Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Love them like my own’ when it comes to step children?

40 replies

LotsOfSmallThings · 09/06/2025 15:51

So I see this quite often on here - posters saying they love their step kids like their own/the same as they love their own biological children. And I always wonder, really? Actually, really, do people feel exactly the same about their SC as their own children that they carried and raised and nurtured and loved from before they were even born? I just don’t get how it’s possible!
I have both DC and DSC and we are generally a happy, functional blend but when I see the ‘love them like my own’ thing it makes me feel like an arsehole because I absolutely do love my DSC, a lot, but not remotely in the same way I love my own DC - it’s just not comparable.
So I suppose my question is AIBU to actually NOT love my DSC like my own, but in a different way that is specific to them? And if you have SC, where do you fall on this/how do you love them and how do you feel about it?

OP posts:
Mightyhike · 09/06/2025 17:06

I've noticed that the people I know who really adore their step kids don't have biological kids of their own. I think it helps not to have that direct comparison.

TheWisePlumDuck · 09/06/2025 17:04

In my experience it is not really the same. I love dsd in a certain way, but it has always been more guarded and conditional than that for my own dc.

For instance, I know that if I and dh had ever split I probably would never have seen her again. I wouldn't have been in absolute pieces unable to carry on with my life, or going bankrupt for the courts to request access, like I would for my own dc, because I'm not batshit.

That also was never my role, she has a lovely mother already. She didnt need me to fill a gap because there was none.

The only person I've seen appear to feel and act the same way is someone whose stepchildren saw her as their mother (theirs had died when they were young) and she had no dc of her own.

TheNightSurgeon · 09/06/2025 16:55

Tandora · 09/06/2025 16:53

So you can only love people you have control over or something?

OP YANBU at all to say you don’t love your SDC like your own DC. However you feel is totally normal and natural.

However you are completely unreasonable to act like everyone should feel the same way as you. Circumstances are different, families are different, people are different , relationships are different. Some people do love their step children as their own, regardless of law, or biology. Those things don’t define a relationship at the end of the day.

So you can only love people you have control over or something?

Wtf, that's quite the reach.

Tandora · 09/06/2025 16:55

LotsOfSmallThings · 09/06/2025 16:40

It’s not inferior 🤷‍♀️ notice I didn’t say my love for DSC was inferior or less than, merely that it’s completely different and therefore not comparable. I think it’s a totally different thing with adopted DC vs DSC for all the reasons the poster above outlined, as well as the fact that the adoption process is long and gruelling and the DC is/are the end goal of it, whereas DSC are a side effect of a relationship rather than the aim of it - no one gets into a relationship with someone purely with the aim of becoming a step parent, whereas you go through the adoption process with the specific aim of adopting at the end of it.

Not sure why you are shrugging your shoulders at that pp, when you wrote this:

Actually, really, do people feel exactly the same about their SC as their own children that they carried and raised and nurtured and loved from before they were even born?

That doesn’t apply to many adoptive parents/ children but they are loved just the same,

Tandora · 09/06/2025 16:53

TheNightSurgeon · 09/06/2025 16:36

I don't think that's a comparison really.

You are a parent, if you and your dp split, you'll still be a parent.

You make decisions about your dc, you have a say in thir lives, you'll have a space at their wedding with no fuss, you'll be a grandparent, no question.

It's an entirely different scenario with a step child, the relationship is based entirely in the relationship with their parent.

As a step parent your expected to love them as your own without reciprocation, or the reciprocation has rules attached.

So you can only love people you have control over or something?

OP YANBU at all to say you don’t love your SDC like your own DC. However you feel is totally normal and natural.

However you are completely unreasonable to act like everyone should feel the same way as you. Circumstances are different, families are different, people are different , relationships are different. Some people do love their step children as their own, regardless of law, or biology. Those things don’t define a relationship at the end of the day.

Victoriawould24 · 09/06/2025 16:46

And to add to that Adoptive parents are the sole parents whereas a step mum is sharing but more likely secondary in hierarchy to the actual mum. I think to cope with this weird dynamic you have to consciously or other wise develop a different kind of love / relationship - like self preservation because loving someone else’s child as you own that is already loved by their mum could lead to a life of eternal rejection and heartache coming last.

jeaux90 · 09/06/2025 16:44

I would die for my DD. It’s my partners job to die for his DS. Fundamentally that is the difference. Love them both, yes.

ohpoowhatnow · 09/06/2025 16:42

That’s weird I had this conversation with my mum yesterday. I care about my step kids and want the best for them but definitely don’t love them which probably makes me a horrible cow but I can’t help it.

LotsOfSmallThings · 09/06/2025 16:40

Createausername1970 · 09/06/2025 16:31

Errr... What about us adoptive parents?

I didn't carry DS, nor raise or nurture him until he was three. I don't like the implication that my love for him is inferior.

It’s not inferior 🤷‍♀️ notice I didn’t say my love for DSC was inferior or less than, merely that it’s completely different and therefore not comparable. I think it’s a totally different thing with adopted DC vs DSC for all the reasons the poster above outlined, as well as the fact that the adoption process is long and gruelling and the DC is/are the end goal of it, whereas DSC are a side effect of a relationship rather than the aim of it - no one gets into a relationship with someone purely with the aim of becoming a step parent, whereas you go through the adoption process with the specific aim of adopting at the end of it.

OP posts:
TheNightSurgeon · 09/06/2025 16:36

Createausername1970 · 09/06/2025 16:31

Errr... What about us adoptive parents?

I didn't carry DS, nor raise or nurture him until he was three. I don't like the implication that my love for him is inferior.

I don't think that's a comparison really.

You are a parent, if you and your dp split, you'll still be a parent.

You make decisions about your dc, you have a say in thir lives, you'll have a space at their wedding with no fuss, you'll be a grandparent, no question.

It's an entirely different scenario with a step child, the relationship is based entirely in the relationship with their parent.

As a step parent your expected to love them as your own without reciprocation, or the reciprocation has rules attached.

Createausername1970 · 09/06/2025 16:31

Errr... What about us adoptive parents?

I didn't carry DS, nor raise or nurture him until he was three. I don't like the implication that my love for him is inferior.

Victoriawould24 · 09/06/2025 16:30

I can confidently say I do love my step child and make similar sacrifices for them as I did my own but the love is not the same at all.

MorrisZapp · 09/06/2025 16:28

I was and am loved by my stepfather as much as he loves his own kids. He was bonkersly in love with my mum and I dare say that led to him investing so much in all of us. They've been separated for 15 years but he's an equal grandad to all the kids. He nursed us through illness, helped with uni applications etc like any dad. I don't think he's in any way typical though.

Holluschickie · 09/06/2025 16:13

I would be at best indifferent to step children.I find other people's kids boring and exhausting.

This is why I would never be a stepmum.

Drummend01 · 09/06/2025 16:08

To each their own, as long as your step children feel the love from you and feel safe with you, trust you etc then that’s what matters. I’m sure you’re not saying to them “I don’t love you like I do my biological children”, so as long as they can’t feel the difference then sounds like you’re doing a great job as a blended family

I have a DSC but no biological children yet, I don’t know how it compares and I don’t know how I will feel but right now I love her so much, I would give my life for her and often watch her with wonder at how I get to be part of this little girls life.

My partner and I discussed early on about adoption, it’s always something I’ve considered and I truly feel like I could love that child as I would a child that I birthed. My partner doesn't think he would feel the same, neither of us are wrong or right.