Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I controlling for asking for these boundaries after birth

209 replies

Anonforthisone1 · 14/06/2025 17:48

Genuinely wondering if I am letting my emotions get to me with this. Have spoken briefly to dp about it but am worried I am
going to come across very precious and controlling. I have never really set boundaries before when it comes to birth.

i will be having a high risk csection under general (due to bleeding disorder) in the next few weeks. I am at a much greater risk of having a pph and also needing a transfusion or a hysterectomy so my recovery is up in the air.

i want to make it clear before I go in some boundaries or expectations due to the fact I have no idea what to expect

i would prefer for no pictures to be sent of ds until i am fully awake and have met him. I understand that this could be as little as 1 hour or could be a lot more if I have complications but the thought of everyone seeing him before me makes me really sad.
i dont want any visitors at all in hospital as from past experience i have had people not be considerate after pph etc.
i don’t know when I will be up for visitors so will tell people when I am ready (this could be a few days but it could be weeks) but they have to come to us. I don’t want to be travelling everywhere.

does this sound ok or am I being controlling as I really don’t want to be.

OP posts:
FinancialWhines · 14/06/2025 19:39

Bless you. Yanbu.
It's understandable you are worried about this. I'm sure it'll be fine but having a plan is a good idea.

TiredMame · 14/06/2025 19:39

Completely reasonable op. Especially point 1.

Timeforyetanothernamechange · 14/06/2025 19:36

Lmnop22 · 14/06/2025 18:42

I wouldn’t set these firm boundaries in place ahead of time (except maybe the photos one if you’re unwell and haven’t met your baby yet) because you don’t know what you’ll need/want yet.

I would say to everyone “as you’re aware, my c section is high risk and because we don’t know what will happen, could you please be patient with us after the birth and we will let you know what we need and when. We know you’re very excited to meet the baby so we will let you know as soon as you can what we can manage around visits but we don’t want to make any arrangements ahead of time given the uncertain nature of the procedure”

Then tell your DH to direct any questions to him and what your boundaries are and let him be the one fielding any questions after the birth so you can focus on healing.

This is great advice and by keeping the discussion quite general, you don't open yourself up to being challenged and needing to justify decisions. If you say now, no visits for the first week, you'll possibly have people saying that's too long, can we come day 3 or 4 or saying you said 7 days when you might not be ready when the time comes. Or, like on this thread, maybe dad can just bring baby to us then? It's perfectly fair to say we'll let you know what we need and when we're ready for visits then you can play it by ear. You never know, you might be feeling great and desperate to show off baby or you might need longer.

I had a difficult postpartum for various reasons and "we'll let you know when/what...." is a really helpful tool to kindly set some boundaries and give yourself some space until you're ready.

ShanghaiDiva · 14/06/2025 19:36

I think the photo issue is easy to manage as presumably your dh is the only person taking photos and requesting they are sent to other people only after you have seen the baby is completely reasonable.
re visits I would follow the wait and see approach that a pp mentioned.ie we would love to see you, but I the delivery is high risk and we will keep you updated.
i had an emergency section under ga and did not want any visitors. Fortunately we were living overseas at the time and nobody was able to drop by the hospital.

Tiredandtiredagain · 14/06/2025 19:35

Perfectly fine, I hope all goes well.

RadiovTV · 14/06/2025 19:34

I was anticipating voting YABU, as so many poster set ridiculous boundaries around childbirth - as though their child is the second coming - but given the circumstances you're not being unreasonable at all. Good luck for your cSection

Likewise, I read some ridiculous boundaries on here, like, immediate family not allowed to feed the baby, hold the baby, change their nappy. Nobody to visit in the first month. And that means nobody. I mean, everybody's read these totally unreasonable posts.

Your boundaries sound absolutely normal to me. I would certainly be gutted if loads of people saw my baby before I did. I had a c-section under general anaesthesia and am still a bit miffed that dh held her before I did. She's 38 now.
You are totally justified OP.

triballeader · 14/06/2025 19:34

Sounds like my third. I also banned visitors as I really did not want anyone seeing me having blood transfusions, possibly in ICU and looking and feeling like death. in fact I was not even sure I would survive and just hoped my son might. The theatre was extra full with NNICU team, surgical team and heamotolgy team with a blood bikes runner on standby to fetch extra blood outside the theatre.
I did ask for my DH to see and hold son if he did not need to go straight to NNICU. I did not see him for seven hours as I kept zonking out after the GA as the CSec took longer than expected. DH took photos for me.
The only visitor I allowed in the first 24 hours was my MIL because she was on a visit from the states and was flying back the next day and we would not see her for another year. Everyone else except immediate family who I knew would help we’re kept away by DH as I really needed the recovery time.
It took a further two weeks after before I felt I could do some things for myself and six weeks to be able to lift my son on my own ( more complex csec than you have for a simple safe delivery plus drugs from haematologist knocking me for six).

I truly hope all goes well for you and that any PPH can be managed safely and that you do not need lots of blood units. may your much wanted baby arrive safe and well enough not to need NNICU and may you see much wanted baby as soon as you can keep your eyes open post GA.

(PS take any offered extra pain relief meds if your looking at a more complex csec and any drugs the haematologist recommends to avoid severe PPHs)

thepariscrimefiles · 14/06/2025 19:32

28Fluctuations · 14/06/2025 18:37

It is your body, your baby, and no photos + no hospital visitors makes perfect sense. You set down whatever boundaries you like.

As for others meeting baby... you have a dp. It's his baby, too. So if he wants to walk down the local with baby, meet friends or family... yes, you would be unreasonable to stop him.

And you really, really want to encourage dp to be independent in looking after baby. His parenting confidence will serve you and baby well for years to come.

You may not be ready for visitors. All fine. He may need friends. Also fine.

If OP is breastfeeding, she won't want her DH taking her baby down the pub. If OP is poorly after the birth, he should be by her side, helping her care for the baby.

DisforDarkChocolate · 14/06/2025 19:30

That sounds perfectly reasonable, good look with the GA, they can be stressful.

thepariscrimefiles · 14/06/2025 19:28

MoreChocPls · 14/06/2025 18:31

The photo bit of fine. Making people wait weeks to see you baby is just nuts.

OP has said that she might be very ill afterwards (she has a bleeding disorder) and may need a blood transfusion and/or a hysterectomy. In that case, she would be reasonable to put off visitors for a while until she feels well enough.

Surroundedbyfools · 14/06/2025 19:25

Those sounds absolutely fine. Anyone with a decent bone in their body should totally respect these boundaries! Personally I never rock up and visit anyone with a new baby until they say they would like a visit and when I do I try to be helpful and not a burden !

thepariscrimefiles · 14/06/2025 19:22

ExtraOnions · 14/06/2025 18:13

What does your husband think? Is it a unilateral decison on photos, or does he get a say?

If OP's husband is sending photos of the baby to people before his wife has even seen the baby, he would be unkind and unreasonable.

LouiseTopaz · 14/06/2025 19:18

I had no visitors at the hospital I just wanted it to be me and my husband, I also had no visitors for the first week after I came home, I was very sick and need time to recover. People were none stop texting and calling me though so next time I won't even tell anyone when I've given birth until I'm ready.

LurkyMcLurkinson · 14/06/2025 19:13

Having a baby is likely to be one of the most vulnerable experiences of your life. It’s therefore very reasonable to have some boundaries around that. Of course you don’t want anyone to see your precious baby before you do. You’ll likely find though that you’re keen for people to visit but it’s always good to manage expectations in case you are not.

Katemax82 · 14/06/2025 19:11

Your boundaries sound perfectly reasonable

OneAmberFinch · 14/06/2025 19:09

Sounds reasonable and I'm also someone who often thinks people ABU with their new baby boundaries!

Re: photos, when you discuss it with your husband, maybe make it clear whether you don't want him to take any pictures or just not share them? I had an EMCS and didn't see my baby for an hour or so but I really like looking at the pics my husband took straight after birth - baby was all cleaned up an hour later so I didn't see the "completely fresh" version :) He might not naturally take any pics if he isn't intending to directly send them to someone.

Katheclepto · 14/06/2025 19:09

This is all very normal!

humptydumptyfelloff · 14/06/2025 19:06

They sound absolutely fine to me op

stick to them xx

DejaMooo · 14/06/2025 19:05

I think you’re being completely reasonable. The photo thing especially - I can completely understand that. Yours is not a typical birth situation and you don’t know yet how things will go. Hopefully everything will go smoothly and recovery will be great, and you may well feel absolutely fine and change your mind about some things. But setting boundaries from the beginning isn’t a bad idea. I hope everything goes well.

TizerorFizz · 14/06/2025 19:05

Maybe OP could get a private room? More control then.

GinnyandGeorgia · 14/06/2025 19:04

TizerorFizz · 14/06/2025 19:00

@GinnyandGeorgia They don’t all visit at once! They do allow parents and DH to visit and then others in the forthcoming days at visiting time. Relatives stick by the rules but can visit.

thankfully not everywhere.

You have mothers complaining that they are not comfortable if someone else' s partner is around, you can't have completely random visitors allowed.

GinnyandGeorgia · 14/06/2025 19:03

28Fluctuations · 14/06/2025 18:45

Umm, no. If she cannot move for weeks, it will be fine for Dad to take baby on short outings (assuming breastfeeding, it will be pretty short). He also needs to bond with the baby. And she needs sleep and time to heal. It's not punishment for Dad to introduce the baby to his family and friends, assuming mum is out of hospital and recovering well and bonding well with baby.

what do you mean, umm no.

It's not up to YOU, mind giving the actual mum a choice on what she feels more comfortable with 😂

I am saying it's absolutely fine for a mum to feel the way she feels. If she's more comfortable with baby nearby, that's fine. Dad can bond at home. How does a mum on a bed rest manage?

It's not up to the dad to decide alone if he can take the baby away! Treating the mother like an actual human being and letting her in charge of her own baby would be a start.

rhrni · 14/06/2025 19:00

Those boundaries sound totally fine and reasonable

TizerorFizz · 14/06/2025 19:00

@GinnyandGeorgia They don’t all visit at once! They do allow parents and DH to visit and then others in the forthcoming days at visiting time. Relatives stick by the rules but can visit.

tuffinmops · 14/06/2025 18:58

28Fluctuations · 14/06/2025 18:45

Umm, no. If she cannot move for weeks, it will be fine for Dad to take baby on short outings (assuming breastfeeding, it will be pretty short). He also needs to bond with the baby. And she needs sleep and time to heal. It's not punishment for Dad to introduce the baby to his family and friends, assuming mum is out of hospital and recovering well and bonding well with baby.

Lots of mums, particularly breastfeeding mums, want and need to be physically close to their babies after birth. Babies who are BF and newborn do not feed on a schedule and may well want to be cluster feeding constantly, not taken out in the car with Dad. It’s unrealistic to separate a new baby and their mother. Have you never heard of the fourth trimester? All my maternal instincts would have fought this! About four weeks in, DH started to take baby for a walk in the pram while I had a bath, but before that I needed her close to me.