Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister issues.

28 replies

Lucytheluckyone · 27/05/2025 11:54

My sister is four years younger than me, we were never really close but we did get on, she used to be lovely, kind and friendly. Our relationship started to deteriorate not long after the birth of her little boy (who is a similar age to mine) mainly because of her husband. He is a horrible man with a god like complex. He appears to control her - he moved her to a very isolated area and unfortunately due to the fact she has no friends there or doesn’t work, all of her opinions are now his, which has sadly made her incredibly unlikeable. On top of that he definitely doesn’t like me, probably because I speak my mind and would tell her what I thought of him (which I never have, might I add). My sister has become consumed by politics and hates the world, she is incredibly sensitive to everything and seems miserable. She turns every conversation into a debate about world goings on and it’s exhausting.

To put it bluntly, I don’t really like her anymore. The issue is - this obviously upsets my mum who wants our little boys to have a relationship. My sister is coming home in September and my mum is desperate to do things with them both, which I understand. Trouble is I don’t want my BIL anywhere near my son (we’ve had issues in the past with the way he treats him) and if I leave him with my mum he will be there. On top of that I wonder if my sister and I should sit down and hash things out, however I’m really reluctant due to the fact I don’t like who she is now and kind of feel at peace with that? Anyone else in the same boat? I sort of feel like I would only be doing this for my mum/wider family (who are close so I don’t want tension).

OP posts:
ClarityofVision · 27/05/2025 13:50

Cutting your sister out of your life because you don't like her political views, and the fact that she goes on about them, sounds like you are also a bit stubborn, maybe even opinionated yourself (personally, I like people with opinions!).
You say you don't like how BiL treats your son but you don't give any more details so it is impossible to comment.
It would be a real shame if two cousins couldn't play together at their nan's house because their mum's don't like each other's political views.

Outrageistheopiateofthemasses · 27/05/2025 12:18

Protect your son from BIL. Ultimately, that has to be the priority

Uricon2 · 27/05/2025 12:05

Trouble is I don’t want my BIL anywhere near my son (we’ve had issues in the past with the way he treats him) and if I leave him with my mum he will be there.

This is what stands out for me. He's your child @Lucytheluckyone and your responsibility is to him, not your sister or DM or wider family. OK, in better circumstances it is nice for cousins to spend time together but that isn't the situation here.

I don't think "hashing it out" with your sister would achieve anything other than make things even more fraught but I do think you need to be firm that your son will not be spending time in any situation where you feel uncomfortable and if there is resultant tension, deal with it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread