Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be upset about the decision my parent has made?

145 replies

Inheritancesucks · 28/05/2025 20:25

Name change for this.
One of my dps died a couple of years ago. The other was left with 2 pensions and a house from the deceased parent. The remaining parent was concerned they couldn't afford to remain in the house which was in very poor repair. The remaining parent has therefore decided to let 1 of the (4) dc move in (with their partner and 2 young dc) and added them to the mortgage so they could get a loan out against the house in order to add a granny flat so they can stay there and the dc and their family live in the original house.
All of this was decided and signed off before the remaining parent told me about it.
Is it wrong that I am upset by this? Is it grabby to be upset that my remaining parent has signed the house over to 1 sibling and essentially provided for them and their family but left me, my kids, and the other siblings out completely?
I'm trying really hard to move on from this, but finding it next to impossible. Im trying to tell myself that the remaining parent just wanted stability, and not that it is a reflection on how they feel about me or my other siblings. Happy to be told I need to get myself together and remaining parent can do whatever they like and don't owe me anything (which i do know). Could you move on from it?
In the interests of openness, the dc who is moving into the house is the only 1 who lived less than a couple of hours away from them.

OP posts:
Treesandsheepeverywhere · 29/05/2025 19:08

Jellyrols · 29/05/2025 15:55

Sounds to me as if your parent has been sold a great plan when she was vulnerable.
It is 100% in your siblings partners interests NOT to marry your sibling.
The house has been signed over to him.
The additional works will benefit him.

Marrying your sibling in not in his interests now that he is on the deeds.

I would contact Age Action UK for advice.

This was not in your mothers best interests and the secrecy is testimony to that.

Agree, the siblings should have been transparent even if DM didn't want to.

Elderly abuse is on the rise and like most abuse, it's usually the people close to the victim.

If i was your DS OP, I would want everything accounted for, to avoid any future accusations.

Getting her DP on the mortgage is a recipe for disaster.

I don't agree it's not your mess to fix though, she is still your DM and together with the other siblings, you can try and help her.

Even if DS and her partner are true to their word and help look after her, would they be in a position to sell if she need the funds for an Old people's home?

If they were genuine, I think they would have been transparent.

Newgirls · 29/05/2025 17:45

It’s really sad that they didn’t discuss it with you first. That is a weird dynamic.

to be honest you are probably better off out of it. Your sibling and fiancé will end up doing a lot of boring care for your parent and are in a very bad situation if their relationship ends. I wouldn’t want to be in their shoes. Try to rise above it and stay well out of it for your own benefit

vinavine · 29/05/2025 17:40

The problem is as you say no wider family discussion and this is what causes the wider family fall out. No idea why people do this tbh.

vinavine · 29/05/2025 17:39

I live closer to my DM than my sister and do lots for her
No way would I think that entitled me to any more of her assets

Same

Stoufer · 29/05/2025 17:36

Inheritancesucks · 29/05/2025 14:33

When asked the parent says they don't know. This could be genuine or could be to avoid admitting they have left themselves in a vulnerable position. I can't see how any of it could be challenged except by the parent who wouldn't. Partly for fear of upsetting the sibling benefitting, and partly because they would not want to admit being wrong.
I think i just have to accept it is as it is now and try and step back. It wasn't my choice, but equally isn't my responsibility to fix.

When did this all happen? You can buy an online copy of the deeds from hm land registry (to check who is named on the deeds) for a few pounds (make sure you go through the actual HM land registry (ie website finishes in gov.uk) site, as third party companies will also do it for you but it is usually £25 + (a complete rip off). However, it can take a few months for it all to be updated on land registry, so you may need to buy the deeds a few times until it has changed, but at approx £3 a go, it is not that expensive.

If your parent truly does not know whose name is on the deeds, that would be a massive red flag for me - did they get legal advice? Have they been misled?

You say it is not your problem, but if your parent is homeless / penniless / not eligible for social care a few years down the line, would you really be able to just say ‘not my problem’? I would really struggle to turn a parent away in those circumstances.

Inheritancesucks · 29/05/2025 16:20

TheignT · 29/05/2025 16:14

Wasn't money raised by the mortgage?

The parent didn't have a mortgage on the house it had been paid off years ago. I am unclear whether they have jointly taken out a mortgage (dp and siblings partner) or if a loan has been taken out against the house. I do know the partner had to be added as they were the only one of the 3 involved who had an income. I could be wrong with those assumptions, the parent could have signed the house over completely. They are very unwilling to admit when they have made unwise choices due to pride, so the likelihood of getting honest answers is small.

OP posts:
Youdontseehow · 29/05/2025 16:20

ItsFreedomBabyYeah · 28/05/2025 20:38

I'm certain no malice was intended. I think the sibling who inherited will be fair, in the end.

Edited

Why do you think this? You have absolutely no way of knowing this! Sibling’s partner being on the mortgage is really sus, especially if sibling not married (which it sounds like).

I’d be upset too OP - I wonder how this idea was “sold” to your DP 🤔

TheignT · 29/05/2025 16:14

Wasn't money raised by the mortgage?

Inheritancesucks · 29/05/2025 16:12

TheignT · 29/05/2025 16:00

Has the house been signed over or has the sister and her fiance raised a mortgage to buy a share in the house and the money spent on the house. A solicitor has almost certainly been involved and should have advised.

I don't know the parent is unclear.
I know there was no money raised by the sibling, as they had to borrow the money for all the works against the house. As the parent is in poor health and doesn't work they couldn't borrow, and the sibling doesn't work so the partner is the one who has signed whatever it is that has been agreed with the bank.
I would hope a solicitor has been involved but the parent is unclear whether they have seen someone or not.

OP posts:
TheignT · 29/05/2025 16:00

Has the house been signed over or has the sister and her fiance raised a mortgage to buy a share in the house and the money spent on the house. A solicitor has almost certainly been involved and should have advised.

Jellyrols · 29/05/2025 15:55

Sounds to me as if your parent has been sold a great plan when she was vulnerable.
It is 100% in your siblings partners interests NOT to marry your sibling.
The house has been signed over to him.
The additional works will benefit him.

Marrying your sibling in not in his interests now that he is on the deeds.

I would contact Age Action UK for advice.

This was not in your mothers best interests and the secrecy is testimony to that.

Phoenix1Arisen · 29/05/2025 15:36

The big if in this particular case would appear to be IF the daughter cares for the mother, for life, as recompense for the assets/house being handed over and in these circumstances, where there appears to be no legal advice, no seeking of expert guidance, no safety measures put in place and no will, no guarantee whatever that is what will happen.

OP - I strongly disagree with other posters that you're being grabby. Your entirely rational views and your obvious concern at this whole hole-in-the-corner scenario does you credit. Good luck.

Inheritancesucks · 29/05/2025 14:51

EmeraldShamrock000 · 29/05/2025 14:29

This way she has company on hand, she is not downsizing out of the area.
Believe me it won't be a walk in the park for Dsis either, looking after an aging parent is difficult.
I would ensure that DM got a fair deal but that would be it.

What you you consider to be a fair deal?

OP posts:
BakelikeBertha · 29/05/2025 14:40

Stoufer · 29/05/2025 14:16

You need to find out who is on the deeds - is it just your sister’s partner? As surely if your parent was also on the deeds then they would also be named on the mortgage - which sounds unlikely. If your parent isn’t on the deeds, then they have given their house away to this partner. You should find out what legal advice was given, and what the legal / financial / tax and care implications are. You should find out if anything can be done to protect your parent, as this is potentially a complete disaster waiting to happen… Was there coercion? Is it possible to challenge this legally?

The parent can still be on the Deeds even if not on the mortgage, in fact the OP's sibling could also be on the Deeds, but ideally the OP needs to get a copy of them, and see for herself what the score is, if her parent or DS won't tell her.

In your shoes OP, I think I would get together with your remaining siblings, and all go to your parent's home, and insist on discussing what has occurred, and why you weren't told about it in advance. I would also want to know, how the sibling who has effectively bought 50% of the property - assuming your parent is still on the Deeds, plans on dealing with it, when/if your parent needs to go into a care home, as they will have to find enough money to give your parent half the cost of the house, and of course the Council could end up looking at it all as 'deprivation of assets', in which case they could all find themselves in VERY hot water.

BruFord · 29/05/2025 14:38

Phoenix1Arisen · 29/05/2025 09:39

I don't believe this is anything to do with inheritance. It's not about pounds, shillings and pence.

In my opinion, the OP's reaction is based upon fear - fear for the mother's (?) well-being, fears for her future care needs, fears for the family relationships in the future.

This situation has financial disaster written all over it for reasons that other posters have already referred to in some depth.

It would be interesting to know if mother took any kind of legal advice and if not, exactly why didn't the daughter (?) urge it, given that the parent is surrendering almost all her assets - surely any reasonable adult would want to see fair play and clarity in operation, especially as the 'other owner' is a free agent who can walk off with the 'booty' at any moment.

My mother had a saying which over my lifetime has proved accurate 99% of the time - when you conceal something, you invite suspicion.

I'm sorry for your trouble, OP, and hope things can be resolved soon with the minimum of upset and difficulty.

I agree @Phoenix1Arisen, the Mum has made herself v. financially vulnerable and as I said upthread, I don’t like the fact that none of the other siblings were aware of this decision until it was done and dusted. It def. suggests that the sibling didn’t want them asking any difficult questions.

I hope it works out well for the Mum, but one of friends is currently dealing with a difficult situation- her sister and family moved in with her Mum to “take care of her” and have been using Mum’s money to pay the family’s bills, everything from food to clothes shopping for her and her teenagers. Unfortunately, the Mum is now showing signs of dementia and can’t remember what she agreed to. Thousands have already been spent.
So the OP and her other siblings need to keep a sharp eye on this situation and ensure that their Mum is OK.

Inheritancesucks · 29/05/2025 14:33

Stoufer · 29/05/2025 14:16

You need to find out who is on the deeds - is it just your sister’s partner? As surely if your parent was also on the deeds then they would also be named on the mortgage - which sounds unlikely. If your parent isn’t on the deeds, then they have given their house away to this partner. You should find out what legal advice was given, and what the legal / financial / tax and care implications are. You should find out if anything can be done to protect your parent, as this is potentially a complete disaster waiting to happen… Was there coercion? Is it possible to challenge this legally?

When asked the parent says they don't know. This could be genuine or could be to avoid admitting they have left themselves in a vulnerable position. I can't see how any of it could be challenged except by the parent who wouldn't. Partly for fear of upsetting the sibling benefitting, and partly because they would not want to admit being wrong.
I think i just have to accept it is as it is now and try and step back. It wasn't my choice, but equally isn't my responsibility to fix.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock000 · 29/05/2025 14:29

Ddakji · 29/05/2025 09:20

Nothing to do with leaving money for others. She has now tied herself to this sibling and their family and left herself financially vulnerable. She had a house that she could have sold and downsized and put the spare money into savings or whatever so it was secure for her future needs.

That’s all gone now.

This way she has company on hand, she is not downsizing out of the area.
Believe me it won't be a walk in the park for Dsis either, looking after an aging parent is difficult.
I would ensure that DM got a fair deal but that would be it.

Stoufer · 29/05/2025 14:16

You need to find out who is on the deeds - is it just your sister’s partner? As surely if your parent was also on the deeds then they would also be named on the mortgage - which sounds unlikely. If your parent isn’t on the deeds, then they have given their house away to this partner. You should find out what legal advice was given, and what the legal / financial / tax and care implications are. You should find out if anything can be done to protect your parent, as this is potentially a complete disaster waiting to happen… Was there coercion? Is it possible to challenge this legally?

Stoufer · 29/05/2025 13:03

Inheritancesucks · 29/05/2025 01:04

@OneQuirkyPanda 'What happens if your mum needs to go into a care home in the future? What happens if your sister separates from her partner?'

I don't know... I don't know anything. It's really hard because I care about my parent and their quality of life going forward. However it feels like they have chosen to make this decision behind my back, so I can only wash my hands of it as a pp said, and leave them to it; if it all goes tits up it's nothing to do with me. But how do you do that? How do you actually just shrug your shoulders and say 'you made your bed' to a parent in need if it comes to it??

I posted upthread, about the elderly relative who was left homeless and penniless after her daughter died and the son-in-law refused to give her the money back that had been put into the house. The elderly relative went to live with her son and his family (the only remaining family that the elderly relative had). It wasn’t easy - it was a small house and the three children had to share a bedroom for many years to allow a bedroom for the elderly relative. This was the 1970s, and there were no other options.

I suspect it would be different now. But in your case I suspect there would be a big issue re: deprivation of assets if your dp needed a care home, if they have essentially given their house away.

If it was me, I would try to get to the bottom of this now (working out what would be the outcome on a number of different scenarios), and try to find out what measures / protections have been put in place re: your dp’s assets and financial security in the long term. This is more important that considerations of inheritance imo. Tbh, I don’t think anyone can assume they will get an inheritance, as elderly parents may need care, and that is hugely expensive.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 29/05/2025 09:44

Motheranddaughter · 28/05/2025 20:47

I live closer to my DM than my sister and do lots for her
No way would I think that entitled me to any more of her assets

Agree completely.

Being able to help a parent is great but shouldn't be with the expectation of being paid for it.

Just because a siblings isn't able to help, doesn't make them lesser and should have been discussed as a family.
Not about the money, but protecting your mum and making sure she's signed the right documents and not been rushed into the decision.

I get you OP as your parent had been left in a vulnerable position.

If the relationship breaks down between your Dsis & BIL, or between them both and her, she could lose everything.

I was reading about a mum who split her house into two flats and set up her DD & DGD in one. Her DD forced her out and won in court.

Phoenix1Arisen · 29/05/2025 09:39

I don't believe this is anything to do with inheritance. It's not about pounds, shillings and pence.

In my opinion, the OP's reaction is based upon fear - fear for the mother's (?) well-being, fears for her future care needs, fears for the family relationships in the future.

This situation has financial disaster written all over it for reasons that other posters have already referred to in some depth.

It would be interesting to know if mother took any kind of legal advice and if not, exactly why didn't the daughter (?) urge it, given that the parent is surrendering almost all her assets - surely any reasonable adult would want to see fair play and clarity in operation, especially as the 'other owner' is a free agent who can walk off with the 'booty' at any moment.

My mother had a saying which over my lifetime has proved accurate 99% of the time - when you conceal something, you invite suspicion.

I'm sorry for your trouble, OP, and hope things can be resolved soon with the minimum of upset and difficulty.

Ilady · 29/05/2025 09:26

N

Ddakji · 29/05/2025 09:20

EmeraldShamrock000 · 29/05/2025 09:10

I haven't rtft.
Imo yes, yabu, your mother shouldn't have to stay lonely in a run down house to ensure that she leaves money for others.

This way, she has company, somewhere new to live, close to her DD, granny flats ain't cheap to build. She'll need support as she will age.

I have two aunts that have sold the family home and downsized, the DC are disgusted that their inheritance is being spent, one aunt moved in with her DD giving her 50,000 she'll buy a cabin, she is only 70, the other siblings are livid.

Nothing to do with leaving money for others. She has now tied herself to this sibling and their family and left herself financially vulnerable. She had a house that she could have sold and downsized and put the spare money into savings or whatever so it was secure for her future needs.

That’s all gone now.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 29/05/2025 09:10

I haven't rtft.
Imo yes, yabu, your mother shouldn't have to stay lonely in a run down house to ensure that she leaves money for others.

This way, she has company, somewhere new to live, close to her DD, granny flats ain't cheap to build. She'll need support as she will age.

I have two aunts that have sold the family home and downsized, the DC are disgusted that their inheritance is being spent, one aunt moved in with her DD giving her 50,000 she'll buy a cabin, she is only 70, the other siblings are livid.

MiniFig · 29/05/2025 09:04

Just because someone is geographically closest doesn’t mean they are emotionally the closest. Nor is 2 hours “far away”.

ain't that the truth - my siblings live a) in the same town and b) an hour by car (which they have) away and i live in another country from our parent.

And yet, because i use all my holiday throughout the year to do this, i have seen my parent more, much much more, than the other siblings over the last 5 years. I make hospital appointments and arrange transport, i book their clubs and associations, and i have sorted out their TV and landline/internet.

The others? one, no idea we haven't spoken for years, just naturally drifted. The other? was given mum's car and lots of furniture. I don't begrudge that because they needed a car and mum really needed to stop driving. But did they even take parent out for lunch as thanks? hahah. no.

Swipe left for the next trending thread