Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM … would you in these circumstances?

146 replies

Jjye · 03/06/2025 13:53

DP is very successful, earns well (over 100k) with scope to earn much more in future too. He has no family wealth. I earn ok (85k) and do have some family wealth ie I already own a home with no mortgage, often am gifted 1k every few months. We are not married as I wanted to keep finances separate and was in no need to tie myself to DP in that way. I would consider marriage in future perhaps.

We had dd accidentally a year into the relationship. She’s now 3. DP often says we could move to a location where he can earn more more quickly and in doing so I could work if I wanted to or just stay at home and have the time to myself and we could have another dc. I was adamant I didn’t want this sort of set up even though I would like another dc.

I recently took a sabbatical of one month from work and loved it. DD in nursery a few days a week and I went to the gym and watched films and saw friends. I loved it. I’m now really keen on the idea of moving with dp to enhance his career and keeping my home rented out and being a stay at home mum. Probably ttc in a few months.

I know nobody can answer this for me but has anyone regretted doing this? We can live off dp’s income but it feels odd to give up my income as I can earn well. I was wildly independent when I met DP.

OP posts:
Fargo79 · 04/06/2025 09:08

NoThankYouSis · 03/06/2025 19:11

Get married first.

Why would that benefit OP?

Cleaningtroubles2 · 03/06/2025 20:10

If you are financially more secure being married, then marry first. If you stand to lose out then don’t, keep your career bubbling along. If it’s overseas do not do it. You will be a trailing spouse and very vulnerable. I have enjoyed being a SAHP and it took the pressure off as a family. It’s not for everyone but I loved it!

NoThankYouSis · 03/06/2025 19:11

Get married first.

unityfire · 03/06/2025 19:08

No since you’re not married. It’s not just about money, please don’t underestimate it.

mucky123 · 03/06/2025 19:06

Yes I did after having 3rd dc (had a great career earning 6 figures plus 14 years ago). Was out for about 10 years (went back 4 days a week working from home after covid). Loved being with my dc whilst they were young. Got back fairly easily on a returnship which was all the rage back then. Am currently working to top up my pension until my youngest is 18 when I will retire and travel.
We never had power /financial imbalances. Never felt there was a his money/my money thing. I also owned my own home from before I met him and I always had the confidence that I could get back into work if I needed it.
Personally I think you have one life and if sahm is something you would enjoy give it a go. There are risks but far less in your position than for most (although might want to consider getting married).

AliBaliBee1234 · 03/06/2025 18:55

Aside from the money, would you want this life? Staying home all day isn't for everyone. I would miss having a job and adult company.

You had presumably a great job and are ambitious? Why can't you stay where you are and have 2 dc's without being a sahm on those salaries?

RawBloomers · 03/06/2025 18:48

Gattopard · 03/06/2025 18:40

I see your point, but her partner is prepared to share his earnings with her so I think she should be prepared to share her potential rental income and inheritance with him.

Rental income perhaps. Inheritance, no. That’s capital, not income.

OP will be giving up earning potential - a huge financial sacrifice - while he will be increasing his. Earning potential isn’t something you can really share in a break up. OP needs to keep a hold of all the assets she can if she goes the SAHM route.

Gattopard · 03/06/2025 18:40

ARichtGoodDram · 03/06/2025 15:27

Given the Op owns a mortgage free house in her name and is possibly going to have a very large inheritance getting married shouldn't be as automatic as it would be for many.

That needs careful advice and consideration as she has the bulk of the assets in the relationship as it stands

I see your point, but her partner is prepared to share his earnings with her so I think she should be prepared to share her potential rental income and inheritance with him.

DoYouReally · 03/06/2025 18:15

A lot of this advice doesn't make sense.

Marraige is advisable in a lot of situation, but not necessarily this one as the OP has options.

If the relationship goes south, the OP has a death free house she can move into (as soon as she gets the tenants out), has monetary family support and also has a skillset and earning power that would allow her to return to the workplace (even if salary is lower for a while).

It's far different to an OP with no housing options or limited earning potential.

OP, there will always be risks with something like this. The main concern is if it's abroad somewhere you couldn't return with the children if you wished, in the event of a split.

Would you consider trying part time first to see how you find it rather than fully committing? Also, agree everything very clearly in advance do you and your partner's expectations are aligned.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 03/06/2025 17:44

As always this thread shows such a negative view of relationships and marriage. It's all about if he leaves you what happens... if you have assets you shouldn't marry him... IMO if you are a couple and get married then everything is pooled. If you are SAHM and he is earning it's much the same, joint account and mutual decisions on how to spend money. Likewise he will get access to income from the mortgage free home if rented out. You shouldn't be any more or any less in a position of power whether working or not if this is a healthy relationship. If your only concern is how to get out of this relationship and financial security as a single person then I think the relationship is simply not right for you.

As for SAHM it's a nice life, I did it for a while and enjoyed a nice lifestyle as dh earned 6 figures. But i found I lacked focus and direction and was both exhausted and bored after a few years. I went back to work PT when youngest started school and have absolutely no regrets about it. That said I work few hours term time only and have little responsibility. Sometimes i yearn for more but on balance I've done very well and we have an easy life. I constantly hear people moaning about being overwhelmed by domestic stuff and too tired at weekends to do anything but we don't have those issues. I work hard during the week so I do v little at weekends and both dh and i take time to ourselves to pursue hobbies or social lives. I consider myself extremely lucky.

RawBloomers · 03/06/2025 17:39

BethDuttonYeHaw · 03/06/2025 17:36

In a family with children and a committed relationship I don’t understand his and her money

Don’t understand (i.e. would people explaining it be useful) or don’t agree with?

BethDuttonYeHaw · 03/06/2025 17:36

In a family with children and a committed relationship I don’t understand his and her money

beetr00 · 03/06/2025 17:35

@RoachFish

"giving up her life" She's not though, is she?

She's making an informed, intelligent decision, that's right for her.

"I’m now really keen on the idea of moving with dp to enhance his career and keeping my home rented out and being a stay at home mum.

Probably ttc in a few months."

She is not beholden wrt finances.

Bottom line @RoachFish we can agree to disagree, for me though, @Jjye is in a powerful, purely autonomous position.

BreatheAndFocus · 03/06/2025 17:34

Don’t ask on Mumsnet, OP! There are far too many women here who sneer at other women who choose to be a SAHM. It’s not seen as ‘real’ job and looked down on by far too many women here. Yes, think about going back to work, pension, etc, but if you want to do it, then do it!

I was a SAHM and loved it. I’d have hated to miss out on those early years and my DC benefited from it. If you’re wanting to have a second child, it’s a no-brainer to be a SAHM in my opinion. Go for it - and also, know that being a SAHP is setting just as good an example to your DC as having a salaried job, contrary to the sneers here.

Potteryblue · 03/06/2025 17:30

beetr00 · 03/06/2025 17:05

I have just re-read your original post @RoachFish, purely because I wanted to ensure that I was being totally fair in my assessment.

You said

"Bear in mind that to your DP you will be a different person

Being with someone who was capable of being on his level career wise was probably quite important to him

your world will become very small

he will find you less interesting

you will be desperate for his company"

I understand that this "may" have been your lived experience?

Reducing a woman to what a man may think of her because of how she would prefer to live her life, is quite frankly, outrageous.

Do you really believe, what you've actually written?

I actually think this is sadly true for some men.
I have definitely heard of similar whining from a type of man whose ego was flattered by being with a high achieving woman.

It certainly isn't all men, but its disingenuous to not believe that some men use this as an excuse as to why they wandered🙄

ARichtGoodDram · 03/06/2025 17:23

yourefreetodowhatyouwanttodo · 03/06/2025 17:14

I would get married at my first step

Why when she's currently the one of them with assets?

Zanatdy · 03/06/2025 17:21

Unmarried, definitely not

RoachFish · 03/06/2025 17:18

beetr00 · 03/06/2025 17:05

I have just re-read your original post @RoachFish, purely because I wanted to ensure that I was being totally fair in my assessment.

You said

"Bear in mind that to your DP you will be a different person

Being with someone who was capable of being on his level career wise was probably quite important to him

your world will become very small

he will find you less interesting

you will be desperate for his company"

I understand that this "may" have been your lived experience?

Reducing a woman to what a man may think of her because of how she would prefer to live her life, is quite frankly, outrageous.

Do you really believe, what you've actually written?

I am not reducing anyone but going from a career woman (because I think she probably is one to make that sort of money) who is independently wealthy to a SAHM relying on her DP to pay the bills is life changing and in my experience driven women rarely thrive in that situation. I met plenty of them as an expat. It's not all about how her DP will view her, it's actually more about OP losing her identity and that identity is the one that her DP happened to fall in love with. There is very little intellectual stimulation in looking after babies and toddlers after all even if it is enriching in other ways.

It's fine that we have different opinions on this, but nevertheless OP is taking a big risk by moving herself away from her area to further her DPs career and giving up her life as she has known it until now.

BookArt55 · 03/06/2025 17:17

Drop to 2 days a week at work, once you come put it is notoriously difficult to get back to your previous career at the same level. It gives you freedom, flexibility and still that independence that you should definitely keep.

yourefreetodowhatyouwanttodo · 03/06/2025 17:14

I would get married at my first step

beetr00 · 03/06/2025 17:14

@Arran2024 is this the correct thread?

Arran2024 · 03/06/2025 17:13

I did it, albeit because i adopted children with additional needs. Loads of women do it. It's your life. Do what you think is right for you and your family. Sign up for carer credits so your NI will be paid. https://www.gov.uk/carers-credit

Carer's Credit

Carer's Credit helps carers fill gaps in your National Insurance record to help you qualify for the State Pensions and other benefits - what you'll get, eligibility and how to claim

https://www.gov.uk/carers-credit

beetr00 · 03/06/2025 17:05

RoachFish · 03/06/2025 16:34

If you read my post properly you would have seen that there was more to it than employment status. But yes, plenty of people still value a partner with a career and they find that stimulating in one way or another. The bigger issue is that OPs life will change and shrink if she stops working and moves away to somewhere she doesn't know anyone. I did it myself: gave up work, moved to a new country, fell pregnant and didn't work for a year and a half. I wasn't the same vibrant person I was before and I certainly wasn't as interesting to be around because my world consisted of my husband and baby. It's one risk that people perhaps don't think of as the financial risk is so obvious, but losing independence in generally is seldom good for anyone.

I have just re-read your original post @RoachFish, purely because I wanted to ensure that I was being totally fair in my assessment.

You said

"Bear in mind that to your DP you will be a different person

Being with someone who was capable of being on his level career wise was probably quite important to him

your world will become very small

he will find you less interesting

you will be desperate for his company"

I understand that this "may" have been your lived experience?

Reducing a woman to what a man may think of her because of how she would prefer to live her life, is quite frankly, outrageous.

Do you really believe, what you've actually written?

venusandmars · 03/06/2025 17:04

Jjye · 03/06/2025 14:07

@PumpkinSparkleFairy he has said he will pay for nursery 2-3 days a week so I am able to have free time.

I am due to inherit around 700k but obviously there are lots of variables to that and it’s not guaranteed.

What does 'due to inherit' mean? Person already died, waiting for probate and a few details to be negotiated is one thing. People still living with no certainty about future care costs or any other decisions - don't count on an inheritance.

Loving one month at home with your dc could feel very different from full time SAHM. During a one month stint your dp would have continued to take wahtever role they had in parenting and household tasks. In a long-term arrangement there may well be an expectation that you take on a much more significant proportion. All night wakings for the new baby (because you don't work). Much larger share of domestic responsibilities (because you don't work). Responsibility for life admin - all family dental appointments, all school events, all planning... (because you don;t work). Even if you are wealthy enough to outsource some tasks, it might still be your responsibility to oversee.

On a personal level I found SAHM my self-esteem was entirely linked to how well (or otherwise) things were going at home. Terrible twos and my esteem was rock bottom. With outside employment I had a more balanced view of what constituted a good day or a good month.

heavenisaplaceonearth · 03/06/2025 16:53

Frostiesflakes · 03/06/2025 15:46

If your due to inherit 700k and you have a mortgage free house then definitely don’t get married 😂

you risk loosing that for a piece of paper that benefits some and not others

I think wait till you get your inheritance and the reconsider

This is what I was thinking.