Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help me feel ok about this will

387 replies

TerryWogansWig · 28/06/2025 18:08

Ok, I know “every will is contentious”, but I’m feeling dejected about this one.

DHs aunt, last remaining relative of that generation. No children of her own, Had over £1m in bank accounts etc. We were expecting a 4 way split between DH, his sister, their late mother ( recently deceased also), and a family friend who’d done a lot for her.

Will opened: £50k to each of the 4 expected beneficiaries, a few other very small specific amounts ( church etc), and the balance ( over 800k) split between 4 named charities .

That’s lovely for those charities, but I feel this is just not right. Why not specify an amount to the charities, with the rest split between family? But hey, that’s what she specified so we have to accept it.

Help me get past this.

OP posts:
Beachtastic · 28/06/2025 21:52

BIossomtoes · 28/06/2025 21:49

I'd go no contact. She can have amazing time getting prescheduled emails from these charities for her birthdays.

She’s dead 😂

She'll probably still get the emails!

WhereHasMyPlanetGone · 28/06/2025 21:52

LondonFox · 28/06/2025 21:47

Oh ffs MN are bat shit crazy abour wills.

Obviously if person got living relatives you will make their life as comfortable as you can unless you have beyond damaged relationship with all.

I'd go no contact. She can have amazing time getting prescheduled emails from these charities for her birthdays.
Daft cow.

I knew the general standard of reading comprehension on this site was poor but fucking hell, this takes the biscuit

BIossomtoes · 28/06/2025 21:49

I'd go no contact. She can have amazing time getting prescheduled emails from these charities for her birthdays.

She’s dead 😂

WhereHasMyPlanetGone · 28/06/2025 21:48

LondonFox · 28/06/2025 21:47

Oh ffs MN are bat shit crazy abour wills.

Obviously if person got living relatives you will make their life as comfortable as you can unless you have beyond damaged relationship with all.

I'd go no contact. She can have amazing time getting prescheduled emails from these charities for her birthdays.
Daft cow.

She’s dead.

WhyCantISayFork · 28/06/2025 21:48

She was thinking of the greater good. You should try it!

Gonners · 28/06/2025 21:48

I worked in probate for many years and have seen enough of this sort of absolute nonsense that nothing shocks or even mildly surprises me. Just let it go, OP. And if it's your husband who's enraged by the "unfairness" if it, give him a slap round the chops from me. Not his money, not his business to decide how his aunt should have disposed of it. The same, by the way, goes for parents!

LondonFox · 28/06/2025 21:47

TerryWogansWig · 28/06/2025 20:44

Again, appreciative of the viewpoints expressed here.

To be clear, I’M not inheriting, DH is. So I’ve no real skin in the game, other than any opinions on joint income.

Oh ffs MN are bat shit crazy abour wills.

Obviously if person got living relatives you will make their life as comfortable as you can unless you have beyond damaged relationship with all.

I'd go no contact. She can have amazing time getting prescheduled emails from these charities for her birthdays.
Daft cow.

EverythingElseIsTaken · 28/06/2025 21:46

I think 50k is a pretty good inheritance! I’ve lost every relative apart from my younger brother and never inherited a penny.

noctilucentcloud · 28/06/2025 21:44

BlazenWeights · 28/06/2025 21:31

You’d probably get agro from people but if you’re here complaining then off course your husband is probably upset and rightly so. This is my opinion on it. Everyone is entitled to spend their money how they want however anyone who gives money away to charities when they have blood family ( who they have great relationships with and not just cultures you’ve never seen that turn up when you are dead) is not a nice person. Charity begins at home! Can’t be given £800k to charities when you have close family members that need it. But when you’re dead you’re dead, nothing changes except my opinion of Aunty Bessie.

I disagree. There's lots of different reasons someone might leave money to charity. As long as you've made provision for dependents - and by that I mean under 18s, maybe young adult children at university, an adult disabled child who cannot live independently - then it is not selfish to give money to charities that mean something to you. There's a big difference between need and want.

Q13 · 28/06/2025 21:44

This actually has to be a piss take.. no one could be so ungrateful surely..

SENNeeds2 · 28/06/2025 21:42

when I read these will posts their are people who express distress that the will does not reflect the nature of their relationship ie they loved their mother dearly but the will was geared towards a less wealthy sibling so they feel hurt - or ones like your's where there is zero mention of a relationship with the deceased other than a blood tie and its all about the money they expected because of that.

FlowerUser · 28/06/2025 21:41

Often people leave a specific amount to beneficiaries and the rest to charity because they don't know how much the estate will be worth.

So leaving everyone £50k 10-15 years ago may have been thought of as a reasonable sum, assuming only £50k left for a charity. The problem comes when any property rapidly appreciates and the remainder vastly outweighs the sums left to beneficiaries.

lifeonmars100 · 28/06/2025 21:36

One of fhe posts I saw on here about inheritance will always linger with me. A poster was bemoaning the fact that people tend to live for longer these days and this meant that they would have to wait until they were well into middle age to inherit! Greed and entitlement writ large

WhereHasMyPlanetGone · 28/06/2025 21:35

Can’t be given £800k to charities when you have close family members that need it

We don’t know that the OP’s partner needs it. Maybe he just wants it.

Greenalien1 · 28/06/2025 21:35

50k would literally change my life so I can't get my head around your reaction I'm sorry... I honestly think it's a lovely thing to do for a charity and a really nice way to leave your mark when you go. To be honest even if my own mum did that I wouldn't be that devastated because she's done more for me throughout my life than I could ever repay her for both financially and emotionally so yeah to be your being v v v v v unreasonable. I'm sure you have your reasons though...

BlazenWeights · 28/06/2025 21:31

You’d probably get agro from people but if you’re here complaining then off course your husband is probably upset and rightly so. This is my opinion on it. Everyone is entitled to spend their money how they want however anyone who gives money away to charities when they have blood family ( who they have great relationships with and not just cultures you’ve never seen that turn up when you are dead) is not a nice person. Charity begins at home! Can’t be given £800k to charities when you have close family members that need it. But when you’re dead you’re dead, nothing changes except my opinion of Aunty Bessie.

ScottBakula · 28/06/2025 21:31

Highsmithery · 28/06/2025 18:33

I don’t think it’s unreasonable to be a bit gutted. The OP was under the impression they’d be inheriting a large amount. It’s disingenuous of posters on here to say otherwise.

But it’s still nice to get 50k.

So you think 50k isn't a large sum of money???

@TerryWogansWig ,tbf if I was your DH and you were complaining about receiving 50k I'd make sure that about 75% was put in trust for your DCS / young nephew/ nieces aa you obviously don't think it's worth having.

housemaus · 28/06/2025 21:30

I think you're confusing the feeling of being massively disappointed with the feeling of injustice. That's not me being snarky, it's just what I think is going on here. Intentionally or not, you've assumed a huge, life-changing sum of money was likely to be coming your way - who wouldn't hope for that? Who doesn't mentally think of all the good that could come of it in their own lives?

And then once you find out you're getting a (still life-changing, for lots of people, and very generous) smaller sum, you feel like you've 'lost' 250k (or 375k, I guess, if DH's mum has died). That has got to feel disappointing and bit surprising.

But you haven't lost anything - you've gained 50k, and your assumptions have made it feel like a loss. So THAT feels unfair - because you feel like you've had something taken from you. I get it, but you need to just....give your head a bit of a wobble. It wasn't ever money that was yours, and when it comes to wills there is no 'fair'. You still got a lovely windfall and many, many, many people will never inherit a penny: lucky you.

SockFluffInTheBath · 28/06/2025 21:27

I think a lot of people, whether they’d admit it or not, feel entitled to deceased relatives’ money. It doesn’t sound nice when you say it like that, but it’s almost a socially acceptable form of greed.

Bigcat25 · 28/06/2025 21:25

I assume they actually got 75K, as the mom already died so if they got her share and was split between the 2 kids.

ilovemydogandmrobama2 · 28/06/2025 21:17

sammylady37 · 28/06/2025 20:40

I have no children and am single, and will remain that way. I’m also a very high earner and am mortgage-free on a house worth over €500k.
I have lots of ‘niblings’ and I know some of my siblings fully expect my estate to be divided among them - one of my sisters has actually said to me that she thinks I should already be giving them 3k annually that would be tax free! In the course of a conversation about a small local charity that’s very close to my heart, I mentioned I’d left them a large donation in my will… my sister looked across at her son with arched eyebrows and a knowing look, as much as to say ‘she’s leaving it to charity, not you!!’

The sense of entitlement people have about inheritance is repulsive to me. I will be very wary of the avaricious crew who start circling around me when I’m older.

something that is close to your heart means that it has value to you, not that you need anyone's permission who you leave your money to; that you have stated this to those, 'expecting,' what is your intentions are leaves no room for disappointment or expectation.

But if one has been told that they will inherit, or if has been inferred, feel it's understandable to be disappointed.

My great aunt cared for her parents for 20 years, and although there wasn't a direct inheritance, after a compulsory purchase of the land, my grandfather, as executor felt it was morally right to give her the proceeds.

She had a blast with the £1.5m.

WhereHasMyPlanetGone · 28/06/2025 21:16

TerryWogansWig · 28/06/2025 21:11

Not backpedaling. It just feels at first sight unjust to me, so I thought I’d get some views from a forum I respect for honesty and no bullshit!

my own thoughts are the ones I feel need adjusting, so again thanks for reality checking.

Unjust in what way? Don’t you think she was of sound mind when she made her decision?

Didimum · 28/06/2025 21:16

It’s ok to feel disappointed, OP. We are expectant of ‘something’ from my husband grandmother one day, which would be very welcome as we are getting increasingly worried about the mortgage after some real bad luck in recent years. We will get over it of course, but I can understand the initial feeling.

WhereHasMyPlanetGone · 28/06/2025 21:15

TammyJones · 28/06/2025 21:13

Agree
people need ti read up on this.
akso , having seen my nieces and nephews grow up and love them very much , then would want to make thier lives better in any way I could …..

It’s irrelevant how the charities spend their money though. The aunt decided where she wanted her money to go, and she no doubt had her reasons for that. No one is entitled to anyone else’s cash.

TammyJones · 28/06/2025 21:15

TerryWogansWig · 28/06/2025 21:11

Not backpedaling. It just feels at first sight unjust to me, so I thought I’d get some views from a forum I respect for honesty and no bullshit!

my own thoughts are the ones I feel need adjusting, so again thanks for reality checking.

Op you do NOT have ti adjust your views
I’m shocked at some of these replies.
Not sure if it’s jealousy or ‘money is the root all evil’
A lot of good can be done with money.