Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a pouch of baby food

141 replies

weaningtime · 30/06/2025 09:58

Just that really. Shamelessly need validation. I am absolutely sweltering in this heatwave with a Velcro baby who only wants to contact nap. DD is nearly 8 months and I’ve watched the panorama on shop bought baby food so not fed her any shop bought jars or meal pouches. I try and be conscious with her food, she has a healthy homemade porridge for breakfast every day with nut butters, seeds and fresh fruit and then usually a BLW style tea or a recipe we’ve followed from a baby cookbook. She usually really enjoys her food. We are getting takeaway, so can’t share that. Last night I cooked a vegetable and cheese pasta for her and she had two mouthfuls and wasn’t bothered, probably the heat I’m guessing. I’m putting so much pressure on myself and have run out of ideas for tonight and food shop doesn’t come till tomorrow.

Would it be that bad nutritionally to just buy and give her a pouch tonight? I have seen people compare it to junk food and fast food so feel like I’m not doing good enough and not prioritising her if I default to that. Is it ok or any other food ideas that are very minimal prep?

OP posts:
AlternativeView · 30/06/2025 13:29

@weaningtime what did paranormal say? Obviously we know home cooked it better what did it say

CosyLemur · 30/06/2025 13:26

Please stop trying to be a perfect parent, it will be detrimental to your health.
And for what it's worth my eldest 2 always had whatever me and their dad was eating I've puréed a whole Sunday lunch, lasagne, moussaka the works - they have loads of health issues and are both ASD, ADHD, ODD plus most of the rest of the alphabet. My youngest because I was doing a lot of health care for her brother's mainly ate jars or pouches. He's the healthiest of all no health issues at all and is part of a nationalally competing sports team.
So I'm sure a couple of pouches won't hurt

Teamustbefromateapot · 30/06/2025 13:25

Baby will be absolutely fine with the odd pouch! An alternative however that I've found handy with my 8 month old is to buy soup. Obviously not as good as homemade soup but there are still some pretty clean ones out there! Handy to give when big siblings are having sausages and chips 🤣

TheCurious0range · 30/06/2025 13:21

In this heat I'd give cold finger foods, cheese, pitta, cucumber, hummus, apple slices, peanut butter, Greek yogurt etc no effort. DS is 7 this year and I never gave him a pouch or jar and I'm not the lentil weaving kind!

Soubriquet · 30/06/2025 13:19

Just give her the pouch. Both my dc were practically raised on the pouches with finger foods offered too.

They thrived

MummyJ36 · 30/06/2025 13:19

DC1 used to pretty much survive solely off fruit pitches between the ages of 1-2. They also barely ate a single scrap of fruit “proper” food until they were nearly 4. I used to tear my hair out and get so upset, but looking at them now….I wish I’d been a thousand times easier on myself. Pouches are not the food of the devil. Go a lot easier on yourself and do what works for you. Your baby will be fine.

hannahbanana93 · 30/06/2025 13:17

TheignT · 30/06/2025 13:07

Tinned beans? Shop bought bread? Don't see why that's any better or worse.

It's definitely better than a pouch IMO. It's actual chewable food for a start...but then I only said beans on toast as something the OP might already have in her cupboards so wouldn't need to go out and buy something.

Doitrightnow · 30/06/2025 13:16

She'll be fine.

Although if you are looking for minimal effort dinners, I used to do toast / pitta bread fingers with tuna and houmous and whatever raw veg was available to slice.

ThatMiddleClassFood · 30/06/2025 13:14

It will be absolutely fine. I did the odd pouch when I weaned mine on days when I just couldn't be bothered, I'd spread it on some toast or rice cakes so they could feed themselves still. But you could also save yourself a trip to the shop if you've got some bits in the house to do a picky tea, toast with cheese spread on or nut butter, fruit and veggies and some rice cakes and maybe a bit of yoghurt if you have one would be fine too.

DiscoBob · 30/06/2025 13:14

I thought you were going to say '..to a dog..to a homeless person..'
Of course it's ok to give it to an actual baby! That's what it's for? Convenient food for infants. Unless you're Jennifer Aniston who apparently uses it as a diet aid?!

Greeneyegirl · 30/06/2025 13:12

Dear lord, we did a kitchen extension and had no kitchen when DD was 7m - 1y. She exclusively had pouches and ready meals. It's fine. If you're really struggling with doing it , buy the Annabel karmel ones

MrsRandy · 30/06/2025 13:11

I also think you’re overthinking this way too much as baby is 7 months old. A pouch is fine but I wouldn’t go out of your way to purchase one if you don’t need to pop out.

At 7 months, milk is their main nutrition. A bit of yogurt and banana will do.

Krakinou · 30/06/2025 13:10

sleepandcoffee · 30/06/2025 12:02

Give it a year and she will be picking bird poo off a slide and eating it , a pouch occasionally truly is fine !

Mine is obsessed with dried cat food. I think it’s the salt combined with a power move over the cat.

OP, not to diss pouches but mine has always outright refused the veg ones. If I cba I just do her a bowl full of frozen peas and she’s delighted. Don’t get too stressed with the BLW three course meal, homemade fennel hummus or whatever.

CherryAlmondLattice · 30/06/2025 13:09

purplehair1 · 30/06/2025 13:08

Sorry - 20 years since I had my kids and please tell me - what on earth is BLW and what is PFB???

Baby lead weaning was definitely around back then 😂

CherryAlmondLattice · 30/06/2025 13:08

I wouldn’t trouble yourself with going out and buying a pouch anyway. In this weather, she is unlikely to eat very much. A banana or some yoghurt will probably do the trick - keeping them hydrated is most important.

purplehair1 · 30/06/2025 13:08

Sorry - 20 years since I had my kids and please tell me - what on earth is BLW and what is PFB???

BexAubs20 · 30/06/2025 13:07

thats what they are for. Convenience. Different matter if that’s all you were giving them. I wouldn’t feel a single bit of guilt.

TheignT · 30/06/2025 13:07

hannahbanana93 · 30/06/2025 12:47

I'd give one if I had one in the cupboard, but to go out and specifically buy one? No I wouldn't personally. Just give her some porridge for her tea, or beans on toast.

Edited

Tinned beans? Shop bought bread? Don't see why that's any better or worse.

BlueandPinkSwan · 30/06/2025 13:07

OP don't beat yourself up, do what you need to do for your baby. As for what family, friends and randoms advise, Take the advice YOU feel comfortable with. There is so much random shite online about the whole process of baby feeding etc.
Heck knows how the human reace has survived as long as it has before the media, shite influencers and apps telling you how to breathe. 🙄
MIne were all raised on a variety of home made, packets and jars as babies and horror of horrors formula.
No allergies, not that many illnesses between them. All healthy adults, no weight issues.
Must have done something right with them.

Bigtom · 30/06/2025 13:07

I would just give her some of the takeaway. My DD had a small amount of whatever we were having, including takeaway (although it’s rare for us to have them anyway).

Jaybail · 30/06/2025 13:05

Definitely putting too much pressure on an already high pressure job. You said you can't share your meal as you're having takeaway tonight so just to put it in context: OMG, takeaway?? Have you seen the salt/sugar/additives in takeaway, how can you eat like that????
Yes takeaway every night would be disastrous, but once in a while is fine. As for pouches, of course home made is going to be better (provided you check that you are giving the right nutrients) just as breast is better for babies but that doesn't mean you are failing if you use formula or pouches/jars. When it comes to kids, fed is best. You clearly are making every effort to give your little one the best start in life, well done to you, but don't forget the most important part of the job - to enjoy the time because all too soon DD will be toddling off eating mud and worms in the garden as soon as you take your eyes off her 😂

SpottedOnMN · 30/06/2025 13:04

I was ill postnatally so couldn’t breastfeed and weaned mine exclusively on jars until they were eating exactly the same as us. They’re both very healthy indeed and very intelligent. Don’t fret.

MrsRandy · 30/06/2025 13:04

Edenmum2 · 30/06/2025 12:46

The advice isn’t to never give them. It’s to not use them as regular daily meal replacements

This ^ is my advice too.

A pouch for convenience a couple times a week isn’t a huge deal. 3 x pouches a day - most likely not ideal?

ricketybeauty · 30/06/2025 13:04

@weaningtime she'll not come to any harm with it, but if she's used to BLW foods and she's into her food then she might well not eat it. My second sounds much like yours and when I tried to give her a ready meal baby thing she refused.

I'd go with PP and give her some toast and a banana or whatever you have in. She's only little still, no need to stress about it.

TheignT · 30/06/2025 13:04

weaningtime · 30/06/2025 10:03

Thank you, I think I posted on the wrong place, I’m genuinely just feeling a bit like I’m not doing enough if I do that because of how frenzied everyone is about baby food and UPFs at the moment. I realise this is probably silly and that I’ll look back and think how PFB of me

Sometimes people don't actually do what they say they do. Look at the array of pouches in the average supermarket, do you think they would be "wasting" that space if no one bought the products? No they wouldn't. Loads of babies being fed baby pouches and other products and they seem to be fine. You sound like you are doing really well but cut yourself a bit of slack, it will be fine and like you said in this heat the baby probably won't eat it anyway. Mum's milk is much better for a hot baby.

Swipe left for the next trending thread