Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking if you took a Ukrainian guest in your home why you want them gone asap?

115 replies

Anhelina2000xx · 25/06/2025 16:19

My experience as Ukrainian coming to UK. Many people want the Ukrainian guest for them house but when we are there straight away want you to leave asap and getting the job asap even if it is the very bad job.
This is my experience and the experience of very many Ukrainian people I speak to. Why? Why does the English agree to have Ukrainians for them house but plan to make them leave asap? In my first home in UK she want me to get the job after 1 week! 1 week not very many time to even relax and try to speak my family from Ukraine! My brothers was forced in war just one day he go and buy the food at the shop!
Was they told the Ukrainian is only staying for a week or something like this? Or when you live with Ukrainian you start to hate them so you say please get a job right now please find a new place? And this is not only me, this is very many Ukrainians. Told to come them to this home. Then told please to leave asap!
Why?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StepawayfromtheLindors · 31/12/2025 09:42

Motomum23 · 29/12/2025 22:58

Why did you feel you needed time to relax? You had the privilege of a safe roof over your head away from war, why not want to pay for your own expenses to help the family who were protecting your life? It's not a holiday after all.

You don’t begin to understand the issue. And btw, “having a roof over your head” is not a privilege, it’s a basic human need.

JKFan · 29/12/2025 23:31

Motomum23 · 29/12/2025 22:58

Why did you feel you needed time to relax? You had the privilege of a safe roof over your head away from war, why not want to pay for your own expenses to help the family who were protecting your life? It's not a holiday after all.

I would guess that was a wrong choice of word from someone who is clearly not completely fluent in English. I took it to mean “recover”. I know the journey alone was extremely stressful for my Ukrainian guest and she won’t have been alone in that. If OP’s host was trying to make her get a job within a week of arrival that wasn’t particularly empathetic, nor was it needed. Those of us who provided accommodation were given an allowance as a thank you.

Motomum23 · 29/12/2025 22:58

Why did you feel you needed time to relax? You had the privilege of a safe roof over your head away from war, why not want to pay for your own expenses to help the family who were protecting your life? It's not a holiday after all.

LBFseBrom · 29/12/2025 22:50

OneFunBrickNewt · 29/12/2025 18:07

I'm relaxed about Ukrainians returning home for medical treatment etc. Although I think this website is on the optimistic side.
https://visitukraine.today/blog/4809/travel-to-ukraine-2025-how-to-come-to-ukraine-as-a-tourist-rules-and-safe-cities#what-countries-can-i-enter-ukraine-from-without-a-visa

That said, it hi-lights the way that white, European, Ukrainian asylum seekers/refugees are treated differently to their black or brown fellow asylum seekers/refugees: if an Afghan or Eritrean returned home even to see a dying relative whilst their claim for asylum was being processed it would mean an automatic denial of claim.

Yes, I agree.

OneFunBrickNewt · 29/12/2025 18:08

And I've been to Lviv and would go again when it's safe, it's a wonderful, fascinating place.

OneFunBrickNewt · 29/12/2025 18:07

Latitudeohyeah · 21/12/2025 20:08

Our Ukrainian colleagues flying back and forth regularly for a variety of reasons- holidays, dental treatments etc.

I'm relaxed about Ukrainians returning home for medical treatment etc. Although I think this website is on the optimistic side.
https://visitukraine.today/blog/4809/travel-to-ukraine-2025-how-to-come-to-ukraine-as-a-tourist-rules-and-safe-cities#what-countries-can-i-enter-ukraine-from-without-a-visa

That said, it hi-lights the way that white, European, Ukrainian asylum seekers/refugees are treated differently to their black or brown fellow asylum seekers/refugees: if an Afghan or Eritrean returned home even to see a dying relative whilst their claim for asylum was being processed it would mean an automatic denial of claim.

Latitudeohyeah · 21/12/2025 20:08

LoveItaly · 25/06/2025 18:46

But why didn’t they move to the part of Ukraine that was unaffected, which was most of the country? Why was my Ukrainian acquaintance travelling back and forth as normal for her beauty treatments etc? (lives in a neighbouring country, not the UK). Why were people still holidaying in Kiev during this time, as I know they were?

Our Ukrainian colleagues flying back and forth regularly for a variety of reasons- holidays, dental treatments etc.

ipredictariot5 · 25/06/2025 22:35

I ran an informal support group in our area for families who took in Ukranians. I would say the success rate was 50/50 and it was more likely to be successful with an older retired
couple with space who took in a mother and child. The intentions of most people who
sogned up to host were honourable and break down of placements was not solely due to the host in most instances. The Govt put together a quick scheme and some aspects worked some
didnt
our family made comment recently of lots of Ukranians not working and relying on benefits when they should be and also that financially it about the same if they worked or stayed on benefits. I don’t have knowledge enough
to know if it is fair comment
I only found out how
much impact it had on my own kids after - they never said a word until they moved out at which point they all said how hard it was,
how pleased they were it was
over but how glad they were we had done it

Hufflemuff · 25/06/2025 22:16

People got caught up in the spirit/novelty of it and then realised the reality was very different.

No privacy in your own home can wear thin fast, especially when your personalities might not gel.

Unfortunately I knew this would be the case from the get go. Especially these people that did it just so they looked generous for social media.

Youdontseehow · 25/06/2025 22:10

Wisen up is a really common expression where I live lol. But maybe I just live in a city full of saddos.

Of course the OP was goady - you need to be really naive not to see that. And OP hasn’t returned which is typical goady poster behaviour.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/06/2025 21:00

Youdontseehow · 25/06/2025 19:56

Wisen up.

OP has written a massively goady and inflammatory post, got you all frothing at the mouth and disappeared.

And yes, the title is written in much better English than the pidgin English post.

I don’t see how it’s goady or inflammatory, it’s quite an interesting conversation. Certainly not frothing.

Saying “wisen up” doesn’t make you sound as cool or street-wise, just a little bit sad.

Genevieva · 25/06/2025 20:57

41Songs · 25/06/2025 18:12

The government actually asked for a minimum commitment of 6 months from host families.

We had a Ukrainian family staying with us for about 2.5 years, and we know others who had guests stay for a similar amount of time. However, I think some people got caught up in wanting to help and invited Ukrainians into their homes, but didn't think through the reality of what it would be like to have strangers living with them.

We were lucky in that we all got on well and our house is big enough that we weren't on top of each other. We went into hosting with an expectation that we would do it for at least a year, but some hosts saw the 6 month minimum as the most they could do.

A lot of people did indeed have them for longer, but the families we know who signed up were strongly under the impression it was long enough to set up the new arrivals, estimated at a maximum six months. There was then an offer to extend the government payment for longer.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/06/2025 20:57

Notreallyme27 · 25/06/2025 20:48

At the start of the invasion, there were rocket attacks all over the country, not just the East. Our guests were from (safe) central Ukraine and they were heavily targeted at the start because their air force is based in that city. They fled and they’ve never returned to Ukraine since, even though they are missing their family terribly. Mum is just too scared to put the children in danger again.

Our guests (Mum, and son now 14, and daughter now 9) all have PTSD. One particular event I’ll never forget was being out with daughter who was about 7 at the time. Some fireworks unexpectedly went off and she screamed and dropped to the floor in a ball, violently shaking. She had wet herself. This is the most beautiful, happy, outgoing little girl. To look at her, you would never guess that she was holding that trauma, but it cuts very deep.

Since then, their city has only suffered one heavy bombing raid. Even ‘safe’ places like Lviv suffer sporadic attacks, even though they’re not occupied like the East. There are daily drone attacks on Kyiv and people are killed. People consider Kyiv to be safe.

Nowhere is completely safe. Some people think the risks are worth going back for, others don’t. I guess it depends on how anxious a person you are. I certainly wouldn’t take my children there.

Absolutely. My friend’s Mum got caught in an air attack in Lviv on her way over here from central Ukraine.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/06/2025 20:55

Islavadaukrani · 25/06/2025 19:19

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing it is in place for him to go. I am aware of the stupidity and I know you get tossers in all walks but having seen this entitlement first hand I am almost in awe of his self confidence.

Ha ha - sometimes I think that about my ex-husband!

I hope you manage to get rid of him soon.

Notreallyme27 · 25/06/2025 20:48

LoveItaly · 25/06/2025 18:46

But why didn’t they move to the part of Ukraine that was unaffected, which was most of the country? Why was my Ukrainian acquaintance travelling back and forth as normal for her beauty treatments etc? (lives in a neighbouring country, not the UK). Why were people still holidaying in Kiev during this time, as I know they were?

At the start of the invasion, there were rocket attacks all over the country, not just the East. Our guests were from (safe) central Ukraine and they were heavily targeted at the start because their air force is based in that city. They fled and they’ve never returned to Ukraine since, even though they are missing their family terribly. Mum is just too scared to put the children in danger again.

Our guests (Mum, and son now 14, and daughter now 9) all have PTSD. One particular event I’ll never forget was being out with daughter who was about 7 at the time. Some fireworks unexpectedly went off and she screamed and dropped to the floor in a ball, violently shaking. She had wet herself. This is the most beautiful, happy, outgoing little girl. To look at her, you would never guess that she was holding that trauma, but it cuts very deep.

Since then, their city has only suffered one heavy bombing raid. Even ‘safe’ places like Lviv suffer sporadic attacks, even though they’re not occupied like the East. There are daily drone attacks on Kyiv and people are killed. People consider Kyiv to be safe.

Nowhere is completely safe. Some people think the risks are worth going back for, others don’t. I guess it depends on how anxious a person you are. I certainly wouldn’t take my children there.

Jc2001 · 25/06/2025 20:39

Youdontseehow · 25/06/2025 17:27

Good attempt at pidgin English @Anhelina2000xx . 7/10 as just a bit too obvious.

Haha. My thoughts exactly.

buckeejit · 25/06/2025 20:34

I’m sorry that you’ve experienced this - I’m in NI & my ndn took in 2 Ukrainians, one of whom still lives there & the other has now gone back to Ukraine.

I think there is very little support from anyone for them anymore & I think a lot of people would find it difficult to live with someone else for a long time.

JKFan · 25/06/2025 20:08

Manxexile · 25/06/2025 18:43

I do wonder whether many people who took in Ukrainians were doing it for genuine humanitarian reasons or whether they were just virtue signalling.

Sounds like the OP has experience of the latter...

My initial reaction was to be offended as I took in a Ukrainian woman who stayed for two years but then I remembered her stories about the first couple they were with who were very controlling and seemed to want to show her and her sister off as their charity project.

Youdontseehow · 25/06/2025 19:56

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/06/2025 19:12

What a horrible thing to say - both you and the person you’re quoting! And the title isn’t written in perfect English.

Wisen up.

OP has written a massively goady and inflammatory post, got you all frothing at the mouth and disappeared.

And yes, the title is written in much better English than the pidgin English post.

WotNowThen · 25/06/2025 19:32

I had a Ukrainian guest for a short time. She decided to leave because she found somewhere she liked better. It was obvious straight away that she had come here because she thought it was a good opportunity to work abroad and she told me she'd planned to leave Ukraine anyway; the war just brought her plans forward. She was prepared to work very hard and do any kind of work but she was very inconsiderate and treated my house like a hotel and me like the staff. I'd assumed she would stay with me for a year or so then move on, at which point I'd offer the room to someone else, but after this experience I decided not to.

Tryonemoretime · 25/06/2025 19:19

We had a Ukrainian student live with us for a year. Yes - sharing a kitchen was sometimes a little challenging, but not terrible. We have a decent sized house and she had a bedsit in it.
She spoke no English when she arrived, but took English lessons as soon as possible at the same time as doing her degree on line with her Ukrainian university. She managed to work at 2 jobs, too. Such a hard worker. When she arrived it took a couple of weeks to do things like signing on etc. and needed ferrying around as we live in a village with minimal public transport.
It probably cost us a bit more in heating bills, but asap she bought her own food. She now house shares with others and we don't hear from her at all. We don't regret hosting her, but it's lovely to have our house back.

Islavadaukrani · 25/06/2025 19:19

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing it is in place for him to go. I am aware of the stupidity and I know you get tossers in all walks but having seen this entitlement first hand I am almost in awe of his self confidence.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/06/2025 19:19

LBFseBrom · 25/06/2025 19:16

Agreed,

Anyway we all understand what the op is saying.

Absolutely!

My own ability to learn foreign languages is appalling, so I don’t judge other people!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/06/2025 19:17

Islavadaukrani · 25/06/2025 19:07

Interesting topic years after the war started and I do think OP could be from where they say they are from although I do not believe their english is that bad.

I am not in England but another country that took on a lot of refugees. I took one in not for moral reasons but because I needed the money quite honestly but it meant sharing my home with a man (I am female) that I did not know trust him with my home.

He moved in, we became good friends I thought. He told me how much he made in his job at home, I encouraged him to get a job locally so he could earn some money and come off the very generous welfare benefits the government were giving him along with paying his rent for him etc. After 4 months it became apparent that he assumed the rent paid on his behalf by the government were his entitlements but not only that but that I should be also sharing some of the money I was getting to rent to him from the government with him. No wish in him to work or support himself, actually started costing me money as he never once paid towards anything like bills etc only HIS OWN grocery shopping and i mean he would cook using my staple ingredients and expect me to replace them. Entitlement is not even the word I would give this man.

Stupidly as both single we ended up in some weird relationship and began sleeping together which is when it became apparent he would love bomb me one day followed by days of the silent treatment. He went away to his family for a month and still claimed welfare and then assumed 'we' were complicit in him claiming which is when I realised they stopped his claim and he thought I would 'share' the rent money with him which is when things soured. I told him in no uncertain terms he gets a job and supports himself and we entered into another 3 month licence agreement where I would get rental money for him to rent his room in my house (he never shared my room only my bed maybe 5 times in total) and he would get a job and fend for himself as at this point I realised he was a fantasist and had not half as much money as he liked to pretend.

The saga continues actually with this man who I now see to be a cocklodger. He never ever wanted to work just wanted to be on a permanent holiday and thought I was some idiot that would help with this. He is currently giving me the silent treatment and while I do not believe I am in danger I have taken precautions and I have made a plan to get him out of my house as he has taken advantage of my hospitality and I mean my not making him pay bills so he could save money etc but now i realise the person he is (he blocked me on instagram only yesterday ffs) and he is being watched like a hawk by people. Not every story ends well and while I never asked him to move out or tried to force him out there is no way I would be entertaining a boychild with walter mitty ideologies to live here much longer. Sorry I did go off on a tangeant there but there are many many variables and as my friends have said when he recently took a pop at me saying he was frustrated as his country was being bombed etc, why if he is so passionate is he not there himself fighting for it.

You get good and bad people from everywhere - and male cocklodgers from everywhere!

Probably a mistake to sleep with him but we live and learn. I would get rid of him asap - he sounds like a right piece of work and will still be looking to take advantage where he can.

LBFseBrom · 25/06/2025 19:16

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/06/2025 19:12

What a horrible thing to say - both you and the person you’re quoting! And the title isn’t written in perfect English.

Agreed,

Anyway we all understand what the op is saying.