Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help me feel ok about this will

387 replies

TerryWogansWig · 28/06/2025 18:08

Ok, I know “every will is contentious”, but I’m feeling dejected about this one.

DHs aunt, last remaining relative of that generation. No children of her own, Had over £1m in bank accounts etc. We were expecting a 4 way split between DH, his sister, their late mother ( recently deceased also), and a family friend who’d done a lot for her.

Will opened: £50k to each of the 4 expected beneficiaries, a few other very small specific amounts ( church etc), and the balance ( over 800k) split between 4 named charities .

That’s lovely for those charities, but I feel this is just not right. Why not specify an amount to the charities, with the rest split between family? But hey, that’s what she specified so we have to accept it.

Help me get past this.

OP posts:
ClaudiaNaughton · 29/06/2025 06:52

A distant relative did this. Left the amount up to inheritance tax level to nephews/nieces and the rest tax free to charities.

Richiewoo · 29/06/2025 03:29

Gold Digger.

Caligirl80 · 29/06/2025 02:57

sammylady37 · 29/06/2025 00:40

The “family are everything/blood family” crew make me laugh. It’s reminiscent of Eastenders. I have far closer relationships with friends than I do with some of my family… I have nieces and nephews who I haven’t seen for years, don’t know what country they’re living in, don’t have a phone number for them, nor they me… why on earth would I leave them my hard-earned money instead of leaving it to close friends and/or a local charity that’s dear to me?

Totally agree with you. I have one nephew I absolutely adore and he and his mum make big time efforts to spend time with me. I also supported his mum when he was born as she was having big time health issues at the time. He is a darling little lad who is kind, considerate, funny, and delightful and we are very close.

Not so with my other sister's children - they are an obnoxious family all round and I wouldn't choose to spend time with them. Sadly my sister's husband has had a very bad influence on all of them - it's unfortunate but she's an adult and has made her choices.

The notion of being "forced" to give my money to family members just because I'm related to them is abhorrent. I'd far rather give my money to the Donkey Sanctuary than a load of money-grubbing oafs who view me as a cheque-book. The OP in this post sounds rather like my sister's grotty husband: just views the Auntie as a chequebook and feels entitled to have a cut of the cash. Yuck.

Caligirl80 · 29/06/2025 02:46

It's not even your aunt!!! If anyone gets to feel perhaps a little perplexed it's your husband. But even then...

It's everyone's right to leave their money two whoever they want. If she wanted to leave her money to charity then so be it. Good for her.

Get over it - if you want some money then earn it yourself.

HouseofDreams · 29/06/2025 02:35

sounds like you spent the money in your head before she was even dead.

so grabby OP. Be thankful for your £50k.

Hoardasauruskaren · 29/06/2025 02:13

As 1 of 4 in a working class family I will be extremely grateful to inherit 1/4 of my parents home assuming they don’t end up spending it on care costs! Never occurred to me that my (childless) aunt/ uncles would leave me a penny!

LondonFox · 29/06/2025 01:51

WhereHasMyPlanetGone · 28/06/2025 22:09

You were the one who assigned a value to having someone visit their grave by saying ‘I wouldn’t visit her grave’. I couldn’t give a shit, I’ll be dead.

I did not assign any value, it is a fact that people do care about their legacy and "who remembers them" factor.
Somwone who pledged xy amount to a charities probably more than others ;)
They do have peoole employed to talk you into it. It's not a secret lol

Cattenberg · 29/06/2025 01:30

Years ago, my then-partner was asked by his elderly uncle to be one of the executors to his will. It was only then that my partner found out his uncle had more than £15,000,000. The uncle had been more fortunate in life than his younger brother (my partner's dad). For example, both brothers had passed the 11+ exam, but their family could only afford to send the eldest to grammar school. The eldest went on to university and ended up with a great career, whereas his brother ended up working in a factory.

When the uncle died, I was convinced that a significant amount of money was coming my partner's way, (although my partner said he wasn't bothered if he got anything). It was just as well my partner wasn't bothered, because he wasn't left a penny. I think the uncle's teenage grand-daughter got the lot.

sammylady37 · 29/06/2025 00:40

The “family are everything/blood family” crew make me laugh. It’s reminiscent of Eastenders. I have far closer relationships with friends than I do with some of my family… I have nieces and nephews who I haven’t seen for years, don’t know what country they’re living in, don’t have a phone number for them, nor they me… why on earth would I leave them my hard-earned money instead of leaving it to close friends and/or a local charity that’s dear to me?

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 29/06/2025 00:32

My great aunt did this. I was the only one who looked after her and made sure her bills were paid (by me) etc whilst she just banked her pension and owned her own home outright. She left everything to a donkey sanctuary she had never even visited! She didn’t even like donkeys-she liked cats! I was a pissed off-least of all because I couldn’t get back the money I had spent on her never mind anything else.

MsAmerica · 29/06/2025 00:25

TerryWogansWig · 28/06/2025 18:08

Ok, I know “every will is contentious”, but I’m feeling dejected about this one.

DHs aunt, last remaining relative of that generation. No children of her own, Had over £1m in bank accounts etc. We were expecting a 4 way split between DH, his sister, their late mother ( recently deceased also), and a family friend who’d done a lot for her.

Will opened: £50k to each of the 4 expected beneficiaries, a few other very small specific amounts ( church etc), and the balance ( over 800k) split between 4 named charities .

That’s lovely for those charities, but I feel this is just not right. Why not specify an amount to the charities, with the rest split between family? But hey, that’s what she specified so we have to accept it.

Help me get past this.

I have to wonder how much you reached out to her over the decades, if you visited her, took her to dinner, sent her birthday presents, often telephoned just to say hello.
I have only one close-ish relative, and I think she's likely to expect me to leave everything to her. But why would I bother, to someone who never calls, never sends thank-yous for gifts? I'm thinking any money would be better left to charities.

Starzinsky · 29/06/2025 00:24

Her money to do what she wants, not yours. So sad you think otherwise.

ScribblingPixie · 28/06/2025 23:56

You'd need a heart of stone not to have a laugh at this one. 😂

k1233 · 28/06/2025 23:52

I'm planning on doing something similar to be honest. I'll leave everything to my mum but if she's passed, then my niece and nephew will get a similar amount to you. My home will be donated to a domestic violence charity as emergency accommodation for women and children leaving abusive relationships and I'll probably leave them funds to cover costs for maybe a decade

BlazenWeights · 28/06/2025 23:49

noctilucentcloud · 28/06/2025 21:44

I disagree. There's lots of different reasons someone might leave money to charity. As long as you've made provision for dependents - and by that I mean under 18s, maybe young adult children at university, an adult disabled child who cannot live independently - then it is not selfish to give money to charities that mean something to you. There's a big difference between need and want.

I mean there are good charities out there that actually help good causes and then there’s the ones that just divert funds and fund their CEOs or execs life. Actively praying on old folks good will. What do you want to bet she’s not left this money to one like that but regardless family comes first… to me anyway. And close family too. Also what’s wrong with leaving money to adults? They don’t deserve it because they are older than 18?

Onedancewontdo · 28/06/2025 23:45

Just wanted to post a different perspective. 25 years ago when we moved into our present home we were told our immediate neighbour was a recluse who hated all her neighbours (told to us by the queen b neighbour) my husband as it was summer was working in the garden and noticed one night her lights were still on. He kept checking and at 2 pm went through her back gate and looked In her window and she was on the floor. Long story short we spent the next 10 years shopping cooking attending hosp appointments with her as we thought she had no family. Imagine our disgust when she died 7 nieces and nephews suddenly appeared. Months later we were invited to her will reading which shocked us as we thought she had no money and she left us £2k and the remaining £800k to her family and they threaten to challenge the will. Some greedy people out there.

HonestOpalHelper · 28/06/2025 23:21

I got a gift of £2000 from an uncle I was close to, I never expected or wanted anything and was touched he remembered me in his will (written when I was much younger) - most of his several million went to a wonderful hospice where he passed - I still support them myself every year.

OP it was her money to do what she wanted with, consider all the good works it will pay for.

mumda · 28/06/2025 23:19

We're they charities that meant a lot to her?

bluesinthenight · 28/06/2025 23:13

hahahahahahahahahahaah!

Auntie knew what she was doing.

IAmTooOldFor · 28/06/2025 23:08

My Great Aunt left 100% of her £1M+ estate to charity 30 years ago, minus a couple of hundred pounds for my dad to “cover his expenses” for being sole executor. He made a loss as her estate was a fair distance away and needed multiple visits to settle it!

10 years age my DGM (dads mum) left her £1M+ estate to her solicitors children rather than her 3 sons/8 grandchildren and left instructions that she be buried in a “paupers grave with no headstone” just to prove how unloved she was 🙄. We buried her properly (because, fuck her getting her own way on that!) but left the money where she sent it. That side of the family had a bitter narcissist streak wider than the English Channel and both women knew damn well what they were doing.

Let it go OP and be at peace ✌️ 😄

BartonInthebeans · 28/06/2025 23:08

A relative left me a slightly smaller amount than the amount you've been left, and in the same will left £300k to charity. I have always been blown away by their generosity and delighted that they were able to leave so much to causes that were important to them (and will have made a difference to a great number of people), it was a fantastic achievement on their part and I hope it brought them joy when they realised they were going to be able to leave such a sum.
In the 15 years since the will was executed it's never struck me that their will should have been different! I have tried to use my inheritance in a way that honours them, and in turn that's brought me both security and happiness.

HonoraBridge · 28/06/2025 23:04

If your DH’s attitude is anything like yours, his aunt made a very good decision.

stclementine · 28/06/2025 23:03

PeggyMitchellsCameo · 28/06/2025 19:02

Why do people of you think if you spend ‘more’ time with a relative you should get ‘more’ money? WTAF?
Sadly, I think when people have an idea of what may be in a will, and what they may get, it’s already in their subconscious and possibly plan for its arrival.
Perhaps the aunt her had seen her young relatives do well, and decided to also help people less fortunate? Perhaps the charities had personal meaning to her?
Maybe she had updated her will to include the charities?
Whatever the outcome, for most of us 50k is life-changing. Be grateful and most importantly…
Was she a decent lady? If she was, toast her life and be grateful.

I’m already finding this with various young adult relatives suddenly showing an interest in me after years of barely knowing who I am. I don’t have a partner or children and am in a senior role so they think I’m wealthy. Or rather their parents do, who are the ones behind this sudden interest as I turned 50 last year. The truth is that I, like most people, struggle ans have few savings. I’ve been on my own for years and even as a moderately high earned it’s fucking hard, especially as I’m supporting my elderly father who gets nothing but his pension. If any of my relatives deigned to talk to me they’d know that there isn’t anything other than my modest house - which I’m leaving to my ex husbands nieces who I have managed to retain a close and wonderful relationship with despite the divorce. My family. Nah. Just because I have no children,doesn’t mean you’re the default inheritors.

Imisscoffee2021 · 28/06/2025 23:03

Ungortunately you've mentally spent money before you had it. I'm in an aunts will for a big inheritance but she changes her mind alot and I also know it may be eaten up in care costs one day or she may choose to spent her money, brilliant. Not counting it in any of our financial planning as inheritance is such a tenuous thing.

Whatare · 28/06/2025 23:00

I think it’s completely fair enough to be miffed OP.

I’m guessing that Auntie probably inherited money herself. Whether she did or not, she could have left the bulk to relatives and a cash legacy to charities not the other way round. That’s my opinion.