Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Relatives living with us - no jobs

239 replies

BunnyVV · 29/06/2025 18:28

we have some relatives from overseas staying with us. I agreed to help them with somewhere to stay and sustenance until they got jobs etc.
i have welcomed them into my home and treated them as family. Things are not easy for us due to the cost of living but I am very good at budgeting. We eat well thanks to good prep for home-cooking. I work hard and earn moderately well but the mortgage etc is big. I enjoy some nice things, eg a glass of posh gin on a Saturday, gym membership etc because I prefer not to spend elsewhere (beauty treatments, takeaways).
the problem is that they are not trying hard enough to get work, or they turn down what they don’t fancy (eg have to get 2 buses to get there).

it’s been 10 weeks. They do not have anything full-time. They agreed they’d take bar work whilst looking for something better, but that’s not happening. I’m tired of sharing nice things 10 weeks on. I need to find the courage to tell them that the smoked salmon is only for me, the gin is only for me, please don’t eat the whole bar of green & blacks chocolate because I like a square at night sometimes. It’s not right I go to the cupboard and theres none there. I need to tell them not to touch the nibbles and beer I keep in a cupboard for unexpected visitors. but I feel like a horrible person in doing so.
they have no income. But my income cannot sustain this any more. I don’t want to stop buying things that I like to have in my own kitchen. I work hard and I get to chose what’s in my fridge and cupboards. why do they eat smoked salmon instead of ham? When the smoked salmon runs out, then they eat the ham.
they seem completely oblivious to the problem. I didn’t set any ground rules because I didn’t imagine it would get to this point. I assumed they’d be gone 40 hours a week working.
how do I sit there and enjoy a posh gnt on a sunny evening whilst they sit there and watch me whilst drinking water?!??? I end up not enjoying the gnt.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ademasstudio · 31/07/2025 09:35

So…. They’re still there, with you during the summer holidays when kids are off and no plan for ever moving out.

BMW6 · 15/07/2025 07:41

Thanks for the update, good luck to you!

Delphiniumandlupins · 15/07/2025 03:01

Your update explains why they were being such unreasonable house guests and you seem to have improved things somewhat. Do you think they will be able to move out soon? You are very kind to have offered help to various family members, even if this experience has not been good.

Such deeply entrenched codependency is difficult to change, Andy happy to do nothing and Jane content to be so needed. If she doesn't want to change things you can't force her, even though from outside you can see it's unhealthy and stifling for both of them.

Mmhmmn · 15/07/2025 00:57

Oh dear. That was kind of you to offer up your house. Get a mini fridge in your bedroom that they won’t have access to. And keep asking them about jobs and flats. Tell them you’ve got other folk you want to have over to stay. The time for politeness is ending. 10 weeks. Jesus. My head would explode.

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 15/07/2025 00:49

That’s awfully complicated. Great news that Jane’s got a job. Much as it would be wonderful to somehow get Andy to be more productive, it’s very unlikely to work without Jane’s agreement. Ultimately you can’t help someone who won’t help themselves. I hope they at least are able to move out sooner. Even if Jane is able to cover what should be their shared contribution to household costs, it must be incredibly frustrating having someone living with you who simply refuses to take responsibility for themselves. It might be worth your while to keep pushing him to pull his weight. Not with any expectation that he will change, but in the hope that it might motivate them to move out (I hope that’s not too advicey). I’d be absolutely furious with him in your position. I hope they leave soon so that you don’t have to deal with this anymore. You’ve done a really kind thing helping them as you have.

BeenThereBackThen · 14/07/2025 19:22

That is a very complicated situation, best case scenario would be Andy emerging from his prolonged cocoon phase as a fully fledged independent adult and flying away with Jane to live their lives.

Hope it all works out in the end, especially for you @BunnyVV , you’ve been more understanding and patient than many of us would have been in such situation.

Kwean · 14/07/2025 19:18

I hope Jane's contraception is fool-proof as assuming late 20's she might well be getting broody and eyeing up your boxroom as a cute little nursery......

Helen483 · 14/07/2025 19:06

Thanks for the update @BunnyVV , I found it very interesting.

No advice here, I just wish you luck in continuing to deal with this difficult family situation with the kindness and grace you have demonstrated so far.

BunnyVV · 14/07/2025 18:33

I requested no more advice… yet people keep on giving it. I will request once more before I ask MN to delete the thread.

OP posts:
godmum56 · 14/07/2025 16:51

ByQuaintAzureWasp · 14/07/2025 14:44

Are you sure they are entitled to work in the UK if they are from overseas?

RTFT. They are not in the UK

GoldDuster · 14/07/2025 16:12

You're not helping Jane by buying into this bullshit. Sorry. While everyone dances around and makes allowances for Andy, she will too. You can have empathy with her situation, AND not want it under your roof. Both things can be true.

GAJLY · 14/07/2025 15:19

I think you're going to have to be more tough on him. He's not cleaning or doing chores because he doesn't want to. My dad had learning difficulties but still cleans, cooks and everything else. Be firm, tell him he has to do it. Even if he forgets, tell him again he's to do it before dinner. He's been silly coddled and now is living rent free like a child

Itisnotdownonanymap · 14/07/2025 15:15

I have had experience of a similar co-dependent relationship in my own family, though in this case it was mother and daughter. The daughter, in her 40s, didn't make any decisions at all, I would ring her and her mother would ring me back. Very difficult to deal with.

ByQuaintAzureWasp · 14/07/2025 14:44

Are you sure they are entitled to work in the UK if they are from overseas?

Chintzcardboard · 14/07/2025 12:32

Some live-in caretaking couple type job could get them out of your home. Housekeeper & gardener type role.

Looks like you are husband are the new enablers … unless you can get them out of your house.

p.s. does Andy have an intellectual disability, or MH issue? I really can’t understand that a “typical” human can be so lifeless and incapable. I have worked in SEN, and also with “at risk” and there is a difference between “can’t” and “can learn” to be independent.

godmum56 · 14/07/2025 12:32

OP, is this your situation to fix? Is this something you can fix? In my professional life (20 years retired now) I used to see similar situations where the wife had done all the domestic stuff and the husband was the wage earner. Husband retires, wife become disabled or chronically sick and husband can't even cope with going shopping or opening a can of soup. The adult children never realised the situation because the home was always clean and organised and the marriage was a happy one. Thankfully it got much rarer. In my experience, the only thing that worked was tough(ish) love from the adult children but there had to be the will to do it. I know you don't want suggestions but the only thing which might work would be to present the change as a cultural thing "How we do things here is that everybody works, everybody contributes, so if you want to stay here you have to change" and set some small steps and deadlines for achievement. it will be hard work for you and Jane will have to massively to buy in to make it work. Of course Assuming that Andy isn't SEN, he may just be a world class manipulator. If he does have developmental problems and he is in your country legally, what options are there for support and benefits?

Kwean · 14/07/2025 11:36

Its kind of you to update @BunnyVV - but I cant help but sense that you are also gaslit into this absolute 'learned helplessness' nonsense and inadvertently enabling it - is that the control dynamics of your extended family?

I really havent read so much 'avoidant' twaddle in my life - if you want to help Jane and Andy you need to kick arse and pull the rug - but it seems you are more comfortable allowing your inner peace, your DCs and DH be practically and financially exploited whilst you tap-dance around the coercively controlling Andy - his behavior is illegal in the UK - dont know how the DA laws sit where you are in the EU.

whackamole666 · 14/07/2025 11:28

@BunnyVV thank you for the update. It does sound like a very disturbing and compex situation.
Wishing you all the best achieving an outcome that suits everyone.

BunnyVV · 14/07/2025 11:12

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 14/07/2025 10:23

@BunnyVV it is disgraceful to think that your or your husbands relatives lied to you both over the years about andy, who seems to be the relative. were there no grandparents around watching what was going on? andy is going to need a lot of help. is he even educationally up to supporting his own existence?

The grandparents died a while ago. There are other older children in this family who were looked after by the grandparents at times. The history of Andy’s parents being useless is a long one! Being looked after by the grandparents was not such a bad thing as these older siblings do have a better sense of responsibility and a good work ethic (even if that work is minimum wage, they work hard and improve their hourly rate the old-fashioned way by proving themselves to be reliable, honest etc).

OP posts:
allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 14/07/2025 10:23

@BunnyVV it is disgraceful to think that your or your husbands relatives lied to you both over the years about andy, who seems to be the relative. were there no grandparents around watching what was going on? andy is going to need a lot of help. is he even educationally up to supporting his own existence?

BunnyVV · 14/07/2025 09:57

We had the conversation. What has transpired is the existence of a deeply complex co-dependent relationship. This trauma runs quite deep.

They are a couple who, on the outside, appeared to have their sh*t together back in their home country. One half of the couple is a close relative so chucking them out is not an option, and please don’t tell me that it is. I don’t want to be too outing so I can’t really explain this in detail. I am not looking for any further advice, I am just giving an update as somebody asked for one.

person 1, let’s call her Jane, does everything for person 2, let’s call him Andy. They’ve been together since they were very very young. Jane does not realise she shouldn’t be doing everything for Andy. She thinks it’s love. Andy failed his exams at school, Jane deliberately failed her’s etc. so she stayed down an academic year and could help Andy in class.

They moved in together at 16 and looked after Andy’s younger sister too as Andy’s parents are useless. Jane took on a lot of responsibility at a young age. She was doing everything for both Andy and his younger sister but the outside world thought they were doing it together. Andy’s parents knew Jane was doing everything and they pushed the narrative of “that’s what you do when you love someone”. This was convenient for Andy’s parents as they now had no responsibility for any of their children. They divorced and continued being useless with new partners. Andy’s parents have never taken responsibility for anything so suggesting they do is pointless.

Andy is a nice guy but hasn’t got a clue about life. We gave him some jobs to be responsible for… he did them once, he then forgot and now Jane does them. Trying to explain to Jane that it’s not her responsibility is like talking a different language. The co-dependency runs very deep and both are genuinely offended, confused and upset when we try to explain what a normal relationship looks like. They think it’s none of our business if Jane chooses to do everything. In one sense I see that but on the other hand I cannot be present in my house watching this level of laziness and uselessness from Andy. He knows no different and doesn’t really listen to anyone except Jane who doesn’t want Andy to change.

Andy is so conditioned by Jane doing everything that it doesn’t matter how we try to explain, neither of them are seeing the co-dependency as a bad thing.

if they ever split up Andy would be lost. I don’t think they will as Jane is so infatuated. Jane has some family issues that mean her co-dependency is this need to do everything for Andy.

we didn’t realise any of this. Andy’s parents are also manipulative enough that over the years they have said things to us that made it seem like Andy and Jane as a couple are a team. That’s the narrative Andy’s parents needed the outside world to see in order to cover up for the fact that they (Andy’s parents) are so selfish and useless, and Jane was essentially doing their job.

We thought they were quite sociable people, and they’d both make friends here in new jobs etc. They are sociable but only ever go out together. We didn’t pick this up when we were visiting their home country on holiday.

the job applications were going slowly as they were applying together, and if they did apply separately it was Jane from Andy’s email address. When Andy got a call about work he didn’t come across as very clued-up.

jane had to accept a job because we put pressure on them to contribute to the household. She was called by more then one place and ended up working a few double shifts to almost 15 hours in total some days. Jane is switched-on and a good worker. She will have no trouble holding down a job in a cafe until she finds something better. However Andy just sits at home waiting for Jane to finish her very long shifts. He even forgot to do the tasks we gave him.

it is a very very sad situation to see. They are a couple who have an opportunity to come to a European country, work hard, save some money, travel and broaden their horizons yet they are held back by a co-dependency so deep that they don’t even understand what is wrong. Andy’s parents, to suit their own selfish needs, drummed it into Jane that what she was doing was love. 14 years later I am not sure me and my husband are going to show her otherwise. On a practical level we are not sure if Andy even has the skills to do stuff by himself, and whilst Jane wants to continue the co-dependent relationship, he will never be forced to do so.

we have pushed them to contribute a set amount each week for bills and food, and set ground rules about snacks and alcohol that they are following. However it’s Jane taking care of all of this.

the problem is now something quite different and not something I think will be easy to resolve without some difficult conversations.

I’m not looking for any more advice, thank you. I just wanted to give an update.

OP posts:
fruitbrewhaha · 14/07/2025 09:50

Oh good lord! Are they still there? Please for the love of smoked salmon tell them they cannot stay any longer.

BeenThereBackThen · 13/07/2025 22:23

Did you actually manage to have tbe conversation with the relatives? If not, why not?

Mushybut · 07/07/2025 06:33

Another weekend with the rellies OP?

Kwean · 06/07/2025 14:38

Beachtastic · 01/07/2025 20:15

This is true. But if OP is like me, she deeply resents being forced into confrontation by people who are fundamentally arseholes 😜

Everyone feels like this. Its how resentment builds. But it's ALWAYS on the 'giver' to specifiy the boundary as 'takers' have none.....tedious but the truth.

Deep breath. Get it done calmly and assertively - then the resentment turns to relief. Much more comfortable way to live.

Swipe left for the next trending thread