Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think someone's sexual predilections reflects on their broader character?

363 replies

MonTuesWeds · 31/05/2025 10:11

Just that really. I feel like I came of age in a time when we were encouraged to believe that someone's 'intimate preferences' were just that, and that they were completely isolated from that persons wider self and personality. I just don't think that's true though. I suppose I'm wondering two things here, firstly if IABU I'm thinking this now but secondly - am I the only one who has felt the pressure not to judge someone on what 'they're into' providing it was always fully consensual.

OP posts:
anytipswelcome · 01/06/2025 10:13

NeymeChenge · 01/06/2025 10:05

I would suspect any adult engaging in DDlg type activities of paedophilia. Obviously problematic

Roleplaying incest (though definitely not for me, or for most people) is pretty harmless.

Sorry to be clear I meant pretending to be the dad of the little girl / baby character in that scenario. I can’t get my head around anyone saying that isn’t creepy but @HuffleMyPuffleseems to think that as long as it is consensual it can’t be described as creepy.

NeymeChenge · 01/06/2025 10:05

anytipswelcome · 01/06/2025 10:02

Surely even if consensual you feel some kinks are ‘creepy’ @HuffleMyPuffle?

Say a man likes his partner to pretend to be a little girl or baby while he has sex with her, or pretends to be her dad while he has sex with her, and she consents. Do you really not find that creepy?

I feel like because you want to defend the kink community in general, you’re disregarding examples that are very troubling.

I would suspect any adult engaging in DDlg type activities of paedophilia. Obviously problematic

Roleplaying incest (though definitely not for me, or for most people) is pretty harmless.

anytipswelcome · 01/06/2025 10:02

Surely even if consensual you feel some kinks are ‘creepy’ @HuffleMyPuffle?

Say a man likes his partner to pretend to be a little girl or baby while he has sex with her, or pretends to be her dad while he has sex with her, and she consents. Do you really not find that creepy?

I feel like because you want to defend the kink community in general, you’re disregarding examples that are very troubling.

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 09:51

AbsolutelyragingImsocross · 31/05/2025 13:39

Oh thank goodness @FruityCider I can stop raging now.
The sarcasm went right over my head. Apparently I need it to slap me in the face before I notice it!

I agree. It wasn’t obvious at all and I think she’s trying to dig herself out of her judgemental hole 😂

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 09:49

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:28

Just before you continue to quote ... this PP was being sarcastic to make a point

Not in my view.

Dangermoo · 01/06/2025 09:48

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 09:11

Just like the noises someone makes when you give them oral then 😂

😆 🤣

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 09:48

Missj25 · 31/05/2025 12:26

And sometimes things just aren’t that deep with something underlying !
I had a FWB one time & I love role play , game was , car broke down outside his house , so I knock on his door for help, he comes out , invites me in, we start to chat , before you know it we are having a few drinks, but then when I go to leave , he won’t leave me & we played rape …
It was hot & we both really enjoyed..
Everyone has a sexual side to them
Nothing sinister underneath it all , just two regular people who liked to have fun 🤷🏻‍♀️😊

That does sound fun! 🤭

Allthebestgone · 01/06/2025 09:33

AGP, Autogynaphilia, affects men especially those who like wearing dresses etc. it’s a deeply disturbing fetish, they like to “feel” like a woman being sexually degraded eg sexually abused,exploited,raped. Provides them with deep sexual gratification. That’s men for you, luckily not all men, but the large majority have sexual fetish, porn a massive influence, and of course they just have to indulge their need to be sexually excited, poor loves, maybe NHS start prescribing Bromide to all males from birth might be a good remedy 😝

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:30

whitewineandsun · 01/06/2025 09:21

I always think dommes must be incomprehensible to many on MN, especially PIV being held up as the only 'expression of love'

They couldn't possibly accept that a woman could hurt a man

They only talk about men hurting women

Can't even comprehend that sex isn't even always about lobe gasp

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:28

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 09:11

Just like the noises someone makes when you give them oral then 😂

Just before you continue to quote ... this PP was being sarcastic to make a point

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:26

Thatsalineallright · 01/06/2025 07:35

Ah yes boxing where participants are carefully separated into weight categories to increase safety, wear protective gear, have a referee to ensure fairness along with a clearly defined amount of time to engage in the activity.

Oh-so-similar to feederism where one participant gets a sexual thrill from the other constantly gaining weight, becoming increasingly dependent on their 'caregiver', suffering more and more health issues until potentially bedbound and immobile, and in a situation that is very difficult to leave or get out of.

Tbh I find your comparison so disingenuous that it is clear that you are arguing in bad faith. I won't be replying to any further posts.

Or you realise there's a very good point behind it

Society DOES have acceptable ways that are considered acceptable to hurt each other. Sometimes those ways cause ongoing and long term harm. But we don't label those people with names and make aspersions on their character

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:24

MonTuesWeds · 01/06/2025 06:20

Because one is an expression of love and a affection and the other is simulated abuse. And clearly it does impact lives - would this thread be so full of women who believed they enjoyed pain and humiliation 40 years ago? It would not, because these preferences are largely conditioned by our environment, by the society we find ourselves in - it might be private acts by consenting adults, but increasingly the statistics show that women are encountering men who automatically assume they want sex to look like abuse. So, this radical individualism in the bedroom doesn't look so individual afterall when there is a measurable ratcheting of expectations when it comes to what "normal" or "pleasureable" sex looks like, the normalisation of disordered sexual expression and the idea that we have no control over our desires. We do. We've just lost, culturally, any sense that some things are bad for us.

Again - sex is not just about love and affection. But the fact you keep going on about that is obvious as to your agenda

No, 40 years ago women might not have been so open about their kinks online. Not because they didn't have them but because the shame was even greater and they felt they couldn't.

Saying they "believe" they like it is also ridiculous. It's taking away autonomy and making out these women can't make up their own mind

The Story of O and The Claiming of Sleeping Beauty are both much older than 40 years and were deeply kinky erotic novels written by women, for women.

There is a growing concern, and practioners of kink will readily acknowledge it, of people using the label "kink" as a front for actual and disgusting sexual abuse. But these aren't people with a kink, they are abusers. Different.

Which is why, instead of shaming and shutting down discussions of kink, calling people with kinks all kinds of names and making accusations about them, we need to be able to talk more freely. So we can educated on safe practices, on what is and isn't a kink, on continual consent

By making these things shameful it's MORE harmful.

whitewineandsun · 01/06/2025 09:21

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:16

They feel shame because narrow minded and judgemental witches like those on this thread tell them they should feel ashamed and that they are abnormal

I always think dommes must be incomprehensible to many on MN, especially PIV being held up as the only 'expression of love'

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:16

BeethovenNinth · 01/06/2025 06:01

Of course it does! We are human!

this is why so many feel shame at their odd kinks.

They feel shame because narrow minded and judgemental witches like those on this thread tell them they should feel ashamed and that they are abnormal

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:15

LHR2JFK · 01/06/2025 05:38

…, OK we’ll leave it that way “People in thrall to [their] kink will defend anything, up to an including murder so as to legitimize it.”

It isn’t that long ago that society could recognize that people who get off on strangling others were extremely dangerous people who should be in prison, and who are not anyone you would want a loved one to encounter. To be blunt -it is not just disgusting, it is callous, it is terrifying, it is warped that there are people who like to strangle.
Your kink has made you blind to danger, it has made you lose your moral compass- that says a lot about your character.

Have I "defended anything"?

Because I'm pretty sure I, and others, have stated time and time again that consent is key and that anyone using kink as a front for abuse etc is not "someone with a kink" but an abuser

There are plenty of completely legitimate hobbies which can accidentally result in someone's death if not practiced safely or if an accident occurs. You don't go around calling all of them morally corrupt...

Death by strangulation during sex is called "death by misadventure" and has been so for a while.

You really cannot tell if someone is a "dangerous person" just because they like some extreme kinks. It's called prejudice

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 09:11

FruityCider · 31/05/2025 11:47

I don't hit people who don't want to be hit. I hit people who want to be hit and have asked me to hit them.
At a very basic level, hitting can release endorphins, which feel nice. When someone feels nice, they make excited faces and noises. Those excited faces and noises are pleasing, and maybe arousing. It's not always that deep.

Just like the noises someone makes when you give them oral then 😂

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 01/06/2025 09:09

ThePhantomoftheEcobubbleOpera · 01/06/2025 08:43

If it weren't weird, perverted and harmful then there would be no objection to it being in the mainstream.

Plenty of people still object to being gay being in mainstream(nevermind in the past). Is that weird, perverted and harmful? Was it actually 50 years ago ?

Don’t forget OP sees anything outside basic PIV sex as an “expression of love” as not quite right.

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 09:09

FruityCider · 31/05/2025 11:38

There is a psychology.

Maybe more people with kinks would be more willing to talk about it if people didn't start talking about 'trangressions' and peados and rapists in the same breath as the question.

I like to hit and (sometimes) be hit. My friends know all about my reasonings/psychology behind it because I talk about it a lot. They're also not assuming that I'm some kind of psycho because of it, and that IRL I'm just a normal person.

And being hit is not degrading but putting your partner’s dick in your mouth is? Ok…

Do you enjoy receiving oral? Is that not degrading to your partner, in your view?

HuffleMyPuffle · 01/06/2025 09:06

Plasticwaste · 01/06/2025 04:21

There we go, the ol' genital-checking fetish.

You tell on yourselves every time.

You're the one deciding who is a man based off anonymous posts

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 09:02

FruityCider · 31/05/2025 11:06

Okay, so take a woman who enjoys putting her partners penis in her mouth, likes missionary sex with no extras, and doesn't ever insist on orgasming herself. (I insist every time, I'm just dreaming up a 'standard' sex life - sorry if I got it wrong. Not in to boring sex myself)

What assumptions can we make about this woman and how does it reflect on her character? Could you give me a run down of your sex life and tell me what it says about you?

Hey, I enjoy sucking a penis immensely, that in itself helps me orgasm. However, my DH always ensures I come before he does. Enjoying oral does not mean a woman doesn’t get to orgasm FFS.

MsDDxx · 01/06/2025 08:55

FruityCider · 31/05/2025 10:49

In some ways I agree. For instance I do not perform oral sex on men because I feel it's degrading. I'm presuming that noone who has this morally superior sex life would ever think of something as disgusting as putting a penis in their mouth. They pee out of those holes! I think women who enjoy that must be insecure and are in many ways perpetuating the patriarchy.

Oh fuck off with that ridiculous statement 🤣🤣

I love giving a man oral sex. And I’m definitely not what you’ve described. What awful experience has made you feel that way???

SALaw · 01/06/2025 08:47

I hate hearing people say “don’t kink shame me” or whatever. Some kinks SHOULD be shamed.

ThePhantomoftheEcobubbleOpera · 01/06/2025 08:43

If it weren't weird, perverted and harmful then there would be no objection to it being in the mainstream.

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 01/06/2025 08:31

I think there’s a massive difference(and a very fine balance to keep) between saying people with kinks are all abnormal, weirdos, perverts, harmful and toxic and not wanting kink to be part of the mainstream.

Missj25 · 01/06/2025 08:11

DontTouchRoach · 31/05/2025 22:16

So what you’re essentially saying is that you believe that unless sex is ‘an expression of love’ it’s disgusting and wrong? And that the only form of sex you believe to be ‘an expression of love’ is someone putting their penis into a woman’s vagina?

Why is having someone’s penis in my vagina an expression of love, but not having someone’s tongue in my vagina? What about gay people? Are two lesbians going down on each other not expressing love? What about two men having anal sex? If someone loves being handcuffed to the bed with a butt-plug in their bum and that brings them immense sexual pleasure, why is their partner not expressing love by providing them with that pleasure?

And also, why does it matter whether it’s about love or not? Why can’t it be about mutual pleasure?

This thread is honestly astonishing. And it’s also full of god-awful sexism and internalised misogyny. People are on here telling women they’re disgusting because their sexual interest goes beyond sweet romantic missionary sex and suggesting that it’s only men who truly want to do anything different. These attitudes are Victorian and so far from anything I recognise as feminism. It’s regressive and depressing.

To all the people on here saying that things other people do are disgusting and harmful - I guarantee you that you will definitely have at least one set of close and much-loved friends, siblings, parents or adult kids who are into the things you think are the sign of a warped and dysfunctional psyche and I guarantee you that a lot of your partners are secretly fantasising about things that would give you a heart attack.

I’ve been a victim of domestic violence at the hands of a terrible, abusive misogynist who was very, very vanilla in the bedroom. Frankly, he’d have been the ideal lover for some of the women on this thread because he shared a lot of your notions of what’s ‘normal’ and ‘healthy’ and ‘loving’ in the bedroom. He was disgusted when I even said certain words in a sexual context; if I’d asked him to spank me or pull my hair or something he’d have shamed me for it just like the women on this thread are shaming people. But he was a violent, controlling abuser who essentially hated women.

I’ve also had relationships with absolutely lovely, kind, sweet and sensitive men who were brilliant feminist allies who were up for anything in bed and totally open-minded and uninhibited and non-judgemental. My DP of 22 years is one of them.

Hey PP 😊..
I hope people take on board what you have to say ..
All the posts on this thread & yours being my favourite , honest & truthful .. x