Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents choosing not to vaccinate their children

443 replies

MidnightPatrol · 13/07/2025 08:39

A child has died in Liverpool as part of an outbreak of measles. 17 are currently hospitalised with it in the city, as part of a wider outbreak.

73% of children in Liverpool are vaccinated against measles - vs an England average of 84%.

A rate of 95% immunisation is required for herd immunity. No child in the UK needs to be getting measles - we can vaccinate against it.

In Liverpool, there is a risk of a widespread measles outbreak due to this low rate of immunisation - it is very infectious, so the risk to the population is significant.

If you are a parent that doesn’t get your child vaccinated, why?

Should the government not be using further incentives to encourage people to take up vaccination - are a third of Liverpudlians really against vaccinating their children?

Should non-vaccinated children be limited from accessing nursery or schools (as in other countries)?

OP posts:
LoveSandbanks · 13/07/2025 12:20

BoredZelda · 13/07/2025 11:13

Your cohort of parents are the only ones I have sympathy for when it comes to vaccines. This was at the height of the Andrew Wakefield stuff. My sister was having to decide whether to give my nephew the MMR vaccine at the time and she was terrified. She has no science background and wouldn’t know where to find a double blind study if her life depended on it. She previously had no qualms about vaccination, my nephew had all of them up to that point, but she really struggled. The reports were so amplified, it became the only talking point for months then reduced to only a dull roar. It was the first time I had noticed news outlets going down the “balanced” route with interviews, for every properly qualified person saying it was fine, they had some kook saying it wasn’t. In the end I was able to convince her that even if it were true, a child with autism was preferable to a child who had died of measles. She did delay it, but he still got the vaccine.

I was really lucky, I had a good relationship with my gp and trusted him. I also had a close friend who was a gp. She explained that many immunisations are given early precisely because a child’s immune system is immature, reactions are more likely with a well developed immune system. Our immune system doesn’t recognise things it’s never encountered before so doesn’t react to it. It’s only by encountering things that it “learns” how to deal with it.

We actually have two boys with autism but a) they were born with it and b) thank god they’re not autistic and blind from measles!!

dh caught mumps about 18 years ago and I was so grateful that the boys were protected. None of the doctors in our local (major, teaching) hospital had seen it!

Corknut · 13/07/2025 12:16

Just to add my 2p on Covid vaccines. I had a severe reaction which resulted in semi permanent nerve damage in my arm. As a result I was scared to have my daughter vaccinated. She got Covid in 2023 so severely that she now has a severe milk intolerance that impacts her daily. This has been confirmed as being a direct link to her having Covid by her consultant who she now has to see. She is also on daily Omeprazole. There isn’t a day that goes by where I don’t think I’m directly responsible. Instead of eating ice cream on holiday today she had to have a piece of pizza cooked with no cheese that my husband had to ask for specially. Something to think about maybe.

titchy · 13/07/2025 12:12

Having several at once doesn’t overload the immune system at all. Kids come into contact with hundreds of thousands of pathogens a day at the same time - an extra half a dozen makes no difference at all. Immune systems cope perfectly well - that’s their exact purpose.

Kirbert2 · 13/07/2025 12:12

Motomum23 · 13/07/2025 12:08

Seems fairly obvious to me - if you want to prove vaccines are safe then a double blind trial of every vaccine needs to take place. Since there haven't been any there is no way to prove they are safe. They have been round for decades that's true - but so has SIDS which is more common post 8 week vaccines.

More information is required - why is a common childhood illness 50 years ago now designated a killer. Did the child in Liverpool die OF measles or WITH measles - there's a difference.

One of my children had a severe allergic reaction to the MMR and was advised against all other vaccines. Am I worried he will get measles? No because most adults are also no longer immune.

SIDS rates have massively reduced over the years. If SIDS was caused by vaccinations then surely the rate would be just as high as before the back to sleep campaign?

Motomum23 · 13/07/2025 12:08

Seems fairly obvious to me - if you want to prove vaccines are safe then a double blind trial of every vaccine needs to take place. Since there haven't been any there is no way to prove they are safe. They have been round for decades that's true - but so has SIDS which is more common post 8 week vaccines.

More information is required - why is a common childhood illness 50 years ago now designated a killer. Did the child in Liverpool die OF measles or WITH measles - there's a difference.

One of my children had a severe allergic reaction to the MMR and was advised against all other vaccines. Am I worried he will get measles? No because most adults are also no longer immune.

Jamesblonde2 · 13/07/2025 12:08

I agree, unvaccinated children should not be permitted to attend nursery or schools, unless certificated that they can’t.

Want to use society’s facilities? Well buy into society then.

Kirbert2 · 13/07/2025 12:08

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 12:02

I’m not suggesting that vaccines are linked to colon cancer. Rather, I’m pointing out that we’ve seen many environmental and societal changes in recent years that may be impacting public health in complex ways. Identifying the root causes of these health trends is challenging, especially since the pace of scientific research often struggles to keep up with the speed of technological advancement and environmental shifts.

How would vaccinating later help with that?

Lorrymum · 13/07/2025 12:08

I had measles as a child and almost lost my sight. It was over 50 years ago but I still remember how horribly ill I was and how worried my parents were.
Measles kills so many people world wide. A quick look at the World Health Organisation website shows some shocking statistics. Over 107,500 people died of measles in 2023, mostly under 5's. I had to read that number several times because of the enormity of it.
To not have your child vaccinated against an easily preventable disease is unforgivable.

Rallentanda · 13/07/2025 12:06

thomasinacat · 13/07/2025 12:06

The first vaccine was developed in 1796.

And is still being used!

thomasinacat · 13/07/2025 12:06

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:48

Vaccines are life-saving, however, we do not have enough data on the long effect of vaccines as it is still in its infancy.

The first vaccine was developed in 1796.

Rallentanda · 13/07/2025 12:05

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 12:02

I’m not suggesting that vaccines are linked to colon cancer. Rather, I’m pointing out that we’ve seen many environmental and societal changes in recent years that may be impacting public health in complex ways. Identifying the root causes of these health trends is challenging, especially since the pace of scientific research often struggles to keep up with the speed of technological advancement and environmental shifts.

This last comment just shows a lack of understanding about how science works. Science is driving technological advancement and at the forefront of understanding environmental shifts. We do not often lag behind unless there's serious underfunding, eg as is happening in TrumpUSA.

cardibach · 13/07/2025 12:05

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 12:02

I’m not suggesting that vaccines are linked to colon cancer. Rather, I’m pointing out that we’ve seen many environmental and societal changes in recent years that may be impacting public health in complex ways. Identifying the root causes of these health trends is challenging, especially since the pace of scientific research often struggles to keep up with the speed of technological advancement and environmental shifts.

What’s that got to do with vaccination though? You were saying children should be vaccinated later. What has this to do with that?

Needlenardlenoo · 13/07/2025 12:03

Parents face barriers to vaccinating children, says report - BBC News https://share.google/GmPpfE1EMSF5Ljp99

Parents choosing not to vaccinate their children
Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 12:02

cardibach · 13/07/2025 11:55

Vaccines have been around ages.
There are lots of reasons young people may be less healthy now and none are connected to the vaccination schedule.
Care to answer my earlier question about what mechanism you see leading to later vaccine issues?

I’m not suggesting that vaccines are linked to colon cancer. Rather, I’m pointing out that we’ve seen many environmental and societal changes in recent years that may be impacting public health in complex ways. Identifying the root causes of these health trends is challenging, especially since the pace of scientific research often struggles to keep up with the speed of technological advancement and environmental shifts.

Rallentanda · 13/07/2025 12:02

SheepInMyShed · 13/07/2025 11:59

Yes, for some that’s enough, for others it’s not.

Some need to know more, that’s how our local kwikfit was found to be taking advantage of women and patronising them, telling them they would t let them drive away without 4 new tires and a new brake system. It got called out because people started questioning it and kwikfit didn’t have a leg to stand on.

We defer to the scientists, but if questions are asked they should be answered, and very often they’re not, because too many are under the impression that scientists know best, let’s leave it at that. And in today’s world there are too many occasions of scientists getting it wrong and covering it up, and this leads to more people asking questions.
If they can’t answer, or they rely on people shutting down the questions, it’s in all our best interests to expect more communication, and in a way that more people can understand.

I can guarantee you that if you ask a vaccine expert how vaccines work, what are the benefits, what are the dangers, they know and they already happily share that information with us.

Rallentanda · 13/07/2025 12:00

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:53

In my view, vaccines have not been around long enough to know the implications. I am going to off on a slightly different tangent but there is some evidence that younger people are actually less healthier than previous generation and some diseases are increasing developing in younger adults. For example, Colon cancer. I read that this may be linked to microplastics in the environment.

Colon cancer is related to diet and physical condition. Vaccines are not causing us to be unhealthier, our diet and levels of exercise are. I don't know where you are reading this stuff, but maybe (and I mean this genuinely and kindly) find out a bit about the history of vaccination and how the various types work within the body? It's genuinely amazing and has saved millions upon millions of lives overall.

SheepInMyShed · 13/07/2025 11:59

Alltheyellowbirds · 13/07/2025 09:53

But isn’t the point here that we don’t need to be able to interpret the scientific documents - we have scientists and doctors to do that for us.

Just as I don’t need to know how my car engine works because we have mechanics for that. And I don’t need to learn all the law on the statute books because should I need to I can hire a lawyer.

We may be interested in knowing more about things, but unless we actually spend a decade studying a subject surely to some extent we should be deferring to the people who have?

Edited

Yes, for some that’s enough, for others it’s not.

Some need to know more, that’s how our local kwikfit was found to be taking advantage of women and patronising them, telling them they would t let them drive away without 4 new tires and a new brake system. It got called out because people started questioning it and kwikfit didn’t have a leg to stand on.

We defer to the scientists, but if questions are asked they should be answered, and very often they’re not, because too many are under the impression that scientists know best, let’s leave it at that. And in today’s world there are too many occasions of scientists getting it wrong and covering it up, and this leads to more people asking questions.
If they can’t answer, or they rely on people shutting down the questions, it’s in all our best interests to expect more communication, and in a way that more people can understand.

Blueuggboots · 13/07/2025 11:58

I have a friend who is a nurse who has chosen not to vaccinate her youngest child. It beggars belief!!

Kirbert2 · 13/07/2025 11:57

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:55

Many of the vaccines available today was not around when I was a baby, which don't have data over long term effects.

Which vaccinations are those?

cardibach · 13/07/2025 11:57

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:55

Many of the vaccines available today was not around when I was a baby, which don't have data over long term effects.

How would these long term effects manifest? What is the mechanism? Vaccines leave the system having primed a natural bodily response. And I’m 60. I had lots of vaccinations. At what point do you think my generation will develop these issues linked to vaccines?

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:55

cardibach · 13/07/2025 11:50

Vaccines in their infancy? What on earth do you mean?
Plus can you explain any mechanism by which a vaccine which clears the body quickly after priming a natural bodily process could have any long term effects?

Many of the vaccines available today was not around when I was a baby, which don't have data over long term effects.

cardibach · 13/07/2025 11:55

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:53

In my view, vaccines have not been around long enough to know the implications. I am going to off on a slightly different tangent but there is some evidence that younger people are actually less healthier than previous generation and some diseases are increasing developing in younger adults. For example, Colon cancer. I read that this may be linked to microplastics in the environment.

Vaccines have been around ages.
There are lots of reasons young people may be less healthy now and none are connected to the vaccination schedule.
Care to answer my earlier question about what mechanism you see leading to later vaccine issues?

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:53

cardibach · 13/07/2025 11:48

You don’t think research will have been done as to the optimal time to protect safely while not leaving a child vulnerable any longer than necessary?

In my view, vaccines have not been around long enough to know the implications. I am going to off on a slightly different tangent but there is some evidence that younger people are actually less healthier than previous generation and some diseases are increasing developing in younger adults. For example, Colon cancer. I read that this may be linked to microplastics in the environment.

Shitzngiggles · 13/07/2025 11:53

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:48

Vaccines are life-saving, however, we do not have enough data on the long effect of vaccines as it is still in its infancy.

Wtf???

Rallentanda · 13/07/2025 11:50

Lavenderflower · 13/07/2025 11:48

Vaccines are life-saving, however, we do not have enough data on the long effect of vaccines as it is still in its infancy.

That's just not true!