Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not believe in unconditional love

141 replies

ZippyPeer · 10/06/2025 23:24

My love for friends and any partner is entirely contingent on them treating me with respect and me in general finding them interesting and enjoyable to be around (of course people have off days/weeks/times, but the overall vibe is positive).

My love for my child I just also feel is finite like if they behave consistently badly I just wouldn't want to be around them and wouldn't have warm feelings towards them... I imagine I'd still think about them but not sure it would feel or seem like love...I don't want to sacrifice everything for them and tbh would only want them around if they had a positive or neutral affect on my life.

Do other people feel this way or is this a me problem?

OP posts:
Sarah2891 · 11/06/2025 10:26

YANBU.
If anyone I loved ever did something absolutely despicable, like raping a child, they would be dead to me.

OnePearlJoker · 11/06/2025 10:25

Mrsttcno1 · 11/06/2025 09:56

I disagree, parents that love their children do not abuse them and vice versa. You do not hurt someone you love.

There is potential for abuse in any relationship, but my point with romantic love is that it shouldn’t be unconditional because to make it unconditional or believe it should be would make it difficult for anyone to leave abusive partners. And it’s a different situation to child to parent. I would still love my child if they hit me, I wouldn’t necessarily like them but I would still love them, whereas if my husband hit me it would be over.

It’s a very narrow minded view to think that you don’t hurt the people you love. Like your example, if your child hit you that does that mean they don’t love you?

Lovemysleeeeeep · 11/06/2025 10:23

I dont believe in love soul mates unconditional love and romantic stuff or being sentimental or being attached etc.

To me its like religion you either believe in it or not.

KPPlumbing · 11/06/2025 10:19

LittleGoldOne · 11/06/2025 09:00

I believe in unconditional love because thats how i love. I may dislike traits or behaviours but it doesnt change my love.

So, as unlikely as it might be, if your husband cheats on you over and over again, and steals your life savings to fund his gambling habit, which costs you your home, you will continue to love him? This is what unconditional love means to me (which is why I don't believe in it, apart from between parents and young children).

TheBig50 · 11/06/2025 10:19

How old are your children?
I have a 28 and a 16 year old. One has destroyed me physically - broken bones.
The other is living at her Dad's for now and whilst they don't mean to, it has destroyed me mentally.

Do I love them?
With all my heart! I take some responsibility and I'm not afraid any more to tell them (well, especially the eldest) and I'm always here for them. I'll always love them. It is completely unconditional.

Other family on the other hand can fuck off 😂

PosiePetal · 11/06/2025 10:15

I cannot relate to this, no. My mother once said something very wise to me. I asked her if she would still love me if I murdered someone and was sent to prison. She said that if this ever happened and because she knows me, she would know that I had lost my sanity and therefore would still love me. I liked that.

MumbleBumbleAppleCrumble · 11/06/2025 10:12

Guinessandafire · 11/06/2025 06:43

I find this ' I will always all them stuff, no matter what heinous crime they commit' attitude a bit performative to be honest.

There will be many examples where you probably wouldn't, sibling on sibling crime is the best example.

I think if my child turned out to be a predatory paedophile the unconditional love thing wouldn't exist.

And equally, perhaps those saying that their moral standards would supersede their love are being ‘performative’. Or perhaps we just have different views and belittling people who disagree with you is petty.

I suspect that none of us can know what may or may not break the love we have for our children. I would say that the thing about the love we have for our children is that it is irrational and cannot be controlled, for all that we may try. As others have pointed out here there are many examples of parents who continue to love their children after they have committed horrendous crimes. That doesn’t mean that they like them anymore, and it certainly doesn’t mean that they are not repulsed by what they have done, but still there is a residual love that holds. Indeed, I suspect that they find that love incredibly hard to understand and feel enormous guilt that they can’t just throw it off. Really, perhaps, that is the definition of unconditional love.

TheWonderhorse · 11/06/2025 10:08

I don't know.

I think loving my children is a part of who I am, it doesn't go up or down in terms of their behaviour. It's fundamental to my consciousness.

I think love and warmth are very different things though, for me love can be purring along in the background even when I'm angry or upset with people. In fact the upset and anger is often because I love the person responsible. I can't imagine not loving my family.

ARichtGoodDram · 11/06/2025 10:01

My Nana often said she was surprised that she still loved her son (my father). She despised the abusive, vile person that he had become and had nothing to do with him after taking us from him (at significant risk to her and my grandad, both from his violence and legal repercussions). But she still loved the person that had been her son.

She felt it was similar to loving someone who had died. You still love them, they just don't exist in person anymore.

Mrsttcno1 · 11/06/2025 09:56

OnePearlJoker · 11/06/2025 09:32

Romantic love isn’t the only love that contains real abuse. Plenty of parents love their children and abuse them, and some kids abuse their parents.

I disagree, parents that love their children do not abuse them and vice versa. You do not hurt someone you love.

There is potential for abuse in any relationship, but my point with romantic love is that it shouldn’t be unconditional because to make it unconditional or believe it should be would make it difficult for anyone to leave abusive partners. And it’s a different situation to child to parent. I would still love my child if they hit me, I wouldn’t necessarily like them but I would still love them, whereas if my husband hit me it would be over.

Meadowfinch · 11/06/2025 09:43

That may be how you feel.

I am certain that I will love my ds no matter what he does. That doesn't mean I will necessarily approve of everything he does or support him in it. I may even not like him much but I cannot imagine a circumstance in which I would not try to get him whatever help he needed.

Arraminta · 11/06/2025 09:33

I wouldn't know how to not love our DDs? The bond is primeval and beyond my control. If DH had an affair/behaved dreadfully then I would leave him, but I would still spend the rest of my life loving him.

OnePearlJoker · 11/06/2025 09:32

Mrsttcno1 · 11/06/2025 09:27

The love for my children is unconditional, they could do anything, I’d still love them though I may not like them.

My love for my husband is conditional, all romantic love should be conditional to an extent because otherwise you’re into real abuse danger territory. Love does not override that.

Romantic love isn’t the only love that contains real abuse. Plenty of parents love their children and abuse them, and some kids abuse their parents.

User37482 · 11/06/2025 09:28

I think I have unconditional love for my DC, she pisses me off pretty regularly already tbh, I would still panic if anything happened to her. I can imagine feeling ashamed of something she’s done etc but I would most likely still love her more than anyone else in the world. She’s probably the only person I don’t have the capacity to stop loving.

Mrsttcno1 · 11/06/2025 09:27

The love for my children is unconditional, they could do anything, I’d still love them though I may not like them.

My love for my husband is conditional, all romantic love should be conditional to an extent because otherwise you’re into real abuse danger territory. Love does not override that.

OnePearlJoker · 11/06/2025 09:24

Saddm · 11/06/2025 08:54

I am not a feeble idiot thanks very much poster a bit up thread..
Quite angry at that accusation..
Walk in my shoes then decide that. Ignorant insults are disgusting..

I didn’t see your first comment about your child so it wasn’t a personal insult to you. What was the crime? That may help understanding walking in your shoes.

MumbleBumbleAppleCrumble · 11/06/2025 09:16

My love you my child is unconditional. Friends, partner, other family, not so much. My love for them is dependent upon their actions. My love for my children is not.

Parents possibly too might be somewhere close to unconditional - that’s a messy and complex though. My mother, for instance, treated me appallingly at times, her fury at my father leaving her channeled at me. Absolute rage. She said and did some awful things. And she was volatile so you were never safe in the moment as she might switch. I have said to others when talking about her that I don’t think I love my mother. That she broke that in me. However, she is now bed bound and with dementia, and recently took a turn for the worse and we were told she might have days left (months later she’s still hanging on!). At that point I started mourning something. Because for all the hard and bloody awful times, as with everything, there were good times too. Dancing on her feet while she sung to me; snuggling up on the sofa as a child. Perhaps there is residual love there, a thread that could never quite snap for all she did, because she was my mother. Or perhaps I was merely mourning what might have been, the potential that was there in our relationship and was never fully realised. Mourning the mother I nearly had.

But I do think (most of us) love our children unconditionally. I remember being struck with a thought recently, while watching Adolescence: while both scenarios are utterly awful - the absolute nightmare for a parent- would it be perhaps better to have a child killed than a child be a killer? At least when a child dies you are left with their memory unaffected by their future actions. Your ‘perfect’ and precious child frozen in time (my father, for instance lost his brother young. My grandparents idolised the dead child and vilified my father for daring to carry on and becoming a difficult teenager). If your child kills another child you then have to try and process that this person, who is the most wonderful and precious thing to you, has done something completely abhorrent. I still think that the love remains, only it is tainted by everything they have done. They break everything you ever thought you held sacred and certain.

LittleGoldOne · 11/06/2025 09:00

I believe in unconditional love because thats how i love. I may dislike traits or behaviours but it doesnt change my love.

Saddm · 11/06/2025 08:54

I am not a feeble idiot thanks very much poster a bit up thread..
Quite angry at that accusation..
Walk in my shoes then decide that. Ignorant insults are disgusting..

ZippyPeer · 11/06/2025 08:54

Seventree · 11/06/2025 06:21

I love my children unconditionally. Even if they grew up to be evil murderers, I'd still love them (though I wouldn't like them).

There are lots of things I couldn't forgive. If they did something bad enough, I'm sure I'd hate them... but I'd still love them too.

There are conditions for everyone else though.

Edited

How could you both hate and love someone at the same time?

OP posts:
ZippyPeer · 11/06/2025 08:43

GreenLeavesInJuly · 11/06/2025 00:18

I don't feel that way. I think really shit behaviour makes you dislike the behaviour and to an extent the person. But love is bigger than that.

It's a gutteral thing - gut wrenching feeling of missing someone. And an ability to drag yourself to do something for that person that you didn't think possible or wanted to do. And desire to go to their aide when they are suffering, or being able to laugh at things about them that aren't particularly attractive, or see the best in them at their worst.

And sometimes it's only defined when it's missing or gone.

It isn't tolerating abuse though. It does require reciprocation. But I don't think it ever dies, it gets transformed. As the law of thermodynamics goes, energy cannot be destroyed.

I have found your description of love helpful,but I guess I can't imagine missing someone if you don't like them. Would it be just missing the parts or snapshots of them you do like?

OP posts:
AirBubs · 11/06/2025 08:00

My love for my children is absolutely unconditional.

100% unconditional

crossstitchingnana · 11/06/2025 07:58

I was taught, years ago, that unconditional love only applies to family. Partners will always be conditional, ie people stop loving partners for all sorts of reasons; affairs, DV, changing, weight gain, getting the ick, losing their job etc etc.

With my kids, parents and brothers I just love them and can’t see a time when I wouldn’t.

OnePearlJoker · 11/06/2025 07:53

I agree. I think anyone who continues to love their child unconditionally after a horrific crime is a feeble idiot.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 11/06/2025 07:52

GreenLeavesInJuly · 11/06/2025 00:18

I don't feel that way. I think really shit behaviour makes you dislike the behaviour and to an extent the person. But love is bigger than that.

It's a gutteral thing - gut wrenching feeling of missing someone. And an ability to drag yourself to do something for that person that you didn't think possible or wanted to do. And desire to go to their aide when they are suffering, or being able to laugh at things about them that aren't particularly attractive, or see the best in them at their worst.

And sometimes it's only defined when it's missing or gone.

It isn't tolerating abuse though. It does require reciprocation. But I don't think it ever dies, it gets transformed. As the law of thermodynamics goes, energy cannot be destroyed.

This.