Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Immigration - can someone please explain it to me in simple terms?

285 replies

Illbeinthehottub · 01/06/2025 13:40

So for as long as I can remember I’ve heard that there is a problem with immigration in the UK. There are headlines about it daily and it’s always an issue for government. It’s a big part of what Brexit was about.

I don’t personally understand all about it, what is the issue, is it simply than people feel immigration is putting additional pressure on services?

I’ve just seen another headline saying that Kier Starmer has lost control of the borders.

Conservatives were in power for 13 years, presumably immigration was still unacceptable to people. Now people are unhappy with Labour.

Can someone who understands explain to me a) what is the problem with immigration b) why hasn’t any government been able to have an acceptable policy that works c) is immigration just something for people to whinge about?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Illbeinthehottub · 02/06/2025 09:08

Araminta1003 · 02/06/2025 09:00

Edited by MNHQ
@BlueKnickers - well good for you. My Indian colleague got called a P**i by a British homeless guy the other day. It’s not her fault she works really hard, pays for our NHS whilst he boozes his life away.
White working class boys have the worst academic outcomes here. They are held back by their own cultural values and their families. It is no bogeyman immigrant or Etonian to blame for that. Look at the Tommy Robinson crowd - we should be shipping them off. What exactly have they contributed?

I would have to agree that there are large cohorts of British born people who have no aspiration and sit and moan and blame everyone else for their problems. Then there are others who are turning to gangs and lives of crime.

I see a lot of this and it’s very depressing.

OP posts:
Illbeinthehottub · 02/06/2025 09:04

Thanks, people have explained it really well in terms of the different types of immigration, the reasons governments have failed to do anything about it, and why communities are unhappy about it.

There are real problems in this country. Not just with immigration but with housing, the cost of living and education and aspirations for young people.

It doesn’t seem that any government has the will to do anything to improve things.

OP posts:
Araminta1003 · 02/06/2025 09:00

Edited by MNHQ
@BlueKnickers - well good for you. My Indian colleague got called a P**i by a British homeless guy the other day. It’s not her fault she works really hard, pays for our NHS whilst he boozes his life away.
White working class boys have the worst academic outcomes here. They are held back by their own cultural values and their families. It is no bogeyman immigrant or Etonian to blame for that. Look at the Tommy Robinson crowd - we should be shipping them off. What exactly have they contributed?

BlueKnickers · 02/06/2025 08:52

As a person of Indian ethnic origin, I've personally not found that my race has held me back here.

HangryLikeTheHulk · 02/06/2025 08:49

Toootss · 02/06/2025 08:32

The immigrants living here are all given iPhones -no reason not to learn English.

No they’re not.

Hellofreshh · 02/06/2025 08:48

@Sash I lived and worked in Spain for a short while when I was younger. The quality of care homes and facilities were shocking compared to England. People who go to retire in Spain will go with funds not to sponge off the Spanish system.

Whilst that maybe your friends "circs" that isn't an average overview. There's an awful lot in your post.....

Nothing is addressing the concerns for the lack of housing here in England or the crisis of homeless on our streets. I'm sorry but there's a well known phrase "Charity starts at home!".

AnotherDayInParadise43 · 02/06/2025 08:38

Many believe that by virtue of a cosmic lottery that led to them popping out of their mother on a certain bit of dirt, they're entitled to first dibs.

That is how nation states work. Those whose ancestry dates back centuries on the 'bit of dirt' typically feel very attached to it, protective of it. Develop tacit relationships and cultural norms at the local, regional and national level that results in a functioning, cohesive society. Unless something happens to rapidly, radically change that society.

User135644 · 02/06/2025 08:36

The Tories under Boris Johnson opened the borders. 4 million came in in under 3 years (legally). Only 500k on work visas. So the benefit bill skyrocketed to a billion a month for migrants.

This was after Brexit which was ultimately about lowering immigration to the average voter.

bluecurtains14 · 02/06/2025 08:35

Toootss · 02/06/2025 08:32

The immigrants living here are all given iPhones -no reason not to learn English.

What nonsense (the iphones).

But the learning English is so important. New immigrants need free access to 6m of full-time language school, with childcare provided, on the basis that failure to learn English will result in deportation.

Toootss · 02/06/2025 08:32

The immigrants living here are all given iPhones -no reason not to learn English.

KarminaBurana · 02/06/2025 08:05

Araminta1003 · 02/06/2025 07:51

I do not think you need to worry about it, at all. There are plenty of white British people who want to leave this racist and xenophobic and politically toxic cesspit as well, so net net, in the long run, figures will go down.

So why do so many non white people want to come if it's such a racist cesspit?

KarminaBurana · 02/06/2025 08:04

ByBlueMoose · 02/06/2025 07:59

Ah, the poor are lazy, and thick?

Are you from the past? It's a very Victorian attitude.

I agree, this sounds very much like the Victorian notion of "the deserving poor".

Araminta1003 · 02/06/2025 08:02

Also, Nigel Farage is the biggest grifter of them all; he will promise your Granny eternal life and your toddler unicorn wings. Anyone who could pass GCSE maths knows his numbers do not add up and spell worse than Trussonomics. I think they need to bring back GCSE Maths for all voters.

ByBlueMoose · 02/06/2025 07:59

Velmy · 02/06/2025 04:33

There are more children than ever growing up in poverty. They're becoming adults who had no education, no real work ethic instilled into them...only a worldview that life is unfair, nobody is listening to them, and 'others' are getting priority treatment.

There are low/no-skilled workers being replaced by technology. Industries that traditionally employ the working class are dying, or being moved overseas to save money. People are hurting.

Many of the people affected are competing for jobs with immigrants who are - to be blunt - willing to work harder for the same or less wages/benefits. That breeds resentment.

The decline of public services breeds resentment. It's a complex issue, but the easy answer is 'more people, less to go around'. Many believe that by virtue of a cosmic lottery that led to them popping out of their mother on a certain bit of dirt, they're entitled to first dibs.

Many who don't contribute much (or anything) to society - the real empty-heads - are happy to believe lies about people coming here illegally and getting benefits, luxury hotels etc, because they need someone to hate. They cannot admit that it's their fault that their life is shit, or not what they thought it would be, so they accept the boogyman that's been fabricated for them.

Whatever you think of those people, whether you write them off as idiots, or bigots, or lazy...whether you think they should pull their socks up or adapt to the times...whether you write them off completely and think we should simply leave them to wallow in their own misery...the fact remains that they exist, they have a voice and a vote.

Immigration is an issue. It's nowhere near the issue it's made out to be. What people should be worried about are the people who are trying to weponise it.

Ah, the poor are lazy, and thick?

Are you from the past? It's a very Victorian attitude.

Araminta1003 · 02/06/2025 07:51

I do not think you need to worry about it, at all. There are plenty of white British people who want to leave this racist and xenophobic and politically toxic cesspit as well, so net net, in the long run, figures will go down.

EasternStandard · 02/06/2025 07:47

MiloMinderbinder925 · 01/06/2025 23:51

I haven't shut the conversation down at all, in fact I said in my first post that the current level of immigration is unsustainable.

However I'm picking up on far right language and the influence of the far right in countries like Sweden which are being used as examples.

Labour have recently brought in restrictions on immigration so they are addressing it. Net zero immigration is for the delusional.

Net zero is just another reduction. If you think reducing from one number to another is sensible but reducing again isn’t it’s more political association than much else.

Joystir59 · 02/06/2025 07:40

I strongly believe that all immigrants should have to speak read and write English as a condition of their right to remain here. Asylum seekers cannot integrate without this. Asylum seeking women coming from countries where women are oppressed cannot benefit from the freedoms of our culture without this and remain in the ghetto.

KarminaBurana · 02/06/2025 07:38

BlueKnickers · 02/06/2025 07:36

I think they also have to reach these men that women wearing revealing clothes is okay

Yes, I saw that they are doing that in Denmark, with images of acceptable Western clothing in order to change attitudes.

BlueKnickers · 02/06/2025 07:36

converseandjeans · 01/06/2025 23:00

I just watched this episode. Denmark has made a policy of redistributing newcomers from ‘non Western’ countries & implemented compulsory language classes & they have made a decision that they all need to adapt to Danish ways. They have moved families into predominantly Danish areas so they can integrate. They are also keen on babies & toddlers going to nursery so they can adapt to being Danish & learn the language. Simon Reeve didn’t seem too keen.

I think they also have to reach these men that women wearing revealing clothes is okay

Joystir59 · 02/06/2025 07:36

I was born and bred in the UK and worked here paying taxes until I was 47. My ancestors going back hundred of years were born and bred here too. I left the UK to live and work for four years and on my return at 51 I had to prove I was habitually resident here and wait 6 months before I could get medical care under the NHS. I couldn't get any help with housing as I was fit and healthy and under 75. So I was street homeless for a period of time. I gained a temporary place in a hostel where I made friends with other women including asylum seekers. Once they gained asylum status they were given social housing. I was pleased for them but angry that I was not considered in housing need.

KarminaBurana · 02/06/2025 07:28

Toootss · 02/06/2025 07:25

I can see immigrants sitting chatting and smoking in the local town centre, live in hotels in or near the town . Dont need to visualise anything.

Most people don't see that unless they live near it. However, they see the small boats on the news.

Toootss · 02/06/2025 07:25

I can see immigrants sitting chatting and smoking in the local town centre, live in hotels in or near the town . Dont need to visualise anything.

KarminaBurana · 02/06/2025 07:20

The problem with the small boats is that people can visualise it. You can see the boats arriving, illegally, with mostly young men. 1,100 yesterday. Perhaps in the scheme of things, it's not that many, but it's not a good migration policy, and rightly or wrongly it worries people.
It then becomes weaponised, as pp have said.

KarminaBurana · 02/06/2025 07:16

Velmy · 02/06/2025 04:33

There are more children than ever growing up in poverty. They're becoming adults who had no education, no real work ethic instilled into them...only a worldview that life is unfair, nobody is listening to them, and 'others' are getting priority treatment.

There are low/no-skilled workers being replaced by technology. Industries that traditionally employ the working class are dying, or being moved overseas to save money. People are hurting.

Many of the people affected are competing for jobs with immigrants who are - to be blunt - willing to work harder for the same or less wages/benefits. That breeds resentment.

The decline of public services breeds resentment. It's a complex issue, but the easy answer is 'more people, less to go around'. Many believe that by virtue of a cosmic lottery that led to them popping out of their mother on a certain bit of dirt, they're entitled to first dibs.

Many who don't contribute much (or anything) to society - the real empty-heads - are happy to believe lies about people coming here illegally and getting benefits, luxury hotels etc, because they need someone to hate. They cannot admit that it's their fault that their life is shit, or not what they thought it would be, so they accept the boogyman that's been fabricated for them.

Whatever you think of those people, whether you write them off as idiots, or bigots, or lazy...whether you think they should pull their socks up or adapt to the times...whether you write them off completely and think we should simply leave them to wallow in their own misery...the fact remains that they exist, they have a voice and a vote.

Immigration is an issue. It's nowhere near the issue it's made out to be. What people should be worried about are the people who are trying to weponise it.

So therefore it is a problem, because people can weaponise it.

Toootss · 02/06/2025 07:16

We need a complete crisis in social care before older Brits will pay out. In Mays gov I think it was £37,000 everyone must pay to cover care costs -no 100Ks for some and council funding for the other but it was shouted down.