Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never invited on sibling holiday.

30 replies

NeedToLetItGo · 28/05/2025 19:24

My sister and brother go on holiday each year with their families and have never mentioned or suggested we go. AIBU

Background: I was single until my late 30s, was very close to my sister, her husband and kids, I called up, brought the kids out to give her a break (and also as I loved spending time with them), babysat, took annual leave when they were sick to help out.

When I met and married a man who had kids and we went onto a child of our own, she never once offered a single hour of practical support to me. I was hurt by that, but more so by her lack of interest in my kids. She makes a token visit once or twice a year, always to me, never asks us up, my child doesn't know what her house looks like. I asked her kids down for days and sleepovers, she came down once and left them for 3 hours. The relationship I valued so much as an aunt to her kids didn't seem to be valued by my sister or her husband and I really really missed them.

In the first few years of my married life. I asked her to holiday with us, she was under financial pressure and we were not holidaying abroad at that stage, sent her Air bnbs etc, it didn't materialise.
We went from being very close and involved to once I became a mum, very limited contact. She gets on well with my husband who is very easygoing and not the problem!

She has for the last few years holidayed abroad with my brother. I would have no problem with this if she showed interest in catching up otherwise but it is very hurtful that she wants to spend a few weeks every year with his family, while seeing so little of mine. The trip is never mentioned until months after it is booked. If she even acknowledged it and said Look love you but just prefer to holiday with X, Id have no problem. It is the silence that is the killer.

My kids ask why we arent invited, my friends and some of her friends have asked me why we dont go with them and I know my parents feel for me & the kids especially as one of them innocently asked why we never go with them in front of my Mum and Dad - but I keep them out of it, and brush it off.

I wont ever say anything to my sister, you can't make someone want to be a part of your kids lives. I know there will always be an emotional distance between us now, but wonder if anyone else has faced something similar with a sibling and has advice?

Re my brother, I don't expect him to ask me, we are not close so he doesn't factor in. I just want to have the positive outlook on it that I can take to manage the hurt and also the hurt of my kids who genuinely love their cousins. I guess at the heart of it, I couldn't imagine telling some of my nieces and nephews I would holiday with some of the others and not think about asking them!

I remind myself that I am very close to another sibling that I have great friends and while it took me a while to get to know them, have really lovely and kind in-laws who are so inclusive. We are regularly asked away with friends. I love all the kids involved very much and keep the focus on them. This situation won't change so I need to manage it, as it does hurt every year. AIBU to feel hurt?

OP posts:
NerrSnerr · 28/05/2025 20:37

How many siblings are there? Are they closer In age to each other or their children close in age?

Diarygirlqueen · 28/05/2025 20:28

I have 4 siblings and get on better with certain ones, same personality etc
However, I would be really hurt by this and would probably distance myself. Wait till she rings you, make yourself less available especially if you look after her kids and it's never reciprocated.
It's easy for people to give reasons why you're never been included, but it bloody hurts! I've been in your shoes, so took my own advice and feel so much better.

OtterlyMad · 28/05/2025 20:27

It’s not unreasonable that you feel hurt. Why don’t you just ask for the reason? Obviously if you do that then you need to be prepared for a frank (and potentially hurtful) response. It might be something really simple and innocuous, like your brother’s and sister’s kids are similar ages. Or it could be something bad, one of them doesn’t like you/your husband. But either way, at least you’d know the truth…

UndermyShoeJoe · 28/05/2025 19:33

Does your brother have children? If yes are they the same ish ages as her children?

I notice you say you are very close with another sibling so it’s almost like 2 pairs rather than a huge sibling group, as this other sibling also isn’t invited on the holiday.

Obviously she’s taken full advantage of the child free hands on aunty and she was never going to be able to give you fully the same experience as she does have children but to almost drop you like a rock the second you have a child isn’t on at all because even a huge age gap between cousins they can still spend some time together and she can be interested without babysitting or it being a horror of a holiday for 15 year olds and a 2 year old and yet she’s not.

Unless theirs some huge backstory where she thinks your husband isn’t good enough and the baby she feels cemented the marriage as such and so she’s noped out.

howshouldibehave · 28/05/2025 19:27

My sister and brother go on holiday each year with their families and have never mentioned or suggested we go. AIBU

Well, I would say YABU not to ask one of them if you want to know.