Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Separating from DH with no warning

166 replies

AndiD87 · 15/05/2025 10:21

Hi All,

First time poster and just want some advice.

I basically told my DH of 12 years I want to separate. This is a complete shock to him but comes after a row last night where I came back from a 2 day trip, turned on the TV and seen it was on a porn channel - he admitted his been watching it while I was away. My real issue with this is 1) we’ve small kids who could have turned on the TV and found it 2) I find it really uncomfortable knowing the stats for sex trafficking/underage girls forced into it etc and 3) our bedroom antics are in tatters, my self confidence is at an all time
low and this just felt like a real blow.

I had been trying to make a real effort with our relationship and had in the last month started to wear my wedding ring again so this just felt like a real kick.

Previous marriage issues involved:

  • my utter frustration at carrying the mental load but especially all the financial stress and decisions for the house (I earn double his income but really hate the pressure of sorting out all finances, making all decisions etc - don’t fee like a partner more like his mum). He is a great dad and does a lot of housework etc - it’s just all decisions are my responsibility and I am drowning under the pressure with a stressful job, 2 small kids and caring for a family member. I’ve begged him to take some decisions off me but alas he doesn’t
  • We had a bad period where he was really pressuring me for sex, this really damaged our relationship, my self esteem and my trust. After explaining to him how awful his behaviour was he completely stopped all the pressure and is very considerate now, however I don’t know I’ve really dealt with my feelings on this and it’s only know looking back I can elements of this type of behaviour where there at the start but not as serious
  • early in the marriage he was fired from his job for misconduct (broke a law) which caused 2 years of complete stress and he completely lost my trust as i never would have thought he could be so wreck-less and risk our future

I’m not painting him in the best light but last night broke me and I just feel I can’t go on as when we are just back on track something else happens

YABU - last night was minor and your overreacting
YANBU - last night was disrespectful and my feelings are justified given the history

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MintChocCat · 19/05/2025 18:22

How are you today @AndiD87 ?

SirRaymondClench · 19/05/2025 16:10

All the men on this post: "I can't believe you're dumping him for watching porn, how stupid, I don't see the problem with your DH wanking off to porn, porn is great and 99.9% of it isn't trafficked women, all men watch it blah blah fucking blah"

So fucking what? OP can dump him for whatever she feels like and if she wants to dump the useless waste of space then she can. Whether you're cool with your DH/You wanking off to porn is totally irrelevant.

Themaghag · 18/05/2025 19:48

I'm an older person too and my generation often elected to put up with useless/abusive husbands because frankly, there weren't many alternatives. Nowadays, thank God, women don't have to stick with a marriage that is making them stressed and unhappy. Do whatever you think is best for you and your children OP and use your energy to build the best co-parenting relationship you can instead of trying to resurrect a marriage that's already dead on its feet. Good luck for the future.

pointythings · 18/05/2025 15:16

ZanyGreyFinch · 18/05/2025 04:56

You say he is good at doing tasks when directed. So direct him and get on with looking after your family.

Nah, don't do that. He's a grown man, he should be able to handle the basics of running a household and family without needing his hand held. Women need to stop indulging this pathetic mock helplessness that lets men off the hook.

ZanyGreyFinch · 18/05/2025 04:56

You say he is good at doing tasks when directed. So direct him and get on with looking after your family.

RachCmomma · 18/05/2025 01:24

AndiD87 · 15/05/2025 12:52

Just to clarify we do have sex maybe 3-5 times a month, not a huge amount I know and honestly I would like it to be more frequently but I’m normally up at 6 and crawling into bed at 10.30 completely exhausted and one of the kids is a poor sleeper so hard to get any unbroken sleep.

I do appreciate all of the opinions.
Marriage counselling would be an obvious thing to do but I just feel exhausted at the thought of having to find a therapist, having to book, having to find a babysitter as no family near - just another thing for me to have to do and he can say he went through the motions. Previously he was to organise counselling but it came to nothing, I ended up doing sessions myself.

I know he says he feels much less capable than me and he is self conscious of contributing less financially to the household - but I just feel I am carrying him through life and at the expense of my own peace

There's your answer lovely. Xx

Fizled · 17/05/2025 21:55

AndiD87 · 15/05/2025 10:21

Hi All,

First time poster and just want some advice.

I basically told my DH of 12 years I want to separate. This is a complete shock to him but comes after a row last night where I came back from a 2 day trip, turned on the TV and seen it was on a porn channel - he admitted his been watching it while I was away. My real issue with this is 1) we’ve small kids who could have turned on the TV and found it 2) I find it really uncomfortable knowing the stats for sex trafficking/underage girls forced into it etc and 3) our bedroom antics are in tatters, my self confidence is at an all time
low and this just felt like a real blow.

I had been trying to make a real effort with our relationship and had in the last month started to wear my wedding ring again so this just felt like a real kick.

Previous marriage issues involved:

  • my utter frustration at carrying the mental load but especially all the financial stress and decisions for the house (I earn double his income but really hate the pressure of sorting out all finances, making all decisions etc - don’t fee like a partner more like his mum). He is a great dad and does a lot of housework etc - it’s just all decisions are my responsibility and I am drowning under the pressure with a stressful job, 2 small kids and caring for a family member. I’ve begged him to take some decisions off me but alas he doesn’t
  • We had a bad period where he was really pressuring me for sex, this really damaged our relationship, my self esteem and my trust. After explaining to him how awful his behaviour was he completely stopped all the pressure and is very considerate now, however I don’t know I’ve really dealt with my feelings on this and it’s only know looking back I can elements of this type of behaviour where there at the start but not as serious
  • early in the marriage he was fired from his job for misconduct (broke a law) which caused 2 years of complete stress and he completely lost my trust as i never would have thought he could be so wreck-less and risk our future

I’m not painting him in the best light but last night broke me and I just feel I can’t go on as when we are just back on track something else happens

YABU - last night was minor and your overreacting
YANBU - last night was disrespectful and my feelings are justified given the history

Your feelings are valid, you need to work on you sweet and start listening to what you feel. You are important but sit down and have a serious conversation as with you feeling this way. Porn on the tv is a deffo no. You need to rest and make it clear he pays half to all the bills xxx

Bear No GIF
trixie1970 · 17/05/2025 21:22

I think it sounds like you could do with some couples counselling. Your feelings are very valid but there are two sides to a story and I think a counsellor could help bottom things out.

If you love each other, it's well worth sorting the issues out together. Good luck x

Goingoutofmymind25 · 17/05/2025 21:22

Sounds like you have an extra toddler!
I get that many men are a bit clueless (mine wouldn't know what to do to organise a child's birthday party, how to book after school clubs, or how to pay for school trips), butbit sounds like yours doesn't know how ANYTHING runs in the world. How can he not know how much money you as a family have??

AuroradelaNotte · 17/05/2025 21:07

I personally can understand why you are upset but before you make any rash decisions I think you both could do with talking it out or getting counselling. He probably didn't think he was doing anything wrong and never thought the kids would see.

Griff1963 · 17/05/2025 20:57

Your mind is obviously made up, going back on it will only put a Band-Aid on the relationship, which as all know, is temporary. Good luck Ma'am 🙏🏾

ThisGutsyNewt · 17/05/2025 20:49

I listened to a podcast by Mel Robbins : : Trust your gut- how to make a hard decision (28th April). I feel this could be really useful for you.

DraigCymraeg · 17/05/2025 20:42

2024onwardsandup · 15/05/2025 11:21

Also - men can live without sex

Why stay married to someone if you don't want to have sex with them? That's really sad.

D0891 · 17/05/2025 20:36

It's just porn not all but probably the majority of men do especially good men in relationships with no sex life. It sounds like you wasn't listening when he was showing his needs. But later down the line when you have bothered to make an effort you are then wondering why you found porn on the TV???
I don't know him and he sounds far from perfect . But maybe he is using porn so he doesn't have to go elsewhere to be satisfied.

Walkden · 17/05/2025 20:20

"Maybe 'exploited' would have been a better word, and yes, I do believe all porn is exploitation.

What if he was watching bonnie blue...?

BlueTitShark · 17/05/2025 20:18

Pices · 17/05/2025 19:45

@MintChocCatIt doesn’t have to be ok for her and if it’s a deal breaker than so be it but 75% of men watch porn. Younger men are more likely to watch. If we assume she also wants someone who matches her salary then that’s 17% of men. Now you need a man who falls in both very small buckets that she actually likes who is willing to date a woman with two small kids…I’d try to work it out with this guy given that he’s a good father. I think it’s that or accept she will most likely be alone.

There’s also the perspective of the kids involved who love their Dad. There’s no upside in this for them. They will go from a family unit to possibly being dragged into two blended families….

So… we should just accept it then?
Like we accepted marital raie, sexual assault etc…

Instead if saying 75% of men watch porn so you’d better accept it, maybe we should say let’s not accept it and if 75% of women do NOT accept their partner watching porn, then theyll have to accept it.

MintChocCat · 17/05/2025 20:13

Pices · 17/05/2025 19:45

@MintChocCatIt doesn’t have to be ok for her and if it’s a deal breaker than so be it but 75% of men watch porn. Younger men are more likely to watch. If we assume she also wants someone who matches her salary then that’s 17% of men. Now you need a man who falls in both very small buckets that she actually likes who is willing to date a woman with two small kids…I’d try to work it out with this guy given that he’s a good father. I think it’s that or accept she will most likely be alone.

There’s also the perspective of the kids involved who love their Dad. There’s no upside in this for them. They will go from a family unit to possibly being dragged into two blended families….

And it’s also possible for that statistic to change. I have a friend who stopped consuming it, and my partner did too. I’m not going to normalise or accept it, and setting it as a boundary within a relationship is possible. Your stat may or may not be true / accurate, but that’s not to say it has to stay that way. It is of course a choice.

Regardless of the porn consumption issue - there are other difficulties within OP’s relationship as well. Their relationship a multifaceted issue. In most cases it is better for both parents to stay together for the sake of the children, but not always.

ShiningStar3 · 17/05/2025 19:54

You're completely within your rights to not want to be with someone that consumes porn. Be prepared for people to tell you all men do it and it's something you should just tolerate. The porn industry is disgusting and there's no way to determine if the 'actors' are trafficking victims, and even then sex workers are disproportionately victims of childhood abuse, rape or other trauma that makes them vulnerable. All that asides, even if we were in a perfect world where women aren't trafficked and all porn is magically ethical and respectful (don't get me into the disturbing misogynistic and dangerous 'kinks' depicted in much mainstream pornography) you're not unreasonable for not wanting your partner to masturbate over other people ffs. It's depressing that it's normalised to the point we are shamed and ridiculed for what is when you think about it a very reasonable preference. I'm really sorry you're in this situation, I know how painful it is.

Pices · 17/05/2025 19:45

@MintChocCatIt doesn’t have to be ok for her and if it’s a deal breaker than so be it but 75% of men watch porn. Younger men are more likely to watch. If we assume she also wants someone who matches her salary then that’s 17% of men. Now you need a man who falls in both very small buckets that she actually likes who is willing to date a woman with two small kids…I’d try to work it out with this guy given that he’s a good father. I think it’s that or accept she will most likely be alone.

There’s also the perspective of the kids involved who love their Dad. There’s no upside in this for them. They will go from a family unit to possibly being dragged into two blended families….

FunMustard · 17/05/2025 17:48

ItGhoul · 15/05/2025 15:14

There is a vast, vast range of porn out there, and without knowing exactly what the OP's husband was watching, you have no idea whether it involved anyone being brutalised. It's highly, highly unlikely that it did, if it was on an adult TV channel.

Saying that 'porn is just women being brutalised' is a bit like saying 'pubs are just alcoholics drinking themselves to death' or 'motor sport is just drivers dying in burning cars'.

As I said in my other post, it's perfectly fine and valid to have objections to porn - there are plenty of reasons anyone might have a problem with it. But I see so much oddly massive exaggeration about it on Mumsnet.

To be quite frank, Ghoul, I just CBA to write a longer post.

Maybe 'exploited' would have been a better word, and yes, I do believe all porn is exploitation. But the point was that masturbation doesn't have to include pornography.

MintChocCat · 17/05/2025 14:50

Pices · 17/05/2025 13:03

You sound like you could benefit from some couples counselling. I imagine you’re not going to be pleased to see him with another woman having fabulous sex and being a Disney Dad. You’ll be every bit as exhausted as you are now…personally I can’t see the issue with him viewing porn and it feels like you might be the controlling one in this relationship.

I think what you said about the porn is pretty dismissive and minimising. Like a PP said, just because you’ve normalised it, doesn’t make it ok for others.

Pices · 17/05/2025 13:03

You sound like you could benefit from some couples counselling. I imagine you’re not going to be pleased to see him with another woman having fabulous sex and being a Disney Dad. You’ll be every bit as exhausted as you are now…personally I can’t see the issue with him viewing porn and it feels like you might be the controlling one in this relationship.

auderesperare · 17/05/2025 13:00

Hi OP, I know you are not coming back to this thread and that’s ok but I’ve been thinking about your situation and reading the posts.
I think people are getting too hung up on sex when the issue is trust. You’re doing amazingly managing to keep any sort of sex life going when you are considering leaving.
I don’t think you have entirety checked out of this marriage yet and I agree you should not do anything rash without considering all the options.
Also do not underestimate the exhaustion - mental, physical and emotional - that comes from looking after a sick relative. It’s a really difficult time and you need your husband to step up here.
You have given him a shock by telling him you want to separate. If he doesn’t step up now, he never will and you’ll have your answer but first you need to let go of the resentment over his job loss.
It sounds like he did a really stupid thing and paid the price and you’ve all been paying it ever since. He is living with the guilt and must know how disappointed you are in him. You overcame the resentment enough to have two DC with him so for their sake, you need to deal with this - either by talking it out with him, talking it out with a therapist or writing it all down, tearing it up and deciding to put it behind you. You can’t change the past, just your attitude to it.
Then make proper time away from the kids to really discuss your relationship wants and needs. Get him to bring his wants and needs to the table too. Both of you should write lists of what you want to discuss. Decide your non-negotiables and work out what you are prepared to compromise on. Listen to him. Only you know what these are. But one thing you could consider is getting him to do more of the things he already does which help - cooking meals, bathing DC etc, plus a list of weekly chores he can easily master that he does every week and is stuck to the fridge door. You shouldn’t have to do this but you are where you are. If finances are an issue set aside time weekly or monthly to discuss these. Set aside time for regular progress reports on the new arrangements. Give it a good six months to bed in. Carve out time every week for yourself.
Good luck OP. I hope it works out for you.

Bowies · 17/05/2025 10:03

If you have a boundary about this and he broke it then I agree. Concerns about DC having got to the TV first also valid,

Also agree with you in general about porn. Just because some people normalise it even if it were a majority, doesn’t make it ok.

If you look into its effects they are all detrimental including on relationships, not to mention the exploitation involved as you said.

Ultimately I think you’ve just had enough of the relationship and aren’t interested in him sexually because of the earlier dynamics. The relationship was over years ago and since then you’ve been getting through the day to day, but being unhappy and stressed. Trust was broken with the initial incident you describe at his work.

Focus on separating amicably if you can and ways to co-parent effectively.

AgentJohnson · 17/05/2025 08:34

I don’t know if the porn was a straw camel thing or an excuse to end a relationship that hasn’t worked for a really long time. I think you’ve realised that he’s never going to be the partner you want him to be and staying in the marriage just postpones the inevitable.

Your marriage didn’t work out, it’s okay, it happens.