Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nanny Dilemma

286 replies

BlankStreetMatcha · 17/07/2025 18:20

I feel terrible for bring this problem to here, I have no children of my own so I would like some advice from other mothers.

So....

I am currently Nanny to a 12 year old boy, this is my sixth year working with this family, they are lovely people and I am really enjoy being part of their family and they've always treated me very well.

Now the Dilemma is Mum & Dad want to take a 12 day holiday alone and they've asked if I could take care of their son in the meanwhile. I have never minded helping them out in the past, a few days here and there, I don't feel as if they realise that I have a life of my own, and them dragging me away from it can be a huge inconvenience at times.

I find it very hard to say no, simple reason he is the most sweetest child you'd ever come across, and he has always been an absolute pleasure to take care of.

It seems like Mum & Dad do not want him or only want him with them when it's convenient for them i.e family events etc, they haven't attended parents evening for years, it's always been left down to me, which I don't mind, but I just can't comprehend why they don't feel the need to have any input in his school life or his life in general.

During the last couple of months there has been a few times when he has randomly expressed that he hates his Mum & Dad, I have never asked him why, because I don't feel as if it is my business or my right to question him further, and he is at that age children tend to start expressing themselves. I just tell him that they love him very much and then change the subject.

I feel as they believe showering him with the most expensive gifts, ludicrous clothing brands and the latest gadgets makes up for the time unspent with him and I just can't understand why they don't want to bring him along with them on their holiday.

I had made plans and now I feel as if it's my only option to cancel them, if I say no I am instantly going to feel guilty and they will probably try and palm him off with someone else, he should not be made to feel unwanted.

What would you do if you were in my situation?

OP posts:
BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 15:38

I am here now, I have asked him what he'd like to do whilst his parents are away, I suggested that go somewhere nice, a place of his choice.

He said that he is fine with staying home and just going out during the day, I asked if he was sure because I don't want him to feel as if he is missing out on anything, he told me that he didn't and wouldn't be going anywhere with his parents and he is actually pleased that they aren't here. I didn't want to dig further because he rapidly changed the conversation, but the more he starts opening up, I will listen and possibly ask why he is feeling like this.

OP posts:
BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 15:29

croydon15 · 20/07/2025 14:08

OP you sound like a lovely person, in a tricky situation as no doubt you love that child, don't listen to the nasty posts who imply that you are in it only for the benefits and want you to contact SS or the school.

💐

I have been a lurker on the site for a while, so I am fully aware of how nasty some people here can be, I know that I am not just around for the benefits.

They obviously want me betray the family and lose my job, that's why they are encouraging me to contact SS and his school. SS wouldn't even take on this case and the school wouldn't even take me serious.

OP posts:
croydon15 · 20/07/2025 14:08

OP you sound like a lovely person, in a tricky situation as no doubt you love that child, don't listen to the nasty posts who imply that you are in it only for the benefits and want you to contact SS or the school.

Mookie81 · 20/07/2025 12:42

BlankStreetMatcha · 18/07/2025 20:30

I am going to start standing up for myself, but he has been a big part in my life for the past 6 years now, if it wasn't for him and his family I would never be able to have obtained the things I have. His parents have been so good to me, that's why I find it very difficult to say no to them.

Reaping the benefits, so not wanting to rock the boat. I see now.

Mookie81 · 20/07/2025 12:41

saraclara · 18/07/2025 19:57

It just gets too much for me sometimes, it almost feels like he is my child. I have had relationships break down because of it,

This is SO unhealthy and I'm amazed that no-one else has picked up on it. It's as if you are not a person on your own right. You've never had a break from your job for more than four days. You've lost more than one relationship because of this. You are seriously going to cancel your own holiday plans for these people. To them you are just a handy robot that they can program with every single element of parenting. And you're letting them do it, at a cost to your own personal life and relationships.

As a nanny you should be communicating with the parents about your charge's needs. Yet you're afraid to do so. That is how you're letting him down. Not by saying to his parents 'sorry but I have already made plans, and no I'm not prepared to shelve them for you'.

Edited

Exactly.
The OP doesn't sound 'lovely', she's a pushover who hasn't reported safeguarding issues and is weirdly enmeshed in this family.
You find him fitting and being ignored, they take absolutely no interest in any care and he reguarly says he hates them, what are you doing about this? Do you get something out of being needed to this extent?

Blondeshavemorefun · 20/07/2025 12:12

Schoolchoicesucks · 19/07/2025 21:49

Are you in the UK? It would be highly unusual in the UK for a 14/15/16 year old to be taken to and from school by a nanny.

The school must have concerns with you attending all parents evenings in place of the parents. And being the one to attend routine and emergency medical appointments too.

I understand you care for the boy, but if this is true then you must share your concerns. If the family is "lovely" then set out to them how they are not meeting their son's basic emotional needs. If not then with the school who can refer to SS who can support with parenting. You need to plan for a time when you are not there and ensure this child will have some involvement and care from his parents.

Private school are diff

They usually get dropped off my parent or nanny.

I’ve dropped off teens and picked up

Rocketpants50 · 20/07/2025 10:49

You sound lovely and the parents are very lucky to have found someone like you to essentially bring up their child. BUT you sound very much like my friend, a nanny for a lovely family with 2 children she was there for years, right from the birth of the youngest. Went on wonderful holidays, rescued them at weekends when mum had a headache and couldn't cope with the children, looked after them whilst they went on trips but also did holidays with the family. Was at their beck and call and never felt she could say no for similar reasons. Fast forward 12 years, the children were sent off to boarding school, the job finished, they didnt even have the decency to inform her of the passing of the house keeper. She had done her job yes but she came out and realised she had sacrificed a lot for them - always wanted her own children, hadn't had time to meet anyone.. so they might be paying you well but at that cost to your own future happiness.

Secretsquirels · 20/07/2025 10:34

BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 09:34

It is not my place to speak to the school about it, I feel as if I would be betraying the family. I am already betraying them by posting on here.

Different families are different, and different parents make different choices.

You are a brilliant nanny to love him so much and be so much on his side, but I would really caution you to think very carefully before following the advice on this thread. You have posted a few times about not overstepping boundaries and I think that you have a good gut feeling here of what is/isn’t ok within this family. Don’t lose a good job with a child you like because of mumsnet advice!

Social services will not care at all that a child has been left at home with a qualified, professional nanny who he knows well. Or that he hasn’t had a holiday. Or that his parents want to holiday without him.

If he goes to a well know private day school there will be many many families who holiday without their children, or who travel for periods of time. Diplomats, CEOs, musicians, politicians etc - a really high percentage of roles which pay the money to afford these schools need international travel and long hours. It also won’t be uncommon for the nanny to attend parent meetings, although probably less common at secondary.

What I think that you could do which might help is to suggest some sort of therapy/counselling for him. Position it to the parents as something which a lot of families at school are doing to support over teenage/puberty years. That might give him the insight and skills to raise concerns himself.

saraclara · 20/07/2025 10:19

BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 09:19

I am in the UK, he is 12 now. I am sure as he gets older his parents will arrange for a car to take him and collect him.

I do want to share my concerns with his parents but I don't want them to feel as if I am being rude and disrespectful.

You would not be being rude or disrespectful. They have employed a professional to look after him. As a professional you have a responsibility to communicate with, and update your employers on their child's wellbeing.

In any job, omitting to inform your employer or manager of a serious problem would be seen as neglectful and you would be pulled up on it.

I really don't want to sound nagging, but seriously, this is your job! You are letting him down by not advocating for him, and not communicating his needs to your employers.

Have a good trip with him, and then definitely take a break, if only so that you can think this all through away from your work environment. And talk to your mum.

croydon15 · 20/07/2025 10:10

Hope you both have a lovely holiday, you both deserve it.

Goldbar · 20/07/2025 09:58

Bluestone in Wales is lovely, although a bit of a trek from London. Centerparcs (either Woburn Forest or Longleat) might be a good shout. Lots of cheap and cheerful caravan or lodge holiday parks with pools and activities if he might enjoy that?

Portsmouth is accessible on the train and has lots to do and see, including the dockyard there. Also lot of fairground rides on the front he might like. Winchester is another good one - there's Marwell Zoo (which might be a bit young for a 12yo) but also the science centre and lots of other stuff to do and see. Again, an easy one by train if you don't want to drive, though you might need to get buses/taxis to some stuff. Or if you felt confident enough, you could do Edinburgh on the train from King's Cross. Definitely lots of options to chat to him about and see what appeals.

BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 09:34

Francestein · 20/07/2025 09:21

Poor kid… Can you speak to his school counsellor about it perhaps? (After this?) They might have some more insight.
Why the hell do these people have kids? I bet if they had a snappy little white dog it would be going everywhere in a designer handbag and travelling first class.

It is not my place to speak to the school about it, I feel as if I would be betraying the family. I am already betraying them by posting on here.

OP posts:
BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 09:32

Goldbar · 20/07/2025 09:19

OP, just focus in the meantime on having a lovely time with him.

What part of the country are you based in (very roughly)? Maybe we could suggest a few holiday or day trip ideas.

Then you can decide how you want to proceed when the parents return and you get some down-time.

I am based in London, so we are obviously going to have to venture out. I am going to ask the parents for a break once they get back, I need time for myself.

OP posts:
Francestein · 20/07/2025 09:21

Poor kid… Can you speak to his school counsellor about it perhaps? (After this?) They might have some more insight.
Why the hell do these people have kids? I bet if they had a snappy little white dog it would be going everywhere in a designer handbag and travelling first class.

BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 09:19

Schoolchoicesucks · 19/07/2025 21:49

Are you in the UK? It would be highly unusual in the UK for a 14/15/16 year old to be taken to and from school by a nanny.

The school must have concerns with you attending all parents evenings in place of the parents. And being the one to attend routine and emergency medical appointments too.

I understand you care for the boy, but if this is true then you must share your concerns. If the family is "lovely" then set out to them how they are not meeting their son's basic emotional needs. If not then with the school who can refer to SS who can support with parenting. You need to plan for a time when you are not there and ensure this child will have some involvement and care from his parents.

I am in the UK, he is 12 now. I am sure as he gets older his parents will arrange for a car to take him and collect him.

I do want to share my concerns with his parents but I don't want them to feel as if I am being rude and disrespectful.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 20/07/2025 09:19

OP, just focus in the meantime on having a lovely time with him.

What part of the country are you based in (very roughly)? Maybe we could suggest a few holiday or day trip ideas.

Then you can decide how you want to proceed when the parents return and you get some down-time.

BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 09:16

Murdoch1949 · 20/07/2025 03:23

You could offer to take him on a UK based holiday where he would be able to enjoy activities that he would enjoy, under professional tuition - surfing, climbing, football, gaming, music - whatever he enjoys. This would reduce the time you are in sole control of him and give you spare time to recharge your battery! You need paying for your 24/12 care, it's not a normal nanny week.

Yes, that's what I plan to do. We will have a look once I am there and his parents have left, they have paid me £6.5K for the 12 days and I will be reimbursed for the money spent on our getaway.

OP posts:
BlankStreetMatcha · 20/07/2025 09:14

saraclara · 19/07/2025 21:37

How old are you, @BlankStreetMatcha ? Apologies if you've said and I've missed it.

Your mum is right to be worried and unhappy. And I agree with a pp that this is not good for the child. He will/has become so dependent on you that it's massively bad for you both.

I can only reiterate what I said earlier in the thread. It's time for you to talk to the parents as a professional. Let them know that you're concerned about him, about his lack of connection with them, about him seeing his friends having holidays with their parents, and the risk of him feeling neglected and unloved. Going on holidays with his nanny is no compensation for his mum and dad. Say that you're concerned that he's seeing you as his parent, which is dangerous as you won't be around forever.

You have your own life to live and the space to have your own relationship and children. You might want to remind them of that.

Edited

I am 28 years of age, I always wanted to be settled down and have my own child by the age I am at now.

I just feel very drained at the moment, I need to leave to care for him soon, next time I will definitely stand up for myself.

OP posts:
Murdoch1949 · 20/07/2025 03:23

You could offer to take him on a UK based holiday where he would be able to enjoy activities that he would enjoy, under professional tuition - surfing, climbing, football, gaming, music - whatever he enjoys. This would reduce the time you are in sole control of him and give you spare time to recharge your battery! You need paying for your 24/12 care, it's not a normal nanny week.

Wallichiana · 19/07/2025 22:24

BlankStreetMatcha · 17/07/2025 21:22

The Father just doesn't seem interested and Mother is always busy.

It's just not school appointments, it's all appointments e.g doctors/dentist etc

There was a situation last year where he wasn't feeling too good during the night, he went into his parents room and his Father got annoyed so he knocked on my bedroom door, he had a very high temperature so I took him to A&E just to be on the safe side.

There had previously been a situation a few years prior, he wasn't feeling well for the whole day, it was the end of the day and I was getting ready to leave. His Mother had put him on the sofa in the living room to keep a close eye on him, something told me to go back to the house, when I returned he was fitting, because his temperature had got so high and she didn't even realise because she was pre-occupied. Since that incident, anytime he has a high temperature I stay by him and monitor him, and if it gets too high we go to A&E.

Bloody hell
It sounds like child abuse smothered in wealth

Schoolchoicesucks · 19/07/2025 21:49

BlankStreetMatcha · 19/07/2025 16:06

Maybe I am just being silly.

We are located in an area where the robbery crime rate is at all time high, last week a young man was murdered for his expensive watch, he also wears a very distinctive school uniform.

Are you in the UK? It would be highly unusual in the UK for a 14/15/16 year old to be taken to and from school by a nanny.

The school must have concerns with you attending all parents evenings in place of the parents. And being the one to attend routine and emergency medical appointments too.

I understand you care for the boy, but if this is true then you must share your concerns. If the family is "lovely" then set out to them how they are not meeting their son's basic emotional needs. If not then with the school who can refer to SS who can support with parenting. You need to plan for a time when you are not there and ensure this child will have some involvement and care from his parents.

Hol9191 · 19/07/2025 21:42

I don’t have any advice for you in your situation because what you ‘should’ do and what you ‘should’ say is very easy for people to advise but from reading your posts you can clearly see that you’re more than just a Nanny to this boy. I do however just want to say that he is very lucky to have you and for the rest of that boys life he will always remember the care you’ve given him and will forever appreciate you. I think you probably typed this more out of frustration because you already knew from the minute the parents asked you that you was going to cancel your own plans for the boy. I feel for you because that is really annoying and it is unfair for them to put you in this position. As crap as the situation is, remind yourself in those 12 days that you’re making such a difference to his life just by being in it. You sound lovely x

saraclara · 19/07/2025 21:37

BlankStreetMatcha · 19/07/2025 20:59

My Mother has raised her concerns, she is not happy that I haven't been able to live my own life since I have been working with this family. I want to settle down and have children of my own.

How old are you, @BlankStreetMatcha ? Apologies if you've said and I've missed it.

Your mum is right to be worried and unhappy. And I agree with a pp that this is not good for the child. He will/has become so dependent on you that it's massively bad for you both.

I can only reiterate what I said earlier in the thread. It's time for you to talk to the parents as a professional. Let them know that you're concerned about him, about his lack of connection with them, about him seeing his friends having holidays with their parents, and the risk of him feeling neglected and unloved. Going on holidays with his nanny is no compensation for his mum and dad. Say that you're concerned that he's seeing you as his parent, which is dangerous as you won't be around forever.

You have your own life to live and the space to have your own relationship and children. You might want to remind them of that.

Isthisit22 · 19/07/2025 21:24

Going against the grain here, but I really don’t think you are helping the child in the long run. Surely his parents need to take more responsibility and daily care for him.
By agreeing to this you are facilitating their neglect of him.
If you said no then they wouldn’t be able to go and it might give them pause for thought?

andthat · 19/07/2025 21:23

BlankStreetMatcha · 17/07/2025 19:43

That sound ideal, I will ask him what he'd like to do.

@BlankStreetMatcha you could consider centre parcs. Really safe and loads to do for both of you. It sounds like they can afford it.