Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To shut my dog in the garden for the day?

442 replies

Dogingarden · 07/07/2025 10:49

Please read the full thing before you call me cruel.

I will be gone from about 8am until late on the night because I'm travelling for a medical procedure that I can't put off any longer. There is no way to make the time shorter due to where I live in relation to the hospital and I need the treatment asap.

I had a dog sitter booked but she had an accident and is currently on crutches and unable to drive. The others in my area are booked or just far too expensive. I have family but only my brother is able to drive and works 12hr shifts so he's only able to visit after 8pm. The house is rural detached with no close neighbours.

He can't go to kennels because I accidentally missed his vaccine boosters during the move and the local ones won't take him without them being up to date.

Dog is a large terrier. I have a large, safe garden with plenty of shady spots regardless of the time of day. I would leave multiple beds for him, including a dog house that was already in the garden when I moved in. There is also an automatic water bucket fitted to the house (previous owner) which he uses happily when we're in the garden. I will leave dry food out.

He absolutely will not toilet in the house, even with puppy pads, so he'd potentially be going 12+ hours without a wee which makes me very uncomfortable because he's had kidney issues in the past.

Please don't be awful - I'm terrified of what the biopsy will show and I'm doing my best.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Nothanks17 · 09/07/2025 10:20

I would be worried about a heatwave, no shady spot is going to help your dog if theres a heatwave x

I would be booking another sitter, its just one day. Or puppy pads for toileting and buy a food dispenser.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/07/2025 10:10

You really need to organise the dog’s vaccine boosters, especially as you live rurally.

Personally, I’d use the available dog sitter, regardless of cost. It’s all part and parcel of owning a dog. Could they visit once during the day then your brother come over after work?

poppy10101 · 09/07/2025 10:07

bridgetreilly · 09/07/2025 09:37

In 18 degrees in Scotland? Don’t be silly.

I didn’t realise it was Scotland, sorry. For most of the UK we have very high temperatures planned.

NewAgeNewMe · 09/07/2025 10:03

owlexpress · 09/07/2025 08:58

@BennyBee When I was a kid, everyone in our entire neighbourhood who had a dog (about half) would let them out onto the street in the morning and they didn't come back until tea time. Our lovely little mutt would paw at the back gate about 6pm and come in for dinner and a cuddle on the couch after. People are bonkers about dogs now and treat them as if they are children.

In fairness, you could say the same for how children used to be treated versus now. We've learned more about safety and risk and emotional care. Has it gone too far? Perhaps. But it is what it is, and harking back to the past is rarely the right thing to do.

Edited

Agreed. There was also less cars on the road. We and our dogs in the 70’s would be out all day. Doesn’t mean I’d do the same now with either my DCs or dogs! My DCs are in their 20’s but you get the gist.

bridgetreilly · 09/07/2025 09:37

poppy10101 · 08/07/2025 20:03

This would worry me, my dog would sunbathe (even with access to plenty of shade) and end up with heat stroke or worse.

In 18 degrees in Scotland? Don’t be silly.

bridgetreilly · 09/07/2025 09:36

WordsFailMeYetAgain · 08/07/2025 17:27

My dog would be frantic even after 1 hour alone. Maybe yours will be different but I think you need to look at the more expensive dog care. Is there a local Facebook group that can help or borrow my doggy?

This is not normal. Just because your dog has separation anxiety doesn’t mean OP’s does. Mine is very happy to snooze quietly on his own for three or four hours.

ClaredeBear · 09/07/2025 09:25

Options before leaving him in the garden are

  1. finding someone to help on Facebook.
  2. paying for the expensive dog sitter.

more for your own peace of mind.

owlexpress · 09/07/2025 08:58

@BennyBee When I was a kid, everyone in our entire neighbourhood who had a dog (about half) would let them out onto the street in the morning and they didn't come back until tea time. Our lovely little mutt would paw at the back gate about 6pm and come in for dinner and a cuddle on the couch after. People are bonkers about dogs now and treat them as if they are children.

In fairness, you could say the same for how children used to be treated versus now. We've learned more about safety and risk and emotional care. Has it gone too far? Perhaps. But it is what it is, and harking back to the past is rarely the right thing to do.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 08/07/2025 21:50

@WordsFailMeYetAgain
@poppy10101

OP has now found someone to dog sit for her.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 08/07/2025 21:47

Glad you found a solution OP. All the best for your tests.

poppy10101 · 08/07/2025 20:03

This would worry me, my dog would sunbathe (even with access to plenty of shade) and end up with heat stroke or worse.

BennyBee · 08/07/2025 19:56

Dogingarden · 08/07/2025 11:08

Try having a bit of fucking empathy.

You have no idea how fucking hard my life had been over the past couple of years. No idea at all.

I hope you have the life you deserve.

Well said, OP. Some people must just be trolling for outrage.

When I was a kid, everyone in our entire neighbourhood who had a dog (about half) would let them out onto the street in the morning and they didn't come back until tea time. Our lovely little mutt would paw at the back gate about 6pm and come in for dinner and a cuddle on the couch after. People are bonkers about dogs now and treat them as if they are children.

A dog on its own in the garden with food, water and shade is living the life of Reilly!

OP on the other hand has a serious medical emergency that some idiotic people can't seem to find any empathy for. Tsk.

WordsFailMeYetAgain · 08/07/2025 19:26

Cherrytree86 · 08/07/2025 18:56

@WordsFailMeYetAgain

how do you go to work? Have a night out? Do a supermarket shop even??

There is always someone home. If we need to go out for longer my PIL live over the road and will take her.

Cherrytree86 · 08/07/2025 18:56

WordsFailMeYetAgain · 08/07/2025 17:27

My dog would be frantic even after 1 hour alone. Maybe yours will be different but I think you need to look at the more expensive dog care. Is there a local Facebook group that can help or borrow my doggy?

@WordsFailMeYetAgain

how do you go to work? Have a night out? Do a supermarket shop even??

WordsFailMeYetAgain · 08/07/2025 17:27

My dog would be frantic even after 1 hour alone. Maybe yours will be different but I think you need to look at the more expensive dog care. Is there a local Facebook group that can help or borrow my doggy?

My10centsworth · 08/07/2025 15:18

it sounds like you have thought of everything and have your dog’s best interest at heart. However, for your own peace of mind, pay for the expensive dog walker. Chalk it up as another expense as a result of your procedure. Then relax on the day, knowing your dog is in good hands. And good luck.

Bringchocolate · 08/07/2025 13:40

Hope it goes well on Thursday OP, and that you get some good news. 🤞💐

BooneyBeautiful · 08/07/2025 13:05

reversegear · 08/07/2025 00:16

But then you’ve told everyone you are out?

OP can post anonymously in most local groups and just give a rough idea of the area. Then if she finds someone, she can just pm them with her address.

Gloriia · 08/07/2025 12:59

JustAnInchident · 08/07/2025 12:46

‘The dog will have food, water, shade, room for toileting, and a garden it enjoys spending time in.’
Well, quite. Honestly I’m so surprised so many people on here seem to think this plan is something akin to cruelty 😅 I see you’ve now got a solution by way of your sister in law but I couldn’t see much of an issue with a one off as your original plan, with no other options and given the reason why you were to be out.
best of luck with everything op.

Pets are creatures of habit. If the op stuck the dog outside every day from 8am tip 8pm yes it would also be cruel but it'd what the dog was used to.

When they are used to at least some human interaction they become distressed when things change. They become distressed and confused.

Yes good that the <allergic to dogs> sil is stepping in.

JustAnInchident · 08/07/2025 12:46

‘The dog will have food, water, shade, room for toileting, and a garden it enjoys spending time in.’
Well, quite. Honestly I’m so surprised so many people on here seem to think this plan is something akin to cruelty 😅 I see you’ve now got a solution by way of your sister in law but I couldn’t see much of an issue with a one off as your original plan, with no other options and given the reason why you were to be out.
best of luck with everything op.

Cherrytree86 · 08/07/2025 12:41

Ignore those saying pay the expensive sitter. In real life I bet there’s no way they would fork out £250. Also there are some really privileged people on here too with more money than sense!

Cherrytree86 · 08/07/2025 12:40

CarmellaSopranosKitchen · 08/07/2025 11:41

It is incredibly hot. You need to fork out for a dog sitter. In the scale of looking after a dog this needs factoring in. Or ask in the local area if someone can look after him for the day.

@CarmellaSopranosKitchen

the dog has shade it’ll be fine

Behaveyourself88 · 08/07/2025 12:39

Phone the Cinnamon Trust, they have people all over the country that will help people with their pets in circumstances like above.
personally I’d never leave my dog outside under any circumstance, the weather is about to change to another heatwave etc. you’re dog needs to be left inside and if possible get someone to pop in. I’ve also got a little camera in my lounge so that I can keep an eye on my dog for my own peace of mind.

OnlyHerefortheBiscuits · 08/07/2025 12:37

OP you have my sympathies and I'm sorry your plan fell through with the original sitter. Glad to hear family have come to the rescue but totally understandable you were conflicted about what to do.

I also live alone with a dog and absolutely rely on the local daycare being in business and my mum in order to go to work and other things where dogs aren't permitted.

I am even considering using another local walker in addition to daycare for no reason. just to keep another option warm if you know what I mean, so that in a pinch I have a third option.

In your shoes I still would have had reservations about getting a random stranger from an internet site to look after your dog alone. I just think the worst - this is how sick animal abusers would gain access to animals unsupervised. I wouldn't do it with a child (if I had one) and I reeealllllyyy wouldn't want do it with my dog. It is really tough when you lead a solitary life sometimes and I sympathise.

Best wishes for Thursday 💐

magicstar1 · 08/07/2025 12:32

OP, he sounds like he enjoys his garden normally, so don't be worrying. It's one day of him hanging out in his favourite place, with snacks and water. I'd love a day like that lol. He'll snooze, and as it's summer, it'll still be bright when you get back.

He'll be totally fine, and if he does feel it's a bit long, then he'll be even happier to see you when you get home, and you'll get loads of slobbery kisses.
Look after yourself, and don't stress about him.