the early 80s. Back then,I noticed an even bigger change in the attitude of people towards me. I think people's attitudes to obese/overweight people back then was even worse than it is now. I think a lot (but not all) people have become more accepting of overweight people, probably because there is so many of them nowadays,compared to 40 years ago!

DadBodAlready · 21/07/2025 16:59

Bias exists in everything we do, and every decision we make. Some of the time its conscious and some of the time it's unconscious.
Anyone who claims otherwise is well, lets just say misinformed.

asrl78 · 21/07/2025 14:05

cyvguhb · 19/07/2025 14:43

I don't know how you're wanting the voting to work but does anyone not think fat bias is a thing?

I think it is a subset of attractive person bias. People percieved to be attractive are more likely to be successful at job interviews, more likely to be promoted, get lighter court sentences, and are often favoured in social situations, leading others to assume they possess positive traits such as intelligence and kindness. The dumb blonde stereotype is merely a way of trying to combat this by bitter, less attractive people.

Humans have cognitive biases that are not fully rational and it takes significant effort to reign in those biases. The vast majority of people would rather take the easy option of letting their biases do the thinking for them hence we end up with frequent poor decision making. The scientific method helps to a point but human cognitive biases are powerful and are not going away anytime soon.

TabbyCatInAPoolofSunshine · 21/07/2025 06:10

Frederica4 · 20/07/2025 21:05

I wa telling DH recently that I welcome the zero attention I get from men nowadays. But how depressing is it that I feel safer because I’m now invisible?

Yes exactly - it's protective and peaceful. We shouldn't have to be subjected to creeps thinking they can touch us (what is it with thinking slimmer women need a man's hand on their lower back, propelling them to go ahead through a door or in a queue?) or making slimey comments.

Duechristmas · 20/07/2025 22:04

I recently lost 6.5 stone. I had become invisible and thought it was just a sign of ageing as the media told me. Absolutely not, I am treated entirely differently now when I'm out and about.

Frederica4 · 20/07/2025 21:05

TabbyCatInAPoolofSunshine · 20/07/2025 20:39

I agree, although I think there's a sweet spot. I tend towards being overweight and actually found that women in service industry and retail were more helpful and friendly when I was obese, while acquaintances and neighbours are friendlier when I'm middle to high healthy BMI.

I got down to a size ten for a bit and the sudden occurrence of regular creepy, slimy attention from a certain type of slightly older man (something I thought I'd thankfully aged out of attracting) really repulsed me.

I'm socially and professionally most comfortable at the top end of healthy BMI size 12/14.

I wa telling DH recently that I welcome the zero attention I get from men nowadays. But how depressing is it that I feel safer because I’m now invisible?

TabbyCatInAPoolofSunshine · 20/07/2025 20:39

I agree, although I think there's a sweet spot. I tend towards being overweight and actually found that women in service industry and retail were more helpful and friendly when I was obese, while acquaintances and neighbours are friendlier when I'm middle to high healthy BMI.

I got down to a size ten for a bit and the sudden occurrence of regular creepy, slimy attention from a certain type of slightly older man (something I thought I'd thankfully aged out of attracting) really repulsed me.

I'm socially and professionally most comfortable at the top end of healthy BMI size 12/14.

GiveDogBone · 20/07/2025 20:06

Yes fat bias exists, in the same way that if somebody turned up at work looking like they’d spent the night sleeping on a park bench. Or didn’t take a shower for a month. People would judge them for that. It’s basically a sign you don’t take care of yourself.

(And being stick insect thin will also lead to judgements)

Humans are hard-wired to make instant judgements on people and things. Grounded in experience, however unrepresentative, rather than facts. We trust our instincts even though they can often be wrong.

August1980 · 20/07/2025 19:29

Well done on your weigh loss and your new job! I admire your willpower!

canyouseemyhousefromhere · 20/07/2025 19:04

When I was younger I was always naturally slim a size 8/10 (dad was very skinny).
At work I was constantly bullied, especially by older women. I was told that I should eat more. I had a very healthy appetite.
I Remember walking out of work one day and a group of women behind me laughing saying I may fall between the cracks in the pavement. If I spoke to them in the office they would pretend they couldn’t see me because I was standing sideways.
Eventually I went to the GP who told me I should eat cream cakes and drink alcohol if I wanted to put on weight.

My son is very slim and has had lots of zoom interviews which have gone really well. When he goes for the in-person one he doesn’t get through.

Some people have an inner ‘ideal’ of what a person should look like and dismiss anyone who doesn’t match up.

YoNoHeSido77 · 20/07/2025 18:46

I’m in a friend group of 4. At size 24 I was the smallest.

I am now a size 8 and my friends have been wonderful. My biggest friend was so impressed with my progress that she asked her GP for help and she had weight loss surgery a few months ago, I’m so proud of her for taking action, but I loved her no matter what.

my family though… totally different story. Other than my husband, kids and mum it was dreadful.

YoNoHeSido77 · 20/07/2025 18:41

I was a size 24 with many illness and disabilities. I was pretty much bedbound.
I went to my GP a lot due to this and felt fobbed off constantly.

I'm now a size 8 (god bless gastric bypass) and while I still have the illnesses and disabilities (they aren’t weight related, but my weight was mainly disability related) I now get offered X-rays and MRI etc (I’ve had more investigations in the 5 years since my bypass, than in the previous 20+ years). I get referred to various hospital departments and I never hear “It’s down to your weight” when speaking to consultants. They actually seem interested in helping me!

it’s wonderful.

people also don’t look down at me when I order food and eat out.

Fat bias is VERY real, I’ll never allow myself to be overweight again.

ChocolateGanache · 20/07/2025 07:02

Ernestina123 · 19/07/2025 15:08

I don’t think anyone would claim that fat bias was not real. The question is whether or not it is justified.

There are loads of biases based on non protected characteristics: accent, appearance (good looking or not) clothes etc.

Depending on the context and the role they can be more or less justified. eg Banks employ people with Scots accents in call centres because the Scots are perceived to be good with money.

If I was employing someone as a receptionist I would discriminate based on appearance.

If I was employing a nanny for toddlers I would discriminate based on my perception of their ability to keep up with the children and model a healthy lifestyle. Some obese people say that their weight does not impact performance, but it depends on the role.

Wow.

mondaytosunday · 20/07/2025 02:03

Of course it does. I’m considerably overweight myself and I am guilty of it too. I do judge people on how they look, I think it’s almost impossible not to! I think people gravitate to people who look like they do - so many groups of friends and they look like carbon copies of each other! And this is also why of one person in a group loses or gains a fair amount they find their friends not as supportive as they would expect.

MyQuirkyTraybake · 20/07/2025 01:27

Skinny bias exists too. People will be judgemental about anything!

Glassball · 19/07/2025 19:35

I get this ive been on both sides.
I had the body of a model slim toned you name it, it took a lot of hard work to get it.
I did it because i was fed up of being the fat one bullied for it i was size 16-18 at the time.

A few years later i went from size 8 to a size 16.
I was treated alot lot different even my partner left me.
Im now a size 12 and i like it i dont care what others say i learned to love me for me.
If i get bigger i will get bigger clothes.

Absentmindedsmile · 19/07/2025 19:04

Of course it exists. Like ‘attractiveness’ bias exists. Etc etc.

Flossflower · 19/07/2025 19:01

Yes it does exist. There may be valid reasons for this.

privatenonamegiven · 19/07/2025 18:56

bananafake · 19/07/2025 18:52

But attractiveness is in part culturally driven. For example what was considered beautiful in Renaissance, Victorian, 1920s or current times are very different. Given that relative slimness is considered generally more attractive people are drawn to that in the West. I'm neither particularly slim nor beautiful and I just know this. No point in complaining as I can't change my looks much. Also medium extroversion is also valued. Do you honestly think we can eliminate all forms of judgement?

Exactly the point I was try to make to other poster who was suggesting that we are somehow designed to see fat as unattractive.. and no we can't eliminate all judgements that would be foolish to think so - but we can be more aware and not so bloody awful to other people....

bananafake · 19/07/2025 18:52

privatenonamegiven · 19/07/2025 18:24

Of course it's that easy...

Of course people will treat you differently for being over weight, we are

and you're wrong about that - yes people judge but not always negatively - in some cultures being fat is associated with wealth, fertility, and social status.

Edited

But attractiveness is in part culturally driven. For example what was considered beautiful in Renaissance, Victorian, 1920s or current times are very different. Given that relative slimness is considered generally more attractive people are drawn to that in the West. I'm neither particularly slim nor beautiful and I just know this. No point in complaining as I can't change my looks much. Also medium extroversion is also valued. Do you honestly think we can eliminate all forms of judgement?

JustSawJohnny · 19/07/2025 18:46

Bit of a 'do bears shit in the woods', OP!

LimeQuoter · 19/07/2025 18:37

100%. I remember I lost a lot of weight with Crohn's disease. I had never been very skinny before. I looked healthy otherwise but I was very skinny/underweight. One day I was in a cafe. When I saw 2 separate tables of people looking over at me. I heard a woman say, god I'd hate to be that think. It's looks awful. You can see her bones. Another agreed. I know, and it doesn't even look well, her clothes are hanging off her. It looks disgusting. A man with them agreed. I was skinny for a few months and in that time I noticed how socially acceptable it was to comment on someone/including to their face that they looked too thin.

I was told dished out more food when eating out while people laughed and got comments about my weight until I told them the reason behind it. It made me wonder is that what naturally skinny people have to deal with. You would never publicly laugh at an overweight person and take food away from them because they need to lose a few pounds or call them really chubby to their face

Violinist64 · 19/07/2025 18:32

cyvguhb · 19/07/2025 17:28

Whilst I am certain that fat prejudice exists in amazed that anyone who is a size 16 would notice it unless they happened to work in a job where slimness was a required criteria or only hung out with models, that's a pretty normal size nowadays. In what situations did you experience that?

By the spelling, l would hazard a guess that this poster is from the USA, where a size 16 is equivalent to a British size 20.

Frederica4 · 19/07/2025 18:27

Disturbia81 · 19/07/2025 18:16

Yes people definitely treat fat people like they’re thick.

I was told how important it is to read to my DC the other day. I nodded and smiled and didn’t say I once led on reading interventions at work. It wasn’t said to the other mum, also reading to her DC.

Swipe left for the next trending thread