Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be scared people aren't taking far-right extremists seriously?

157 replies

AnxiousApocalypse · 18/05/2025 20:43

There is so much anti-immigrant sentiment in the UK and the West in general. There are a lot of people that believe if you are a person of colour that has grown up in the UK but have immigrant parents, then you are not British enough- even if you have spent your whole life here and integrated into British society. On Wednesday, three far-right extremists were convicted in Sheffield Crown Court of planning a terrorist attack but there was hardly any coverage. At my workplace, people talk about immigrants coming over on scam care worker visas schemes, bringing their dependants and taking up resources such as school places and NHS appointments when those are already lacking for those born in Britain. I thought that scrapping overseas recruitment for care workers and heightening the qualifications threshold for skilled worker visas by the government was quite severe, but comments on the Daily Mail and Telegraph articles show that this isn't enough for most people. What about all the universities having to make cuts due to losing significant income from the new restrictions on international student visas? Will most people not be happy until the UK has no non-white people at all?

OP posts:
Dangermoo · 18/05/2025 23:04

Ooral · 18/05/2025 21:23

Nailed it, the only thing I would add..... 99% of people that are worried about 'far right' have no idea what far right actually is.
Reform aren't even middle right. Ask your grandfathers.

👏 👏

MiloMinderbinder925 · 18/05/2025 22:55

BundleBoogie · 18/05/2025 22:54

Are you claiming therefore that white British people either don’t exist or our existence is somehow ‘far right’? If there are no people regarded as indigenous (the exact definition of this is a whole other conversation) British then what are we?

Do you have the same issue with people who are proud to be black Africans? Or Nigerians that have a national identity that requires a Nigerian to be black and have originated from Nigeria?

I think it is fine when people describe themselves as British Asians or similar as that signals an adoption of what it generally regarded to be British but acknowledges their actual heritage. What words like your do is erase the concept of British heritage. You wouldn’t do that do any other nationality, why us?

I wouldn’t move to India and expect all Indians to refer to me as Indian and pretend that India heritage and culture has now expanded to include me.

Why is being 'indigenous' so important to you?

BundleBoogie · 18/05/2025 22:54

MiloMinderbinder925 · 18/05/2025 21:34

There's a lot of talk about being 'indigenous' or white. It's all far right ideology. The other day someone posted a far right meme about invasion and eugenics - on a parenting forum. That's how ubiquitous it's getting.

Are you claiming therefore that white British people either don’t exist or our existence is somehow ‘far right’? If there are no people regarded as indigenous (the exact definition of this is a whole other conversation) British then what are we?

Do you have the same issue with people who are proud to be black Africans? Or Nigerians that have a national identity that requires a Nigerian to be black and have originated from Nigeria?

I think it is fine when people describe themselves as British Asians or similar as that signals an adoption of what it generally regarded to be British but acknowledges their actual heritage. What words like your do is erase the concept of British heritage. You wouldn’t do that do any other nationality, why us?

I wouldn’t move to India and expect all Indians to refer to me as Indian and pretend that India heritage and culture has now expanded to include me.

TempestTost · 18/05/2025 22:53

Sabire9 · 18/05/2025 22:39

@TempestTost

"He is really concerned about the effects of too liberal an immigration policy."

Is that concern about pressure on public services and housing after 15 years of biting government austerity, or what?

If it's about cultural change and crime, what makes that different to the massive objections raised by white Brits in response to waves of immigration from the West Indies in the 1950's?

Why should it be a problem if people worry about crime, whatever the decade?

In the end it really doesn't matter if austerity is the real cause of problems in the NHS or not. It doesn't make it ok to put a lot more pressure on those things and ignore the population that is already here. And it's not really good for new immigrants either.

Could austerity have been avoided? I don't know that it's clear that it could have been.The 1970s ended with the UK requiring a loan from the World Bank, and they exact a price for those kinds of loans in the form of demanding certain kinds of spending cuts. Blair managed to fudge some new spending, but by the end of his time they were looking at cuts again. This pattern isn't confined to the UK, it's similar in many western economies, and is at least in part the effect of globalism.

None of that makes it sensible to admit more people than can be housed or educated however.

converseandjeans · 18/05/2025 22:52

Masmavi · 18/05/2025 22:28

They’re not getting those basic services or needs met not because of immigrants but because of years and years of underfunding.

Yes I’m sure there has been underfunding. But you can’t expect people in areas where there is already some poverty sit back & not complain when they can’t afford much. They see groups of men put up in what used to be quite decent hotels & if they try to question it they are shut down, threatened with court action if they speak out. So because they have been kept in the dark & threatened about speaking out they feel like the only way is to protest.

Personally I don’t agree with them & I find it worrying. But I live in an area with not much immigration & so am not affected. I don’t need a council house & I can get GP appointments. If governments keep forcing certain areas to accept large numbers then they will get protests. We seem to be getting more protests now they are housing immigrants in more affluent areas.

MiloMinderbinder925 · 18/05/2025 22:52

Sabire9 · 18/05/2025 22:46

@Potsofpetals
"I have no issue with the Conservative Party, Reform, Katie Bloody Hopkins or any other person who is trying to protect the rights of uk citizens."

Is that you Suella? 🙄

Love that you frame someone like Katie Hopkins, an out and out fascist who's called for child asylum seekers to be left to drown in the channel, as 'trying to protect the rights of UK citizens'. H

"No, I don’t care. Show me pictures of coffins, show me bodies floating in the water, play violins and show me skinny people looking sad.

I don't care."

Rescue boats? I’d use gunships to stop migrants.

She also called them cockroaches. Katie Hopkins, thank God we've got her defending our shores.

Sabire9 · 18/05/2025 22:49

@TempestTost

"That dismissal, for years, is the behaviour that has led to the place we are now".

Wrong - what's led us to where we are now is the rise of the neoliberal
right in the US and in Europe, who have NOTHING to wind working class people over to their side, except pandering to their racism by blaming immigrants for all the problems caused by late stage capitalism, and by engaging in perpetual culture wars around race.

rubicustellitall · 18/05/2025 22:49

We need names OP of the groups of far right extremists that they belong to..Any individual name /person that concerns you so much?

TheBlueUniform · 18/05/2025 22:48

JacquesHarlow · 18/05/2025 20:51

Ok this post @AnxiousApocalypse is packed with assumptions here and , as someone "of colour" (!) that is British born but who is concerned about rising immigration, let me try and help:

There is so much anti-immigrant sentiment in the UK and the West in general.

There has been a lot more migration from certain countries, many of them not necessarily officially in conflict or in war, but which seek the UK as an attractive destination due to language and existing family members.

So this has led to concerns.

There are a lot of people that believe if you are a person of colour that has grown up in the UK but have immigrant parents, then you are not British enough- even if you have spent your whole life here and integrated into British society.

Am in my 40s, female, grew up in the worse times than this, and I would challenge the "there are a lot of". I think there are a lot more outlets now such a social media that give coverage to these voices, but in my professional and personal life, no one is questioning me!

At my workplace, people talk about immigrants coming over on scam care worker visas schemes, bringing their dependants and taking up resources such as school places and NHS appointments when those are already lacking for those born in Britain.

But I don't think scam visas are ok?

Will most people not be happy until the UK has no non-white people at all?

This is seriously extreme, sorry OP, and deliberately provocative. NO, I don't think this is the case at all. You'll find "non white" people like me are also concerned about mass arrivals of young men, from particular communities and countries, time and time again arriving without families or any context, and slipping away into society without any identification, any screening, any support for integration. Where I live, this concerns people. Not their colour, but the culture issues.

Thank you for this wonderful and insightful post

Sabire9 · 18/05/2025 22:46

@Potsofpetals
"I have no issue with the Conservative Party, Reform, Katie Bloody Hopkins or any other person who is trying to protect the rights of uk citizens."

Is that you Suella? 🙄

Love that you frame someone like Katie Hopkins, an out and out fascist who's called for child asylum seekers to be left to drown in the channel, as 'trying to protect the rights of UK citizens'. H

TempestTost · 18/05/2025 22:46

Sabire9 · 18/05/2025 22:30

@TempestTost

"The dismissal by well off liberals of concerns about immigration as racist,"

Except people are racist - you can see it all over social media. It' s not just about numbers or pressure on services.

"and the labeling of particularly working class people as bigots, is %100 what has allowed more extreme right wing parties to grow."

If someone's referring to migrants and asylum seekers as 'illegals' and 'muslamics' who want to force us all to live under Sharia law, then I'm going to call them deluded bigots who like dehumanising immigrants.

Concerns about the effects of mass immigration were being dismissed as being bigoted long before those terms were common. That dismissal, for years, is the behaviour that has led to the place we are now.

If it doesn't stop it will lead to worse.

Goldenbear · 18/05/2025 22:45

MiloMinderbinder925 · 18/05/2025 22:39

I've seen it loads of times on MN.

Yes, it is definitely on the rise on MN. Last night when I watched the newish film, The Age, with Jude Law about the terrorist white Supremacists in 1980s U.S. it reminded of some of the racist language you now see on here, before it is deleted.

I lived in

ArcticTvrn · 18/05/2025 22:45

converseandjeans · 18/05/2025 22:43

Yes I would class Windrush as working class - they were invited over & took on jobs like train drivers, nurses. I think it’s different as we knew who was coming & presumably had housing & jobs in place for the new arrivals.

You don't know your own history.

Many Windrush arrivals had been back and forth already and some from families involved in fighting for Britain in one or both world wars. It wasn't a one time arrival situation.

There was no welcome package.

Try reading Samuel Selvon.

Incidentally there were upper middle and middle class arrivals to study as well and different classes of lodging on the boats.

converseandjeans · 18/05/2025 22:43

ArcticTvrn · 18/05/2025 21:43

The traditional working class? Like the Windrush generation? Or does traditional mean white?

Migrants would be the working class if allowed to earn their keep. They don't choose to be put up in state accommodation and prevented from working towards a life of their choosing.

Yes I would class Windrush as working class - they were invited over & took on jobs like train drivers, nurses. I think it’s different as we knew who was coming & presumably had housing & jobs in place for the new arrivals.

TheBlueUniform · 18/05/2025 22:43

TempestTost · 18/05/2025 22:26

Why would it mean white? My partner is a wc man, Caribbean, came with his parents as a boy in the 70s. He is really concerned about the effects of too liberal an immigration policy.

You people insisting that concerns like that have to be about some kind of white supremacist lens are a huge part of the issue. It's like there is a total inability to even conceptualise other possibilities.

Exactly this!!

But your view and that of your DH doesn’t suit their narrative so your post will be skimmed over as it can’t be used as a weapon.

BundleBoogie · 18/05/2025 22:42

MiloMinderbinder925 · 18/05/2025 21:13

It's been known for some time that far right extremism is growing. We had two anti immigrant protests this weekend, one in Bristol and one in Birmingham. Both cities are very racially diverse.

The protesters had remigration flags which is a far right term for deporting all people of colour.

Many European countries have a far right presence, and some have been voted into the European parliament. Some have asked for extensive remigration programmes.

There's a lot of talk on social media about a coming race war and people seem obsessed with 'immigrants'.

There's a lot of misinformation online fuelling division and hatred.

Edited

Yes. Most of the misinformation coming from people going on about the ‘rise of far right extremism’. I guess you can claim there is a rise in the ‘far right’ if you label everyone who wants a conversation about we let into our country as being far right.

That is not the case however and you are just creating an issue where there doesn’t need to be one.

My main fear is the serious and very deadly issue of Islamic terrorism which takes up approx 75% of the work of MI5 in prevention and costs us millions per year in security measures like crowd protection barriers etc. Individuals like Lee Rigby have been murdered on the street, little girls murdered in their dance class and Ariana Grande fans murdered on a night out. Not to mention the London bus bombings. There are more. Name an equivalent number of ‘far right’ murders please.

It is quite an unsurprising fact that if we let in an uncontrolled number of immigrants who are not properly checked, we are letting in some people who have sworn to kill us. It is only fair that we get to discuss this openly without people like you calling us ‘far right’.

I have no issue with controlled migration and am proud that we are a welcoming and tolerant society. We can’t let the extremists and those who would silence us change that.

Quote on stats below from Hansard.

hansard.parliament.uk/lords/2023-07-24/debates/03C258B1-5D37-4875-A575-204A0BFE9766/ContestUKStrategyForCounteringTerrorism2023

“By far the biggest terrorist threat comes from Islamist terrorism. It accounts for 67% of attacks since 2018, and about three quarters of MI5’s caseload. The remainder of the UK terrorist threat is largely driven by extreme right-wing terrorism, which accounts for approximately 22% of attacks since 2018 and about a quarter of the MI5 caseload.”

Sabire9 · 18/05/2025 22:39

@TempestTost

"He is really concerned about the effects of too liberal an immigration policy."

Is that concern about pressure on public services and housing after 15 years of biting government austerity, or what?

If it's about cultural change and crime, what makes that different to the massive objections raised by white Brits in response to waves of immigration from the West Indies in the 1950's?

MiloMinderbinder925 · 18/05/2025 22:39

TempestTost · 18/05/2025 22:29

The whole indigenous/First Nation stuff is just far right ideology seeping into the nation's consciousness.

I will first say I have never heard this in the UK, the closest is some things you might hear in Scotland or Wales, but that's typically more specifically anti-English.

But if there is rhetoric like that, I would expect it's coming from North America, where it's considered quite acceptable by some. Some of it is quite nasty too.

I've seen it loads of times on MN.

Potsofpetals · 18/05/2025 22:35

JacquesHarlow · 18/05/2025 20:51

Ok this post @AnxiousApocalypse is packed with assumptions here and , as someone "of colour" (!) that is British born but who is concerned about rising immigration, let me try and help:

There is so much anti-immigrant sentiment in the UK and the West in general.

There has been a lot more migration from certain countries, many of them not necessarily officially in conflict or in war, but which seek the UK as an attractive destination due to language and existing family members.

So this has led to concerns.

There are a lot of people that believe if you are a person of colour that has grown up in the UK but have immigrant parents, then you are not British enough- even if you have spent your whole life here and integrated into British society.

Am in my 40s, female, grew up in the worse times than this, and I would challenge the "there are a lot of". I think there are a lot more outlets now such a social media that give coverage to these voices, but in my professional and personal life, no one is questioning me!

At my workplace, people talk about immigrants coming over on scam care worker visas schemes, bringing their dependants and taking up resources such as school places and NHS appointments when those are already lacking for those born in Britain.

But I don't think scam visas are ok?

Will most people not be happy until the UK has no non-white people at all?

This is seriously extreme, sorry OP, and deliberately provocative. NO, I don't think this is the case at all. You'll find "non white" people like me are also concerned about mass arrivals of young men, from particular communities and countries, time and time again arriving without families or any context, and slipping away into society without any identification, any screening, any support for integration. Where I live, this concerns people. Not their colour, but the culture issues.

I second that. Also not white. My family entered this country legally and the last bit of racism I faced was 25 years ago. Winter 2000 if you want a specific year.

This is the second time I’ve wrote this on similar threads this week. It’s almost like the left want us to face racism.

I have no issue with the Conservative Party, Reform, Katie Bloody Hopkins or any other person who is trying to protect the rights of uk citizens.

TempestTost · 18/05/2025 22:35

Sabire9 · 18/05/2025 22:17

"If mainstream politicians had even acknowledged a fraction of the problems caused by the policy of unfettered mass immigration"

All countries trying to grow their economies while experiencing falling birth rates are reliant on immigration, and this will continue to be the case.

What we've had in the UK is problematic because it involves high levels of immigration alongside prolonged, eye watering austerity and BREXIT, which has damaged public services and sucked huge amounts of money out of local economies. And then we have a right wing press which has relentlessly blamed the resultant fall in living standards on immigration alone.

This is not likely to be the case long term, at least not in anything like the way it is being carried out now.

Adding large numbers to the population isn't effective at long term propping up the economy unless the newcomers manage to be on the higher side of economic prosperity. otherwise the effect tends to be to drain more resources from the system.

The idea that all immigration was helpful in that way was believed for a long time but it's clear now it's a more complicated picture. It has to be well managed and thought out.

Even then, it's not really a long term solution, especially when it prevents us from looking at other ways to become sustainable.

Sabire9 · 18/05/2025 22:30

@TempestTost

"The dismissal by well off liberals of concerns about immigration as racist,"

Except people are racist - you can see it all over social media. It' s not just about numbers or pressure on services.

"and the labeling of particularly working class people as bigots, is %100 what has allowed more extreme right wing parties to grow."

If someone's referring to migrants and asylum seekers as 'illegals' and 'muslamics' who want to force us all to live under Sharia law, then I'm going to call them deluded bigots who like dehumanising immigrants.

TempestTost · 18/05/2025 22:29

The whole indigenous/First Nation stuff is just far right ideology seeping into the nation's consciousness.

I will first say I have never heard this in the UK, the closest is some things you might hear in Scotland or Wales, but that's typically more specifically anti-English.

But if there is rhetoric like that, I would expect it's coming from North America, where it's considered quite acceptable by some. Some of it is quite nasty too.

ArcticTvrn · 18/05/2025 22:29

TempestTost · 18/05/2025 22:26

Why would it mean white? My partner is a wc man, Caribbean, came with his parents as a boy in the 70s. He is really concerned about the effects of too liberal an immigration policy.

You people insisting that concerns like that have to be about some kind of white supremacist lens are a huge part of the issue. It's like there is a total inability to even conceptualise other possibilities.

I'm one person :)

Thinking in 'you people' terms is a giveaway...

Masmavi · 18/05/2025 22:28

converseandjeans · 18/05/2025 21:36

Agree with this. You can’t just keep on letting in more people & putting them up in hotels without people getting fed up. I think people who have come here legally are getting annoyed too as they had to pay lots for visas and NHS access & most are working. I don’t think anyone is representing the traditional working class politically. Years ago they would have managed to get a school place, GP appointment & a council house. Now they see people arriving & taking what they see as theirs. I’m not affected where I live & I work with lots of migrant children (who are lovely). But I can see why people in areas which have hotels full are getting pissed off. They feel like they aren’t being listened to. So they have resorted to protesting.

They’re not getting those basic services or needs met not because of immigrants but because of years and years of underfunding.

TempestTost · 18/05/2025 22:26

ArcticTvrn · 18/05/2025 21:43

The traditional working class? Like the Windrush generation? Or does traditional mean white?

Migrants would be the working class if allowed to earn their keep. They don't choose to be put up in state accommodation and prevented from working towards a life of their choosing.

Why would it mean white? My partner is a wc man, Caribbean, came with his parents as a boy in the 70s. He is really concerned about the effects of too liberal an immigration policy.

You people insisting that concerns like that have to be about some kind of white supremacist lens are a huge part of the issue. It's like there is a total inability to even conceptualise other possibilities.

Swipe left for the next trending thread