Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you expect a care home to stay with care user when going to urgent care/ a&e

111 replies

itispersonal · 15/06/2025 21:10

Anyone in the know - have an elderly dementia aunt in a care home. Had a fall 2 weeks ago no fracture but had a moon boot. Stopped weight bearing on foot over the last few days and knee swollen a little bit. Care home and a carer took aunty to urgent care but called my elderly mum to come and be with her as they couldn’t stay due to staffing! 10 hours later after being transferred to OOT drs and then to a&e they are back home.

mum has been in tears it is too much for her, she can’t push the wheelchair, help her physically or emotionally. I went to help later in the afternoon but couldn’t help with transport as couldn’t get wheelchair in car. And hard for me to help aunty move.

should care home be staying with aunty? What would happen if my mum didn’t go? Aunty has children but they aren’t involved, and aren’t emotional attached if aunty is at the hospital on her own. Whereas my mum and I are.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BernardButlersBra · 17/06/2025 15:40

The home most likely struggles to staff itself full stop, never mind having to find another 2 staff each day (1 night and 1 day). A hospital escort is in effect like a 1:1 carer and that's rather expensive. So no l wouldn't expect them to and they probably couldn't even if they wanted to

Valeriekat · 17/06/2025 15:06

IReallyLoveItHere · 15/06/2025 21:17

I would have expected them to. PP appears to know the correct answer.

What if there's no local family? Or just no family at all? Do social services cover?

Hospital should have a transport service.

SheilaFentiman · 17/06/2025 15:04

Daphnise · 17/06/2025 15:01

From my experience you can't expect much from care home staff, they do very little and take no responsibility.

They love getting rid of inmates to hospital- less owrk for them for the same fees.

In this instance, the aunt is not transferring to hospital, she is there having a swelling reviewed.

What would you expect staff to do in this case?

Daphnise · 17/06/2025 15:01

From my experience you can't expect much from care home staff, they do very little and take no responsibility.

They love getting rid of inmates to hospital- less owrk for them for the same fees.

SheilaFentiman · 17/06/2025 14:50

Hospital transport can be arranged - however, if it’s for an appointment like a scan ie non urgent, then if the ambulance gets called to something else, it may be cancelled at fairly short notice.

Tiredofwhataboutery · 17/06/2025 14:42

Fragmentedbrain · 17/06/2025 14:03

I think it's important people realise how limited care homes actually are in what they provide. If you don't have family you're really shafted even if you have cash. (I am absolutely set on euthanasia to avoid this)

I’m with you having seen a number of relatives go through the care process I’d much rather shuffle off after I’ve had a decent innings.

MissMoneyFairy · 17/06/2025 14:42

IReallyLoveItHere · 15/06/2025 21:17

I would have expected them to. PP appears to know the correct answer.

What if there's no local family? Or just no family at all? Do social services cover?

The care home or hospital can arrange hospital or community transport, it's not up to relatives to transport residents especially if they need any sort of manual handling or use of equipment which they wont be trained how to use.

Strawberriesandpears · 17/06/2025 14:38

I will be an old person with no family (only child, no children) and I am terrified of all this. 😔

SheilaFentiman · 17/06/2025 14:24

Junoornotjuno · 15/06/2025 21:21

My DM’s nursing home arrange patient transport and charge £35 per hour per member of staff to accompany residents to appointments.

Similar for my dad (dementia) - with my mum, the hospital didn't want her to take a carer as she has mental capacity, so then it's just a question of arranging transport.

OP, there are private ambulance/wheelchair taxi services that come with suitable staff who can quote for the expected round trip and staying with your relative, but they are expensive.

Smallsalt · 17/06/2025 14:24

QuickFawn · 15/06/2025 21:17

Is there not patient transfer available that could take your aunt? L
I mean this kindly, would you really expect that care home to take them to a medical appointment?

Yes I would expect it. The care home are the persons carer and are getting funds to do that. A hospital visit is care. The family are not.

Justlurking10 · 17/06/2025 14:17

In case of attending A&E care home do
not have to send a member of staff and often won’t as it’s an emergency. Unless a resident has 1-2-1 funding in which case a member of staff should escort as that carer is there for that particular resident only.

In cases of planned appointments a member of staff should attend and escort aunt and patient transport can be arranged by the home if your mum cannot do it. Your aunt will likely have to pay to be escorted to her appointments but as it’s a planned appointment the home should be able to arrange this with their staff in advance.

Your best option is to speak to the home and see what they can offer x

Ginisatonic · 17/06/2025 14:16

My MIL has dementia and is in a care home. She’s had a few visits to A and E over the last couple of years and a member of staff always takes her and stays with her until she’s either ready to come back to the home or admitted.

She’s also had a number of hospital/dentist appointments and these are put in the diary so the staff know she’s going and she is accompanied.

We’re the closest relatives but we are 450 miles away.

She is self funding but many - probably most - of the residents are funded by the council. I’m fairly sure the home don’t differentiate. Many of the residents have no one visiting them. We don’t think the staff know who self funds and who is funded. The manager does but the staff probably don’t.

Fragmentedbrain · 17/06/2025 14:03

I think it's important people realise how limited care homes actually are in what they provide. If you don't have family you're really shafted even if you have cash. (I am absolutely set on euthanasia to avoid this)

ThePure · 17/06/2025 13:55

TheignT · 17/06/2025 13:22

Depends where you are. My local hospital are quite clear that the home is paid to provide care, if a patients needs that level of care they expect a carer to be present ideally 24/7 but definitely for a good portion of the day.

Bloody hell. Is this in the U.K.? Its not a thing where we are that carers stay in the hospital
If a person has been admitted to hospital then that is beyond the care that the care home can provide and the NHS is responsible. The NHS funds a 1:1 from ward staffing at their discretion if absolutely necessary ie acute risk to self or others but obviously not just for being confused or ill which everyone is.
The only exceptions I can think of are prisoners, people on MHA sections and occasionally very posh people whose 1:1 carer has been paid to accompany them.

Tiredofwhataboutery · 17/06/2025 13:51

TheignT · 17/06/2025 13:44

I retired a year ago. We certainly weren't charging £3k a week, we weren't charging £1.5k a week. We still did it.

So basically you are telling me what we did and what organisation is still doing isn't possible. Maybe we were magicians.

Maybe you were, possibly it balanced out over it time or was cross funded by other residents but I don’t think many businesses can afford to absorb regular additional costs of £400 per day.

TheignT · 17/06/2025 13:44

Tiredofwhataboutery · 17/06/2025 13:38

I can’t help but think that’d be really expensive. Even at minimum wage, the wage bill would be £300 plus holiday pay, employer NI, payroll, pension contributions so probably closer to £400. Fixed costs of running the home are still there.

You’d have to be paying £3k + a week for them to be able to fund it.

I retired a year ago. We certainly weren't charging £3k a week, we weren't charging £1.5k a week. We still did it.

So basically you are telling me what we did and what organisation is still doing isn't possible. Maybe we were magicians.

sillyquestionalert · 17/06/2025 13:38

No it’s not the norm for staff to go- it would mean they are a carer short then what would happen if the persons shift finished and they are still waiting at hospital? Are they expected to stay unpaid?
sometimes they arrange for a carer to take service users to scheduled appointments - if it’s a private care home- they will charge for this

Tiredofwhataboutery · 17/06/2025 13:38

TheignT · 17/06/2025 13:22

Depends where you are. My local hospital are quite clear that the home is paid to provide care, if a patients needs that level of care they expect a carer to be present ideally 24/7 but definitely for a good portion of the day.

I can’t help but think that’d be really expensive. Even at minimum wage, the wage bill would be £300 plus holiday pay, employer NI, payroll, pension contributions so probably closer to £400. Fixed costs of running the home are still there.

You’d have to be paying £3k + a week for them to be able to fund it.

Forktrip · 17/06/2025 13:29

My understanding is that they need to make sure someone is with her, and if family can't/won't help it would be care home staff, but they obviously give family the impression it needs to be them.

I remember my friend being very upset when her mother's care home was very unkind to her because she couldn't stay with her mother in hospital.

TheignT · 17/06/2025 13:23

LindorDoubleChoc · 17/06/2025 08:35

My mother was sent to hospital from her care home without her hearing aids, phone charger, glasses, handbag. My brother was in California at the time and I was at home in London 70 miles away with covid. I had to ask a very kind and understanding neighbour to go to the care home and collect these essentials and deliver them to the hospital. You'd think they'd have some sort if check list?

They really should.

TheignT · 17/06/2025 13:22

DemonsandMosquitoes · 17/06/2025 10:14

THIS!
Nurse of 37 years.

Depends where you are. My local hospital are quite clear that the home is paid to provide care, if a patients needs that level of care they expect a carer to be present ideally 24/7 but definitely for a good portion of the day.

TheignT · 17/06/2025 13:19

Tiredofwhataboutery · 17/06/2025 09:24

I think the problem is staffing levels, the home can’t spare a carer. So they’d have to get in bank staff or ask someone to come in and do an extra shift.

I would consider contacting care agencies thst do home care/ bank staff and ask. Trickier for emergencies but I’m sure they could cope with routine appointments.

Or the on call comes in.

Saz12 · 17/06/2025 10:44

DF was in a care home. At the start there were fairly frequent trips to A&E by ambulance, and I'd meet him there. Every time it was for suspected sepsis. GP travelled to care home to see residents, and care home nurse had tests for (eg) uti, so no need for emergency GP visits. No non-emergency hospital appointments as life expectancy and ability to undergo treatment didn't warrant it - also he had made it consistently clear that he wouldn't want that when he was able to.

Your DM cannot possibly be expected to do this. Care home needs contact details updated ASAP, to ensure she isn't expected to take physical care of her sister. That needs to be included in handover paperwork from home to ambulance to hospital. I really sympathise with you, it's an awful situation.

DemonsandMosquitoes · 17/06/2025 10:14

SleepyRic · 15/06/2025 22:16

In my experience as a Paramedic it's extremely rare for care homes to have staff to send with patients. It used to be done years ago but no longer and it's families that are informed about the admission/if they want to meet them at A&E etc. Considering placements seem to be charged at around £800 a week and staff are paid minimum wage you'd think there would be some funding to assist.

If there's no family essentially the patients go to Hospital without anyone to advocate for them - we obviously hand over why they've been taken upto A&E but that's all we can do.

When I started in the role it was normal for care home staff to travel with patients when they had dementia/lacked capacity but it's just not the case anymore - I suspect it's partly due to becoming a much more defensive society/expectations for being taken to hospital to try anything/every test possible are higher (even when even when x condition is diagnosed the patient is too frail for the treatment.

A perfect example of this today - 92yr old booked for transport to hospital for biopsy of a lump found on CT (at families insistence) ?whether it was cancerous. they've already been palliated, they've already have end of life medications prescribed (injectable opoids for pain etc but not being given as they're not in pain at present! Admittedly not expected to die imminently but in the notes they weren't going to be for further surgery beyond biopsy as that's all that could be done under a local anaesthetic as were too frail for general. So essentially patient just being put through a painful procedure which could well result in a complication - infection from surgery, c.diff/hospital pneumonia from the ward with absolutely zero expectation that any treatment would be provided should it turn out to be cancerous beyond what's already been prescribed for them.

The over testing in my opinion only leads to very frail confused people being taken out of the place that had some familiarity & staff who know them - to end up on a ward in Hospital surrounded by strangers/staff who dont know them, plus there's no lounge or dining room they can walk to, staff have such little time/though must not fall in hospital so patients kept in bed/transferred in wheelchairs/trolleys they just decondition with little hope of ever getting back the strength they had before they were admitted 'just in case'.

Sorry bit of a rant, but it always strikes us as totally mad that when you're 40 and need tests because you have severe symptoms/worsening pain/headaches/exhaustion - where you might actually be fit enough to survive treatment/live long enough to have a meaningful benefit - enjoy family/get back to work etc - then you end up waiting months or more. But instead wait 40years till you're 80 with dementia living in a care home and now you're expedited for all tests - have a bad headache get a CT same day, bit of abdo pain - CT/bloods/USS... More complicated then this obviously/more likely to be something sinister when older but you've got to die of something!

THIS!
Nurse of 37 years.