Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school system is ridiculous

531 replies

Suflan · 10/06/2025 21:11

This post is talking about the school system in the republic of Ireland, but I know that the school system in the UK has some similiatites, so this is also relevant to people in the UK.

I went to school in Ireland a long time ago, 20 years ago.

My younger cousins are just sitting their school leaving certificate (irish equivalent to a levels) this year and they and their friends have been posting about the exams, after it happened, on social media.

I was just thinking what they learn and do exams on is such a load of shite. Like how is it relevant or necessary in todays world at all.

They posted about their maths paper, all the quadratic equations, prove that point 5,1 is on the line etc etc, extremely complicated equations, and algebra.

Like what do you need that for in life? Its so totally pointless. And maths is mandatory to do, so they need points from maths to get into University.

Like what is the point of learning these things. Surely they should be learning something useful. My cousins have said to me that they think that a lot of what they learn is totally pointless too

OP posts:
healthyteeth · 11/06/2025 07:49

bipbopdo · 11/06/2025 06:59

It’s not just about logic and reasoning though. It teaches abstraction too, which is an important cognitive skill.

Again though, same point.
SO many ways to teach all of these things other than just algebra. To think we can only develop these skills via algebra is very naive.

sashh · 11/06/2025 07:46

Popsicle1981 · 11/06/2025 07:14

Mathematics upgrades the mind, as well as being foundational for many careers:

computer scientist
engineer
actuary
statistical analysis for academic research
economist
scientist
any career where an analytical, logical mindset is required

The OP is implying that anything more than basic maths be optional or not covered in a national curriculum. What would happen in their scenario is that well-off families would ensure their children received tutoring to have access to these careers. Everyone else would be limited in terms of prospects.

I'll add in lots of medical careers.

Paediatric medication is often given in x ml per Kg weight of child.

Radiographers need to calculate how much radiation they expose someone to.

Surgeons putting things like metal pins in your broken arm.

A chef scaling up a menu to feed 50 people at a wedding. Yes you can do it with ratios but you don't want to increase the salt content by 50.

bipbopdo · 11/06/2025 07:40

Suflan · 11/06/2025 07:34

"Makes me question whether you should be working in education"

What rubbish.

Wanting the currciulum to be updated and improved is a good thing.

I listen to students, and a lot of them want things in the education system to be changed.

The teachers in my school complain all the time about the English education system. You should hear the conversations in the staffroom. They want things to be improved.

Should they not be working in education either?

Students since time immemorial have wanted to change education. That doesn’t mean it’s the right thing to do. Designing a curriculum requires a lot of expertise that they won’t have yet.

A huge amount of time and effort goes into ensuring the curriculum hits all the right notes. It’s not like it comes from nowhere.

legyeleven · 11/06/2025 07:39

But HOW do you suggest changing it.

That’s the answer you aren’t giving.
Of course it can be updated and changed but cutting out key subjects and concepts is not a good good start!

My two pence worth. It should be broader, more subjects at a slightly lower level until 18. Coursework to account for at least 40% of the grade.

Sharptonguedwoman · 11/06/2025 07:37

Suflan · 10/06/2025 21:22

What careers use algebra?

For example accountancy requires a basic understanding of maths, but they dont use algebra

Did a quick google for jobs needing algebra:
Jeweller
Dietician/nutritionist
Air traffic controller
Working in broadcasting
Carpenter
Market research analyst
Buyer
Meteorologist

Just for starters

It's about being able to learn and think, as much as the subject.

Suflan · 11/06/2025 07:34

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/06/2025 07:09

The point you're missing OP is the subjects you study and the content of those subjects aren't the most important part of school. What's important is learning how to learn.

If you do that you can turn your brain to anything from algebra to Russian to car maintenance. It's about the discipline of critical thinking, skill acquisition and study.

Carping about how much you hate algebra and Shakespeare demonstrates that you haven't really grasped that most fundamental point about education.

I really don't enjoy maths either because I find it hard but I don't find it hard to understand that its hugely important and that many people get a huge amount of value from it.

You seem very hostile to the idea of learning in general and it really makes me question whether you should be working in education.

"Makes me question whether you should be working in education"

What rubbish.

Wanting the currciulum to be updated and improved is a good thing.

I listen to students, and a lot of them want things in the education system to be changed.

The teachers in my school complain all the time about the English education system. You should hear the conversations in the staffroom. They want things to be improved.

Should they not be working in education either?

OP posts:
MustTryHarderAndHarder · 11/06/2025 07:24

Fetaface · 10/06/2025 22:39

Doesn't matter the level it is still using algebra in daily life which Dave here says that he never does.

They were obviously talking about the complex algebra taught in A level maths, not basic maths that a primary school child should be able to do.

legyeleven · 11/06/2025 07:21

Honestly this thread has made me sad. We are so lucky to have the chance to study up until 18. You get the chance to use your brain every day and see where it takes you. As a teen you simply aren’t equipped to make decisions about what may or May not be relevant to you in the future. A good broad education gives the best foundations.
Op I really hope you aren’t telling the kids in your care about how useless it all is. Maybe rethink your career

oh and yes we could shake up education a bit but the basic cornerstones need to stay in place

MustTryHarderAndHarder · 11/06/2025 07:17

Tangfastic71 · 10/06/2025 23:02

You don’t “need” to pass maths at higher level to study history in most cases though? Certainly at UCD you don’t

So you fail the equivalent of A level maths in Ireland and still study history at uni at s good uni?

Popsicle1981 · 11/06/2025 07:14

Suflan · 10/06/2025 21:22

What careers use algebra?

For example accountancy requires a basic understanding of maths, but they dont use algebra

Mathematics upgrades the mind, as well as being foundational for many careers:

computer scientist
engineer
actuary
statistical analysis for academic research
economist
scientist
any career where an analytical, logical mindset is required

The OP is implying that anything more than basic maths be optional or not covered in a national curriculum. What would happen in their scenario is that well-off families would ensure their children received tutoring to have access to these careers. Everyone else would be limited in terms of prospects.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/06/2025 07:09

The point you're missing OP is the subjects you study and the content of those subjects aren't the most important part of school. What's important is learning how to learn.

If you do that you can turn your brain to anything from algebra to Russian to car maintenance. It's about the discipline of critical thinking, skill acquisition and study.

Carping about how much you hate algebra and Shakespeare demonstrates that you haven't really grasped that most fundamental point about education.

I really don't enjoy maths either because I find it hard but I don't find it hard to understand that its hugely important and that many people get a huge amount of value from it.

You seem very hostile to the idea of learning in general and it really makes me question whether you should be working in education.

Superhansrantowindsor · 11/06/2025 07:06

There is nothing wrong with learning for the sake of it. In fact, it should be encouraged.
I also agree with all the comments about algebra and how important it is. Just because I never use it doesn’t mean it’s not essential to others.

bipbopdo · 11/06/2025 06:59

healthyteeth · 11/06/2025 06:49

There are SO many other ways in this world to learn reasoning and logic other than algebra/quadratics etc!

We are so wedded to this outdated idea that we cannot see how single minded it is.

It’s not just about logic and reasoning though. It teaches abstraction too, which is an important cognitive skill.

Biskieboo · 11/06/2025 06:58

Suflan · 10/06/2025 22:28

Did you do maths to A level?

It's funny how no one is answering this key question....

I don't get why you think this is the 'gotcha' question you think it is, but since you asked me: yes I did. Further Maths too. Given I'd already said I've got a maths degree, somebody with decent deductive reasoning abilities (which maths is good for), wouldn't have needed to ask the question.

Anyhoo, in this wonderful world where all kids' opinions are 'valid' (whatever that means), I've just asked my son what he'd like to do at school. Football and Dude Perfect. A bright future awaits.

Fetaface · 11/06/2025 06:53

BreatheAndFocus · 11/06/2025 06:14

Algebra stretches the brain. Although some people won’t use it in adult life, the skills they learnt by doing it will continue with them and be applicable to other subjects, as well as having developed their brain.

Everyone uses algebra in adult life!

Fetaface · 11/06/2025 06:51

PyongyangKipperbang · 11/06/2025 01:45

And yet I bet you use algebra regularly but disregard it!

He clearly doesn't know what algebra is if he doesn't know that he uses it frequently in his daily life.

When he was at school he obviously didn't understand the concept and thinks it is all about letters and if he doesn't see a letter then it can't be algebra.

healthyteeth · 11/06/2025 06:49

mathanxiety · 11/06/2025 02:16

They're not 'learning those things' (i.e. quadratic equations, etc).

They're learning to reason using abstract terms and complex operations.

Learning to think is what education is about.

Everything else is training, not education.

Edited

There are SO many other ways in this world to learn reasoning and logic other than algebra/quadratics etc!

We are so wedded to this outdated idea that we cannot see how single minded it is.

WomenInSTEM · 11/06/2025 06:34

Suflan · 10/06/2025 21:26

In what area? In Some specific areas probably

Because i know a few people who work in the science industry, and they definitely don't use algebra in their jobs

Any scientific study applies statistical analysis to the data collected.

The stats tests used (there are many different ones, the test used depends on the type of data collected) involves equations and arithmetic.

All science involves maths and we definitely need scientists!

sashh · 11/06/2025 06:33

Suflan · 10/06/2025 21:19

But maths in particular. The curriculum looks like it was desigbed 100 years ago.

Algebra is so completely irrelevant in this day and age.

No it isn't. You use maths in virtually every practical subject. You might not notice it while you are cooking making a dress or putting petrol in the car.

AlertEagle · 11/06/2025 06:28

Suflan · 10/06/2025 21:11

This post is talking about the school system in the republic of Ireland, but I know that the school system in the UK has some similiatites, so this is also relevant to people in the UK.

I went to school in Ireland a long time ago, 20 years ago.

My younger cousins are just sitting their school leaving certificate (irish equivalent to a levels) this year and they and their friends have been posting about the exams, after it happened, on social media.

I was just thinking what they learn and do exams on is such a load of shite. Like how is it relevant or necessary in todays world at all.

They posted about their maths paper, all the quadratic equations, prove that point 5,1 is on the line etc etc, extremely complicated equations, and algebra.

Like what do you need that for in life? Its so totally pointless. And maths is mandatory to do, so they need points from maths to get into University.

Like what is the point of learning these things. Surely they should be learning something useful. My cousins have said to me that they think that a lot of what they learn is totally pointless too

I agree with you, no one that I know has had to use any algebra in their life

dayslikethese1 · 11/06/2025 06:23

Kids only hate school cos they haven't been to work yet. Then they'll look back and appreciate their 3pm finish and mass amount of holidays😁Seriously though OP, I can see hundreds of uses for algebra as pp have pointed out and I say that as someone who hated maths at school. Do you think other subjects are pointless too or just maths?

ladyamy · 11/06/2025 06:21

Soozikinzii · 10/06/2025 21:24

Maths should have one paper of pure maths and one paper of financial maths for life and work. And I have taught maths in mainstream comprehensive.

In Scotland there’s Maths, and Applications of Mathematics. The latter is not abstract and can be said it’s slightly easier.

BreatheAndFocus · 11/06/2025 06:14

Suflan · 10/06/2025 21:22

What careers use algebra?

For example accountancy requires a basic understanding of maths, but they dont use algebra

Algebra stretches the brain. Although some people won’t use it in adult life, the skills they learnt by doing it will continue with them and be applicable to other subjects, as well as having developed their brain.

CushionNeck · 11/06/2025 05:54

Algebra is probably one of the more useful and relevant parts of Maths. You should have chosen something else to denigrate, OP!

taptaroundtheworld · 11/06/2025 05:51

Maths is incredibly important- in my line of work a decent understanding of maths will quite easily triple your salary.
Project manager - screwed without
PA - absolutely necessary if you want to earn more than 15k a year (our current one is at 50k and will go higher - she’s amazing with budgets, planning etc)
Scientist and engineers: goes without saying
Researchers: absolute necessity
Designers: absolute necessity
and so on

Swipe left for the next trending thread