Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think about evening things out between the kids

108 replies

MyKindHiker · 11/06/2025 22:39

I have a bit of a dilemma. I have two sons, 7 and 9. The elder one last year was in a nasty accident (not his fault) and has received a substantial insurance payout as a result. He's all recovered now thank heavens. By law this goes into a trust fund until he's 18, by which point it will be a pretty big chunk of money.

I was thinking about what this means for my younger son, and whether I should try to make provisions for him to match a similar amount for when he's 18, as it feels unfair one child having a head start over the other in terms of being able to put down a deposit on a house, or pay for university without taking out loans etc.

I do put money into trust funds for both of them already, but if I wanted to 'top up' the younger son, I'd have to funnel all money into younger one's fund. If I got to the point where it was equalised I'd of course then continue to put anything extra equally for both.

I'm not sure what is the right approach. Should I try and make sure their start in adult life is 'fair' or evened out, or would by elder son feel it was unfair his brother getting a handout from mum where he didn't, even if the amounts were the same. Genuinely on the fence about it.

Would I be unreasonable to make extra provisions for the youngest?

OP posts:
BellaEllaWella · 12/06/2025 00:18

I don’t think it should be evened out - your elder son was awarded money for a reason. He suffered from the injury and so this is his compensation - your other son didn’t so there is nothing to even out. Any further contributions
from yourself should be split equally between them and anything else seems unfair.

Loubylie · 12/06/2025 00:17

I don't think you should even it up. Your eldest had a traumatic injury. That is why he got compensation. Even though he has recovered there might still be psychological effects further down the line.

Horseebooks · 12/06/2025 00:13

I think I would try to even it up yep. I also think I would be honest about that and hopefully your kids will agree it was the right thing to do. I know I would if I was in the same position with a sibling.

InterestedDad37 · 11/06/2025 23:30

I think it's totally fair, and probably a very good idea to even things up, if you are able to, either by topping up for other son, or even by splitting the compo (I may need to rethink the second option 🤔)
But yes, it strikes me as a very sensible thing to do, for all the right reasons.

Bourbonversuscustardcream · 11/06/2025 22:55

I don’t think you can even things up in these sorts of circumstances. If they had unequal savings because of some family inheritance issue or a windfall that you’d only passed on to one child I’d say you should be fair and even it out. But this is outside of your control and a consequence of something awful that only happened to one child - I think in evening it up you risk unfairness to your eldest.

MyKindHiker · 11/06/2025 22:52

BakelikeBertha · 11/06/2025 22:47

Is the son who was injured permanently affected by his injury OP? This would have a bearing on the decision for me. For example, if he'll never be able to do certain things again, due to his injury, then I think to some extent he deserves the extra money to compensate for what he's lost. It's definitely a tricky one otherwise.

Sorry, just noticed you said that he's all recovered now, so does that mean there are no further problems whatsoever?

Edited

Yep no lasting damage but he was out of school for 4 months recovering. Was a very nasty injury but kids bounce back thank god. So what do you think?

OP posts:
BakelikeBertha · 11/06/2025 22:47

Is the son who was injured permanently affected by his injury OP? This would have a bearing on the decision for me. For example, if he'll never be able to do certain things again, due to his injury, then I think to some extent he deserves the extra money to compensate for what he's lost. It's definitely a tricky one otherwise.

Sorry, just noticed you said that he's all recovered now, so does that mean there are no further problems whatsoever?

Screamingabdabz · 11/06/2025 22:43

I would try and make it the same but I understand the moral dilemma. It’s a tricky one!