Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to navigate this mil/sil situation

32 replies

Helpinghand1234 · 13/05/2025 22:59

Looking for any advice/guidance how to handle this situation please?

I, 41f have been married to DH 41 for 2 years (together almost 5). We have 1 DS, 19 months, and I’m 37 weeks with our second child.

Our marriage has been through an extremely difficult time for the last 6/7 months, after I found messages between DH and my MIL on his phone going back to the time of our wedding. He was complaining about me, my cooking skills, washing, how I cared for our son, kept house etc etc. They had an extremely emeshed and toxic relationship, so she of course loved hearing the criticism and took it several steps further, calling me unstable, a terrible wife and mother and telling him he should tolerate me until DS was older and he could move back in with her and take DS with him. I cannot explain how hurt and betrayed I felt, and it seriously knocked my confidence and made me question my capabilities as a mum.

We separated for a few months (still lived together) and have only recently reconnected through marriage counselling where it became apparent he has been in an extremely abusive and damaging relationship with his mother since childhood. We’re very slowly trying to work through things, but I’m still not sure how things will work out in the long run- I don’t know if he has the strength to work through his issues and I don’t know if I can ever forgive what feels like a betrayal from him. DH has put several boundries in place with mil now and they have a sort of uneasy truce, but the situation is further complicated by the fact that DH sees in-laws every day (they farm together) and this can’t/won’t ever change.

Since I found the messages mil blocked me on all social media platforms and has made no contact with me or made any attempt to explain her behaviour or apologise. When DH told her I’d seen the messages her response was “she was entitled to say whatever she wanted about anyone.” I don’t allow DH to take our DS there as my view is if she can’t respect me (she doesn’t have to like me) and doesn’t want to communicate with me then I don’t want her around my child. DH says she regularly asks to see pics of DS and asks how he is etc.

Now my issue is when this baby is born, how do I navigate the relationship with her and sil (who has also not reached out throughout my pregnancy, which I understand to an extent as she has the same emeshed relationship with mil where she would no doubt be punished for being disloyal to mil be reaching out to me.)

DH says mil asks him how I am etc, and so I think she will expect to come and visit when baby has arrived, and I suspect sil will also want to visit with her DH and DC to meet the baby.

What do I do? Do I allow them here and just be civil for the sake of keeping the peace?
Do I tell DH they’re not welcome as they have made no effort to reach out to me, and mil has made no attempt to apologise for her hurtful messages over many months about me?

I’m so conflicted. If I refuse then I know that’s closing the door on any type of reconciliation in the future, but at the same time I feel like I’m being pushed into a corner where I have to once again tolerate their behaviour and keep quiet so as not to rock the boat, which is what I’ve done throughout our marriage when mil was always passively aggressively treating me like a surrogate or nuisance (I.e. held DS who was only a day old for four hours while I was trying to establish breastfeeding, and despite my many hints refused to give him back saying everyone had a right to their turn, would tell DH he wouldn’t be able to bond with DS if he couldn’t feed him, I had dressed DS inappropriately etc etc) I hate myself for tolerating this behaviour, but I’m worried this has made me unable to see what is reasonable in this new situation without bringing all of my bagge with me.

Thank you in advance for any advice, apologies for the long post.

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 13/05/2025 23:45

A woman who said DH should take my child away from me and essentially give him to her would not see my DC again.,

Helpinghand1234 · 13/05/2025 23:44

sesquipedalian · 13/05/2025 23:32

“telling him he should tolerate me until DS was older and he could move back in with her and take DS with him”

OP, why would you want this toxic woman in your life? I would be feeling she was just biding her time until she could take my DH and my DC away from me. MIL has chosen to block you on social media platforms - why on earth would you want to see her? As for her holding your newborn for four hours, enough! You have the whip hand here - you are the mother: they’re your DC and she, as a result of her behaviour, has ensured that she won’t see them. She can “expect” to come and visit all she likes: I’d tell your DH that you feel her presence is undermining your relationship and you want nothing to do with her. What does your DH say about all this? As for SIL, that’s up to you - you make excuses about her being enmeshed with MIL, but the whole thing sounds most unhealthy - and she could have sent you a few words of congratulation or encouragement, even if she hasn’t been to see you. Very odd to ignore you for nine months and then expect to be welcomed into your home.

Thank you, I appreciate the perspective.

DH doesn’t ever disagree with me when I say DS can’t go over there, but we haven’t had an explicit conversation about what will happen when baby is here. He still has a lifetime of issues to work through, and deep down he still hopes things can blow over and we’ll somehow get to a point where mil has more access to DC.

I don’t particularly want a relationship with her, I tried so hard to have her accept me but she’s a deeply damaged woman and I don’t want the damage she’s done to DH to be passed on to DS in any way. But I was worried I was being too harsh by saying I don’t want her to visit the new baby, even once. I know once I say that then reconciliation will be impossible, and the narrative will be that I’m keeping DC away from her etc.

Thank you again.

OP posts:
Readytohealnow · 13/05/2025 23:37

You need to get yourself and your two children far away from this toxic set up.
I hope you have stable employment and good RL support.

sesquipedalian · 13/05/2025 23:32

“telling him he should tolerate me until DS was older and he could move back in with her and take DS with him”

OP, why would you want this toxic woman in your life? I would be feeling she was just biding her time until she could take my DH and my DC away from me. MIL has chosen to block you on social media platforms - why on earth would you want to see her? As for her holding your newborn for four hours, enough! You have the whip hand here - you are the mother: they’re your DC and she, as a result of her behaviour, has ensured that she won’t see them. She can “expect” to come and visit all she likes: I’d tell your DH that you feel her presence is undermining your relationship and you want nothing to do with her. What does your DH say about all this? As for SIL, that’s up to you - you make excuses about her being enmeshed with MIL, but the whole thing sounds most unhealthy - and she could have sent you a few words of congratulation or encouragement, even if she hasn’t been to see you. Very odd to ignore you for nine months and then expect to be welcomed into your home.

2024onwardsandup · 13/05/2025 23:21

I wouldn’t have anything to do with them and wouldn’t let them near my children

and your husband needs to give up his part of the farm and you all need to move very very very far away

Lifeisapeach · 13/05/2025 23:18

Do not welcome them into your home. No good can come of it.

S0j0urn4r · 13/05/2025 23:13

I wouldn't let them within 10 feet of my children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread