Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH is accusing me of cheating because DS “looks nothing like him” - wtf??

214 replies

Gamyerco · 07/06/2025 19:08

Need to let this out cos I’m fuming. Been with DH nearly a decade, married 7 yrs, DS is 3. Out of nowhere today he says he’s been “thinking for a while” that DS doesn’t look like him and he’s not sure he’s the dad. Like… what??

DS has my colouring - brown eyes, dark hair. DH is lighter, blue eyes, dark blonde. But DS has his exact chin and same daft sticky out ears. It’s not like he came out looking like the postman.

Now DH is moping round the house, barely talking to me, keeps going quiet then saying stuff like “I just can’t stop thinking about it” and “maybe we should do a test”. I’m gobsmacked. Never even looked at another man. Had a bloody EMCS, couldn’t even walk for weeks after giving birth and now he’s chucking this at me?

Told him he’s being ridiculous and hurtful. He reckons he’s “just being honest”. Nah mate, you’re being a prat.

I honestly dunno where this is coming from. He’s never been insecure like this before. I think maybe it’s cos DS is all over me at the moment and barely gives DH the time of day, but still - accusing me of cheating? That’s serious. I’m properly hurt.

Has anyone else had this crap? Did you manage to move past it or is this the start of the end?

OP posts:
Boopdasnoot · 08/06/2025 00:21

Enrichetta · 07/06/2025 19:10

(1) get a DNA test
(2) take steps to leave your ‘D’H

I don’t think there is any coming back from this…

God almighty- this! Came on to say the same thing. I’d be off like a shot.

Gamyerco · 08/06/2025 00:05

Thanks again all – honestly this thread is keeping me sane right now. Haven’t said anything to real life mates yet, feel too raw, so it’s helping loads just to get it out here.

No, he hasn’t said anything to DS (as far as I know) but I’m watching like a hawk now. If I even suspect he’s putting this shite in DS’s head I’ll be out the door faster than you can say CMS. No way is my boy growing up thinking his dad doubted him like that. Not having it.

Re the phone – good idea. I’m gonna try it, when we’re calm enough to talk. Will tell him straight: I’ll do the test, but I see your phone right now. No warning, no time to delete anything. If he refuses, then I’ve got my answer.

And yeah, now I think about it, he has always dipped out of the crap jobs – nappies, night feeds, bath time. Says he’s “not good with that stuff”. But then sulks cos DS always comes to me. Wonder why eh.

I’ve had enough of walking on eggshells. Feel like this is the first proper time I’ve let myself look at the whole picture – and it’s not great is it. I’ve been doing all the emotional graft, all the parenting, keeping the house going, and now I’m being accused of cheating on top. It’s laughable if it wasn’t so bloody depressing.

Gonna try to sleep but doubt I’ll manage much. Just feel hollow.

OP posts:
MeTooOverHere · 08/06/2025 00:02

Gamyerco · 07/06/2025 19:08

Need to let this out cos I’m fuming. Been with DH nearly a decade, married 7 yrs, DS is 3. Out of nowhere today he says he’s been “thinking for a while” that DS doesn’t look like him and he’s not sure he’s the dad. Like… what??

DS has my colouring - brown eyes, dark hair. DH is lighter, blue eyes, dark blonde. But DS has his exact chin and same daft sticky out ears. It’s not like he came out looking like the postman.

Now DH is moping round the house, barely talking to me, keeps going quiet then saying stuff like “I just can’t stop thinking about it” and “maybe we should do a test”. I’m gobsmacked. Never even looked at another man. Had a bloody EMCS, couldn’t even walk for weeks after giving birth and now he’s chucking this at me?

Told him he’s being ridiculous and hurtful. He reckons he’s “just being honest”. Nah mate, you’re being a prat.

I honestly dunno where this is coming from. He’s never been insecure like this before. I think maybe it’s cos DS is all over me at the moment and barely gives DH the time of day, but still - accusing me of cheating? That’s serious. I’m properly hurt.

Has anyone else had this crap? Did you manage to move past it or is this the start of the end?

NO personal experience but the manosphere advises men to always get a DNA test, because so many women cheat (allegedly). If the woman refuses this is taken as proof she cheated and is trying to get him to pay to raise another man's child. "If she was innocent, she'd not refuse."
Has he been getting onto incel sites lately? Or has one of his mates been maybe?

Givingitagoodgo · 08/06/2025 00:00

Maybe a dna test and then therapy for your DH.

You may find that it is a projection, but therapy may get to the bottom of it.

Give yourself a set amount of time to see if you can forgive him. You must be heartbroken.

Sending a virtual hug x

SpeakingAsAManKlaxon · 07/06/2025 23:56

Calliopespa · 07/06/2025 23:50

Things like height don’t work with a punnett square. They are continuous not just dominant/recessive.

Even a punnett square can’t explain genetics neither parent possesses for continuous data. But the poster has clarified what she meant now.

Edited

I appreciate that punnett squares are limited, and are poor predictors of some traits but, similarly, two short parents can produce a tall child (its just less likely).

I'm 6" taller than either of my parents.

Lookuptotheskies · 07/06/2025 23:50

I would also bet money he's cheating. It's such a cliche that they project and view others with their own shitty moral standards. 😡

I'd say nothing for now. Nada.

But I'd definitely be trying to see his phone. I'd also be getting my ducks in a row to leave.

Calliopespa · 07/06/2025 23:50

SpeakingAsAManKlaxon · 07/06/2025 23:23

Genetics.... dominant and recessive genes... you very likely covered punnett squares in school at some point.

Things like height don’t work with a punnett square. They are continuous not just dominant/recessive.

Even a punnett square can’t explain genetics neither parent possesses for continuous data. But the poster has clarified what she meant now.

Calliopespa · 07/06/2025 23:47

scotstars · 07/06/2025 23:20

Sorry missed punctuation...I meant neither of us have the tall and slim build hes got the best of both sets of genes. The blue eyes and fair skin is genetic from me 🤣🙈

Oh I see! That makes more sense!

MNersSufferFromContextomy · 07/06/2025 23:33

Gamyerco · 07/06/2025 20:55

Yeah you’re all right – it’s bloody grim. I did a bit of digging earlier and some of the vids in his watch history are full-on MRA crap. Proper toxic stuff. “All women cheat”, “paternity fraud is normal”, “masculinity under attack” – absolute brain sludge. Can’t believe he’s gone from normal, funny, mostly decent bloke to this overnight. Feels like I’ve lost him to the internet.

I might try saying that to him, that I see what’s happening and he needs to snap out of it if there’s any hope. But truth is, part of me’s already halfway out the door. I don’t even want to touch him right now. Don’t want him near me. It’s not just the accusation – it’s that he looked me dead in the eye and said he didn’t know if DS was his. After everything. How do you come back from that?

He’s upstairs now watching telly like nothing’s happened. I’m downstairs shaking.

I’ll get the test sorted, more for my own sanity at this point. But yeah. He’s a prize cockwomble and I deserve better. Just need to get through the next few days without crying in front of DS.

Blimey OP! Having red all of your updates the evidence is clear, isn’t it? It hasn’t happened over night though, you’ve been watching it unfold in plain sight for some time.

time to get your shit together and protect yourself. Couples counselling is likely the only solution. I’m sorry but good luck op!

rach2713 · 07/06/2025 23:27

I have 3 girls who are all totally different. 1st is the spit of her dad nothing like me but still makes her mine as I pushed her out lol. 2nd girl is a very good mix of both and 3rd girl is just me lookings hair color and attitude nothing like her dad at all he has never once said to me he thinks she is someone else's as he knows how genetics work sometime they take after more of 1 person than the other.

SpeakingAsAManKlaxon · 07/06/2025 23:23

Calliopespa · 07/06/2025 23:11

um … how is he like that then ?!

Genetics.... dominant and recessive genes... you very likely covered punnett squares in school at some point.

scotstars · 07/06/2025 23:20

Calliopespa · 07/06/2025 23:11

um … how is he like that then ?!

Sorry missed punctuation...I meant neither of us have the tall and slim build hes got the best of both sets of genes. The blue eyes and fair skin is genetic from me 🤣🙈

imnotwhoyouthinkiam · 07/06/2025 23:19

JoBrandsCleaner · 07/06/2025 23:07

Well get a DNA test. You’ll need it to claim maintenance when you split up.

Edited

You don't need one assuming he's on the BC. He can contest paternity, but he'll be liable for CM unless he gets a negative test. And I think the CMS have certain services that they use so he can't fake it.

Calliopespa · 07/06/2025 23:11

scotstars · 07/06/2025 23:09

I don't think I could come back from this op..he's accusing you of cheating, the worst type of deception with zero grounds just because he's got an idea in his head.
I could say many things about my ex dp but he never once questioned parentage and our son looks nothing like him - distinct hair colour (that neither of us have) fair skin, blue eyes tall and extremely slight when neither of us are like that!

um … how is he like that then ?!

scotstars · 07/06/2025 23:09

I don't think I could come back from this op..he's accusing you of cheating, the worst type of deception with zero grounds just because he's got an idea in his head.
I could say many things about my ex dp but he never once questioned parentage and our son looks nothing like him - distinct hair colour (that neither of us have) fair skin, blue eyes tall and extremely slight when neither of us are like that!

HeyWiggle · 07/06/2025 23:09

The incel stuff is bloody awful

JoBrandsCleaner · 07/06/2025 23:07

Well get a DNA test. You’ll need it to claim maintenance when you split up.

SpeakingAsAManKlaxon · 07/06/2025 23:06

To me, this doesn't sound like a accusation born from him being unfaithful. He sounds more like he's fallen down the MRA rabbit hole, and is well along the path of radicalization (as evidenced by his baseless accusations and the hurt they are causing his family).

I can somewhat understand lonely and isolated men (who arent inherently awful) getting sucked into this nonsense, but one with a wife and child? He's likely just instinctively very misogynistic, and the prominence of the likes of Tate now makes him feel emboldened to show his true colours.

Honestly, I couldn't respect someone like that or maintain a relationship with them, nor do I think there's likely any way back. I expect he will become worse over time.

Sorry, OP, but I think its ducks in a row time, and if you try to make the relationship survive, I think you will likely come to regret it.

There might be a slim chance of him snapping out of it if you take decisive action and separate, but I wouldn't bank on it.

FWIW, which is probably nothing, I've made an appropriate namechange for this post.

Calliopespa · 07/06/2025 23:05

Gamyerco · 07/06/2025 21:37

Yeah I’ve wondered that too. DS has always been a bit of a mummy’s boy and lately he’s full-on clingy with me, won’t let DH do bedtime, pushes him away sometimes. Think it’s bruised his ego a bit tbh. But instead of working on bonding with him, he’s jumped to “he must not be mine” like a bloody toddler himself.

You’re right tho – I’ll get the test sorted, if nothing else for DS so he never has to deal with this hanging over him. He deserves better than this weird cloud of doubt.

As for the rest of it… yeah. Only I know the full picture but it’s not looking good right now. Can’t stop thinking that if he wanted a reason to walk away, he’s just created one.

Well that’s kinda what they do: create a reason for you to walk away. That way they get what they want but don’t actually have to take the plunge or wear the guilt.

TheOrphanTree · 07/06/2025 22:57

One of my DC looks nothing like me (I'm their mum!) so it's perfectly possible to be completely genetically related and look absolutely nothing like one of your parents!

Your DH has put one drop of poison into your marriage but that's all it takes to kill it.

planetfall · 07/06/2025 22:49

I'm so sorry. My first thought was that he wants OUT of the marriage and out of any and all parenting responsibilities and doesn't have the courage to discuss this with you. Instead, he's making you reject him/end things, and then he will play the victim to the outside world while casting you as the villain. The cowards who do this often go way too far, wanting to make absolutely sure their partner HAS to end a relationship they've made intolerable and there's no way to back out. And bonus for him, when asked why the breakup happened he just says that the two if you fell out when he confronted you about pretending that the baby was his, garnering him sympathy for the ignorant. In his mind, he's not even lying.

Whatever else you do, consider telling him in no uncertain terms that there's no chance that the baby's not his biological child, and he can fully expect to be doing his half of the parenting for the next fifteen plus years including paying his share of the costs and doing his share of the work, and he needs to drop the insane misogynistic bigotry in order to parent a son. Then take the test but be prepared for him to start ranting about you poking holes in the condom, or whatever. But remind him, he hasn't just accused you of cheating on him, but also of lying, for years, about the most important thing in both of your lives. Not just to him but to everyone, including your son. If he ever was a decent human, he must be feeling at least a tiny bit of dissonance about this.

YRGAM · 07/06/2025 22:46

imnotwhoyouthinkiam · 07/06/2025 21:40

What a prick he is.

When DS1 was born my then in-laws told DP that he couldn't possibly be the father because DS was blonde and no one in their family is blonde. My entire family are though! Luckily he told them where to go.

20 years later DS' hair is dark blonde/ light brown, but other than that he's the spitting image of his father.

DS2 OTOH has his dad's colouring, but other than that is my twin.

Everybody knows rationally that children come out with all sorts of features and complexions (and I'd imagine even the husband in this story knows it too), but online radicalisation is so powerful it gets you completely suspending your belief in basic, obvious facts.

My two sons look very different from each other - one has my darkish skin and curly hair, the other somehow looks like Ragnar Lothbrok with fine, almost white hair. But I don't watch Andrew Tate, so I don't then reach the conclusion that my dw has had a secret affair around the conception

jljlj · 07/06/2025 22:46

ilikemethewayiam · 07/06/2025 22:43

This!

What he has accused you of is a bell that can’t be unrung. No way, would I get a test done in order to prove my innocence, It’s giving credence to his accusation. If he thinks he isn’t the father, then he can get a test done to prove either way, but for me, the marriage would be over. The secrecy with his phone and his opportunities for cheating would be a big red flag for me. as others have said he’s projecting.

I would disagree that it gives credence to his accusation. I would say that the mum saying "absolutely, do the test" shows she is 100% confident he's the dad. I have been in this situation with my dad saying he wasn't our dad. Course he was, DNA proved.

jljlj · 07/06/2025 22:44

my dad said similar shit

we got tested

guess what, nasty dad is definitely the father of all of us - made up fiction to suggest otherwise - mum was keen to do the tests to prove him absolutely 100% wrong.

we don't speak to him as adults

ilikemethewayiam · 07/06/2025 22:43

TomatoSandwiches · 07/06/2025 19:13

I'd not hang around to be accused of cheating, I'd leave and put my claim in for CM and he can request a test through them.

What a twat.

This!

What he has accused you of is a bell that can’t be unrung. No way, would I get a test done in order to prove my innocence, It’s giving credence to his accusation. If he thinks he isn’t the father, then he can get a test done to prove either way, but for me, the marriage would be over. The secrecy with his phone and his opportunities for cheating would be a big red flag for me. as others have said he’s projecting.