Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s a real crisis in men being able to express how they truly feel about life and society?

365 replies

TheGentleSwan · 08/06/2025 18:56

It feels like, in the West, men are struggling to be honest about their emotions, their frustrations, and how they view the world. Whether it’s societal pressure, fear of judgement, or just a lack of spaces to talk openly, it seems like many men keep things bottled up. AIBU to think this is a real issue?

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 09/06/2025 04:15

Funny they seem more than willing to open up about all sorts of topics they know fuck all about, offering opinions willynilly when not asked.

If men can't talk about sensitive stuff, because other men are dicks to them over it... I'd say thats a man problem, they need to sort themselves out.

SO far though the loudest group seem to be the ones who want to sit in their mommys basements bitching about how its all womens fault. They probably aren't really the majority but until sensible men put these incel twerps back in their boxes, they're sure sounding like they're a majority.

echt · 09/06/2025 04:04

FluentLilacPombear · 09/06/2025 03:46

Have you seen the rates of domestic violence in lesbian relationships?

Staggering.

Are you expecting lesbian women to STFU about their problems till they stop battering each other?

Thought not.

Misandry is just as unacceptable as misogyny.

Hugely misses the point.

If lesbian relationships are as violent as you claim, with no evidence whatsoever, they'd still be women in the society outlined by @Bulldogdreams bar the marital violence, i.e. Could you imagine a life where we were safe to go running at night ,or safe to walk home from the pub a few blocks ,or safe in our homes from the man we married,or safe from sexual abuse by our male relatives .or safe from our boss and his wandering hands ...it would be amazing

Bulldogdreams · 09/06/2025 04:02

FluentLilacPombear · 09/06/2025 03:46

Have you seen the rates of domestic violence in lesbian relationships?

Staggering.

Are you expecting lesbian women to STFU about their problems till they stop battering each other?

Thought not.

Misandry is just as unacceptable as misogyny.

Maybe start a thread about that ,sounds awful,no I'd not realized the rates of violence were so high in lesbian relationships.
But this is a thread about men ,so I was replying about men

FluentLilacPombear · 09/06/2025 03:46

Bulldogdreams · 09/06/2025 03:33

I have no inclination to discuss mens mental health, until their violence towards women is discussed and stopped.
Maybe if they stop battering women ,they may find more people to talk to them .
Could you imagine a life where we were safe to go running at night ,or safe to walk home from the pub a few blocks ,or safe in our homes from the man we married,or safe from sexual abuse by our male relatives .or safe from our boss and his wandering hands ...it would be amazing

Have you seen the rates of domestic violence in lesbian relationships?

Staggering.

Are you expecting lesbian women to STFU about their problems till they stop battering each other?

Thought not.

Misandry is just as unacceptable as misogyny.

Firefly1987 · 09/06/2025 03:44

HowardTJMoon · 08/06/2025 19:09

I think you're right that many men struggle to express emotions. We're often raised/socialised with the view that the only acceptable emotions that can be expressed are happiness and anger. I've recently attended a personal and professional development course aimed at men where this is a topic that came up a lot.

There are a fair number of efforts underway to encourage men to speak up. It's certainly a lot better than it was 30 years ago when I could have done with something like that.

This is a male problem whose solution needs to be, and is, spearheaded by men. But I have to say that the toxic views of what men should be like aren't solely held by men. There's a fair number of women out there who are repulsed by the idea of a man showing vulnerability or weakness and that doesn't help.

Who is telling you anger is an acceptable emotion? Not women I'll bet, I for one want to be nowhere near an angry man. Anger is an undesirable emotion to have, even more so for men. So why is it always the default emotion out of all the other "undesirable" emotions? You don't think women would far rather a man show vulnerability than anger? Male anger and violence (which it often leads to) is ALWAYS spoken about as a huge issue, why do men always ignore this and pretend they've been told it's the only acceptable emotion they can have?

Bulldogdreams · 09/06/2025 03:33

I have no inclination to discuss mens mental health, until their violence towards women is discussed and stopped.
Maybe if they stop battering women ,they may find more people to talk to them .
Could you imagine a life where we were safe to go running at night ,or safe to walk home from the pub a few blocks ,or safe in our homes from the man we married,or safe from sexual abuse by our male relatives .or safe from our boss and his wandering hands ...it would be amazing

FeministUnderTheCatriarchy · 09/06/2025 03:23

Just to add:
It is not the responsibility of the oppressed to help the oppressor.

When men begin to actively change society in favor of equality, then a conversation can happen.

But what motivation do men have for society to change, when it benefits them far more than it harms them.

FeministUnderTheCatriarchy · 09/06/2025 03:15

Women attempt suicide more than men. Men just choose more violent methods which are in line with their general nature, so they are more successful.

If we use those stats to say there is a men's mental health crisis, then equally (if not more so) there is a women's one.

It is laughable PPs saying "women hold all the power" in dating.
Women are told they have an expiration date. You have successful vivacious women being passed over by substandard men who are going for women 20 years younger than them. And when those younger women don't want them, they don't look inward, they just rage against women as a whole.

Men aren't sending photos of their date to a friend for safety in case they get raped or murdered.

And I'm sorry, but when 1 in 6 girls stop being sexually abused and 1 in 4 women sexually assaulted or raped and two women every week being killed by men... Maybe then, I will be open to a conversation about how tough men have it.

But if I am being honest, I will probably tell them to get out and make the change that they want to see happen. Just like women have had to. We have had to fight for everything we have been given, whereas men are used to being handed things in a society shaped for them.

Bulldogdreams · 09/06/2025 03:00

TheGentleSwan · 08/06/2025 18:56

It feels like, in the West, men are struggling to be honest about their emotions, their frustrations, and how they view the world. Whether it’s societal pressure, fear of judgement, or just a lack of spaces to talk openly, it seems like many men keep things bottled up. AIBU to think this is a real issue?

When they are not raping and murdering us ,you mean ..
I think mens violence towards women is a far bigger problem.
Why can't they control themselves

SD1978 · 09/06/2025 02:53

Yes and no- there are many men’s mental health podcasts out now- and they (many of them) seem to be toxic as fuck under the guise of this is how men are/ think/ act.

ntmdino · 09/06/2025 02:50

5128gap · 08/06/2025 23:14

If you don't believe white male privilege exists, why are white men so disproportionately represented at the top of our society? The power holders, the decision makers, the highest earners? Do you think that white men are disproportionately more intelligent and competent than women and people of colour?

Look a bit closer...is there anything else those people (including the women in those positions) have in common?

Could it be...money, as @SquashedMallow said?

SquashedMallow · 08/06/2025 23:23

5128gap · 08/06/2025 23:14

If you don't believe white male privilege exists, why are white men so disproportionately represented at the top of our society? The power holders, the decision makers, the highest earners? Do you think that white men are disproportionately more intelligent and competent than women and people of colour?

Ok, so uk is a predominantly white country by a very large majority - therefore far more white people will be in power. Same way if you went to the African continent, most of their leaders , if not all will be black.

Why more men ? Traditionally the majority of women have children, this will impact their career to some degree logistically. Men are more likely to take no career breaks and be able to steam ahead.

There are many, many, many female politicians, CEOs etc. have you not looked around lately ? We're not in the 1930s anymore.

I think that covers why the majority of "high up" people are white males. I'd argue there are a fair few women in high up places though in 2025.

5128gap · 08/06/2025 23:14

SquashedMallow · 08/06/2025 23:02

You've drank the kool aid I'm afraid. "You can't be racist to white people " that's untrue. We're brainwashed now to take that as fact.

"White males are especially privileged" untrue. (See above )

This division helps nobody.

In 2025 females and people of colour are not lawfully discriminated against In UK countries- in fact there is moreso positive discrimination occuring. I'm not even bothered really about it, although I do think job should be given on merit, not because someone has wet their knickers that a black women has applied.

The only true privilege that exists really today is wealth. Wealth buys things, wealth attracts status and equally wealthy friends, business partners and associates. Money talks. All the rest is utter bullshit that we've all swallowed.

If you don't believe white male privilege exists, why are white men so disproportionately represented at the top of our society? The power holders, the decision makers, the highest earners? Do you think that white men are disproportionately more intelligent and competent than women and people of colour?

BountifulPantry · 08/06/2025 23:10

I don’t know if this has been mentioned upthread but the success of Andy’s Man Club shows stuff is changing

JenniferBooth · 08/06/2025 23:07

OneAmberFinch · 08/06/2025 21:49

I think it's also important to disentangle "men aren't telling us what their issues are" and "I don't like the implications of what they are saying".

For example: dating apps & general modern sexual culture - it is well known that "sexual freedom" has led to an imbalanced dating market with hot guys sleeping with multiple women casually while most get nothing.

In the past when women had fewer options and consensus was to get married before sleeping together, more young men were able to settle down with a wife and make a life.

Obviously this came with some side effects, like shame for women who had sex outside of marriage, or being trapped in abusive relationships, or being pressured to marry etc.

But there's this dynamic where men will say - usually via some ironic meme rather than a confession in therapy - that they long for the world where you could be pretty confident you'd find a wife and have a nice life in the suburbs! And the response will either be (1) "so you want to bring back forced marriages" or (2) blank silence and "why won't men talk about their issues" - because we just refuse to acknowledge what was lost because we value too much what we gained

Well according to Louise Perry we didnt gain much.

https://www.thefp.com/p/loveless-sex-is-not-empowering

What Sexual Liberation Really Looks Like

Hookup culture benefits men at the expense of women.

https://www.thefp.com/p/loveless-sex-is-not-empowering

SquashedMallow · 08/06/2025 23:02

Itsonlypantsandsocks · 08/06/2025 22:52

It’s not ok to be abusive to anyone. True. It’s not helpful to make sweeping judgements about any group of people. True.

White men however, are not a protected group, precisely because they hold so much privilege. As a group, there is no comparison to those who experience discrimination based on their protected Characteristic. You really can’t compare it.

You've drank the kool aid I'm afraid. "You can't be racist to white people " that's untrue. We're brainwashed now to take that as fact.

"White males are especially privileged" untrue. (See above )

This division helps nobody.

In 2025 females and people of colour are not lawfully discriminated against In UK countries- in fact there is moreso positive discrimination occuring. I'm not even bothered really about it, although I do think job should be given on merit, not because someone has wet their knickers that a black women has applied.

The only true privilege that exists really today is wealth. Wealth buys things, wealth attracts status and equally wealthy friends, business partners and associates. Money talks. All the rest is utter bullshit that we've all swallowed.

SquashedMallow · 08/06/2025 22:56

housesellin · 08/06/2025 19:16

You mean, men are facing the consequences of their own actions?

Maybe if men stopped killing their partners, they’d have someone to talk to and express themselves with :)

What a horrible and sensationalist generalisation about "men" as a group

Let's replace that shall we with, I dunno, say Muslims. "If Muslims stopped bombing people we might accept them " . Crass isn't it ? It's no more acceptable to generalise in the first example as it is the second.

JenniferBooth · 08/06/2025 22:55

Styker · 08/06/2025 21:27

Also follow childfree women over 30 on Instagram and you’ll see random males - (sometimes with women /wives/daughters in their profile pics) trolling them with terrible abuse when they post a holiday reel or a picture of a girls brunch etc.

They seem incredibly angry that some women have chosen not to have children - whether it’s because they don’t want children or they haven’t found a suitable partner yet.

They also troll single mothers. Go figure.

And yes as pp have said- anger is an emotion too.

Im child free by choice Im now in my early 50s. I went for a job interview back in 2004 Got asked by the male interviewer if i was planning to have children. I said no and that i didnt want them. He asked if i was frightened of responsibility. I got offered the job and had no choice but to take it as i was sent there by the Job Centre who arent known for being champions of equality. In the late 90s when both DH and i were sighning on they took me to one side to sign an agreement saying i would do part time work. DH had to sign no such thing.

MsTamborineMan · 08/06/2025 22:53

Tartanboots · 08/06/2025 22:11

The men I know are all well able to express themselves, emotions and all. And they are from a range of backgrounds.
Changing roles mean that men don't have to shoulder all the financial burdens of a family, be strong and silent all the time etc, now. That's a good thing. Its a shame that some factions (both male and female) want to drag us back to the 1950s.

I also think this is true

I have lots of male friends and they are all kind, decent men. They express their emotions well. I've seen a good proportion of them cry. They've kept long term friendships and prop each other up. They call each other on the way to work and in their lunch breaks. In exactly the same ways as my female friends. None of these men are hot guys but all have wonderful, intelligent girlfriends/wives.

The discourse online that men can't open up, are all lonely, have societal pressure to not display emotion is just not true, and I think is often a reflection of mens misogyny and anger towards women rather than an accurate depiction of reality. Most men I know do have community, friendships and support and are frequently emotionally vunerable.

Itsonlypantsandsocks · 08/06/2025 22:52

SquashedMallow · 08/06/2025 22:41

I agree. At the moment white males are a real target for abusive comparison. They're the only group that we hurl defamatory insults at and downplay their successes and achievements under the "you only got where you are because you're a straight white privileged male". Men aren't all abusive narcissistic bullies. White males are also kind, loving, generous, helpful , and peaceful. We're abusing and mocking innocents in this 'target all ' put down. People forget, that for many , our sons are going to grow up to be this target group.

Once again, I think women are really enjoying jumping on the victim bandwagon by labelling all men big bad bullies. These competitive victimhood and insult hurling has to stop. If you don't pick on a group of black females, or gay males, you don't blanket a group of white straight males either.

So, in conclusion, how some men are instantly wrong for their very "privileged " existence, no wonder they daren't express much

It’s not ok to be abusive to anyone. True. It’s not helpful to make sweeping judgements about any group of people. True.

White men however, are not a protected group, precisely because they hold so much privilege. As a group, there is no comparison to those who experience discrimination based on their protected Characteristic. You really can’t compare it.

EmeraldRoulette · 08/06/2025 22:50

Couple of posters have mentioned men and friendship. There's a nice conversation here that you might be interested in. Those of you looking for male role models for kids might want to look at this. But generally, it's a good conversation about friendship. Maybe of interest to men and women.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=CNBxIhxHHxM&pp=0gcJCdgAo7VqN5tD

SquashedMallow · 08/06/2025 22:46

MsTamborineMan · 08/06/2025 22:14

I think that men essentially expect support from others, and women often don't. And this means they process and rationalise their emotions differently. Many men get angry and become more distressed when they don't receive the level of support they expect

Another part of my job is carrying out surgical procedures under local. Men will again immediately make it known if they are in pain, or discomfort, usually by moaning or spluttering, they will quite frequently be rude or aggressive. They will question me more than women. Women will often tolerate discomfort, ( I give all my patients a signal to give if they are in discomfort) they are more polite

Of course this is generalising. There are many, many decent men. But I think it's absolute crap that men don't have the space to express their emotions and women do. Women suffer with higher rates of mental illness than men, and attempt suicide at the same rate. The men's mental health crisis is MRA propaganda, designed to discredit feminism, talked about in Andrew tate/reddit spaces. Its used in the same way abusive men will often threaten to kill themselves. Women should not be expected to do yet more emotional labor to cure men of their mental health problems

It's strange you say that, I've found the opposite. I'm generalising of course, but young to middle aged women I find often are very expressive at any perceived level of pain, men I find (more so older ones, granted) tend to grimace and feel they mustn't "make a fuss,". I think we're really cruel to men as a general population.

EmeraldRoulette · 08/06/2025 22:46

@TheGentleSwan "Mocking abusive behaviour and creating space for emotional honesty aren’t mutually exclusive but if we blur the lines too much, we risk reinforcing the very silence we claim to want to challenge"

you claim that there is a silence and that you want to challenge it. I don't know why you keep saying "we". You have said it quite a lot.

I actually find it a very old-fashioned idea that men can't talk about their feelings. It's 2025! I don't think anything cultural is stopping them. If there is something, then it's under the control of men. It's not something I can do anything about. Nor, the majority of posters on here, who are women.

If it is, it's a bit like telling people to go off-line and touch grass. if we are adults, at some point we have to take responsibility for ourselves, our actions and the media we consume. This is not specific to men or women. Even if you look at this board, if someone posts things that show clearly they have been consuming a bunch of crazy online stuff, they get told to touch grass very quickly.

You have consistently talked about this as if you think everyone should agree that this is a problem. I don't claim to be an expert, but I'm not sure it is a problem. And as many posters have said, there are resources set up for men specifically.

ntmdino · 08/06/2025 22:44

MsTamborineMan · 08/06/2025 22:39

Again this is just MRA propaganda.
There's equal amount of men and women. There are lots and lots and lots of women swiping yes on not the "hot guys".

If men are struggling on dating apps they can go to the gym, work on their skincare routine, dress well and write something interesting. Like women do.

My husband works in a male dominated field, he has lots of singles colleagues who moan that they can't get women, he points out that a)they don't really like women b) they have nothing to offer women and c)their expectations of women they will find attractive are way too high. Your incredibly naive to think that men have a good grasp of their league

It really isn't. Take Bumble and Tinder, for example - there are two (Bumble) to three (Tinder) times as many men on dating sites as there are women. That, by definition, puts the choices almost entirely in the hands of the women.

Out of each 100 users, 11 women and 11 men will be matched. That's a 30-50% success rate for women, and a 15-20% success rate for men. It will never be more than that, by definition.

And, you'll note if you read my comment carefully, that I was talking about the women referred to in the previous comment - the ones who complain that they're being ghosted after a one-nighter. That's because the guys who've found success on there know exactly how to play the game, and they're in just as much of a minority as the women on there.

SquashedMallow · 08/06/2025 22:41

TheGentleSwan · 08/06/2025 18:56

It feels like, in the West, men are struggling to be honest about their emotions, their frustrations, and how they view the world. Whether it’s societal pressure, fear of judgement, or just a lack of spaces to talk openly, it seems like many men keep things bottled up. AIBU to think this is a real issue?

I agree. At the moment white males are a real target for abusive comparison. They're the only group that we hurl defamatory insults at and downplay their successes and achievements under the "you only got where you are because you're a straight white privileged male". Men aren't all abusive narcissistic bullies. White males are also kind, loving, generous, helpful , and peaceful. We're abusing and mocking innocents in this 'target all ' put down. People forget, that for many , our sons are going to grow up to be this target group.

Once again, I think women are really enjoying jumping on the victim bandwagon by labelling all men big bad bullies. These competitive victimhood and insult hurling has to stop. If you don't pick on a group of black females, or gay males, you don't blanket a group of white straight males either.

So, in conclusion, how some men are instantly wrong for their very "privileged " existence, no wonder they daren't express much