Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nanny Dilemma

286 replies

BlankStreetMatcha · 17/07/2025 18:20

I feel terrible for bring this problem to here, I have no children of my own so I would like some advice from other mothers.

So....

I am currently Nanny to a 12 year old boy, this is my sixth year working with this family, they are lovely people and I am really enjoy being part of their family and they've always treated me very well.

Now the Dilemma is Mum & Dad want to take a 12 day holiday alone and they've asked if I could take care of their son in the meanwhile. I have never minded helping them out in the past, a few days here and there, I don't feel as if they realise that I have a life of my own, and them dragging me away from it can be a huge inconvenience at times.

I find it very hard to say no, simple reason he is the most sweetest child you'd ever come across, and he has always been an absolute pleasure to take care of.

It seems like Mum & Dad do not want him or only want him with them when it's convenient for them i.e family events etc, they haven't attended parents evening for years, it's always been left down to me, which I don't mind, but I just can't comprehend why they don't feel the need to have any input in his school life or his life in general.

During the last couple of months there has been a few times when he has randomly expressed that he hates his Mum & Dad, I have never asked him why, because I don't feel as if it is my business or my right to question him further, and he is at that age children tend to start expressing themselves. I just tell him that they love him very much and then change the subject.

I feel as they believe showering him with the most expensive gifts, ludicrous clothing brands and the latest gadgets makes up for the time unspent with him and I just can't understand why they don't want to bring him along with them on their holiday.

I had made plans and now I feel as if it's my only option to cancel them, if I say no I am instantly going to feel guilty and they will probably try and palm him off with someone else, he should not be made to feel unwanted.

What would you do if you were in my situation?

OP posts:
BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 12:11

Blondeshavemorefun · 31/07/2025 12:07

Why leave it till they are back

im saying this over years of safe guarding courses and experience . Im over 50

you said you are 28 so maybe 10yrs of nannying experiences if from 18

I’ve been in childcare for over 30yrs - you need to inform the parents

if they don’t tell the school , again you need to mention to the school that he said he is depressed

it is your duty to safe guard him

it is not going behind their backs

the school will keep an extra eye on him

I have already stated my reasons more than once, I am currently safe-guarding him now whilst he is in my care.

I do not want to hear any more on this matter, I've already explained myself.

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 31/07/2025 12:07

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 07:51

I have already stated that I will tell them when they arrive back home, and I will not be notifying the school either, it's not my place to do so.

I am already safe-guarding him and I do not need to safe-guard myself.

I appreciate the advice, but it's strange how people here think they can dictate to me and I am just going to listen to them. He is in my care at the moment, he is safe with me. I would never take it upon myself and go behind his parents back, all trust will be lost and I am not willing to let that happen.

Why leave it till they are back

im saying this over years of safe guarding courses and experience . Im over 50

you said you are 28 so maybe 10yrs of nannying experiences if from 18

I’ve been in childcare for over 30yrs - you need to inform the parents

if they don’t tell the school , again you need to mention to the school that he said he is depressed

it is your duty to safe guard him

it is not going behind their backs

the school will keep an extra eye on him

Zonder · 31/07/2025 09:57

Ddakji · 31/07/2025 09:47

But it sounds like they do that anyway? You say you’re the one to take him to the doctor’s, hospital etc. Presumably that’s when they’re around to do so, they just don’t?

Face to face it will be easier for the OP to tell them it's something they need to deal with. Id she tells them now they can legitimately say we are not there so you take him. It doesn't sound like he needs an urgent appointment - he's not done anything drastic which would warrant immediate help, he has expressed something worrying that needs to be looked at soon but not urgently.

Ddakji · 31/07/2025 09:47

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 09:43

Thank you, finally someone that actually gets it!!

If I told them right away, they'd ask ME to take him to the GP.

But it sounds like they do that anyway? You say you’re the one to take him to the doctor’s, hospital etc. Presumably that’s when they’re around to do so, they just don’t?

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 09:44

Swiftie1878 · 31/07/2025 09:39

Apologies for misreading the ‘trust’ thing, but my point still stands. Your ‘job’ is to look after him whilst he is in your care; your ‘responsibility’ goes beyond that, as you know.
You need to alert his parents (even if they ignore you). That is your responsibility with regards to safeguarding him, and goes beyond the reach of your job.

Again.

I will alert them when they arrive back, not before.

OP posts:
BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 09:43

Zonder · 31/07/2025 09:42

I think you're being wise, @BlankStreetMatcha to speak to them when they're home and make sure one of them takes him to the GP, rather than them expecting you to do it. They need a wake up call.

Thank you, finally someone that actually gets it!!

If I told them right away, they'd ask ME to take him to the GP.

OP posts:
Zonder · 31/07/2025 09:42

I think you're being wise, @BlankStreetMatcha to speak to them when they're home and make sure one of them takes him to the GP, rather than them expecting you to do it. They need a wake up call.

Swiftie1878 · 31/07/2025 09:39

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 09:29

Yes it is up to date, I have never spoken about losing the child's trust and I would never ever make any promise of secrecy, I wouldn't even do that with my own child.

I do not want to lose his parents trust, that's why I would never ever go behind their backs. My job is to keep him safe whilst he is in my care, which I have always done, he told me that he is depressed I have been doing my utmost best to keep his mind busy to take his mind off things.

Apologies for misreading the ‘trust’ thing, but my point still stands. Your ‘job’ is to look after him whilst he is in your care; your ‘responsibility’ goes beyond that, as you know.
You need to alert his parents (even if they ignore you). That is your responsibility with regards to safeguarding him, and goes beyond the reach of your job.

Ddakji · 31/07/2025 09:30

I’ve read all your posts, @BlankStreetMatcha and I’m going be honest with you - it sounds like his parents have bought your collusion with how they treat him. You say you couldn’t have bought the things you have without their salary.

May I ask - are you this child’s legal guardian?

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 09:29

Swiftie1878 · 31/07/2025 09:23

Is your safeguarding training up to date?
You talk about losing the child’s trust; I hope you’ve made no promises of secrecy.
Your posts are a worry. I understand your position is a very tricky one, but you mustn’t succumb to a Messiah complex. You have very real responsibilities around this child, and can’t use your specific circumstances to avoid them.

Yes it is up to date, I have never spoken about losing the child's trust and I would never ever make any promise of secrecy, I wouldn't even do that with my own child.

I do not want to lose his parents trust, that's why I would never ever go behind their backs. My job is to keep him safe whilst he is in my care, which I have always done, he told me that he is depressed I have been doing my utmost best to keep his mind busy to take his mind off things.

OP posts:
Swiftie1878 · 31/07/2025 09:23

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 09:15

Yes, I have completed safe-guarding/child protection course, can you please explain why this is "quiet worrying" to you?

I am not being a friend to him, I am simply caring for him. I also do not believe that I am crossing any boundaries either, his parents are currently on holiday I am not going to text them and ask them to call me, to tell them that their son has recently told me that he is depressed. They aren't able to do anything whilst they aren't even in the country, and I do not want them to ask me to take him to the GP, this is something that they have to tackle, as I am not the problem.

Is your safeguarding training up to date?
You talk about losing the child’s trust; I hope you’ve made no promises of secrecy.
Your posts are a worry. I understand your position is a very tricky one, but you mustn’t succumb to a Messiah complex. You have very real responsibilities around this child, and can’t use your specific circumstances to avoid them.

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 09:15

Swiftie1878 · 31/07/2025 09:10

Have you been trained in safeguarding?
You unwillingness to ‘rock the boat’ is quite worrying to me. Don’t get me wrong, I think you are being a wonderful friend to this child, but I think you may be crossing boundaries here.

Yes, I have completed safe-guarding/child protection course, can you please explain why this is "quiet worrying" to you?

I am not being a friend to him, I am simply caring for him. I also do not believe that I am crossing any boundaries either, his parents are currently on holiday I am not going to text them and ask them to call me, to tell them that their son has recently told me that he is depressed. They aren't able to do anything whilst they aren't even in the country, and I do not want them to ask me to take him to the GP, this is something that they have to tackle, as I am not the problem.

OP posts:
Swiftie1878 · 31/07/2025 09:10

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 07:51

I have already stated that I will tell them when they arrive back home, and I will not be notifying the school either, it's not my place to do so.

I am already safe-guarding him and I do not need to safe-guard myself.

I appreciate the advice, but it's strange how people here think they can dictate to me and I am just going to listen to them. He is in my care at the moment, he is safe with me. I would never take it upon myself and go behind his parents back, all trust will be lost and I am not willing to let that happen.

Have you been trained in safeguarding?
You unwillingness to ‘rock the boat’ is quite worrying to me. Don’t get me wrong, I think you are being a wonderful friend to this child, but I think you may be crossing boundaries here.

BlankStreetMatcha · 31/07/2025 07:51

Blondeshavemorefun · 30/07/2025 22:56

I think you need to tell the parents @BlankStreetMatcha. As a professional nanny and safe guarding you need to inform the parents

and the school esp if parents don’t or won’t

yes maybe they won’t call you or be that bothered but you need to do things by the book and as much as protect /sage guard him as protect yourself

I have already stated that I will tell them when they arrive back home, and I will not be notifying the school either, it's not my place to do so.

I am already safe-guarding him and I do not need to safe-guard myself.

I appreciate the advice, but it's strange how people here think they can dictate to me and I am just going to listen to them. He is in my care at the moment, he is safe with me. I would never take it upon myself and go behind his parents back, all trust will be lost and I am not willing to let that happen.

OP posts:
user1492809438 · 30/07/2025 23:10

The term for the parents behaviour is affluent neglect. I think you are doing an amazing job, but that's what it is, your job. In no way should you be a substitute for these dreadful parents.

Blondeshavemorefun · 30/07/2025 22:56

I think you need to tell the parents @BlankStreetMatcha. As a professional nanny and safe guarding you need to inform the parents

and the school esp if parents don’t or won’t

yes maybe they won’t call you or be that bothered but you need to do things by the book and as much as protect /sage guard him as protect yourself

BlankStreetMatcha · 30/07/2025 19:29

Iwasneverafan · 30/07/2025 12:18

OP, you sound like such a lovely selfless person and this lad is soooo lucky to have you in his life. I’ve no doubt he will always remember that, whatever path he takes.

I dont have kids and am also an only child born to crap parents who didn’t want to be parents or do any parenting.
Something you said this lad said to you resonated with me:

“'perhaps I just got unlucky, but I will create my own luck”

He’s not daft. Like me, he will find his own way when he is able to and will do brilliantly.
I wasn’t parented, I brought myself up and I’ve done OK.
He has you and will do more than OK …. It’s amazing the opportunities a few more quid in your bank account can do to help you along the way and it doesn’t sound like this is an issue for him.

I wish I’d had a fairy godmother like you that had my back when I was 12. You are an angel.

I can’t offer any advice on what you should do about this lad’s welfare - that’s for you to decide professionally and morally; but at your age you really should be making time and a life for yourself too and this should also be a goal for you when his parents return.
🌸

Thank you so much, you've left me with tears in my eyes.

OP posts:
BlankStreetMatcha · 30/07/2025 19:04

Doseofreality · 30/07/2025 13:44

That is not your call to make. His is their child, not yours. They need to know.

Yes, I will tell them when they get back, not before.

I know what I am doing, I will allow them to enjoy their holiday and in the meantime we've been doing things to keep his mind off things, we had a nice day out today.

OP posts:
croydon15 · 30/07/2025 18:31

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 30/07/2025 11:45

I disagree, they are bothered enough to pay for quality childcare - they have employed a qualified live in Nanny, what more can they do.

Yes I suppose they could spend more and employ a Norland Nanny, indeed 2 Norland Nannies so one can cover for the other for time off / sickness.

They could send him to boarding school, and only have Nannies for school holidays.

What more can they do ? It's a child with feelings not a pet, you have a child you spend time with him, not just farm him to someone else. In this case he's lucky as OP sounds lovely and clearly loves him but it doesn't stop him from feeling rejected by his own parents. These parents don't deserve that child they are emotionally neglectful and will damage him, as previously said money doesn't replace love.
Even Kate and William spend as much time as they are able to with their children

Doseofreality · 30/07/2025 13:44

BlankStreetMatcha · 30/07/2025 10:53

I will tell them when they get back, I am not going to text them and ask them to call me, simple reason they will not be able to do anything about the situation until they get back anyway.

They probably won't even be that bothered, so I am not going to waste my time and energy.

That is not your call to make. His is their child, not yours. They need to know.

Iwasneverafan · 30/07/2025 12:18

OP, you sound like such a lovely selfless person and this lad is soooo lucky to have you in his life. I’ve no doubt he will always remember that, whatever path he takes.

I dont have kids and am also an only child born to crap parents who didn’t want to be parents or do any parenting.
Something you said this lad said to you resonated with me:

“'perhaps I just got unlucky, but I will create my own luck”

He’s not daft. Like me, he will find his own way when he is able to and will do brilliantly.
I wasn’t parented, I brought myself up and I’ve done OK.
He has you and will do more than OK …. It’s amazing the opportunities a few more quid in your bank account can do to help you along the way and it doesn’t sound like this is an issue for him.

I wish I’d had a fairy godmother like you that had my back when I was 12. You are an angel.

I can’t offer any advice on what you should do about this lad’s welfare - that’s for you to decide professionally and morally; but at your age you really should be making time and a life for yourself too and this should also be a goal for you when his parents return.
🌸

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 30/07/2025 11:45

I disagree, they are bothered enough to pay for quality childcare - they have employed a qualified live in Nanny, what more can they do.

Yes I suppose they could spend more and employ a Norland Nanny, indeed 2 Norland Nannies so one can cover for the other for time off / sickness.

They could send him to boarding school, and only have Nannies for school holidays.

BlankStreetMatcha · 30/07/2025 10:53

Doseofreality · 30/07/2025 08:45

No, text his parents now and ask them to call you.

He is not your child. As a professional you have safeguarding responsibilities and you must follow correct procedures. A child has confided in you that they are struggling with possible mental health issues, you have to tell the parents asap.

I will tell them when they get back, I am not going to text them and ask them to call me, simple reason they will not be able to do anything about the situation until they get back anyway.

They probably won't even be that bothered, so I am not going to waste my time and energy.

OP posts:
Doseofreality · 30/07/2025 08:45

BlankStreetMatcha · 28/07/2025 16:16

Yes I have consent, it's usually me who takes him to doctors/dentist appointments.

He is 12 years of age, his friend is sleeping over tonight so hopefully it will take his mind off things, I hate to see him suffering like this.

I will tell his parents when they get back.

No, text his parents now and ask them to call you.

He is not your child. As a professional you have safeguarding responsibilities and you must follow correct procedures. A child has confided in you that they are struggling with possible mental health issues, you have to tell the parents asap.

mikado1 · 29/07/2025 10:15

BlankStreetMatcha · 28/07/2025 20:59

Yes, I will be telling them. I am so upset for him 😞

As I said last week, he's not getting out of these circumstances unscathed despite your best efforts. The situation has to be pointed out to his parents. A good psychologist, play therapist or psychotherapist would do this as part of a therapy plan. I know people who've helped their children jn this way without the professional even meeting their child by the parents changing their behaviours (often v subtle ways that parents just not aware of as causing issues). But these parents would have to be willing to take it on board...