Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fighting with spouse over child spacing and our marriage

89 replies

Mamnuni · 12/07/2025 05:57

Please, I need objectivity and clarity.

Married 6 years, together for 10. I am mid 30's have a newly 2yr old daughter who isn't a chill baby. She is very hyperactive, requiring lots of hands-on interaction. Just to give an idea how full on she is, Nursery kicked her out as they could not cope with the demand on their strained resources 5 to 1 ratio. She is currently with a minder and is happy with one 2 one care as I work full time.

I had a difficult pregnancy, which has left me with some lasting disability with walking and gait. I have pain from this most days. I'm hoping it resolves at some point.

My husband travels for work and is around 10 days a month during term time and 8 to 9 weeks during summer months.

Since our daughter was born, my husband has been trying to convince or cagoule me into having the next child.I am open to another child and happy to start trying when our daughter is 3.

The issue here is that he does not like the time line I am proposing and thinks the spacing is too much. I honestly have nothing to give to another child now and with my bad leg, I worry that the next pregnancy will knock me out completely and it would be easier to manage a nearly 4 year old in his absence than a 2 or 3 year old. He has suggested moving to his work location so he could help more but I am reluctant to uproot my life here as there are no jobs for me where he is and we will loose 45 to 50% of our household income.

We have been fighting over this up to the point of being verbally abusive and not being nice to each other.

I have a low libido and frequency of intimacy has been a problem. The current situation has just made it worse and I am closing up even more. We havent been intimate in 6 months due to constant fighting over another child and horrible name calling on his end. We don't use protection condoms dont work for him. We use NFP.

OP posts:
Channellingsophistication · 12/07/2025 07:47

Your husband does not sound like a good one. He is bullying you into having another baby despite the fact that he knows you have been disabled by the first pregnancy, are working full-time and he is away on business a lot! So it will all be down to you to do. He is calling you names when you arent doing as he wants - that is not what a loving husband does.

The thing I think you need to be thinking about is whether you want to stay in this marriage?

Katemax82 · 12/07/2025 07:44

Daleksatemyshed · 12/07/2025 07:41

You need clarity Op so look at your DH, a man who loved his wife wouldn't bully her into having another DC.

my husbands friend who is a total cock did this

Katemax82 · 12/07/2025 07:43

Stop with the nfp too as I used it now have my 4 months old son

Daleksatemyshed · 12/07/2025 07:41

You need clarity Op so look at your DH, a man who loved his wife wouldn't bully her into having another DC.

MySaintedAunt · 12/07/2025 07:41

Jesus Christ.
Your husband is trying to bully you into another pregnancy which could disable you. He's seen what the first pregancy has done, but what he wants is more important than your health. Just no. Stop having sex with him. You are not a brood mare.
I had 2 high risk pregnancies and births, and difficult recoveries. I would run like the bloody wind from any man who tried to force me to risk that again.

Mauro711 · 12/07/2025 07:40

Wow, this is quite disturbing. He doesn’t view you as a human. To him you are just there to facilitate his wants. You have to give up work to come and live where he works. You have to forget about healing from your last physically damaging pregnancy and provide him with another baby when he thinks it’s time. You then have to look after a toddler and a baby whilst being in an even worse physical state because you weren’t allowed to get better and stronger until you had to pop the next one out.

He wants you poor, disabled and completely reliant on him. .

He is honestly completely vile and you need to get on some kind of contraception asap.

ExpertArchFormat · 12/07/2025 07:39

I'm afraid I am having some difficulty understanding this, because the very moment a man expects his preferences to be considered as more important than a woman's autonomy, he stops being someone who anyone reasonable would want to be married to or to conceive children with. There is no reasonable basis for this to be an "argument" - he is wrong.

If you yourself @Mamnuni get to the point where you feel you have the physical health and emotional energy to conceive another child, then that is when he gets a vote, if your marriage survives that long. It wouldn't if it were me in your position.

Thatsalineallright · 12/07/2025 07:38

What do you mean that condoms don't work? How can they not work? If he's bigger or smaller than average, they still sell ones that fit.

Honestly this all sounds like a horrible environment to be raising your first child in. I wouldn't plan for a second until there's been a significant, long-term improvement.

Marriage counselling might be a start. But if he's abusive (not entirely clear from your OP, but the name calling and bullying don't sound good), then couples counselling isn't recommended.

MrBallenIsaFittie · 12/07/2025 07:35

I would definitely be looking at more permanent types of contraception (coil,implant etc) and would probably be generously applying spermicide around the area just to make sure none of the little blighters make it!
I would also be taking my 2 year old for a check up with her GP, things usually have to be pretty out of control for a nursery to 'kick them out' (unless it is a particularly crap nursery?) Just remember that in 2 years or so she will be starting school and the care ratio is going to come as a shock to her if she can only function one to one.

BeachPossum · 12/07/2025 07:34

Needspaceforlego · 12/07/2025 06:40

Going against the grain.
Babies just don't always come to order. You are mid 30s, a third of women who start trying at 37 won't have a baby.

The bigger the age gap the harder it is to have them do things together. 4-5 years is quite a big gap.

4 years is fine. Mine are 4 years apart and it works brilliantly, it's the perfect age gap imo.

And anyway - OP is trying to heal from a serious birth injury, with an incredibly high-needs toddler and an abusive husband. Age gaps are the least of her worries.

Needlenardlenoo · 12/07/2025 07:32

Do see if you can get a referral from the doctor but also call round some physios and see if you can find a women's health physio.

This might be a place to start if it's spd related?

www.guysandstthomas.nhs.uk/our-services/pelvic-health-physiotherapy

Pelvic health physiotherapy - Overview

We assess and treat people with pelvic floor dysfunction and  people with musculoskeletal pain in pregnancy.

https://www.guysandstthomas.nhs.uk/our-services/pelvic-health-physiotherapy

whynotmereally · 12/07/2025 07:27

He’s pressuring you to have another child when you are not physically or mentally ready. He refuses to use protection (if hormonal contraceptives don’t work for you get a coil or diaphragm) He calls you names.

He doesn’t sound like a nice person, why would you want another child with him at any point?

IveGotAnUnusuallyLargePelvisISwear · 12/07/2025 07:26

As others have said, I wouldn’t want to have another child with him at all. You’ve stated you want to wait another year which really isn’t long at all and he’s verbally abusing you, refusing to use condoms and trying to get you to move to where he works because it would make his life easier. The absolute nerve of him.

Thuraya17 · 12/07/2025 07:23

Mamnuni · 12/07/2025 05:57

Please, I need objectivity and clarity.

Married 6 years, together for 10. I am mid 30's have a newly 2yr old daughter who isn't a chill baby. She is very hyperactive, requiring lots of hands-on interaction. Just to give an idea how full on she is, Nursery kicked her out as they could not cope with the demand on their strained resources 5 to 1 ratio. She is currently with a minder and is happy with one 2 one care as I work full time.

I had a difficult pregnancy, which has left me with some lasting disability with walking and gait. I have pain from this most days. I'm hoping it resolves at some point.

My husband travels for work and is around 10 days a month during term time and 8 to 9 weeks during summer months.

Since our daughter was born, my husband has been trying to convince or cagoule me into having the next child.I am open to another child and happy to start trying when our daughter is 3.

The issue here is that he does not like the time line I am proposing and thinks the spacing is too much. I honestly have nothing to give to another child now and with my bad leg, I worry that the next pregnancy will knock me out completely and it would be easier to manage a nearly 4 year old in his absence than a 2 or 3 year old. He has suggested moving to his work location so he could help more but I am reluctant to uproot my life here as there are no jobs for me where he is and we will loose 45 to 50% of our household income.

We have been fighting over this up to the point of being verbally abusive and not being nice to each other.

I have a low libido and frequency of intimacy has been a problem. The current situation has just made it worse and I am closing up even more. We havent been intimate in 6 months due to constant fighting over another child and horrible name calling on his end. We don't use protection condoms dont work for him. We use NFP.

Your husband sounds diabolical. Sorry, but I’m shocked.

I have a just turned 2 year old, my husband travels a lot for work, we are both on the same page that we could not have another child right now even though I actually adore being a mother, I want to give each of my children my all for at least 3 years. I still have some tailbone pain from giving birth, I haven’t stopped breastfeeding completely (he still has milk for naptime and bedtime) AND my husband consistently tells me that I’m the best mum and loves to take our son out and do bath time and storytime etc.

I’m telling you this so that you can set the standard in your home. I wouldn’t even have a second child with a man who called me names. What a bad example for your children too! Don’t be coerced into bringing a child into the world that you have nothing to offer right now. Explain to your husband that you don’t want to have kids for yourself, you want to have kids that you have time to raise thoughtfully and with your full presence. Just because it’s trendy to have 2 under 2, doesn’t mean we should all be doing it.

HeyThereDelila · 12/07/2025 07:22

Your husband sounds awful and controlling. You absolutely must not have another child now.

Why can’t he use condoms? Only a very immature man would say something like “they don’t work for me”. Pathetic.

Another pregnancy could you leave you disabled and your DD sounds very high needs - totally wrong time for her to have a sibling.

Do you work? I’d seriously be considering my future with a man like that. Do not on any account move or move away from your friends and family.

BeachPossum · 12/07/2025 07:21

OP your husband is verbally abusive and rarely home. Are you sure you definitely want another child with him?

I wouldn't rely on NFP with someone who was desperate for me to get pregnant.

babasaclover · 12/07/2025 07:20

Christ why doesn’t he just bind your feet so you really are tied to the house. What an arsehole

Isitreallysohard · 12/07/2025 07:19

Girlygal · 12/07/2025 06:03

Your husband is barely at home, you had a difficult pregnancy and a toddler so unruly she was kicked out of nursery. I think you should stick with one child. Your life will be even more difficult with two. Edited to add that there’s loads of different types of condoms so your husband is making excuses not to wear one. He wants to get you pregnant when you’re not ready to. The NFP method leads to a lot of pregnancies. Use condoms and the pill.

Edited

This 💯
Tell him you'll consider it once he changes his job and gets another one closer to home and steps up massively with your DC. Spoiler alert, he won't. Do not have another child with this man, you will break.

TourdeFrance25 · 12/07/2025 07:18

MollyButton · 12/07/2025 06:10

Go and see a doctor and get a referral for your physical issues. Do not let them fob you off!
Second see if the doctor can refer you to a Paediatrician for your daughter - her behaviour is far beyond “usual” if a nursery has “kicked her out” (or that nursery is rubbish, although 1:5 sounds low staffing for that age group).
Get on better birth control if you are ever going to sleep with your husband again.
And maybe start looking for a good divorce lawyer.

Do not have another baby!

This!!

LurkyMcLurkinson · 12/07/2025 07:15

I’m not at all surprised you don’t want to have sex with someone whose attempts at control and coercion using emotional abuse have occurred over a 2 year period, despite you being disabled and despite doing the majority of care for your child. That doesn’t sound like someone most people would want near them, let alone would want to have a baby with them. When you challenge him on his disgusting his behaviour is what does he say?

Didimum · 12/07/2025 07:13

Your husband doesn’t get a say when you carry a child or not. He is entitled to a discussion with you about it, but ultimately it’s your decision and you get final say. He can accept it or find another wife to be his childminder, cleaner and chef.

P.S I don’t think it’s normal that your daughter was ‘chucked out of nursery’ because they couldn’t meet her needs (unless there was something else unusual going on with the setting). There might be some additional needs at play there which should be considered for the future.

P.P.S Your husband sounds like a horrible man. Get contraception.

Cucy · 12/07/2025 07:11

You need to tell him that you are physically and mentally not ready for a child right now and when you are then you will discuss it.

But until then the discussion is off the table and if he continues to bring it up then you will have to consider a separation.

The fact that you’re arguing and name calling over this should be a massive red flag and you’re not in a healthy position to bring another child into it.

Tell him you are not ready and you need to both work on the relationship before you can even consider a second child.

WhatNoRaisins · 12/07/2025 07:07

I would really think long and hard about whether an additional child would be a good idea for your family. You have a disability, your DC could have one and your DH works away most of the time. Unless you have additional family help or can afford to pay for more help I wouldn't do it.

Survivingnotthriving24 · 12/07/2025 07:03

He sounds charming, can't think why you wouldn't be jumping to get pregnant.

My first pregnancy was awful, I needed an op to fix some side effects at 3 months postpartum, then our little one didn't sleep for years. My husband was adamant we wouldn't have another because he couldn't watch me go through it again. Other friends/family have had similar experiences with their husbands. Life had other plans and thankfully the second pregnancy was much smoother but he was very protective and took on a lot of the load during pregnancy.

Jumpthewaves · 12/07/2025 06:51

Needspaceforlego · 12/07/2025 06:40

Going against the grain.
Babies just don't always come to order. You are mid 30s, a third of women who start trying at 37 won't have a baby.

The bigger the age gap the harder it is to have them do things together. 4-5 years is quite a big gap.

I think slightly bigger age gaps are actually healthier for children, though all tend to work out fine in their own way. However, this man sounds borderline abusive, I'm not sure age gap should even come into it.