Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think I have no liability here? (diagram attached)

532 replies

WiggyClawsThe2nd · 30/06/2025 12:46

I think I'm fairly sure on this but can't stop panicking so I thought I'd ask on here.
Friday night I had a car accident. It was a real shock and it's only now that I've stopped to think about it that I'm feeling really really cross.
In the diagram I'm the blue line, the other driver is the green line. The thick lines show where we went, the thin lines indicate where you would have expected us to be going. Given that the lady tried to tell me she'd been going straight on when obviously she didn't makes me wonder if she had a mad moment!
Anyway, this particular roundabout leads onto a bridge over a dual carriageway. On the other side of this bridge you can go left onto a local road, or right to join the dual carriageway.
When we joined the roundabout, the other car was to my left. Neither of us indicated before joining the roundabout, however I did indicate left after I passed the 1st left exit as I was planning to go over the bridge and turn right to join the duel carriageway. As I was about to leave the roundabout the lady turned in front of me to head back round the roundabout and I hit her in the side of the car. Slow speed, maybe 15 mph.
It turns out that we have the same insurance company just to complicate matters.
I'm pretty sure that she is liable for this accident, what do you all think?

YABU: you are liable
YANBU: you are not liable

AIBU to think I have no liability here? (diagram attached)
OP posts:
Thread gallery
38
Sauvin · 30/06/2025 14:19

Strawber · 30/06/2025 13:11

Actually your both in the wrong so 50/50.

1st lane is for 1st exit and 12oclock straight ahead exit. For anything after 12oclock it’s right hand.

But here aren’t any exits after 12 o’clock on this roundabout so I would say you can use the right hand land for the last exit, which is at 12 o’clock

CaptainRossPoldark · 30/06/2025 14:18

Glad you're ok.
Having dealt with many insurers and accident claims over the years, all roundabout collisions are classed as 50/50 with insurers regardless of apparent blame, even with video evidence.
Last one was earlier this year in similar circumstances to yours. Our vehicle was written off and 50/50 blame. All on dash cam.

Farageisacupidstunt · 30/06/2025 14:18

The exact same thing happened to me and the insurance company settled 50/50.

anyolddinosaur · 30/06/2025 14:17

Your insurer will say 50/50 - because there is precedent and it's very difficult to get any roundabout accident anything other than that. She was an idiot and caused the accident but you are supposed to check your exit is clear.

Sorry I dont remember the names of the court case but it was similar to this in that the driver did something stupid and still got 50/50.

imagiantwitch · 30/06/2025 14:17

I had this exact scenario, and I’m sorry to say op, but it went in the other person’s favour! I still feel rage about it

maddening · 30/06/2025 14:17

MageQueen · 30/06/2025 13:01

Honestly, I think you were both wrong. Unless it's a three lane roundabout? YOu should have been in the left hand lane to turn left by then, and she should have been in the right hand lane. She is MORE wrong, but if i was your insurance company I would consider this joint liability.

Not on the roundabouts near us on dual carriageways - the left is turn left and straight on (if straight on you exit to the left hand lane of the dual carriageway) and the right hand lane is straight on or right (and if you go straight on you exit to the right hand lane of the dual carriageway).

In this scenario the green car cut the blue car up effectively changing lanes.

WiggyClawsThe2nd · 30/06/2025 14:16

Have always wanted to post diagrams 😀

OP posts:
Shekoni · 30/06/2025 14:15

Fratolish · 30/06/2025 14:11

I don't understand? The op did have to cross the left hand lane to exit? How would she have got from the right lane to the exit without crossing the left lane? Op herself doesn't seem to be arguing that the other driver drove into the right lane, rather that she suddenly decided to keep going round in the left lane.

Because there are two lanes on the exit! And two lanes on the roundabout. She is in the right hand lane on the roundabout going to the right hand lane on the exit. The other car is in the left hand lane on the roundabout going on to the left hand lane of the exit (in theory). The only way for someone in the left hand lane to go around the rounabout in this particular instance would be if they come out of the left hand lane and drive across the right hand lane.

WiggyClawsThe2nd · 30/06/2025 14:14

The other side of the road from the bridge onto the roundabout is only 1 lane so only 1 stream of traffic entering.

OP posts:
howaboutchocolate · 30/06/2025 14:14

Fratolish · 30/06/2025 14:11

I don't understand? The op did have to cross the left hand lane to exit? How would she have got from the right lane to the exit without crossing the left lane? Op herself doesn't seem to be arguing that the other driver drove into the right lane, rather that she suddenly decided to keep going round in the left lane.

it's a two lane exit, the left hand lane can only exit, it doesn't carry on.

Walker1178 · 30/06/2025 14:14

Unfortunately OP I think you will be seen to be at fault. The other driver was absolutely in the wrong lane but if you are switching lanes or exiting a round about the onus is on you to make sure it’s clear.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 30/06/2025 14:14

Shekoni · 30/06/2025 14:09

Yes exactly - all the talk of the OP crossing the left hand lane to exit the roundabout - when in fact she would have been staying in the same lane and the other car crossed out of the left hand lane and drove across the right hand lane into the OPs path.

But that's not what the google earth picture the OP posted shows. It shows 2 lanes on the roundabout, delineated by white lines and that the OP moved from one lane on the roundabout (the inner one) across the other to exit. I agree that the other driver was in the wrong lane, but there is no doubt that the OP moved across lanes, and presumably without checking, and so 50:50 is the most likely outcome IMO.

gottabereallyhonest · 30/06/2025 14:13

Jonesboot · 30/06/2025 14:10

When there are no signs or arrows on the lanes follow the guidance in the Highway Code. In which case you were both in the wrong place.

Here is that highway code guidance you speak of. It says "appropriate lane". Eith two lanes on entry, on roundabout, and on exit, it is appropriate to use the right lane if safe to do so.

AIBU to think I have no liability here? (diagram attached)
Shekoni · 30/06/2025 14:13

Jonesboot · 30/06/2025 14:10

When there are no signs or arrows on the lanes follow the guidance in the Highway Code. In which case you were both in the wrong place.

As someone has helpfully shared the link to the relevant text in the highway code above, the guidance for lanes are to 'take the appropriate lane' if you're going anywhere other than left or right, so in this instance, the appropriate lane would definitely be the right hand one, given there is no right hand turn, and the exit had two lanes.

WiggyClawsThe2nd · 30/06/2025 14:12

Waiting for image to be reviewed!
Turns out the lane she was in and I was crossing ends after that junction and is crosshatched out.

OP posts:
Fratolish · 30/06/2025 14:11

Shekoni · 30/06/2025 14:09

Yes exactly - all the talk of the OP crossing the left hand lane to exit the roundabout - when in fact she would have been staying in the same lane and the other car crossed out of the left hand lane and drove across the right hand lane into the OPs path.

I don't understand? The op did have to cross the left hand lane to exit? How would she have got from the right lane to the exit without crossing the left lane? Op herself doesn't seem to be arguing that the other driver drove into the right lane, rather that she suddenly decided to keep going round in the left lane.

WiggyClawsThe2nd · 30/06/2025 14:10

If she'd had continued round the roundabout in the left hand lane then I could understand it. But it looks as if she actually turned too late to even do that! See new diagram........

AIBU to think I have no liability here? (diagram attached)
OP posts:
Jonesboot · 30/06/2025 14:10

WiggyClawsThe2nd · 30/06/2025 13:01

No signs telling you which lane to be in, although going right would mean you are going right round the roundabout and there's no way you'd be in the left lane for that!

When there are no signs or arrows on the lanes follow the guidance in the Highway Code. In which case you were both in the wrong place.

Shekoni · 30/06/2025 14:09

howaboutchocolate · 30/06/2025 14:03

If the OPs roundabout is like this one, then if you're in the left lane at the point of exit then you're not really on a roundabout any more and the woman essentially turned right in front of an oncoming car. I don't see how it's the OPs fault at all.

Edited

Yes exactly - all the talk of the OP crossing the left hand lane to exit the roundabout - when in fact she would have been staying in the same lane and the other car crossed out of the left hand lane and drove across the right hand lane into the OPs path.

BumpyWinds · 30/06/2025 14:06

IMO she was completely at fault before I'd even realised that the third junction on the first roundabout wasn't even an exit she could have taken!

If she thought she was in the right to be in that lane, where the hell was your lane supposed to go?!

oviraptor21 · 30/06/2025 14:05

It sounds like you had the opportunity to stop, if you had checked your left and/or rear view mirror. Were you doing this as you exited and did you brake as soon as possible?
To be honest, when I have a car on my inside on a roundabout I'm like a hawk with the mirrors and drive relatively slowly as many drivers are unpredictable.

howaboutchocolate · 30/06/2025 14:03

OnTheBoardwalk · 30/06/2025 13:39

I was going to suggest to see what google maps says? Can you get a clearer picture than the one above and are there any markings?? There are a load of roundabouts not far from me like this. She was completely in the wrong

here's a picture for those incorrectly saying you should have moved over to the left hand lane to take your exit

If the OPs roundabout is like this one, then if you're in the left lane at the point of exit then you're not really on a roundabout any more and the woman essentially turned right in front of an oncoming car. I don't see how it's the OPs fault at all.

tumblingdowntherabbithole · 30/06/2025 14:02

I see why others are saying you have some liability but I wonder if there is a case to be made for the other driver causing the accident through careless driving?

They were both as careless as each other.

KrisAkabusi · 30/06/2025 14:00

HurryUpHilda · 30/06/2025 13:58

The front wheels comment was directed at the OP. If the Green car is still on her front left as she prepares to exit straight-on into lane 2, it is always good to check that the Green car has gone, or is going, where you think it is going to go.

That's what I'm saying. The OP drove in to the side of the other car. She is at least partly at fault.

Poshjock · 30/06/2025 14:00

It is most likely to be 50/50 and the Case Law that supports this is the Grace and Tanner ruling which all Insurance Companies will use.

Ultimately the other driver will have to accept liability for driving in the wrong lane (going past the 12 on a standard roundabout unless road markings indicate otherwise which doesn't sound like the case here) and the OP will also accept liability for not being aware of a car positioned incorrectly (Rule 187) and exiting the roundabout into the path of that vehicle.

If the other driver accepts liability fully, due to her mistake then it would be unlikely her insurance will fight it and accept all liability, however, if she takes that general advice in the case of collisions "never accept liability" then it will likely be settled 50/50.

Here is a video from an experienced insurance liability claim handler to explain. www.instagram.com/itsbigjobber/reel/DFISIVFI2XU/

Swipe left for the next trending thread